The Great Orange Whale

In an op-ed in the New York Times billionaire environmentalist (that very phrase is so fraught with irony I can barely stand it) Tom Steyer illustrates handily why impeaching President Trump is likely to become for House Democrats what repealing ObamaCare was to House Republicans after the midterm elections of President Obama’s first term of office:

Should the establishment refuse to give up conventional orthodoxy and take up impeachment proceedings when the new Congress convenes, freshmen members — many of whom ran and won because of their promise to stand up to the president — must challenge the establishment and demand a say over the agenda. An overwhelming majority of people in this country elected them to hold this president accountable. There is no majority without them. That means no one has the votes for a leadership title without their support.

At a moment when just one-third of all Americans trust their government to do what is right, winning a majority has to mean much more than just frustrating Republican legislative goals and scoring debating points. Democrats must stand up for the safety of the American people and our entire democratic system.

We cannot allow this to be an argument about what Republicans will permit — it’s about demanding the truth and protecting the foundations of our free society. Anything less would mean abandoning the Constitution.

Basically, it will be an act of self-preservation. Their increasingly radicalized base will demand it. Not to mention increasingly radicalized big donors like Tom Steyer. When you take the king’s shilling, you are the king’s man.

3 comments

Smart But Gullible

In response to Mohammed El-Erian’s plea for Congress to unite on an infrastructure spending bill at The Hill:

Infrastructure is an area that in the past has attracted broad-based support. By potentially enhancing supply and demand at the same time, it is one of the few policy areas that simultaneously benefits both companies and workers. And it is a promising area if the U.S. is to maintain its strong economic and financial performance.

Like other advanced economies, our country faces the challenge of supplementing its short-term cyclical growth impulse with longer-term secular contributors.

Absent the required structural reforms, the economy will eventually experience what both Europe and Japan are feeling now: a slowdown in economic momentum, the threat of falling back into stagnation and a higher risk of recession and destabilizing financial volatility.

An infrastructure modernizing plan would be one of the ways to improve the probability of a more powerful cyclical-secular handoff. It would upgrade aging facilities that increase business cost and lower business efficiency. It would place the economy in a better position to benefit from technological innovations and compete internationally. And it would help crowd-in other sources of demand, investment and production.

I can only point out:

  1. Under present law the federal government bears much of the cost of new highway and bridge construction while state and local governments foot the bill for most of their maintenance.
  2. We do not have a great need for new highway or bridge construction.
  3. Such problems as exist are maintenance problems. The federal government is in no position to adjudicate among competing priorities at the state and local levels.
  4. Congress could appropriate $1 trillion in the form of block grants to state and local governments and it would disappear without a trace and without substantially improving roads and bridges.

If you really want to modernize and you want it to be financed at the federal level, the way to accomplish it is with a much more tightly defined and structured plan. A federal program to improve the power grid, analogous to the Interstate Highway System, would be a good way to do that. We could really use a better, smarter, more redundant power grid and private industry won’t construct it.

Mohammed El-Erian reminds me of an old joke about a man who moved to a small Maine town at two weeks of age, lived to 92, and died. On his tombstone his neighbors carved the message: “He was almost one of us”. I think that Mr. El-Erian is a very smart guy but also extremely naive about the United States and its politics. We are an enormously large, very decentralized, and complicated country. Our infrastructure problems aren’t due to a lack of money. They’re due to differing priorities and how the priorities are established.

7 comments

Money Matters. But How Much?

Boy, I really draw a different conclusion about Tuesday’s elections than the wisdom that’s emerging from the media. I think it underscores what Trump’s election in 2016 proved. There is a cadre of people who are extremely dissatisfied with politics as it was. And you can’t win an election simply by throwing money at it.

Yes, money continues to matter in electoral politics. But how much does it matter? Beto O’Rourke raised and spent nearly twice as much as incumbent Ted Cruz and was defeated nonetheless. On the other hand in Florida Rick Scott raised and spent about twice as much as Bill Nelson, the incumbent whom he defeated. In Missouri incumbent Claire McCAskill raised and spent more than three times as much as her challenger, Josh Hawley, and went down to defeat.

2 comments

The Connecting Thread

The news reports this morning are filled with the story of a gunman who walked into a Southern California nightclub and started killing people. Eleven are dead including the gunman who as of this writing remains unidentified. The sad event took place in Thousand Oaks, considered one of the safest communities in the country.

I predict that the reactions will be predictable with people merrily riding their hobbies. Some will claim that tougher gun controls would prevent recurrences of such events. Second Amendment advocates will chime in with claims that if the people in the club had been armed only the gunman would have been killed.

