Vacancy

Well, that’s something I didn’t know. According to this article at Bloomberg, 30% of apartments in China are vacant. I’m not sure how anyone knows what the vacancy rate actually is. I’m pretty confident that if reports that it’s 30% get out at all, it’s at least 30% and could be much higher.

Note: China’s working age population has already peaked.

3 comments

Congressional Nonfeasance

It would help if the “bipartisan, bicameral Select Committee to design a package of budget process changes to improve the timeliness and efficiency of federal budgeting” that Brookings refers to were something other than a strategy for doing nothing while appearing to be doing something.

Our experience is not good. Bowles-Simpson. Peterson-Pew. Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. Kerrey-Danforth. Plenty of good ideas. Not much in the way of practical results.

Congress has decided that its best strategy is to do nothing and there is a bipartisan consensus on that. That’s the bureaucrat’s decision. You’re less likely to get blamed for doing nothing than for doing the wrong thing. Is it any wonder that Congress’s approval rating is significantly lower than Trump’s?

As Sam Clemens put it more than a century ago, the U. S. has no native criminal class excepting, of course, the Congress. Or Will Rogers 90 years ago: “This country has come to feel the same when Congress is in session as when the baby gets hold of a hammer.”

Large percentages of Americans think their owner Congressmen are corrupt, under the control of special interests, and out of touch with their districts. Nonetheless they’re returned to office year after year because 51% (and I do mean 51%) of voters think they deserve to be re-elected. That’s the untold story of the last election. Most incumbents were re-elected.

0 comments

Conservatism of Disconnection

I think there’s something that Pete Peterson is missing in his post about the “conservatism of connection” at RealClearPolicy:

What began with some contentious conversations about the president evolved into deeper discussion about these historic levels of alienation, and how an “invitational conservatism” focused on defending civic institutions — including a healthy patriotism — is the necessary response to this era of disconnection. Out of three days of deliberations, we composed a principles document titled, “A Way Forward,” defining a term we’ve come to call a “conservatism of connection.”

“Authentic conservatism is essentially about three connections.” The essay lists:

  1. Connection to the Past: We retain from our heritage what is valuable and worth cherishing
  2. Connection to Our Future: We innovate as conditions change to adapt inherited ways to new conditions
  3. Connection to One Another: Through America’s famed mediating institutions, we connect to one another in achieving the common good.

This is the conservatism of Burke’s “little platoons,” Tocqueville’s “individualism rightly understood,” and also of Robert Nisbet’s “quest for community,” Russell Kirk’s commitment to “voluntary communities”, and, more recently, Rod Dreher’s “crunchy cons.” This conservatism of connection confronts radical individualism and exclusive forms of community on all fronts — from Ayn Rand’s “Galt’s Gulch” nirvana on the right to the left’s identity politics.

which is that not all people called “conservative” are conservative in any discernible way. Burkean conservatives, paleocons (William F. Buckley-style conservatives, mostly over 70), and social conservatives are. Anarcho-capitalist objectivists aren’t. Neoconservatives aren’t. And what to make of “Trump conservatives”?

Here’s the problem: those three latter groups have disproportionate influence.

1 comment

The Art of Polling Has Become Tougher

According to Tom Bevan’s post at RealClearPolitics only one major pollster got both the results of the 2016 presidential and the Florida midterms right—Robert Cahaly, senior strategist for the Trafalgar Group:

Cahaly managed to pick up support for Trump that all other pollsters missed by employing a unique method that sought to measure support from voters who’d been “inactive” in recent election cycles, as well as adding a question to his surveys designed to isolate the effect of social desirability bias among Trump voters – the concept that people won’t tell pollsters their true intentions for fear of being stigmatized or being politically incorrect.

After asking voters who they were supporting in 2016, the pollster followed up by asking them who they thought their neighbors were supporting, Trump or Clinton. Cahaly consistently found a high degree of variance between who respondents said they were voting for and who they thought their neighbors were voting for, suggesting there was in fact a “shy Trump effect” at play.

Two years later, Cahaly’s method once again proved solid. In one of the most polled races of the cycle, Trafalgar stood alone as the only polling firm to correctly show a Ron DeSantis gubernatorial victory in Florida – as well as Rick Scott winning the Senate race there. (Both narrow outcomes will likely result in recounts.)

