Does anybody? I rarely read John Stossel’s pieces because he is just too much of an anarcho-capitalist for my taste. He promotes the operation of the market but with peculiar blinders which I’ll expand on later in this piece. However, his assessment of single-payer health care in this piece is correct:
“In Germany, employers provide most of the health care … just as they do in the United States,” he says. France and Switzerland also offer multiple options, public and private, and most people buy private health insurance. Some of the Swiss government subsidies are similar to those of Obamacare.
But Canada, England, Norway, Cuba and a few other countries do have genuine single-payer. I’m constantly told that it works well — people get good care and never have to worry about a bill. They spend less on health care and live longer.
Pope says that claim is naive.
They do live longer in many of those countries, but it’s not because they get superior health care; it’s because fewer of them are fat; fewer crash cars; and they shoot each other less often. “Take out (obesity), car accidents and gun violence, the difference in life expectancy disappears entirely,” Pope says.
up to a point. That point is his prescription. He thinks that competition among hospitals and among insurance companies would make health care affordable. There are several problems with that. The most serious is that to the best of my knowledge that is supported by no studies. When Americans have responsibility for paying for their own care they do economize but they do not necessarily economize in an informed manner which will actually result in savings.
The second problem is that he considering only one side of the subsidy equation. For the U. S. actually to have a market-based system we would need to eliminate professional licensing, patents, royalties, and mandates (like requiring hospitals to provide care regardless of ability to pay, something that has only been the case for the last 35 years). Additionally, we’d need to stop determining the relative value of procedures bureaucratically as is the case now. The problems with our health care system did not start in 1965. They started in 1906.
What would such a system look like? The well-to-do, about 3% of the population, would continue to receive whatever health care they wanted because they could pay for it. Those who had the knowledge and prudence to manage their own health care (those able to “advocate for themselves” in the common parlance) would receive health care that was more affordable than at present. Those two groups, which have substantial overlap, account for about 10% of the population all told. The rest would receive substandard health care or be swindled by huckstsers. The poor would not receive health care at all.
I think that very few want that sort of health care system.
Who wants single-payer?
Arguendo, let’s assume that the form that a single-payer system would take would be along the lines submitted as legislation by Democrats in the House in the last Congress. Private health care insurance would become illegal (that’s one of the ways in which they intend to pay for their system). Additional money required would either be obtained through a payroll tax, a tax on work which would reduce the number of jobs and increase unemployment, or through the general fund which means that the entirety of health care in the U. S. would be paid for by the highest quintile of income earners. I don’t think the numbers add up. If from the general fund, it would mean an additional $1 trillion in taxes levied on families earning $100,000 or more. Those families presently account for about 50% of all income or $6.5 trillion, i.e. additional income taxes of about 15 percentage points on those families would be required.
Since money is fungible, that would mean $1 trillion less spent on houses, cars, clothing, food, and other consumer goods. It would not merely mean moving money from one pocket to another as is claimed by some. It would be a major redistribution of income from to pharmaceutical companies, hospitals, health care providers, and other people working in health care from the other people in the top 20% of income earners.
Additionally, care that is not deemed worthy by federal bureaucrats would need to be paid for out of pocket. So much for not getting between patients and their doctors. Or physician autonomy.
I don’t think that’s what most of its advocates think of when they imagine a single-payer system. I think they mostly think of health care that is more affordable and, if that occurs after implementing such a system, it would be a coincidence.
We cannot make health care more affordable without reducing the wages of people in the health care sector, rationing care, or both.
I think I’m going to wrap this post up there. All I have to add is that the idea that there is a right to health care is the moral equivalent of saying that there is a right to Hennessy Ellipse. It’s a slogan—easy to say but impossible to deliver.