Breaking Eggs

The editors of the New York Times are, apparently, four square behind a regressive tax on poor residents of Washington State:

Climate scientists and economists have long argued that the single best way to slow global warming is to put a price on greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels and raise that price over time, thus creating a sensible market incentive to reduce emissions and invest in cleaner energy sources. Carbon pricing was also high on the list of urgent recommendations of the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which warned in a major report this month that without swift action to control emissions the world will begin suffering global warming’s worst consequences — including, but not limited to, the displacement of millions of people by drought and sea-level rise — as early as 2040, much sooner than previously forecast.

It is thus encouraging that in this time of torpor and climate denial at the highest levels of the federal government, voters in the state of Washington will soon be given the chance to adopt, by initiative, a carbon pricing plan that would charge polluters like refineries a fee for emitting greenhouse gases. This would be what economists call a Pigovian tax, after the British economist Arthur Pigou. In this case, the fee would factor in the now unaccounted for costs of more frequent and intense hurricanes, wildfires, droughts and other natural disasters linked to climate change. In the words of George Frampton, a senior environmental adviser to Bill Clinton and co-founder of a group that favors carbon taxes, Partnership for Responsible Growth, it’s an overdue stab at “honestly pricing carbon,” which industry has until now been able to hurl into the atmosphere pretty much for free.

presumably on the grounds that you can’t make an omelet without breaking eggs. My question is why are the eggs that are broken always poor eggs?

As structured Washington’s tax is regressive. It will hardest on the poor in the form of higher energy bills.

The record of carbon taxes in reducing carbon emissions is mixed but its record in raising revenue is strong. On the emissions side their biggest effect has been to give European bureaucrats more opportunities for graft.

A better-structured plan would be one that was much, much higher and prebated the tax on a scale based on income. Such a plan would fall more heavily on the rich who, since carbon emissions increase geometrically with respect to income (relatively few of the poor have private jets or 10,000 sqft mansions), apparently need greater incentives to reduce their carbon emissions.

4 comments

What the Midterms Will Turn On

There’s a pretty good analysis of the issues the midterm elections will turn on by A. B. Stoddard at RealClearPolitics which I commend to your attention. The issues include immigration, domestic terrorism, and health care just to name a few. Here’s a snippet:

The separation of families was a liability for the GOP, but the caravan was midterm manna for Trump. It began at just the right time for him to tell Americans watching hordes of people traveling from Honduras and Guatemala that criminal elements, including various and sundry “Middle Easterners,” were intent upon invading the homeland. More than 5,000 active military personnel are now deployed to convince voters something is being done, and this number could stretch, Trump says, to 15,000 or more. Though no laws have been changed, and no new restrictions on asylum have been enacted, what is likely is that when the dwindled caravan arrives, its entry will surely be more organized and less dysfunctional with active duty troops on hand.

Read the whole thing. Her conclusion, meekly enough, is that it’s hard to tell what will actually happen.

Frankly, I doubt that most of the House elections or for governor will be on national issues and I’ll still be skeptical even when the major media outlets declaim that the election was a referendum on Trump, about health care, or about immigration. All politics remains local and we don’t conduct national referenda. The winners are likely either to be incumbents or the candidate best able to convince voters of their bona fides or both.

8 comments

What Are They Trying to Accomplish?

I’ve got to admit that I have no idea what the editors of the Wall Street Journal were trying to accomplish with their most recent editorial on the recent ups and downs of the stock market:

Stocks bounced back Wednesday, but before that the tech-heavy Nasdaq had slumped 12% since its August peak. Falling FAANG stocks— Facebook , Apple, Amazon, Netflix and Google parent Alphabet—have swung the S&P 500 into a correction zone. Netflix tumbled 21% and Amazon fell 20% in October. Texas Instruments , IBM and Nvidia have also seen substantial stock price declines.

A tech revaluation was perhaps inevitable as prices leapt over earnings like LeBron James over Kevin Durant. Amazon’s stock in September was trading at nearly 160 times earnings, which wasn’t going to last. But what makes this month’s tech sale so jarring is that it comes amid strong quarterly earnings growth.

and

It’s not surprising that investors are struggling to price tech stocks properly amid this evolving regulatory and competitive landscape while factoring in stronger U.S. growth and rising interest rates. Big tech was one of the few industries that prospered during the economic malaise under Barack Obama and thus naturally attracted more investors.

Tech stocks also received a boost from the Fed’s monetary exertions that kept the federal funds rate at nearly zero for years and suppressed long-term rates with quantitative easing. Investors thirsting for higher yields piled into riskier assets, and some are now retreating as the Fed unwinds its balance sheet and raises rates.

