Potential vs. Actual

I haven’t commented on Mike Pompeo’s speech in Cairo last week, which provided an ironic contrast with President Obama’s speech in Cairo a decade earlier. I may consider it in detail later but I want to focus on one statement. From the transcript provided by Haaretz:

I’ll be very blunt and direct today: America is a force for good in the Middle East.

I’m skeptical. Considering only our actions rather than our intentions has America been a “force for good in the Middle East”? Please show your work.

Consider just Libya and Iraq. Since we connived at the Qaddaffi’s overthrow, there has been a return to open air slave markets in Libya. Is that what happens when America is a force for good? Is the decimation of the Yezidis in Iraq by DAESH (that also included slavery) an artifact of America’s leaving Iraq or a consequence of our ouster of Saddam Hussein? I think the latter. The moral is that there are worse things than dictators and we unleashed those things by removing dictators. Good intentions are not enough.

8 comments

The Immigration Question

Politico’s Bill Scher summarizes the basics of the debate over Trump’s wall succinctly in a piece at RealClearPolitics:

Those who are eager for both sides to compromise, like center-right New York Times columnist David Brooks, describe “a wall for DACA” as an “obvious deal” that only doesn’t happen because of “a massive leadership vacuum in Washington.” But it’s not because of a lack of leadership. It’s because the two camps have opposite views on immigration itself.

The Democratic opposition to a complete wall or barrier, running the entire length of the southern border, is not strictly because it would be “ineffective,” but because of the desired effect: to send a stark message that immigrants from Mexico and Central America are not welcome here (unlike immigrants from Canada, where a border wall has not been proposed). Democrats do not want to send that message.

And they don’t need to. The “Dreamers” who get work permits through the DACA program are not facing imminent deportation, thanks to court rulings that have indefinitely shelved Trump’s attempt to scrap the program. Democrats, in turn, feel no urgency to make concessions to codify DACA. They can still play for time.

A wealth of polling indicates that most Americans view immigration positively. In a September NBC/Wall Street Journal poll, 61 percent of respondents said immigration “helps the United States more than it hurts.” And Trump didn’t help the Republicans keep the House by campaigning on “the caravan” in the run-up to the midterms. So you can see why Trump may not want to advertise what he’s doing to clamp down on legal immigration, and have “the wall” then be viewed as part of that restrictionist strategy.

However, while Trump’s hard-line immigration rhetoric didn’t help Republicans, the Democrats who flipped red districts didn’t spend much time talking about immigration at all. They felt voters wanted to hear more about issues that directly impact their pocketbook, like health care. Today, Democrats may feel politically safe opposing the wall, but not every Democrat may want to fully engage Trump on the larger question of how welcoming our immigration policies should be. Therefore, Democratic leaders tend to emphasize a less polarizing, more pragmatic message about effective border security.

But if we are to ever achieve comprehensive immigration reform, at some point we will need a real debate about what kind of immigration system we want: Do we want to make it easy to come to America, or do we want to make it hard?

I have made no secret of my views. Immigration to the United States should be hard. We should emulate the policies of the countries we most closely resemble, e.g. Canada and Australia, impose substantial requirements on prospective immigrants, and enforce them.

It isn’t the 1880s. Wages for unskilled workers have been declining for decades. Wages for tech workers, those admitted under H1-B visas, have been flat for at least a decade. The instances of native-born workers being forced to train their immigrant replacements are too numerous simply to be dismissed. Whatever purpose immigration served in the past today it serves primarily to keep wages low and afford American companies the luxury of not automating.

Higher education is no solution to the employment problem in the U. S., at this point largely a problem of underemployment, for the simple reason that it is not applicable to between half and two-thirds of the U. S. population who do not thrive in colleges and universities.

A tighter immigration system would allow wages to rise in the U. S. and change the areas that U. S. businesses engage in towards what we can do effectively rather than trying to compete with the low wages that prevail in Asian countries. In my opinion if you favor making immigration to the U. S. easy, you have a moral obligation to do something about the workers that will be displaced or whose wages will be kept low that extends beyond rhetoric.

9 comments

YMMV

At Medical Xpress there’s a recommendation that your parents, aunts, and uncles are a fair guideline for your own life expectancy:

(HealthDay)—Your chances of inheriting genes linked to longevity are highest if you come from a family with many long-lived members, researchers say.

And that includes aunts and uncles, not just parents.

Using databases at the University of Utah and in the Dutch province of Zeeland, investigators analyzed the genealogies of nearly 315,000 people from over 20,000 families dating back to 1740.

“We observed . . . the more long-lived relatives you have, the lower your hazard of dying at any point in life,” said study lead author Niels van den Berg. He is a doctoral student in molecular epidemiology at Leiden University in the Netherlands.

My reaction to that was maybe, maybe not.

I’m already 20 years older than my dad was at the time of his death so that’s not much of a model and, although my mom was nearly 90 when she died, she had smoked since she was 14, ultimately dying of lung cancer. What killed my dad wasn’t communicable or heritable (as far as anyone knows) and it wasn’t a “lifestyle disease”. I have no aunts or uncles so no help there, either.

