Sausage-Making

I watched about 5 minutes of the “negotiation” among Nancy Pelosi, Chuck Schumer, and Donald Trump yesterday and then lost patience. There is a transcript here. I have also read quite a bit of commentary on the exchange.

I think that Trump and the Pelosi-Schumer combine both won to the extent that they got something they wanted. They got Trump to say he’d take the heat for any government shutdown which they think will work to their benefit. And Trump got Pelosi and Schumer to say they were satisfied with the status quo on the border which he thinks will work to his.

Beyond that who you think won or lost the exchange depends on the views that you came into the discussion with.

5 comments

Concerns About Outmigration

I wanted to draw your attention to this piece at Pew Research While the people in countries like the U. S., Australia, France, and Germany are alarmed at the massive levels of immigration, their concerns are dwarfed by the concerns of the people in countries from which people are migrating over outmigration:

At the same time, people in many countries worry about people leaving their home for jobs in other countries. Among surveyed nations, Greece and Spain – two countries that have seen significant numbers of people move abroad in recent years – have the highest shares of people who say this is a very or moderately big problem (89% and 88%, respectively).

About eight-in-ten (79%) say this in Mexico, which has one of the world’s largest numbers of people living outside of their country, at 13 million, according to the United Nations. (The country’s mass migration to the U.S. has slowed over the past decade or so.) In India, the nation with the largest international migrant population (16.6 million), 64% say people leaving for jobs elsewhere is a big problem.

I think that is a far too underreported story—the social upheaval being caused by mass outmigration. So, for example, I have little doubt that the Mexican authorities are telling their American counterparts that the people leaving Mexico for the U. S. are criminals and malcontents, the reality is that they also include some of Mexico’s hardest-working and most ambitious young people, people that Mexico desperately needs.

0 comments

What’s Wrong?

I don’t say he’s a great man. Willie Loman never made a lot of money. His name was never in the paper. He’s not the finest character that ever lived. But he’s a human being, and a terrible thing is happening to him. So attention must be paid. He’s not to be allowed to fall in his grave like an old dog. Attention, attention must finally be paid to such a person.

Arthur Miller, “Death of a Salesman”

In his latest Wall Street Journal column Walter Russell Mead asks a pair of intertwined questions. Why are voters in the UK, France, and Germany rebelling against the status quo? And if they’re rebelling when conditions are, at least on average, pretty good, how will they react when the inevitable downturn occurs?

The turbulence in these countries, pillars of European and indeed world order, isn’t just about particular leaders. Their entire political systems have come under strain. In the U.K., even before the Brexit referendum, the rise of the Scottish National Party and Jeremy Corbyn’s victory over the moderate wing of the Labour Party had already transformed the political system. In France, Mr. Macron came to power as the existing party system imploded. In Germany, the antiestablishment Left and Alternative for Germany parties have been steadily gaining strength as centrist parties falter in the polls.

It’s one thing for political systems to face populist revolts when times are bad. President-elect Jair Bolsonaro’s victory in Brazil came on the heels of a deep recession and a massive corruption scandal. Voters turned against a political establishment that was corrupt and economically inept. Italy’s populists came to power in a country where, a decade after the financial crisis, gross domestic product has not yet returned to 2008 levels. Persistent crime and poverty helped elevate a left-wing populist to the presidency in Mexico.

But that is not what is happening in Europe’s Big Three. The German economy under Ms. Merkel is the envy of much of the world. Britain’s economy has also done relatively well, with unemployment low and declining despite uncertainty from Brexit. And while growth in France is slow, it is real; average wages as reported by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development rose more than 1% a year between 2007 and 2017. Any material grievances voters may have are not extreme by historical standards.

The discontent shaking Europe’s governments, and the anger reverberating through American politics, comes as times are about as good as they get. The crash of 2008 and the Great Recession are far behind us, and most countries are at the peak of their business cycles. Conventional political science suggests this should be a better environment for incumbent politicians. People normally get cranky when the economy is doing badly but mellow out as things improve. Now a long period of steady if not exceptional growth is in the rearview mirror, but voters are in revolt across much of the West.

I think I can answer those questions. Ordinary people are working hard or at least they think they’re working hard. Promises have been made or at least they think that promises have been made. They don’t see those promises being fulfilled but they do see the lifestyles of their leaders and the economic elite. They see their lives changing irrevocably and not, from their point of view, for the better.

And those leaders respond by ignoring their concerns, dismissing them. Attention must be paid.

I’ve issued this warning before but maybe it’s time for me to do it again. Kicking the can down the road indefinitely is not a viable strategy. The choices are between smart and prudent change or foolish and ill-conceived change not between hoping it will all blow over and making changes that upset your own cozy circumstances.

