Why Doesn’t Keynesian Stimulus Work?

In an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal award-winning economist Edmund Phelps argues against Keynesian stimulus:

Among economists and policy makers it is widely thought that fiscal stimulus—increased public spending as well as tax cuts—helped pull employment from its depths in 2010 or so back to normal in 2017. The new tax cuts on personal income are thought to be increasing demand further.

But is there evidence that stimulus was behind America’s recovery—or, for that matter, the recoveries in Germany, Switzerland, Sweden, Britain and Ireland? And is there evidence that the absence of stimulus—a tight rein on public spending known as “fiscal austerity”—is to blame for the lack of a full recovery in Portugal, Italy, France and Spain?

A simple test occurred to me: The stimulus story suggests that, in the years after they hit bottom, the countries that adopted relatively large fiscal deficits—measured by the average increase in public debt from 2011-17 as a percentage of gross domestic product—would have a relatively speedy recovery to show for it. Did they?

As the accompanying chart shows, the evidence does not support the stimulus story. Big deficits did not speed up recoveries. In fact, the relationship is negative, suggesting fiscal profligacy led to contraction and fiscal responsibility would have been better.

Isn’t this a fluke? Don’t history and theory overwhelmingly support stimulus? Well, no. First, the history: Soldiers returning from World War II expanded the civilian labor force from 53.9 million in 1945 to 60.2 million in 1947, leading many economists to fear an unemployment crisis. Keynesians—Leon Keyserling for one—said running a peacetime fiscal deficit was needed to keep unemployment from rising. Yet as the government under President Harry S. Truman ran fiscal surpluses, the unemployment rate went down (from 3.9% in 1946 to 3.1% in 1952) and the labor-force participation rate went up (from 57.2% to 58.9%).

Standard economic theory points to other ill-effects of fiscal stimulus. Economist Franco Modigliani showed in 1961 that fiscal deficits have a negative impact on both the supply of labor and the supply of saving. I explored this territory further in a 1965 book on “fiscal neutrality.” The deficit may cause people to feel richer, and thus to work and save less. The Keynesian James Tobin showed in 1955 how consumer demand can simply crowd out investment demand. Another possibility, suggested by Robert Mundell’s early work, is that the effect of a country’s fiscal stimulus is diffused over the global economy, so that the deficit-running country itself feels little of the effect.

If fiscal stimulus is not effective in combating a recession, what about monetary stimulus—increasing the supply of money or reducing the cost of money in relation to the return on capital? We can perform a similar test: Did countries where monetary stimulus in the years after they hit bottom was relatively strong—measured by the average quantity of monetary assets purchased by the central bank from 2011-17—have relatively speedy recoveries? This is a complicated question, but preliminary explorations do not give strong support to that thesis either.

I don’t know if “most economists” believe it but my account of Keynesian stimulus (counter-cyclical deficit spending to offset a shortfall in aggregate demand) would be somewhat different. I think that Keynes was right on the theory but it’s very difficult to make work in practice. In other words I believe that a properly timed stimulus carefully applied can reduce the depth of a recession. The problem is not that it can’t but in practice stimulus is almost always applied too late and rarely applied prudently.

In the specific case of the ARRA, I think that the stimulus provided by the Bush Administration, although probably inadequate, was responsible for reducing the depth of the recession of 2008-2009 and that the stimulus of 2009 was mostly misapplied—plain old pork barrel politics rebranded as fiscal stimulus—and might even have contributed to the shallowness of the recovery.

1 comment

Is Stalemate the Best Case Scenario?

In his New York Times column Ross Douthat seems to think that it is:

To the extent that any Republicans deserve credit for this constraint, though, they are mostly elected Republicans in the Senate. The House is more pure, uncut MAGA, more reflexive in its defense of a president whose behavior is often indefensible, more poisoned by the worst Trumpist tendencies (witness the steady migration of the Iowa congressman Steve King toward an overt white nationalism) and more inclined to allow Trump a free hand should he seek to make his actual presidency exactly like his Twitter feed.

So a Democratic House would supply a much more effective check on that temptation, along with more vigorous scrutiny of corruption in the White House, about which congressional Republicans have been studiously incurious. And it would offer that check without jeopardizing any potential conservative legislative achievements — because, let’s be frank, the congressional G.O.P. isn’t going to do anything serious with its power if it gets re-elected except confirm judges, and you don’t need the House to elevate Amy Coney Barrett if there’s one more high court vacancy.