According to the reports the gunman was armed with a single handgun. Even if we were to repeal the Second Amendment and confiscate the hundreds of millions of handguns and long guns presently in Americans’ possession, it would not eliminate the possibility of one crazy person obtaining a firearms and killing people.

One of those killed was a sheriff’s deputy. Was he armed? I suspect he was. Were others in the club armed as well? If every single person in the club had been armed, I suspect that the death toll would have been higher as frightened people, not sure where the shots were coming from, killed each other in the crossfire.

There is a connecting thread between this, other similar events, and many, many other developments in modern life. Personal empowerment is dangerous. It’s dangerous when a single motivate individual, crazy or just angry, can kill a dozen people. It’s dangerous when people can move about, freely and unhindered, without being searched or even remarked on. It’s dangerous when people can publish whatever they care to, unrestrained and unmonitored by media or government watchdogs.

It will take a lot more to end events like this than disarming the law-abiding citizenry or arming everybody. It would take orders of magnitude more police officers, curfews, and surveillance checkpoints. We’d need a police state.

In a country of 330 million people there are bound to be many, many crazy, angry, or otherwise motivated people. We need to recognize that and decide how much liberty we’re willing to relinquish for imagined safety.

6 comments

The Wall Street Journal Is Pragmatic

Meanwhile, the editors of the Wall Street Journal are more pragmatic in their reactions:

This is largely Mr. Trump’s failure, and the nearby table from the October Wall Street Journal-NBC poll puts his problem in sharp relief. While 44% of voters approve of Mr. Trump’s policies, nearly half of them dislike him personally. That 20% is five times the percentage who disliked George W. Bush but liked his policies when he lost the House in 2006, and 10 times the share that disliked Barack Obama in 2013.

More glaringly, the share of voters who dislike Mr. Trump personally but like his policies increased in the past two years. This is extraordinary for a new President and shows the extent of his missed opportunity. Some two-thirds of voters on Tuesday expressed satisfaction with the state of the economy, and these are people he’d win if he didn’t alienate them with his persona.

Unlike Richard Nixon or Ronald Reagan, Mr. Trump has made no effort to build a larger coalition than the minority who helped win the Presidency narrowly over Hillary Clinton. Instead he has played constantly to his base who are already loyal. If he wants to be re-elected, he will have to win over more of those suburban Republicans and independents.

Mr. Trump’s closing argument on immigration also looks to have been a bust. It didn’t help in suburban districts and may have cost Republican Carlos Curbelo his House seat in South Florida. White House aide Stephen Miller bears much of the responsibility for this misjudgment. He advised Mr. Trump to walk away from a potential deal trading legalization for the so-called Dreamers in return for money for border security and “the wall.” Then he urged the border crackdown that became the fiasco of family separation that further turned off suburban voters.

Mr. Trump could have improved his chances to hold the House by accepting a deal and declaring a border victory. Suburban Republicans want border security, but they also want a humane and generous immigration policy. Mr. Trump needs to rethink his immigration strategy for 2020.

The other liability for Republicans was their failure to repeal and replace health care. Democrats played on voter fears of repeal but the GOP could never point to the benefits of a replacement they didn’t pass. Then too many Republicans simply ran away from the subject, giving Democrats an open field. The late Senator John McCain delivered the final blow against reform, but the general GOP incoherence on the subject was also to blame.

I think I would be a little harsher on the Republicans than that. The Republicans need a health care policy beyond repealing the Affordable Care Act. Other than their opposition to ObamaCare they’re basically AWOL on the issue and Democrats took advantage of that vacuum.

I’ve got to admit that I have no idea what a viable Republican health care policy beyond repealing ObamaCare might be. They may have painted themselves into an ideological corner.

24 comments

The Washington Post Is Jubilant

And the editors of the Washington Post are jubilant:

THE DEMOCRATS’ return to control over the House of Representatives is much more than a victory for one party. It is a sign of health for American democracy.

Distrustful of untrammeled majorities, the authors of the Constitution favored checks and balances, including, crucially, the check that the legislative branch might place upon the executive. Over the past two years, the Republican majorities in the House and Senate have failed to exercise reasonable oversight. Now the constitutional system has a fresh chance to work as intended.

The Democratic victory is also a sign of political health, to the extent it is a form of pushback against the excesses, rhetorical and in terms of policy, committed by the Trump administration and propounded by President Trump during this fall’s campaign. Turning against the dominant party in Washington even in a moment of economic prosperity, voters from Key West to Kansas refused to accept the continued degradation of their nation’s political culture. Republicans retained control of the Senate, where the map this year favored their defense. But voters nationwide refused Mr. Trump’s invitation to vote on the basis of fear of immigrants; they did not respond to his depiction of his opposition as dangerous enemies.