4 comments

We Never Had It So Good

Rather than dissecting Robert Samuelson’s Washington Post column which could be summarized “we never had it so good”, let me just make a few observations.

  1. If you ignore enough factors, you can prove anything.
  2. If you deal only in aggregates, things do look pretty darned good.
  3. Heavy concentration of wealth in relatively few hands tells us that dealing only in aggregates does not jibe with ordinary people’s life experience nearly as well as it used to.
  4. Yes, we have better smartphones.
  5. What value do you place on confidence that you won’t be a victim of violent crime? Violent crime used to be unheard of in my affluent neighborhood on the Northwest Side of Chicago. Now it’s a block and a half away.
  6. What value do you place on the confidence that your children will lead happier, more prosperous, longer lives than you did? That is no longer the case.
  7. What value do you place on young people not being so burdened with educational debt that they may never dig their way out? That is no longer the case, either.
  8. What value do you place on every news broadcast not devolving into a shouting match?

I don’t think the widespread dissatisfaction, not just here in the U. S. but, rather obviously, in Europe as well, is just petulance or because the people are ingrates. When people is behaving as though something were wrong, there probably is.

Update

In a related vein, Charles Duhigg’s article at Atlantic might be summarized

  1. Americans are a bunch of angry ingrates.
  2. There’s good money to be made in anger.
  3. My anger is better than your anger.
10 comments

History Is Alive and Well

I was taken aback by this statement in James Dobbins’s Wall Street Journal op-ed, “History Ended in 1945”:

In 1989 Francis Fukuyama published an essay heralding the “end of history,” by which he meant the triumph of representative democracy over all other forms of government. For a decade he appeared prescient, as democracy swept through Central and Southeastern Europe, Latin America and much of Asia. More recently some of those democracies have faltered. Although few have definitively collapsed, the democratic wave seems to have begun ebbing.

Yet in a larger sense, the “end of history” came in 1945. Since then there have been no wars between major powers and few between smaller states. The business cycle has been moderated if not eliminated. The subsequent seven decades saw almost continuous economic growth, lifting nearly half the world’s population into the middle class.

These accomplishments are based on two basic, widely accepted norms of international behavior: Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor’s territory, and thou shall open thy markets to all equally. The norms were buttressed by numerous postwar institutions—the United Nations, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund and the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, now the World Trade Organization. Equally important, the norms were backed by U.S. military and economic power and the attractiveness of the American political and economic model.

because it is so Euro- and America-centric. Yes, those two norms are basic and widely accepted—in the United States and Europe. Outside those two areas not so much.

Based on the World Bank’s assessment of tariffs China’s, India’s, and most of Latin America’s trade-weighted tariffs are four times ours. In most African countries they’re ten times ours. And that doesn’t even take into account the enormous non-tariff barriers the very same countries have in place.

Or consider territory. Since 1945 the total territories of the United Kingdom, France, the United States, and even Russia have declined. China’s has expanded and continues to do so.

The first 30 years of the period in question were accompanied by enormous expansion of the U. S. economy and increases in wages for ordinary American workers. For the next 40 years those both slowed substantially.

Perhaps a recalibration of Mr. Dobbins’s thesis is in order. The United States, Canada, and Europe adopted the “two basic, widely accepted norms”. The balance of the world, about three-quarters of the people and land mass, did not. That condition resulted in bringing a lot of people, mostly in China and India, out of poverty while a handful of people in the United States, Canada, Europe, India, and China became fantastically wealthy.

History is alive and well. We’re just ignoring it.

0 comments

Happy Birthday, Kirk Douglas!

Today Kirk Douglas turned 102.

0 comments

Currency Manipulation

At Bloomberg Christopher Balding makes a pretty good case that the Chinese authorities are engaging in currency manipulation:

Theoretically, the yuan’s value is set against a basket of currencies compiled by the China Foreign Exchange Trade System, an arm of the central bank based in Shanghai. In practice, the CFETS RMB Index closely matches the U.S. dollar Index. When the dollar gauge rises, the greenback should strengthen against the yuan. Most of the time, this is what happens – except when it doesn’t.

From December 2017 until spring this year, daily changes in the dollar-yuan exchange rate closely matched movements in the dollar index. But beginning around April 1, Beijing started keeping the yuan above the value implied by that gauge. That state of affairs held until late June, when China’s currency nosedived.