At the same time, for the genuinely populist sort for conservative (that is, the best kind), having a Democratic House might force Trump himself back toward the economic populism of his campaign, which he mostly abandoned but has suddenly remembered in the last days before the midterms, talking up a phantom middle-class tax cut and proposing an “America First” approach to drug pricing.

I think he’s misreading both political parties, assuming good faith and willingness to compromise where none exists. Today’s Republican Party at the national level is divided between anarcho-capitalist objectivists like Rand Paul and Paul Ryan and MAGA nativists. The only thing those two wings can agree on is cutting taxes. Today’s Democratic Party at the national level is divided between social democrats who view anyone who disagrees with them as fundamentally evil and Rubinesque technocratism as a façade for plain old machine politics—credentialism as a pretext for personal enrichment. The only thing they can agree on is that more money is needed to accomplish their goals and their goals are forever changing.

Where is there room for compromise? There’s barely room for compromise within the two parties let alone between them. Consequently, Mr. Douthat is preaching kicking the can down the road and hoping for the best as a political strategy.

If only we could get rid of everybody. We need a Mulligan.

9 comments

Why Inequality Matters

I’m having some difficulty finding a hook for commenting on Joseph Michael Newhard’s defense of income inequality at the Foundation for Economic Education. The best I can come up with is a series of counter-punches. For example:

People don’t maximize income; they maximize utility. If college students only cared about maximizing income, they would all major in petroleum engineering.

That’s factually incorrect. There are just a handful of programs in petroleum engineering in the entire country, they all have limited enrollments, and they’re all highly selective. In other words market and preference aren’t determining the number and wages of petroleum engineers. Artificial scarcity is.

And I challenge his notion that people major in lower-earning fields by preference. They do so because they can’t cut it in the highly competitive highly remunerative and for good reason. A very high percentage of people who enroll in college just aren’t college material. Only about half of people who enter college these days actually graduate with a degree over six years.

Or how about this? Wages aren’t determined by productivity. The most productive person with the title “business analyst” at Big A$$ Incorporated earns just about the same as the least productive person with that title. Your wages are determined by your position in the organization and the wages of people whom you resemble superficially, not by your own productivity.

When I graduated from college (before the glaciers descended and dinosaurs ruled the earth), a CEO of a major company earned on average 17 times as much as the average workers in his company (in France it was 13 times). Today major company CEOs earn 350 times what his average worker does. That can’t be explained by productivity, a failure to apply oneself, or anything other than cooperative boards of directors.

The reasons we should be concerned about increasing income inequality is that, at least in the U. S, income inequality leads to social inequality and income is increasingly running in family lines. That means a stratified, class-based society. That isn’t the United States I grew up in or the U. S. that I want.

Do I believe in strict income equality? Of course not. But there’s got to be something between the crony capitalism-based inequality we have now and Soviet-style enforced equality in which everybody but the party bosses are equally poor.

24 comments

What’s Wrong With Illinois?

I rarely read The Weekly Standard but I wanted to commend this article there by Andrew Ferguson on the mess that Illinois is in to your attention. I wish the article had started with this paragraph because it sets the stage:

A few years ago a pair of NPR reporters worked with a demographer from the Brookings Institution on a silly but revealing project. They set out to find the “perfect state”—the state that was most representative of the USA as a whole. They tested five criteria for a state’s population: racial makeup, educational attainment, age, median income, and religiosity. Illinois took the prize, mapping the country more closely than any other state in one category after another. In some important respects, Illinois is the country built to scale. You don’t have to be a native deeply attached to your home state to worry that if Illinois can’t make it, then maybe the country can’t either.

and it should give you a certain sense of foreboding. Illinois is the state most representative of the U. S. as a whole. If the U. S. adopts the practices that has caused Illinois’s decline, it will suffer from the same problems as Illinois.

What are those practices? Sadly, the article doesn’t really do much to explain them. The closest it comes is this. Political machines are like single-celled organisms:

The purpose of the machine is to keep the machine alive. This is the evolutionary stage that the Chicago machine, downstate version, has reached over Madigan’s long reign. There’s little chance that Rauner, given a second term, could reverse it, and no sign that Pritzker, once elected, would care to. Governor Pritzker’s political destiny will likely resemble that of Louisiana’s Oscar K. Allen, a puppet that the state’s true ruler, Huey Long, installed in the governor’s chair in the 1930s. He earned the nickname “OK.” “A leaf blew in through OK’s office window yesterday,” one observer said. “He signed it.”

So, what happened in Illinois? Political corruption is the obvious response but that’s no answer. Why the political corruption? You can’t blame old man Daley—the corruption preceded him. He was part of it rather than its cause.

