What Can I Say?

What can I say about the five pipebomb-containing packages sent to George Soros, Hillary Clinton, President Obama, John Brennan, and Eric Holder? Here’s the FBI’s statement:

Between October 22 and 24, 2018, suspicious packages were received at multiple locations in the New York and Washington, D.C., areas and Florida. The packages are being sent for analysis at the FBI Laboratory in Quantico, Virginia.

“This investigation is of the highest priority for the FBI. We have committed the full strength of the FBI’s resources and, together with our partners on our Joint Terrorism Task Forces, we will continue to work to identify and arrest whoever is responsible for sending these packages,” said FBI Director Christopher Wray. “We ask anyone who may have information to contact the FBI. Do not hesitate to call; no piece of information is too small to help us in this investigation.”

[…]

The packages were mailed in manila envelopes with bubble wrap interior. The packages were affixed with computer-printed address labels and six Forever stamps. All packages had a return address of “DEBBIE WASSERMAN SHULTZ” [sic] in Florida. Packages identified to date were addressed to:

  • George Soros
  • Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton
  • Former President Barack Obama
  • Former CIA Director John Brennan, care of CNN
  • Former Attorney General Eric Holder

The package addressed to former Attorney General Holder did not reach its intended destination, but was rerouted to the return address in Florida.

Don’t do it. Don’t make excuses for it. Don’t get ahead of the reports.

What else is there to say?

13 comments

A Question of Math

If something is 99.994% right, is it 100% wrong?

12 comments

Health Care Spending

Annual health care spending in the U. S. is presently about $10,000 for every man, woman, and child in the country. In 1970 U. S. per capita health care spending was about $355. In inflation-adjusted terms health care spending is something grown something between sixfold and thirty-fold, depending on how you calculated it.

That cannot be attributed to pharmaceutical company profits (drugs are about 8% of expenditures) and it cannot be attributed insurance company profits. The numbers just don’t add up.

What gripes me about the Republicans’ approach to health care reform is their childlike belief in the magical ability of markets to reduce costs. Markets could reduce costs but not without denying care to tens of millions of people and probably not even then.

What gripes me about the Democrats’ approach to health care reform is their childlike belief in the magical ability of a single-payer system to control costs. It’s not magic. It’s commitment. It’s willingness to deny care and raises to people working in the health care sector. If Democrats could demonstrate for me their willingness to cut costs, I’d be willing to vote for a single-payer system. In the absence of such commitment it’s just a ticket to an unpayable bill.

5 comments

Too Many Zeros

In her Washington Post column Megan McArdle points out what should be obvious but apparently is not—that we don’t have the time for a protracted national dialogue on immigration. Not months or years but days:

Trump is of course wrong to cast fact-free aspersions on desperate people seeking a better life. But the left is wrong if they think that making that observation ends the argument, because even a caravan of nothing but decent, hard-working people would raise big questions. There are billions of decent, hard-working people living in the world. Do all of them have a right to migrate to the United States merely because doing so would make them better off?

Immigration restrictionists and advocates both struggle with that question to some degree, depending on the scale they use when considering it. On the macro scale, restrictionists find it easy to say, no, of course we can’t let in every single person who wants to come, because doing so would transform the country into one that few Americans of any political persuasion would want to live in.

If we decide to admit the people in the “caravan”, on what basis would we reject the next and the next and the next? The number of people involved is truly vast—estimated to be in the tens or hundreds of millions all told. The level of tax and transfer required to clothe, house, feed, transport, educate them (and their children!), and provide for their bodily needs is truly unimaginable. It just has too many zeros.

If we decide not to admit them, we need to figure out how to do it. Merely dispersing them will only delay the inevitable.

We don’t have a lot of time to decide.

11 comments

Dreaming

I think that Tom Friedman is dreaming in his latest New York Times column:

What is there left to say about the terrible murder of moderate Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi and its aftermath? Only one thing, and I have said it before, but I feel it even more strongly now: In the midterm elections, vote for a Democrat, canvass for a Democrat, raise money for a Democrat, drive someone else to a voting station to vote for a Democrat.

I don’t say that because I’m particularly liberal and want to shift the whole country to the liberal agenda. I say that because I’m particularly American and I want to put the best of American values back at the center of our diplomacy and politics. President Trump has spent two years attacking our best values — truth and trust — and I believe that Democrats getting a lever of power is necessary, but not sufficient, to reverse that.

Democrats could blow it if they get back a lever of power and use it just to bully Trump and Republicans the same way he has them. But I’ll take that chance. Because there is a basic respect for truth, science and decency in the Democratic caucus and because I know that two more years of the G.O.P. holding every lever of power and blindly following Trump’s basic disrespect for truth, science and decency will make it impossible to elevate America’s best values.