I think it’s only going to get tougher from here on out.

BTW I wanted to touch on my thoughts about voter fraud. I was a judge of election for 25 years. Not only have I seen actual attempted voter fraud, I can see the opportunities for fraud. Those who scoff at voter fraud are generally being highly specific. They’re talking about voters walking into a polling place and casting a vote by pretending they’re someone they aren’t. I agree that’s pretty rare. It’s just too easy to detect. As an election judge I have personally turned people away for just this reason. Under present law I would probably be required to issue them provisional ballots.

But there are other types of fraud. There’s voter fraud perpetrated by the election staff at a voting place. I believe that any polling place that hasn’t finished tabulating the votes three hours after the polls have closed is probably engaging that sort of voter fraud. Tabulation doesn’t take time but manufacturing votes does and it’s pathetically easy though tedious to do. I haven’t seen or done this because I run a taut ship but I know enough to see how it could be done by people less scrupulous than I.

There are also non-citizens who claim the right to vote fraudulently. When they’re detected at the polling place, they may be issued provisional ballots. They’re still fraudulent and there’s practically no way of detecting it. I believe I have seen this, also, as a judge of election.

Another species is voter fraud is perpetrated by voters who are registered multiple times in different jurisidictions and who vote multiple times, either absentee or in person. I think there are millions of such voters, particularly in Florida.

Yet another variety of voter fraud is at the wholesale level, perpetrated by election officials manufacturing ballots in mass quantities. There’s plenty of reason to suspect that’s what’s going on in Broward County. What else is one to think when boxes of ballots show up for the first time days after the election? Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

Our system depends on trust and as trust is eroded through misfeasance, malfeasance, or nonfeasance it becomes unworkable.

1 comment

Referenda Ain’t What They Used To Be

Sociology prof Musa al-Gharbi casts some rain on the Democrats’ parade in an op-ed at the Washington Post:

Despite significant structural disadvantages and a difficult Senate map, some great ballot initiatives were passed, state legislatures got bluer in many instances, and Democrats won governorships in some key states. These are worth celebrating (in contrast with claims to have “won the popular vote,” which are spurious). Yet, on balance, Democrats should be more disturbed than comforted by how the elections shook out.

For instance, turnout was much higher than in 2014. However, the increased engagement proved to be bipartisan: Trump’s supporters also showed up in force, significantly undercutting the expected “blue wave.”

Yes, Republicans ultimately lost control of the House — but even here, the Democrats’ continued weakness shines through:

It was expected that the Republicans would lose a significant number of seats, irrespective of public opinions about Trump. Republicans had many more difficult House seats to defend than Democrats overall. There were twice as many Republican incumbents defending House seats in states Hillary Clinton won in 2016 than there were Democrats defending seats in states Trump won.

Republicans also had more than twice as many “open” House seats to hold on to as their Democratic rivals had: 36 Republican representatives chose not to stand for reelection this year because they were retiring or seeking another office. Seven others either resigned or otherwise left office before the election. As a result, Republicans had 43 House seats to defend without the benefit of a true incumbent candidate. On top of this, Republicans had three “open” Senate seats, and one more with a pseudo-incumbent (interim Mississippi Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith took office in April).

Yet Democrats managed to win surprisingly few of these “open” contests. In the vast majority of cases, a new Republican was elected instead, and they tended to be even closer to Trump than their predecessors. So Trump actually cemented his hold over the Republican Party: Most of his staunchest Republican critics have either stepped down, been removed through a primary challenge or otherwise failed to win reelection. On top of this, virtually all of the Senate Democrats who voted against Supreme Court Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh from the states that Trump won in 2016 were voted out of office and replaced by Republicans.

I have a question for Democrats looking towards 2020. 2018 saw the highest turnout of the “youth vote” in history, much of it going to Democratic candidates. Republicans essentially negated that increased turnout through increased turnout of their own. If your plan is even greater turnout, what makes you think that is likely let alone possible?

The last two years have seen non-stop negative coverage of Trump and Republicans generally. That did not result in a “blue wave” but a continuing stalemate. Is doubling down on strategies that have had disappointing results really the best we can do?