In Illinois’s case I think the answer is complacency born of prosperity. You come to accept political corruption as long as the trains run on time and once the trains stop running on time it’s too late.

Illinois is not California or New York. I do not know a single person in Illinois who, like so many Californians or New Yorkers, cannot imagine life outside their home states. Illinois is a place that people live in and come to for work and Chicago, once known as the “city that works” is its epitome. When the work is gone, driven out by political corruption and politicians who think that Illinois is California or New York, the people will leave and it’s happening even as I write.

1 comment

Cynical Political Opportunism

I think that the editors of the Wall Street Journal strike about the right note in their remarks on the murders in Pittsburgh over the weekend:

Robert Bowers simply hated Jews.

This irrational hatred is one of humanity’s oldest and manifests itself in murder almost daily in the Middle East. Jews are killed simply because they are Jews, as they have been throughout history. This is why millions have sought refuge in a Jewish state, Israel, and also in the religious protections embedded in the Constitution of the United States.

The outpouring of support and grief for the victims of the Pittsburgh massacre is a reminder of America’s unique role as a refuge for the world’s religious. Muslim states often persecute non-Muslims as well as Muslims who do not share their brand of Islam. China persecutes people of all faiths. America protects them.

The U.S. has seen an increase in anti-Semitic acts in recent years, according to the Anti-Defamation League. But there are still fewer in America than in most of the rest of world, and the sources of anti-Semitism range across the political spectrum, including some on the right like Robert Bowers but also from the pro-Palestinian left, especially on university campuses.

I understand that people are shocked and in grief but the notion that Jews are not safer here than in any European country and even safer here than in Israel is simply without basis. Based on the FBI’s hate crimes statistics and European anti-Semitic hate crimes statistics the incidence of such crimes is an order of magnitude greater in France and the United Kingdom than it is here and five times as great in Germany or Sweden than here. And anti-Semitism is considerably stronger in Eastern Europe than in Western Europe.

Hatred of Jews didn’t start last year or the year before—it’s been around for millennia. The temperature is rising in the U. S. and Jews are the canaries in the coal mine to mix metaphors. While I agree that President Trump needs to moderate his rhetoric, the notion that Trump is the only problem is cynical political opportunism.

8 comments

The U. S. Is Still Different

I have now simmered down enough to write about this. Yes, anti-Semitism is a problem and it’s an ancient problem. However, the United States has never sent soldiers into the homes of Jews or Jewish places of worship, dragging them off for imprisonment or execution. France, Germany, Russia, Spain, Belgium, the Netherlands, Iran, Egypt, and any number of other countries have. Many of them within living memory.

Drawing an equivalence between anti-Semitism in the U. S. and that in other countries is at best alarmist and poorly informed. In Pittsburgh first responders, i.e. the police, arrived in a timely manner to help Jews not to kill them.

That is not to defend anti-Semitism in any way, shape, or form. But a difference in degree is a difference in kind.

8 comments

Two Points on Businesses’ Foreign Operations

You can’t read a lot of opinion pieces about diplomacy or trade without two things leaping out at you about American writers. They are incredibly ignorant of American history and even more ignorant about other societies. That’s what struck me in Michael Schulman’s piece at Bloomberg on the “localized operations” set up in other countries by American companies:

There are many such examples of U.S. companies localizing their operations to target the Chinese market. General Motors Co. manufactures nearly all the cars it sells in China within the country. It even has a car brand, Baojun, developed for and only marketed to Chinese drivers. The vast majority of what the Procter & Gamble Co. sells to Chinese consumers is made locally. The company boasts nine manufacturing plants in China.

Such sales don’t directly factor into the bilateral trade data. Yet it most certainly adds to those companies’ bottom lines. GM and its partners sold one million more vehicles in China than in the U.S. last year. China is P&G’s second-largest market after the U.S. Only Americans eat more Oreos than Chinese do.

The local sway of U.S. companies is an indication of just how sophisticated and global they’ve become. With appealing brands and extensive international expertise, American firms very often invest and manufacture in foreign markets instead of exporting their products from the U.S. By contrast, Chinese companies, like those in emerging markets generally, tend to lack brand power and experience operating abroad. So they capitalize on their low-cost base to export to the U.S. and elsewhere.

That’s reflected in the great disparity of direct investment between the U.S. and China. Since 1990, U.S. companies have invested almost twice as much in China — $256 billion — as Chinese companies have in the U.S. And a huge chunk of China’s investment has been made in only the past two years. To a certain extent, the trade deficit is thus a mark of how much more advanced U.S. corporations are compared to their Chinese counterparts.