This return to realism is unfortunate for some investors but shouldn’t undermine the larger economy. The S&P is still up 21% since January 2017. It isn’t bad news if investors steer more capital to other productive businesses that can propel American growth.

The facts of the matter have been quite obvious for most of the last decade. The stock market, particularly the major indices, have become virtually detached from the greater economy. The values of a handful of tech stocks are impossible to justify based on the companies’ performance or just about anything else. The runup in those stocks accounts for most of the increase in the major stock indices over the last decade. And reselling of stocks does nothing to “steer more capital to other productive businesses that can propel American growth”. Only initial stock offerings do that. What percent of the total trade in stocks does the initial market comprise? 1%? 2%?

What’s their point? What goes up come come down?

2 comments

The Crowded Theater

It isn’t very frequently that I agree with remarks of Megan McArdle’s as I did with these paragraphs from her most recent Washington Post column:

Trump’s rhetoric about immigrants and others appalls me. But that’s not in the same category as establishing a fascist dictatorship. Nor is tightening our immigration policy very much like invading other countries and sending millions of citizens to extermination camps. It’s offensive lunacy to suggest that these things are somehow inextricably linked.

And it’s not much more reasonable to claim a direct causal link between Trump’s rhetoric and the monstrous synagogue shooting in Pittsburgh, as is now happening. Jews are not among the groups Trump is known for slandering, and America has a pernicious history of anti-Semitic violence long pre-dating Trump. Sadly, there were deadly attacks at Jewish centers under both Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama.

So, no, friends, I’m not arguing that Trump is Hitler, or even Hitler Lite. I’m entirely confident that even if he wanted to trash the Constitution and impose a racist dictatorship, neither the institutions of the United States nor the people of the United States would permit it.

But one can dislike the president’s unpleasantly evocative phraseology without thinking the dark night of fascism must therefore be almost upon us. One merely needs to ask: Are Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia really the rhetorical company we want to keep? As conservatives, or as a nation?

A “slippery slope” argument is the claim that one step will lead to another step, ultimately culminating in some disastrous outcome. It is a form of proof by consequences. But sometimes an event is just an event, one step does not lead to a greater step, and the feared disastrou outcome is neither inevitable nor even likely. That is what’s called the “slippery slope fallacy”.

I console myself about the rhetorical excesses in reaction to Trump’s rhetorical excesses by believing that they’re just political posturing. Once a politician has engaged in political posturing 1,000 times it’s not too much of a stretch to think that the 1,001st rhetorical excess if probably political posturing, too.

My reaction to somebody who’s yelling “Fire” in a crowded theater first to assess whether there actually is a fire. If there is not I’d tell him not to yell “Fire” and try to calm the crowd. I would also be inclined to wonder why the theater was overcrowded to begin with. My reaction is not to drag a barrel of kerosene into the theater and I have to wonder about anyone who would.

16 comments

What Does “Socialism” Mean to Them?

I don’t think that James Freeman should be overly concerned with the views of today’s college students. From his WSJ column:

When asked for their opinions of capitalism, 45% said they have a favorable view, 31% expressed an unfavorable view and the rest had no opinion, were unsure, or didn’t answer. Not exactly a ringing endorsement of the property rights that have made the United States the most prosperous nation in history, pulled billions of people out of poverty around the world and enabled, among other things, the funding of great universities.

[…]

In fact few things in life are more harsh than living in a socialist economy. What’s the best way to help the youngsters avoid having to learn this lesson first-hand? Perhaps parents will choose not to leave their children’s education entirely up to tenured professionals and instead opt to assign readings on their own. Along these lines they might consider adding requirements each semester for any children who want tuitions paid on time. For example, students could be instructed to read and be prepared to discuss “The Opportunity Costs of Socialism” over Thanksgiving dinner.

I suspect that what most young people think socialism means is getting free stuff and helping poor people. The track record of state socialism—all that present U. S. “democratic socialists” are considering, when given free rein, is not good in those respects.

The track record seems to show that government in Europe is more benign and less grasping and, consequently, more trusted there than here. In the United States whether under alleged capitalism or alleged socialism government inevitably becomes a force for generating wealth for the rulers.

If there’s one think we know about youth it’s that it’s curable. The most straightforward way to combat state socialism in the United States is to ensure that young people have more to lose.

6 comments

Think the Minuet in G

In his WSJ column Holman Jenkins remarks about a New York lawsuit against Exxon:

Despite its general lack of merit, a lawsuit by the New York attorney general’s office is an entertaining symbol of all that has gone wrong with the green movement in the era of climate-change politics.

Exxon is accused of failing to adopt sufficiently penitential accounting for its oil and gas projects in light of climate regulations that, ahem, don’t exist. Indeed, politicians around the world have declined to enact the green wish list even when given the chance, notwithstanding their endless verbal opposition to climate change.

