Land of Opportunity?

Economic Advantage of Dense Cities


There’s an article in the New York Times which, as you will discern, does not surprise me at all but will no doubt come as a bolt from the blue to those who think that the U. S. can use all of the low-skill workers it can get. A recent study has found that large metropolitan areas no longer provide the advantages to low-skill workers that they once did:

For decades, workers migrated to big cities in America that promised abundant jobs and decent wages — in clerical offices in New York, at shipbuilding yards in Oakland, on auto assembly lines around Detroit.

Big, dense cities offered not just better pay for lower-skilled workers; cities offered them better kinds of jobs.

This is much less true today, as workers hurt by the decline in manufacturing know. Because of this, cities no longer offer low-skilled workers the economic advantages they once did, according to new analysis by the M.I.T. economist David Autor.

Workers, whether with a college degree or not, could long count on earning more in denser urban areas than in rural ones. Today, that pattern holds for highly educated workers — and has in fact grown much stronger. For workers without any college education, the added wage benefits of dense cities have mostly disappeared in Mr. Autor’s data…

I would add that I suspect that the economic advantage to highly dense cities does not hold for all workers with college educations but is mostly concentrated on workers with degrees in just a few fields but that’s just my suspicion.

I have one question and one observation about this. First, the question. Who are these low-skilled workers. I think there are several categories:

  • Illegal immigrants
  • The children of illegal immigrants
  • The unskilled spouses of skilled legal immigrants
  • Other legal immigrants sponsored by legal immigrants
  • Blacks
  • Some whites, particularly those from rural areas

And here’s the observation. The cost of these low-skill workers is higher in highly dense cities than in smaller cities or rural areas.

I’ll leave you with this thought from the cited article:

“People have lamented, ‘Well, all these areas that lost manufacturing, why don’t those workers just get up and go somewhere else?’” said Mr. Autor, who looked at wage data from the census and American Community Survey and recently presented the findings at the annual meeting of the American Economic Association. “It’s just not at all obvious what that place is. It’s less obvious to me now than it was a month ago.”

2 comments

Endemic

I had to laugh, a rueful, sardonic laugh but a laugh nonetheless when I read the caption of this op-ed in the Wall Street Journal: “Early Withdrawal Will Lead to More Terrorism”. Also, failing to withdraw with lead to more terrorism. Doing something will lead to more terrorism. Doing nothing will lead to more terrorism.

Terrorism is endemic in the Middle East. There has been terrorism in the Middle East for at least the last millennium and a half. The differences between now and then are that then we just didn’t care and the population of the Middle East was staying in the Middle East. The Ottoman records are actually pretty clear on this subject. Every so often a Jewish village or a Coptic village or a Shi’ite village would be burned to the ground but what’s one Jewish or Coptic or Shi’ite village?

The problem with the Middle East is the Middle East. We should be looking after our actual interests in the region and otherwise maintaining a low profile there.

4 comments

Do We Actually Agree?

I agree with a lot of what’s in Peggy Noonan’s latest Wall Street Journal column, a plea to end the shutdown. So, for example, I largely agree with this:

Those of us who are not politicians agree that neither party has really wanted to solve the problem. Both played it for their own gain, cynically, as if they weren’t even invested in this place. They should be ashamed.

It was not in the interests of the Republican Party to address the border problem because that might leave them open to charges they were driven by questions of race and color. Also their major donors didn’t mind illegal immigration, which was good for business. It’s always convenient when you see things the donors’ way! The affluent and powerful in America enjoy feeling liberal and are uninterested in how poor Americans view chaos (as a threat—America is all they have; they don’t have two passports and a share on a plane) and jobs lost to cheaper labor.

Democrats never intended to control the border because they think doing nothing marks them as the nonracist party, the compassionate, generous party that Hispanics will see as home. They would reap the electoral rewards in a demographically changing country. They will own the future! Their big donors too opposed border strictness. They don’t think about security a lot, even after 9/11. I think it was Murray Kempton who said Republicans are always hearing the creak of the door at night. It’s true. Democrats are less anxious about security. It’s fair to point out they tend to be more affluent and have the protections money can buy. Their fearlessness is not bravery but obliviousness. They off-load anxiety onto Republicans, who are always mysteriously eager to take it up.