I found the part about the “basic respect for truth, science, and decency in the Democratic caucus” particularly amusing. IMO it would only take Mr. Friedman’s living in Illinois for a week or two to disabuse him of that view.

I can already hear the retort “but that’s Illinois”. I see absolutely no reason to believe that things are better in Washington, DC than they are in Illinois. It isn’t just Republicans who lie and abuse power. It is the nature of partisan politics, particularly when entrenched. It is not merely that “both parties do it”. It is that human beings do it. The protection is limited government of enumerated powers and the rule of law not electing Democrats.

I have no particular fondness for Republicans and, as I have said any number of times, I dislike Trump but Trump is the result not the cause. The cause is our whole present political system.

On Tuesday I’ll go and figuratively pull the levers for a lot of Democrats and a few Republicans, none of whom represent my views particularly well because voting for the lesser evil is as good as it gets. We deserve something better. I don’t think we can get anything better within the constraints of the present system.

5 comments

Interview With Gelernter

You may recall that I mentioned the other day that David Gelernter’s WSJ op-ed was the occasiona of substantial reaction. One of the reactions came in the form of this interview at Slate with Dr. Gelernter which I recommend you read in full.

I thought it reflected a substantial failure of a meeting of minds. Let me cite an example. Am I mistaken or did the interviewer believe that any unfair or specious criticism of a non-white president was ipso facto racism while Gelernter did not?

I have active memories of thirteen presidents. I do not recall any of those presidents who did not receive unfair or even untrue criticism, some more than others. That’s politics not prejudice. If politics as usual is construed as racial bigotry what should we conclude from that?

9 comments

Victimized

Matthew Yglesias believes he and those with political beliefs similar to his are being victimized by the major media outlets:

The reason is something I’ve dubbed “the hack gap” over the years, and it’s one of the most fundamental asymmetries shaping American politics. While conservatives obsess over the (accurate) observation that the average straight news reporter has policy views that are closer to the Democratic Party than the Republican Party, the hack gap fundamentally does more to structure political discourse.

The hack gap explains why Clinton’s email server received more television news coverage than all policy issues combined in the 2016 election. It explains why Republicans can hope to get away with dishonest spin about preexisting conditions. It’s why Democrats are terrified that Elizabeth Warren’s past statements about Native American heritage could be general election poison in 2020, and it’s why an internecine debate about civility has been roiling progressive circles for nearly two years even while the president of the United States openly praises assaulting journalists.

The hack gap has two core pillars. One is the constellation of conservative media outlets — led by Fox News and other Rupert Murdoch properties like the Wall Street Journal editorial page, but also including Sinclair Broadcasting in local television, much of AM talk radio, and new media offerings such as Breitbart and the Daily Caller — that simply abjure anything resembling journalism in favor of propaganda.

The other is that the self-consciousness journalists at legacy outlets have about accusations of liberal bias leads them to bend over backward to allow the leading conservative gripes of the day to dominate the news agenda. Television producers who would never dream of assigning segments where talking heads debate whether it’s bad that the richest country on earth also has millions of children growing up in dire poverty think nothing of chasing random conservative shiny objects, from “Fast & Furious” (remember that one?) to Benghazi to the migrant caravan.

I have two questions. First, can anyone parse this sentence for me?

One is the constellation of conservative media outlets — led by Fox News and other Rupert Murdoch properties like the Wall Street Journal editorial page, but also including Sinclair Broadcasting in local television, much of AM talk radio, and new media offerings such as Breitbart and the Daily Caller — that simply abjure anything resembling journalism in favor of propaganda.

Does he mean that Breitbart and the Daily Caller “abjure anything resembling journalism” which I could potentially see or does he mean that all “conservative media outlets” do so which I think is an exaggeration?

The second is can you give me an example of the New York Times, the Washington Post, or the Associated Press bending “over backward to allow the leading conservative gripes of the day to dominate the news agenda”? Or does that just mean they’re being reported?

14 comments

America’s Id

David Gelernter’s essay at the Wall Street Journal is eliciting quite a bit of comment. This snippet resonated with me:

Not that every leftist hates America. But the leftists I know do hate Mr. Trump’s vulgarity, his unwillingness to walk away from a fight, his bluntness, his certainty that America is exceptional, his mistrust of intellectuals, his love of simple ideas that work, and his refusal to believe that men and women are interchangeable. Worst of all, he has no ideology except getting the job done. His goals are to do the task before him, not be pushed around, and otherwise to enjoy life.

but I don’t agree with this:

In short, he is a typical American—except exaggerated, because he has no constraints to cramp his style except the ones he himself invents.

Mr. Trump lacks constraints because he is filthy rich and always has been and, unlike other rich men, he revels in wealth and feels no need to apologize—ever. He never learned to keep his real opinions to himself because he never had to. He never learned to be embarrassed that he is male, with ordinary male proclivities. Sometimes he has treated women disgracefully, for which Americans, left and right, are ashamed of him—as they are of JFK and Bill Clinton.