Presume for a moment the accusations against Exxon are accurate. Then greens should actually be glad because Exxon has spared them future embarrassment when the company is forced to increase the recorded value of its assets to account for the failure of green politics to deliver the expected carbon regulations.

Words are challenged to express how laughable this case is. Before getting lost in distinctions that Exxon internally draws (and the attorney general muddles) between project-specific costs and policies that would suppress demand for fossil fuels generally, let’s remember a few things.

Like all businesses, Exxon seeks to take only those risks that will pay off, and has every incentive to anticipate future regulatory costs correctly. The attorney general’s office and its green backers have an entirely different purpose: They want Exxon to use its internal disciplines to prevent oil and gas development even if it would pay off.

This suit highlights a gripe of mine. How policy is constructed and how it relates to the real world are important. You have to consider actual conditions and how actual people and companies will behave. You can’t govern by The Think System any more than you can learn to play the bassoon by it.

It matters, for example, whether European governments have been calculating their countries’ reductions in emissions based on presumed inputs or based on measurements. If it’s the former, they may not have accomplished anything at all since we know that not just VW but other companies selling diesel-powered automobiles falsified their results. It matters whether the wood pellets that Germans are using to heat their homes to avoid coal or nuclear power were milled from recent growth or old growth. Having good intentions and wishful thinking aren’t enough.

2 comments

Their Own Worst Enemies

In an op-ed at the Wall Street Journal scholar Michael Auslin remarks on developments in Chinese foreign policy and politics:

China will remain an integral part of the global economy. Its strengthening military will give it influence beyond Asia. And its political voice will be heard in international councils. Yet the world now understands the dark side of doing business with Beijing, while Chinese citizens chafe against Mr. Xi’s increasing domestic repression. With the Chinese Communist Party unwilling to reform, Beijing faces major strains ahead.

The Chinese government has linked economic aid to its strategic objectives. In particular, its Belt and Road initiative has promised $1 trillion of infrastructure spending throughout Eurasia. But Chinese aid increasingly is seen as a “debt trap” ensnaring less-powerful nations. They often surrender key facilities or agree to a greater Chinese presence in their countries after they becoming unable to repay development loans.

Malaysia and longtime Chinese ally Pakistan have announced they will be cutting back on Sino-funded projects for fear of indebtedness to Beijing. A recent election in the Maldives oriented the small Indian Ocean nation away from China. Expect more skittishness on the part of potential Chinese partners in vital locations around the globe.

Beijing’s heavy hand against foreign corporations—for example, demanding they list Taiwan as part of China or risk repercussions to their businesses—also is wearing Western patience thin. And the U.S. and Europe are angry over decades of rampant intellectual-property theft. Many companies are playing along for fear of losing China’s market, but they will take the first opportunity to rebuff Beijing’s demands.

Another blow has come courtesy of Mr. Trump. However much criticized at home, his tariff war is hitting China’s economy hard. Its stock market is around a four-year low, while Beijing’s bluster is offset by repeated overtures to resolve the confrontation. Thanks to China’s $350 billion trade surplus with the U.S., Washington can target a broad range of Chinese goods with tariffs. The damage to American firms from the current trade war may be significant, but China can’t weather a prolonged battle nearly as well.

The trade war has highlighted other weaknesses in the Chinese economy. Doubts about the country’s official 6.7% economic growth are widespread, while its massive debt burden, estimated at 300% of gross domestic product, raises alarms, especially within the private and state-owned-enterprise sector. Some Chinese businesses have gone on foreign spending sprees and now seek to unload their holdings. Insurance giant Anbang, for example, wants to sell its $5.5 billion real estate portfolio, which includes the Waldorf Astoria Hotel. Beijing has clamped down on other big spenders, due to fears of corporate failures as well as an overheated property market. Rampant speculation has led to regional bans on corporate property purchases amid concerns of a real estate bubble.

All these problems come on the heels of increased repression in China. Mr. Xi, now president for life, has created a cult of personality unseen since the Mao era. He dominates his putative co-leaders, and his anticorruption campaign served to eliminate potential elite opposition figures. He has clamped down on civil society with impunity.

The country also is poised to become the world’s first total surveillance state. It already has 200 million surveillance cameras and plans to operate more than 600 million, all using the most advanced facial recognition software. This even extends to special glasses worn by the police.

Despite Mr. Xi’s repressive policies, the first signs of discontent have emerged. Mr. Xi’s ambitious reform program, first unveiled in 2013, has resulted in little change. A critique of the government from a professor at the prestigious Tsinghua University recently went viral, while Chinese officials have begun to walk back their boastfulness about the state of the economy. Mr. Xi has had to defend his propaganda blitz.