Of course, there’s been much hand-wringing over the loss of American jobs due to trade with China as factory work has shifted overseas. But in many cases, the plants constructed in China weren’t replacements for those in the U.S.; they were built to meet local needs. In certain industries, such as P&G’s household wares, shipping from far-off locales is expensive and impractical.

Fortunately, economies are never static and, over time, the disparity between the U.S. and China should narrow naturally. It’s almost certain that, barring a complete collapse of relations between the world’s two largest economies, Chinese companies will expand their presence in the U.S. market and hire American workers as they become more global.

Right off the bat is any of that familiar to you? That’s exactly what American pundits were saying 30 years ago about China. If only we wait long enough and liberalize our trade with them, China will naturally liberalize its politics. The only problem with that is that it was wrong. That hasn’t happened and it hasn’t happened because China is different from the United States. Why can’t Americans come to terms with the reality that other countries are, well, other countries?

Second, U. S. companies didn’t set up operations in France, Germany, Brazil, and dozens of other countries in order to tailor their products to local conditions. They did so because they were compelled to by the governments of those countries. We “localized” because we were forced to. That is the actual history and to deny it is absurd.

If we require the Chinese to do the same things they require of U. S. companies, that they accept U. S. “partners”, that they transfer their technology to those partners, and that goods sold in the U. S. should be manufactured in the U. S., will Chinese companies comply in order to increase their sales? Frankly, I doubt it. Their objective isn’t to maximize sales. It’s to maximize the number of jobs in China.

3 comments

Lower the Temperature

First, a Trump-loving Florida Man sends pipebombs (functional or not) to variety of Democratic politicians and media figures. Yesterday, a Trump-hating anti-Semite murdered 11 people in a synagogue during a bris.

While I’m sure that there will be all sorts of recommendations for how to prevent future tragedies, I’m going to repeat an observation and a prescription I’ve made here more than once. The observation is that in a country of 330 million people there are always going to be a certain number of crazy people and it doesn’t take much to set them off.

The prescription is lower the temperature and it’s addressed to people writing on social media, people writing for major news outlets, politicians, and, particularly, President Trump. Lower the temperature. Express disagreement without rancor, your concerns without heat. Whipping up the crowd may be an effective way of motivating your supporters but it also has consequences you may not foresee.

Representative democracy depends on moderation and reasoned discourse. Enraged followers doth not a democracy make but a mobocracy and mobs have dynamics all their own.

Years ago I heard a wisecrack that in California a political party was two people and a television set. Now that’s all over the country and it’s one person posting on Facebook. Tone it down just as a matter of self-defense.

11 comments

Where Do You Get Your News?

Based on Pew Research’s findings social media users are increasingly getting their news from their preferred social media sites and, considering that for most social media sites more of their users get their news from the sites than from cable news, broadcast news, or newspapers, it’s a reasonable inference that quite some number of people get their news from social media alone.

The use of social media by Russia, China, and anyone else so predisposed for publishing disinformation and “fake news” is now well-documented and should give us pause. But not only that. The sites’ censorship rules themselves, removing anything that their censors find offensive, is doubly concerning. Consider this story from the New York Times:

For a few hours after The New York Times published an article about conflict and hunger in Yemen, Facebook temporarily removed posts from readers who had tried to share the report on the social platform.

At issue was a photograph of a starving child.

The article included several images of emaciated children. Some were crying. Some were listless. One, a 7-year-old girl named Amal, was shown gazing to the side, with flesh so paper-thin that her collarbone and rib cage were plainly visible. Tens of thousands of readers shared the article on Facebook, but some got a message notifying them that the post was not in line with Facebook’s community standards.

Whether Facebook and other social media sites recognize it or not they’re deliberately slanting the news and considering how much their stock values depend on what people think of them, that should be of significant concern.

2 comments

The Myriad Forms of Ice

There’s an interesting article on Ice VII, which purportedly is created at high velocities, over at Motherboard:

Research published earlier this month in Physical Review Letters suggests that an exotic phase of water, known as “ice VII” could grow at rates exceeding 1,000 miles per hour under the atmospheric conditions found on alien ocean worlds.

Water exists in three main phases (solid, liquid, and gas) and the phase it occupies is a function of atmospheric pressure and temperature. The solid form of water—ice—has several phases of its own, however most of them exist at extremely low temperatures (but some of them can exist at temperatures upwards of 1300 degrees fahrenheit so long as the pressure is high enough.

They say that theoretically there are 17 different phases of ice. I think I’ve seen all of them on my front sidewalk.

4 comments