3 comments

Interest

In his Washington Post op-ed about the relationship between the United States and the countries of the Indo-Pacific region, Vice President Mike Pence opens with a succinct statement of American interest:

We seek an Indo-Pacific — from the United States to India, from Japan to Australia, and everywhere in between — where sovereignty is respected, where commerce flows unhindered and where independent nations are masters of their own destinies. This region, which includes more than half of Earth’s surface and population, has experienced great progress when these principles have been respected. While some nations now seek to undermine this foundation, the United States is taking decisive action to protect our interests and promote the Indo-Pacific’s shared success.

Our Indo-Pacific strategy rests on three broad pillars. It begins with prosperity. A full two-thirds of global trade traverses the seas, skies, roads and railways of the Indo-Pacific. U.S. trade in the region is worth more than $1.8 trillion annually, supporting more than 3.3 million U.S. jobs, and our total regional investment in the Indo-Pacific is nearly $1 trillion — more than China, Japan and South Korea’s investment combined.

and concludes

The United States seeks collaboration, not control. The president announced our renewed commitment to the region one year ago; this week, it will be my privilege to demonstrate our resolve with further action and investment. Our nation’s security and prosperity depend on this vital region, and the United States will continue to ensure that all nations, large and small, can thrive and prosper in a free and open Indo-Pacific.

I wish he had a better understanding of the U. S. interest which is somewhat broader than that. It is not merely in maintaining the free passage of trade but, in the 21st century, the free passage of information as well. Not only our prosperity but that of all of the countries of the Indo-Pacific region, including China, depends on it.

As a supplemental question, is Google’s facilitation of The Great Firewall of China consistent with American interest? I think the answer is obviously not. Why do we tolerate Google’s engaging in foreign policy antithetical to U. S. policy?

1 comment

More Seats!

I see that the editors of the New York Times have jumped on my bandwagon:

We’re nearly two decades into the 21st century, so why is America still operating with a House of Representatives built for the start of the 20th?

The House’s current size — 435 representatives — was set in 1911, when there were fewer than one-third as many people living in the United States as there are now. At the time, each member of Congress represented an average of about 200,000 people. In 2018, that number is almost 750,000.

This would shock the Constitution’s framers, who set a baseline of 30,000 constituents per representative and intended for the House to grow along with the population. The possibility that it might not — that Congress would fail to add new seats and that district populations would expand out of control — led James Madison to propose what would have been the original First Amendment: a formula explicitly tying the size of the House to the total number of Americans.

The amendment failed, but Congress still expanded the House throughout the first half of the nation’s existence. The House of Representatives had 65 members when it was first seated in 1789, and it grew in every decade but one until 1920, when it became frozen in time.

There’s a solution, which involves adding 158 new seats to the House of Representatives, making it proportionally similar to most modern democracies. To understand the implications of a larger House, we enlisted software developer Kevin Baas and his Auto-Redistrict program to draw 593 new congressional districts for the entire country. (Read on for an explanation of how we chose that number.) Then we used historical partisan scores to determine which party would win each district.

They need to check their math. The population of France is 67 million and the number of deputies is 577. For the U. S. to have about the same degree of representativeness as France we’d need more than 2,000 representatives in the House. The figures for Germany and the U. K. are similar. The frequent reaction to that is that it’s impractical to which I have two responses:

  1. Good
  2. That’s the argument for federalism. We’re just too big to have a highly centralized government like those of France, Germany, and the U. K.

But welcome aboard, anyway. A journey of 10,000 miles, etc. Start by adding 158. Then another 300. Then another 600.

And don’t get me started on the Senate. The Senate was intended to represent the governments of the states and the states themselves not the people of the states. When do we acknowledge that the 17th Amendment was a tremendous error? Repeal it or amend the Constitution to abolish the Senate.

5 comments

Radio Daze

Having listened to all of the extant episodes of high-quality radio Westerns (Gunsmoke, Have Gun Will Travel, Frontier Gentleman, The Six Shooter, and a few others) and detective/crime programs (Dragnet, Richard Diamond, Yours Truly, Johnny Dollars, Box 13, Philip Marlowe, Broadway Is My Beat, Let George Do It, Pat Novak…For Hire, Candy Matson) and a few that were less than high-quality, e.g. Murder Is My Hobby, I’ve now turned to radio comedy. I’ve been listening to Burns & Allen for a few months. I began with the earliest extant episodes (from 1934) and at this point I’m listening to the episodes from 1946.