Now the House will be in a position to investigate any number of potential administration transgressions and demand accountability: the awful separation of migrant children from their parents; the dubious decision to add a question about citizenship to the 2020 Census; the president’s harassment of special counsel Robert S. Mueller III’s investigation.

The new majority also has an opportunity to offer a positive legislative agenda. The Democrats achieved their victory Tuesday night in large part by promising to protect health-care coverage, especially for Americans with preexisting conditions. Though effective in winning over moderate voters, the campaign did not establish a clear mandate for much beyond that — eminently valid — objective. And of course, even if the Democrats set forth a list of specific proposals for the House, before or after Election Day, the Senate and Mr. Trump’s veto pen could block it.

Still, the party can outline an alternative policy direction for the country. It can begin with measures to shore up the Affordable Care Act but then move to reforms of federal gun laws. Where the Republican majority has denied science, the Democrats can offer an approach to climate change. They can propose relief to the “dreamers” and, ideally, other undocumented immigrants, along with generous but not unlimited opportunities for future legal immigration. They should propose to restore the United States to its rightful place as a welcomer of refugees; to end the disgraceful denial of congressional representation to citizens in the District of Columbia; to repeal the most egregious giveaways to the rich in the 2017 tax bill.

Tuesday was a good day for Democrats. It may also be a good day for Republicans, if they take the lessons of their House defeat to heart and reconsider the devil’s bargain they have made with Mr. Trump. Indeed, if the results help lead to a reemergence of that party’s better angels, then it will have been good day for America as a whole.

I wish they had actually mentioned some excesses other than President Trump’s intemperate speech. I can think of a few. Many considered Trump’s “Muslim ban” excessive. Troops to the border? I thought that while cutting corporate income taxes was long overdue cutting personal income taxes at the same time was excessive. What else? It sounds to me as through the excesses they’re complaining about are failures to enact their own pet priorities, an odd diction.

4 comments

The New York Times Is Hopeful

The editors of the New York Times strike a hopeful note:

For the midterms, Democrats adopted a trio of policy goals: lowering health care costs, creating jobs by investing in infrastructure, and cleaning up politics via a comprehensive reform package that would tighten ethics laws and shore up the integrity of our electoral system. These are popular causes with bipartisan appeal.

First up on the Democrats’ agenda is expected to be the reform package. But they also plan to move quickly to address the plight of the Dreamers, some 700,000 immigrants brought to the United States illegally as children and granted protection from deportation by President Barack Obama. Huge majorities of Americans support letting the Dreamers stay. Finding a compromise path with Mr. Trump would be good policy and good politics.

Of course, even if the president is interested in chalking up a few bipartisan wins, the Republican Senate is unlikely to play along. There’s nothing wrong with Democrats pursuing legislation, such as to raise the minimum wage, that fills out their governing priorities even if, for now, it does little more than clarify the contrasts between their priorities and their opposition’s.

I will admit that I struggled with that adjective.

Despite my misgivings I’d actually support the agenda of the first two quoted paragraphs. I think the editors would be disappointed at the actual number of jobs funding for more roads and bridges, the way “infrastructure” is typically defined these days. We don’t really need more roads and bridges and maintaining them is mostly the job of state and local governments. Contractors who can meet the bidding requirements already have all of the equipment and employees they need. And “lowering health care costs” has come to mean lowering out-of-pocket costs to consumers rather than actually reducing costs. Time will tell what might be meant in this instance.

I think it’s far more likely that, aping the Republicans under President Obama, we’ll see a constant stream of investigations, politics masquerading as oversight, and the House will signify their virtue by sending a stream of bills including a $15 national minimum wage, rescinding the cuts in the personal and business income taxes enacted under the last Congress, and environmental legislation, maybe even including a carbon tax to the Senate where they’ll die in silence.

4 comments

Pritzker Beats Rauner

Billionaire Democrat J. B. Pritzker has defeated billionaire Republican incumbent Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner in his bid for re-election. The Chicago Tribune reports:

Billionaire Democrat J.B. Pritzker on Tuesday soundly defeated first-term Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner, who conceded his re-election bid less than an hour after the polls closed, giving Democrats near total control of Illinois’ state government.

“Voting is an act of optimism that the levers of our Democracy still work,” Pritzker told supporters moments after declaring victory. “You embody that optimism. You light the beacon fire on the hill of history that signals from one generation to another that these are the things that we stand and fight for.”

In conceding defeat, Rauner called for unity after a grueling, bitter race in which the two candidates accused each other of criminal activity. They broke national campaign funding records by tapping their personal fortunes for hundreds of millions of dollars.