And this does not resonate with me at all:

But my job as a voter is to choose the candidate who will do best for America. I am sorry about the coarseness of the unconstrained average American that Mr. Trump conveys. That coarseness is unpresidential and makes us look bad to other nations. On the other hand, many of his opponents worry too much about what other people think. I would love the esteem of France, Germany and Japan. But I don’t find myself losing sleep over it.

I don’t think this is true:

Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama know their real sins. They know how appalling such people are, with their stupid guns and loathsome churches. They have no money or permanent grievances to make them interesting and no Twitter followers to speak of. They skip Davos every year and watch Fox News. Not even the very best has the dazzling brilliance of a Chuck Schumer, not to mention a Michelle Obama. In truth they are dumb as sheep.

but only because they’re not sufficiently self-aware to “know their real sins”. I don’t think that Mr. Gelernter understands politics or politicians. Few know their real sins and most have completely conflated their own personal good with the public good.

While at Reason Nick Gillespie retorts:

The most annoying (offensive?) thing about Gelernter’s piece, like others of its type, is that it presumes there really are only two possibilities, pro-Trump and anti-Trump, that swamp everything else, even traditional partisanship. Worse still, the binary hinges not on issues of substance or policy but ultimately on issues of style. To wave away Trump’s relentless cheapening of discourse—calling a porn actress to whom his personal lawyer paid $130,000 in hush money horseface is so fucked up on so many levels—is not really any different than being disgusted that he eats his steak well-done and with ketchup. Trump’s m.o. is to make everything about himself.

The best response to Trump’s general mode of discourse is to not take the bait and make everything about him and his personal preferences. There may be only two major parties in America, but the rest of the political spectrum is alive and well and the increasing number of us who are not represented by existing Republican and Democratic coalitions need to make our independent voices louder than ever. It bears repeating: Just 26 percent of Americans identify as Republican and just 27 percent of us identify as Democratic. Forty-four percent call ourselves independent.

which rings much truer to me.

I don’t think there’s anything of the “typical American” about Donald Trump and I challenge anyone to find anything in Mr. Trump’s history or actions, present or past, that would suggest that there is. I think he’s America’s id. Just as there were vague reminders of Jekyl in Hyde, there are some reminders of typical Americans in Trump. For one thing most Americans live within constraints. They aren’t just an accidental feature. They’re part of who they are.

7 comments

Now He Tells Us

In his column at the Washington Post Michael Gerson restates for the umpteenth time his argument for a perpetual military commitment in Afghanistan:

There is an unavoidable logic to a medium-footprint approach. Terrorist havens can’t be left in peace for jihadists to prepare and increase their technical sophistication. But striking from afar with drones and planes (as we’ve seen) is not enough to destroy these havens. American troops are needed on the ground to gather intelligence, provide reconnaissance and embed with local partners. And these troops, in turn, must be adequately protected.

But will Americans accept — will President Trump accept — what amounts to a limited but indefinite, forward military presence in the Middle East to preempt emerging threats? Will Americans conclude that the resulting military casualties are worth it to prevent potential terrorist murders of civilians?

This would require people to view commitments such as the one in Afghanistan in a different light — not as a war that will eventually end, but as the farthest outposts of homeland defense. And as the terrible price of security in a hostile world.

because there are some ideas so stupid they can’t be repeated often enough. Contrary to Mr. Gerson’s implication the history of our Afghanistan adventure has not been “the patient accumulation of successes”. It’s been at best one step forward one step back. Most of what could be accomplished there was accomplished in the first six months.

As I pointed out back in 2001 the only successful strategy in Afghanistan over the period of the last 3,000 years has been Alexander’s—settle a population there. How about you and your kids, Mr. Gerson?

We should have known. Some of us knew. If people like Mr. Gerson had been saying 17 years ago what they’re saying now, would we have invaded Afghanistan at all? I like to hope not.

4 comments

The Great Divide

In his op-ed in the Washington Post Hugh Hewitt has a one sentence statement of the great divide in American politics:

The court should neither “hurry up” nor obstruct social change. It should not try to redirect or dam the mighty river “Culture,” and it should cease trying to vacuum away the delicate compromises local, state and national legislators make between the deeply felt religious beliefs of a vast and diverse people. Rather, it should read closely the laws that Congress passes, hold them up to the Constitution’s guarantees and refuse the efforts of elected officials to punt power to bureaucracies.

Despite the conviction with which Mr. Hewitt makes that pronouncement there are many Americans whose beliefs about the Supreme Court are quite the opposite. They believe that it is the job of the Supreme Court to “do justice” and navigate the murky waters of the law to find passages to some foreordained destination.

That no compromise between these views is possible is evident from the vitriol of the last six months.

7 comments