I find Burns & Allen extremely funny but I honestly can’t tell whether today’s ears would find it offensive. Although Gracie is portrayed as a Dumb Dora, George is the butt of every joke while between the two of them Gracie is obviously the talent. I don’t know that anybody ever had better comedic timing than Gracie Allen. Occasionally going head to head with the grand master of comedic timing, Jack Benny, she gives Jack a run for his money.

There are many running gags. George’s singing. Gracie’s “Beverly Hills Uplift Society”. George’s age and Gracie’s youth—an inside joke since in 1946 George was 50 while Gracie was 51.

Their orchestras provide an interesting window into the development of music through the period. In 1938 through about 1941 Artie Shaw’s orchestra provided the music for Burns & Allen. The Shaw organization was simply brilliant. I don’t think there’s any other word for it. After Shaw Paul Whiteman took over. Then the lesser-known Felix Mills. Then Meredith Willson’s (he later composed The Music Man) Chiffon Music, sometimes with the Les Paul Trio, some of the earliest electric guitar on radio.

I only have another 50-60 Burns & Allen programs left which should take me into 1948, just about the end of the radio series. I’ll probably turn to the Benny program then.

3 comments

Sticking


November 9 is pretty early for snow to be sticking in Chicago. I don’t recall an accumulation of snow at all in Chicago before Veterans Day.

4 comments

What Is “Middle Class”?

In an article at the Atlantic anthropologist Caitlin Zaloom struggles to define what is meant by “middle class”:

The question of how to define the middle class is one of the perennial mysteries of American social life. Most people say they’re “middle class,” so how can we know what this really means? Every few years some intrepid social scientists venture a new definition.

This September, the Brookings Institution economists Richard Reeves and Katherine Guyot argued that the middle class is “the middle 60 percent of households on the income distribution,” which represents $37,000 to $147,000 for a three-person household. Full stop. Downplaying the importance of education, they wrote that income is the most useful measure of class because it captures all of the other conditions that make a person middling, including consumption, education, and relative social standing; it is not only how much money individuals take home.

That actually makes a certain amount of sense. Were incomes distributed in a statistically normal distribution two-thirds of the people would be in the middle—between one standard deviation below and one standard deviation above median income.

Dr. Zaloom examines and rejects income as a metric for middle class-ness, finally latching onto a certain level of security as an indicator for being middle class. That, too, makes a certain amount of sense.

Some of her other suggestions, e.g. valuing education, possessing the amenities of a middle class lifestyle, etc., I think are flatly wrong. Those are strategies for achieving the security of the middle class rather than metrics for it. Indeed, I might argue that seeking the amenities of a middle class lifestyle without adopting the behaviors and habits of mind that are the hallmarks of the middle class in the United States are a key factor in undermining the middle class.

My favorite definition of “middle class” is that it has less to do with your income than with your sources of income. The lower class is paid by the hour; the middle class receives a salary; the upper class’s primary sources of income are rents, royalties, and dividends.

I think I’m distinctively qualified to comment on class by virtue of my family background and upbringing. My father’s family was bourgeois in the extreme. The traditional family occupation for the Schulers was milk broker. In Switzerland you can hardly get more bourgeois than that. My mother’s family on the other hand was not lower class, middle class, or upper class. Artists and performers are not members of a class, something that can be measured by their relationship with security: zero. They are outcaste.

I spent the first part of my childhood among the lower middle class, the “working class”, and its second part among the upper middle class and petty aristocracy. That gives me a certain level of perspective.

You won’t read it in the history books but, just as the secret of American military success does not reside in its generals but in its non-coms, the secret of American cultural success is in its middle class. To be middle class is to accept the behaviors and habits of mind of the American middle class.

Over the period of the last sixty or so years, a significant portion of the American population has been trying to erode the middle class, rejecting its behaviors and values, while still pursuing the appurtenances of a middle class lifestyle. They are phonies in the same sense that Jack Kerouac was a phony. He may have gone on the road but he always returned to mama.

In the end I think I arrive at a similar destination as Dr. Zaloom albeit from a different direction. It’s very difficult to speak of the “middle class” in the U. S. any more. I think that’s a very sad and ultimately self-destructive error.

3 comments