“This is a time for us to come together,” Rauner said. “This is a time for us to unite.” The governor called Pritzker before speaking to the crowd at his campaign party and promised a smooth transition, Rauner’s campaign said.

I sincerely wish the governor-elect the best. I am not optimistic. Earlier I characterized the contest as of a governor who couldn’t do anything and a challenger who wouldn’t do anything. I see little reason to change that view.

The reality is that Illinois is completely under the control of Mike Madigan and John Cullerton, Illinois House and Senate leaders. There was never any prospect for compromise between them and Rauner. There will be no need for compromise between them and Gov. Pritzker.

Governor-elect Pritzker based his campaign on two planks: enacting a graduated state income tax in Illinois and an ambitious series of spending initiatives include increases in infrastructure, health care, and education spending, an intriguing choice in a state that can’t pay its bills as it is. Illinois’s constitution mandates a flat state income tax. In the entire course of the campaign not a single reporter asked Mr. Pritzker for a list of Illinois legislators that would commit to amending the constitution. I don’t believe there are any and one of the governor-elect’s signature proposals will die on the vine. Illinois already has the highest sales tax in the nation and one of the highest property taxes. The only place to look for new revenue is the income tax.

I predict that by the end of Gov. Pritzker’s first term another half million Illinoisans will have left Illinois for other states, taking their tax dollars with them. About half of those will be black Chicagoans, sick of violence, rising taxes, and decreasing city services.

0 comments

Division of Power

As things look now the Democrats have taken the majority of seats in the U. S. House of Representatives. ABC News reports:

President Donald Trump will wake up to a different Washington when Democrats formally take control of the House of Representatives on Jan. 3, as a tectonic shift in power will begin to unleash a succession of new legal and political challenges for his administration.

“I want to look at all the things the president has done that go against the mandates of our Founding Fathers in the Constitution,” said Rep. Elijah Cummings, the Maryland Democrat who is poised to take control of the powerful House Oversight Committee. “We need accountability, transparency, integrity, and honesty from this Administration.”

Democrats swept to power, having campaigned on the promise of providing a stronger check on the Trump administration. That pledge could initiate bruising legal battles over congressional subpoenas, a stack of demands for documents and testimony from federal agencies — including Trump’s tax returns — and withering investigations into facets of Trump’s personal life, his family business, and his government.

The results have unfolded very much as I have been predicting for months. The Democrats will control the House by 5-10 seats, a narrower majority than the Republican control they will be supplanting. Republicans appear to have netted 2 seats in the Senate.

A number of widely-touted newly emerging Democratic stars failed to secure election including Andrew Gillum in Florida, Beto O’Rourke in Texas, and Stacey Abrams in Georgia. Expect challenges, particularly in Florida and Georgia. They may drag on for years. I also anticipate even more bitter complaints about our present system of representative government. The failure of the “blue wave” to materialize will be blamed on dirty tricks, gerrymandering, and racism. While those are undoubtedly factors, the real cause is that there are genuine differences of opinion.

Democrats and Republicans alike will proclaim victory. It’s already happening with President Trump’s declaring the elections a success. However they paint it winning is better than losing.

Rather than dwelling on the debatable I’d like to focus on what cannot be denied. The Democrats have won the House and picked up some governors’ mansions which will be good for them in 2020. The Republicans strengthened their hold on the Senate.

The new House will have more women in it than any in previous history. It will also be slightly younger than the previous House.

In my opinion advocates will be disappointed with the results. The House and Senate remain firmly under the control of the party leaders, overwhelmingly old and white. More women in the House will make less difference than they might have hoped.

I see no basis whatever for a more businesslike Congress, eager to get to the work of the American people. I’ll be surprised if anything whatever is accomplished over the next two years other than a continuing stream of fruitless investigations.

2 comments

Doug’s Predictions

At Outside the Beltway Doug Mataconis makes his predictions for the midterm elections:

Taking all of that into account, here’s my prediction for the House:

Current makeup of the House:

Republicans — 235 seats
Democrats — 193 seats
Vacant — 7 seats

Makeup of the House after Election Day:

Democrats — 230 seats
Republicans — 205 seats

Net Democratic gain +37 seats

while for the Senate he predicts no net change.

That’s essentially what I’ve been predicting for months now although I think the Republicans will probably do slightly better than he does, gaining a seat in the Senate and losing the House more narrowly than he predicts.

However, as pundits chastened by their own poor predictive performance in 2016 have been saying, anything can happen. Democrats could pick up 60 seats in the House and a half dozen in the Senate; Republicans could pick up several seats in the Senate and hold the House. It depends not just on how many voters show up to vote but whose voters show up and on that the polls may just be flat wrong.

12 comments