In April through June, Chinese officials were negotiating to prevent U.S. President Donald Trump from imposing tariffs. It appears that China played nice by holding the yuan at an artificially strong level, only to switch tactics when officials became convinced that the talks would be unsuccessful – perhaps as a warning to Trump.

and that is currency manipulation and a violation of Chinese agreements under the WTO. Check out the graphs in the article. They’re pretty convincing.

0 comments

Reforming the Asylum Process

I tend to agree with the editors of Bloomberg on reforming our obviously broken asylum process:

Central America’s desperate migrants won’t stop seeking sanctuary or a better life until conditions in their countries improve. That’s one of many reasons why the U.S. also has an interest in sustaining and increasing its foreign aid. And the flood of asylum applicants reflects, in part, the pull from relatives in the U.S., many of whom are either undocumented or have tenuous legal status. Comprehensive immigration reform is needed to address that.

In the meantime, instead of trying to restrict access to asylum through questionable or outright illegal executive orders, the U.S. should be processing applications more humanely and expeditiously. It really isn’t complicated. In this instance, greater administrative efficiency is the key to protecting the vulnerable and upholding American values and interests.

IMO the reforms should take several forms:

  1. We need more immigration judges and more people to administer the system.
  2. Immigration judges need more oversight. When asylum cases granted range from 3% to 91% within the same district, the decisions are pretty apparently arbitrary and capricious. The Supreme Court has responsibility for this oversight. They need to act. If they demur from acting, they should be replaced with justices who will. It’s part of their jobs.
  3. Congress should make the rules much clearer, leaving less room for discretion. One obvious reform: those charging the barriers as recently to enter illegally should be banned from seeking asylum.

I also agree that we need comprehensive immigration reform but I suspect that my views of the contours of such reform would be quite different from those of the editors of Bloomberg. So, for example, I think there should be very stiff penalties for abuses of H1-B or L1 visas, something of which the editors would probably not approve.

2 comments

$10,739

Per capita health care spending of $10,739 per person sounds like a lot of money. And it is. But it’s not as bad as it might have been as noted by Jessie Hellman at The Hill:

National spending on health care reached $3.5 trillion in 2017, or about $10,739 per person, according to new data released Thursday by the Trump administration.

Overall, health spending grew at a rate of 3.9 percent last year, after increasing by 4.8 percent in 2016 and 5.8 percent in 2015.

It’s the slowest increase in spending since 2013, before most parts of the Affordable Care Act took effect, including the expansion of Medicaid to more low-income adults.

Consider that figure in perspective. the median family income for a family of four last year was $61,372. If health care spending were distributed evenly across the population and if people actually paid for their own health care, it means that family would be spending two-thirds of their income on health care. Subtract another $22,000 (education spending per pupil) and what’s left is…nothing. Is it any wonder that economic growth outside of health care and education is slow?

3.9% sounds like a slow rate of growth. It’s also three times the non-health care rate of inflation. It’s also more than twice as fast as incomes.

7 comments

Irradiate?

In an op-ed at USA Today Alex Berezow demands we start irradiating meat and produce:

The United States is being hit by two large foodborne illness outbreaks — first, the E. coli outbreak in romaine lettuce, and now a salmonella outbreak in beef that has sickened more than 200 people. These high-profile cases underscore the inadequacy of the safety measures meant to protect our food supply. If we are serious about addressing this issue, we must implement food irradiation.

Every year, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that 48 million cases of foodborne illness occur, hospitalizing 128,000 and killing 3,000, usually older or immunocompromised people. Those of you who have ever had the“24-hour flu” or “stomach flu” should be aware that those aren’t real diseases; instead, you probably had food poisoning.

As (I suspect) like most of you that idea makes me a bit queasy. Maybe I’m just the victim of propaganda.

There is one factor that Mr. Berezow is not considering: moral hazard. E. Coli isn’t endemic in romaine lettuce. It’s introduced there by bad field sanitation practices. If I understand it correctly, salmonella in meat is a consequence of bad sanitation practices in processing. It’s not the same as milk and, consequently, not the same as pasteurization. Will irradiating meat and produce increase or decrease the the number of bacterial infections from food? I don’t know and I suspect that Mr. Berezow doesn’t, either. How would you go about conducting an experiment?

There are actually real life experiments. In the EU irradiated spices and herbs are a commonplace and Belgium, Czech Republic, France, Italy, Netherlands, Poland, and the United Kingdom allow the irradiation of a wider variety of foods. You’ve probably got irradiated foods in your refrigerator since a lot of produce imported from abroad has been irradiated.

On the con side of the argument there have been instances of serious illness that may have been caused by very highly irradiated foods. Would DoA inspectors be better at overseeing radiation than they are at other food processing?

10 comments