But the crux of the problem is in this paragraph and, sadly, I don’t think it’s true:

Almost everyone would agree we have a right to determine the rules by which legal entry is attained. Most Americans would agree it is desirable to set those rules according to the nation’s needs. America is beginning to experience a shortage of registered nurses. Have you noticed? You will. Wouldn’t it be good to address the shortfall through immigration policy, inviting nurses from other countries to become legal residents and citizens? My people, from Ireland, were welcomed because the dynamic America of 1900 needed laborers and domestic workers. That, luckily, is what my people were. Two generations later I worked for an American president. What a miracle this place is. Let’s keep that up, the miracle part.

It has many problems. I’m not sure that most Americans agree that “we have a right to determine the rules by which legal entry is attained”. I’m not sure when “her people” arrived but when my people, i.e. my Irish ancestors, arrived in the United States (pre-famine Irish), the United States would experience more than another century in which wages would rise for typical workers. That hasn’t been true for nearly two generations now. Importing nurses will increase the number of nurses today but it will also keep wages for nurses down and discourage young Americans from seeking a career in nursing.

Why aren’t more young Americans seeking to become nurses? That’s the question I think she should be asking.

We presently have as high a proportion of immigrants in the population as at any other time in our history. Under the circumstances claiming that more immigrants will solve our problems is extraordinary and deserving of a high standard of proof. Maybe what we need as a society is fewer laborers and domestic workers and more social equality, something that cannot be obtained by importing workers.

3 comments

Know Your Place, Knaves!

Keep the prediction I made immediately following the November elections in mind. When all of the dust has settled the Congressional leadership, Republican and Democratic, will still be in charge. The newly-elected young “radicals” (I don’t know whether they’re actually radicals or not and I don’t much care) will be relegated to the backbenches. They’ll hold their offices as long as they do what they’re told. They are not off to a great start.

1 comment

A Word About Health Care Spending

Most large companies presently self-insure when it comes to their employees’ health care plans. Frequently they hire erstwhile insurance companies to administer their plans. They do this for a reason: they save money relative to what they would otherwise spend.

How payments for a “Medicare for All” system would be structured is important. In all likelihood it would cause those companies to pay more than they do presently and many people who presently have insurance will end up paying more.

The U. S. health care system is very complex. There isn’t just a big pile of money labelled “health care spending”. There are tens of thousands or millions of little piles and how the money is shifted from pile to pile will make the difference between a program that can be passed and one that gets its proponents thrown out of office.

7 comments

Marginal Argument

You may have noticed that I haven’t posted on the brouhaha about claims about tax rates in the 1960s which has drawn in not just newly-elected Congressional representatives but Paul Krugman. I have the utmost of respect for Paul Krugman as an economist but much less in his political judgments and, let’s face it, politically he’s a weathervane. Whether he supports or opposes something depends on what the prevailing wisdom among the Democratic leadership is at any given time.

The reason I haven’t posted on it is that there are so many things being said that are untrue or half-truths it’s hard to know where to begin. The top marginal tax rate in 1960 wasn’t 70% it was 91%. Only a handful of families paid it—something like the top .002% IIRC. Those paying a rate of 70% weren’t a lot more numerous. Something like the the top .01% of income earners.

And—a key point—the effective tax rates being paid were about the same as today. What Americans have been willing to pay in taxes has been tremendously persistent over time, not just the last ten or twenty years but for at least the last 80 years or even longer.

The bottom line is a top marginal rate of 70% would be very, very difficult politically to effect and it won’t bring in nearly as much as either the proponents or foes are claiming. Try again.

One final word, something I’ve mentioned before. In 1960 the top 1% of income earners held 9% of wealth. Today they have 40%. Opinions can differ but I don’t think that’s due to unions, tax rates, or the inherent gifts of the top 1% of income earners. I think the change is due to a web of government policies that include tax policy, trade policy, immigration policy, and many, many others. I don’t think we can maintain a society of social equality in the presence of such stark inequality in wealth. Maybe I’m wrong. We’ve spent 80 years weaving that web of policies and it will take us at least that long to unweave them, its beneficiaries fighting to the death every step of the way.

9 comments

Five Alternative Facts

No Labels states “five facts” about the economy in a piece at RealClearPolicy:

  1. According to POLITICO the nation’s economy added 312,000 jobs in December 2018 alone.
  2. On top of this, the construction industry is facing a critical worker shortage, highlighting the continued real estate development boom.
  3. In December 2018 average hourly earnings had risen 3.2 percent from the year before and 0.1 percent from the month before.
  4. The national housing market slowed in 2018 because of record prices and high mortgage rates, a trend that could continue in the new year.
  5. While the stock market has been volatile over the past few weeks many experts believe it is not an excellent predictor of the economy in the short term.