There are still hundreds, likely thousands, of protests every year against official corruption and the government’s heavy hand. Then there is the severe yet largely hidden repression of Muslim Uighurs in Xinjiang, where as many as one million are reported to be held in modern concentration camps. Combined with its repressive policies in Tibet, the Chinese Communist Party has engendered a seething hatred from the country’s minorities.

No one should expect a revolution soon in China. And as shown by El Salvador’s recent switch of diplomatic recognition from Taipei to Beijing, its economic pull remains attractive to many poor nations. But China’s road ahead is increasingly rocky. Far from adopting many of the norms of the postwar world, Beijing has attempted to rewrite them in its own favor. Now the question is how far will China’s leaders go in curbing their assertive behavior and rapacious policies. Sticking to the current path will lead to greater tension between China and the world and risk more unrest at home.

Chinese politics are more opaque if anything to us than their government or economy are. My advice: ignore the press releases and observe the behavior. If the Chinese people behave as though the Chinese economy is in recession, it probably is. If China’s authorities behave as though they were losing control, they probably are.

I don’t think we should waste time trying to discern what will happen in China or what we want China to do. In particular we need not be concerned that China’s influence will eclipse our own. I have confidence that the Chinese authorities will be their own worst enemies. I think we should reserve our attention to what will happen in the United States and what we will do.

0 comments

What Is “Under the Jurisdiction”?

The editors of the New York Times, the Washington Post and the Wall Street Journal are all convinced that President Trump has put his foot in it by declaiming that he’ll limit birthright citizenship by executive order one week before the midterm elections. Here’s the WSJ’s take:

Mr. Trump has the political high ground as long as he is trying to stop lawlessness or deter migrant caravans mobilized by left-wing groups in Central America. Even deploying soldiers to the border in nonmilitary roles can be justified to assist immigration agents overwhelmed by asylum seekers. The U.S. has to send a signal that no one can bum-rush the border—not least to deter migrants from making a trip that will end in disappointment, or worse.

By contrast, the birth citizenship gambit puts Mr. Trump on the wrong side of immigration law and politics. Did Michael Cohen give him this legal advice?

The right to citizenship for anyone born on U.S. soil is derived from the Fourteenth Amendment adopted in 1868: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” This is the common law doctrine of jus soli, or right of the soil.

Opponents of birth citizenship try to obscure this plain meaning by interpreting “subject to the jurisdiction” as applying only to those who owe allegiance to America. Because alien parents owe allegiance to a different sovereign, the argument goes, their children have no right to citizenship.

or is he? Isn’t the meaning of the phrase “subject to the jurisdiction” a candidate for interpretation by the courts? Every case I have seen cited to date only pertains to the children of legal immigrants. In what sense is someone in the United States illegally, who doesn’t obey other U. S. laws, who doesn’t pay taxes other than unescapable use taxes, and who votes in the elections of other countries subject to the jurisdiction of the United States? I don’t know the answer to it but it seems to me to be a legal and political question.

Additionally, until Mr. Marshall arrogated to the courts the sole right to interpret the laws, difficult as it may be to credit, that right belonged equally to the courts, the other branches of government, and the citizenry. That was part of the common law.

As to the politics, the political streets are littered with the figurative corpses of people who’ve underestimated Donald Trump’s political acumen. I don’t know whether the American-born children of illegal aliens should have birthright citizenship. I do not know whether the 14th Amendment covers their case. I don’t know what the courts would decide on the subject. And I do not know whether stirring that particular pot is good politics or bad.

We will probably find out the answers to at least one of those questions very soon.

20 comments

Question

I have a question. Is nationalism on the part of whites the same as “white nationalism”?

Also, I can see the allure of a world without nationalism. I don’t think that a world in which the United States is the only country that isn’t nationalistic is particularly appealing.

6 comments

Blame America First

This isn’t in response to any particular article but to a whole raft of articles I’ve seen lately. People in South and Central America or people who have ties to the people of Latin America are strongly predisposed to blame the entire region’s problems on the United States. I’ve seen at least a dozen articles over the last week or so to that effect.

I won’t dispute that the U. S. has intervened in the affairs of Latin American countries and continues to do so or argue that our interventions have been benign. The record says otherwise. If it had been up to me I would not have so intervened but most of the intervention took place before I was born.

What I dispute is that we caused their problems. I think they have the causality backwards. Every repeat every country colonized by either Spain or Portugal has similar problems and those problems have moved us to intervene in those countries. We didn’t create a Mexico divided by race into social classes. That predates the existence of the U. S. let alone U. S. intervention.

As proof I would submit that even Latin American countries in which we have barely intervened have very similar problems and that countries South and Central American countries that weren’t colonized by Spain or Portugal tend to be more prosperous than those that were.

1 comment