Here are my five alternative facts in response:

  1. We don’t really know whether jobs were lost, gained, or their number stayed the same. The actual number of jobs counted in the Bureau of Labor Statistics’s Employment Situation report is just a fraction of the reported number. More of the jobs reported are derived from the broken business birth/death ratio than are actually counted.
  2. Not merely in construction but in many other sectors of the economy there are critical labor shortages because the pipeline is broken. It used to be that laborers became apprentices became journeymen became master craftsmen. The “laborer” level jobs are now being filled by immigrants (legal or illegal) who are less likely to rise to “master” status.
  3. If Jamie Dimon’s wages rise high enough, it will cause the average wage to rise noticeably. With wages as unequal as they are today “average hourly earnings” has become next to meaningless.
  4. In my neighborhood houses that have been on the market for a year or more with too high an asking price are being withdrawn from the market. In every block of my neighborhood there is at least one unoccupied house.
  5. 15% of the stocks that make up the DJIA are technology stocks of companies whose total employment accounts for just one or two percent of total employment. Another 15% are financial company stocks that represent a similarly small proportion of the actual economy. How good a predictor could the DJIA be?
14 comments

Hoist By Your Own Petard

At The Hill Jonathan Turley makes an observation in rebuttal of the present debate about whether President Trump has the authority to build his wall without Congressional approval by declaring an emergency:

Congress has refused the funds needed for the wall, so Trump is openly claiming the right to unilaterally order construction by declaring a national emergency. On its face, that order would undermine the core role of Congress in our system of checks and balances. I happen to agree that an emergency declaration to build the wall is unwise and unnecessary. However, the declaration is not unconstitutional. Schiff, now chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, insists that Trump “does not have the power to execute” this order because “if Harry Truman could not nationalize the steel industry during wartime, this president does not have the power to declare an emergency and build a multibillion dollar wall on the border.”

The problem is Trump does have that power because Congress gave it to him.

I would be completely delighted if President Trump started building his wall without Congressional authorization, the case were challenged in court, and the Supreme Court issued a broad ruling striking down all similar abrogations of authority to the executive as unconstitutional.

Getting elected to Congress should not be a lifetime sinecure. It should be so difficult and exhausting a job that no one wants to hold it for a lifetime or, indeed, is able to. Congress should not be able to escape its responsibilities by delegating them to a president whom they find congenial only to panic when a president they despise takes office. Sadly, the Court is disinclined to issue such sweeping opinions, a case of the Court’s delegating its own authority to the Congress by showing excessive deference to a Congress unwilling to do its job.

3 comments

A Presidential Address

I listened to President Trump’s address on television last night. I thought it was okay—I wasn’t particularly impressed one way or another. My wife, no Trump fan, thought it was presidential in content and delivery and ventured that if Trump had been behaving this way for the last two years rather than tweeting he wouldn’t be getting the sort of news coverage he’s been getting. I disagreed with that. I think he would get the sort of news coverage he has regardless of his demeanor if for no other reason because he’s not Hillary Clinton. As evidence I would submit the coverage of the address today from the major media outlets. They’re not reporting on the address. They’re reporting on their opinions of the underlying policy.

I thought that Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer looked old and tired.

Did you listen to the address? What did you think?

11 comments

The Devil Is In The Details

Well, this is interesting. According to a preliminary estimate of 2018 carbon emissions from the Rhodium Group, U. S. carbon emissions increased sharply last year despite notable reductions on the use of coal and gasoline:

After three years of decline, US carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions rose sharply last year. Based on preliminary power generation, natural gas, and oil consumption data, we estimate emissions increased by 3.4% in 2018. This marks the second largest annual gain in more than two decades — surpassed only by 2010 when the economy bounced back from the Great Recession. While a record number of coal-fired power plants were retired last year, natural gas not only beat out renewables to replace most of this lost generation but also fed most of the growth in electricity demand. As a result, power sector emissions overall rose by 1.9%. The transportation sector held its title as the largest source of US emissions for the third year running, as robust growth in demand for diesel and jet fuel offset a modest decline in gasoline consumption. The buildings and industrial sectors also both posted big year-on-year emissions gains. Some of this was due to unusually cold weather at the start of the year. But it also highlights the limited progress made in developing decarbonization strategies for these sectors. The US was already off track in meeting its Paris Agreement targets. The gap is even wider headed into 2019.

Since the most likely approaches to implementing a carbon tax (cf. France’s “Yellow Vest” protests) would in all likelihood exempt diesel, that suggests that reductions in emissions can’t be accomplished just on the basis of a switch to natural gas and implementing a carbon tax could be more painful than some have assumed.

7 comments