When you go back to my grandparents’ generation, I’ve already outlived all of them. My paternal grandparents were chronic alcoholics and, basically, died of complications of alcoholism. My maternal grandmother died in her 40s of a brain aneurysm. My maternal grandfather basically just decided to die. He died of a medical condition that was readily treatable 80 years ago. He refused treatment. My parents’ aunts and uncles died fairly young but most frequently they died of conditions which today are readily treatable with antibiotics, TB being a biggie. Those who did not succumb to infectious diseases tended to be fairly long-lived. My mom’s Uncle Ed, for example, was in his 90s when he died.

I think I’m in unknown territory.

2 comments

Watson

What do you think of the ongoing defenestration of James Watson, one of the scientists who receive a Nobel Prize 50 years ago for the discovery of the double helix structure of DNA? Here’s the background:

James Watson, the Nobel Prize-winning DNA scientist who lost his job in 2007 for expressing racist views, was stripped of several honorary titles Friday by the New York lab he once headed.

Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory said it was reacting to Watson’s remarks in a television documentary aired earlier this month.

In the film, Watson said his views about intelligence and race had not changed since 2007, when he told a magazine that he was “inherently gloomy about the prospect of Africa” because “all our social policies are based on the fact that their intelligence is the same as ours — where all the testing says not really.”

In the 2007 interview, Watson said that while he hopes everyone is equal, “people who have to deal with black employees find this is not true.”

My take is two-fold. On the one hand I suspect his observations about race and intelligence are incorrect because the effects of the non-genetic factors underpinning IQ overwhelm whatever genetic component there might be, IQ is only of limited use as a gauge, and “average IQ” is completely useless in dealing with individual human beings. Additionally, the actions by the labs and other organizations stripping him of honors appear opportunistic to me. He’s been saying stuff like that for decades. Many of the awards bestowed on him were conferred after he had already made comments along these lines by institutions that bestowed them for their own purposes. Any shame is on the institutions as well as on Dr. Watson. They’re acting now because the wind has changed and he’s no longer of any use to them. I don’t think they’ve escaped responsiblity for their actions. If they’d done due diligence they’d’ve known. I think they’re doubling their guilt by shaming an old man in his dotage.

There are also larger issues. Can only good people make great discoveries? Do you honor the discovery or the individual? Should these honors be conferred at all?

3 comments

Popular American Music

This is just something I’ve been musing about lately. Who would you say was the most important American composer of popular music of the first half of the 20th century? There are a number of good candidates including Richard Rodgers, George Gershwin, Duke Ellington, and Jerome Kern but I think the best candidate is Irving Berlin.

Now, who would you say was the most important American composer of popular music of the second half of the 20th century? Candidates range from Brian Wilson to Chuck Berry, Smokey Robinson, Madonna, and Lady Gaga. I would say that Carole King would be a very solid pick.

10 comments

Stirring the Pot

Reuters reports that Brazil has recognized Juan Guaido, President of the Venezuelan National Assembly, as the president of Venezuela:

SAO PAULO (Reuters) – Brazil’s government on Saturday issued a statement saying it recognized Venezuela’s Congressional leader, who opposes President Nicolas Maduro, as the rightful president of Venezuela.

Maduro, who started a second term as president this week, has found himself increasingly isolated as countries around the world have called his continued leadership illegitimate.

Juan Guaido, the head of Venezuela’s opposition-led Congress, said this week he was prepared to assume the country’s presidency on an interim basis and call elections.

Over the last several years nearly 4 million Venezuelans of a population of 32 million have fled Venezuela to Brazil, Colombia, and Guyana, disrupting those countries. Neither the shutdown of the federal government nor the flood of refugees at our southern border is the gravest emergency in the Americas. The situation in Venezuela is and Brazil is stirring the pot.

0 comments

Shutdown Politics

I don’t have a great deal to say about the federal government shutdown. Those who say that President Trump is only pursuing his wall to to fulfill a campaign promise are right. Those who say that the Democrats are only refusing to give him the $5 billion for political reasons are right. The total federal budget is around $4 trillion. $5 billion is .125% of that—a significant amount to you and me but completely insignificant in the larger scheme of things. I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if the shutdown itself costs us more than $5 billion.

I have made my views of illegal immigration and what to do about it clear and I won’t repeat them here. I don’t believe any real principle is at stake in the conflict. It’s primarily a headbutting contest between Donald Trump and Nancy Pelosi. The news media who are overwhelmingly blaming Trump for the shutdown are rather obviously taking an overtly partisan stance. The president is under no obligation to knuckle under to the Speaker of the House and, contrariwise, the Speaker of the House is under no obligation to defer to the president.

They should craft a compromise that allows both of them to save face, an ironic diction under the circumstances. Both should get something they notionally want and both should relinquish something they notionally want. My confidence that will take place approaches zero.

12 comments

Rule #1

When I saw the title of the post in the Small Wars Journal, “Phil Walter’s Five Rules for Counterinsurgency from a U.S. Perspective”, I was prepared to hate it but his Rule #1 changed my mind:

1. Don’t do counterinsurgency. Better to let the insurgents win and then engage their newly-formed country in state-on-state warfare, a U.S. strength, than to play the game the insurgent prefers.

Read the whole thing. It is short and to the point and advice I wish that American politicians would heed.

I would add one additional rule:

6. Never, ever do insurgency. It has never ended well for the United States.

6 comments

What Are the Congress’s Powers?

In a post at Outside the Beltway James Joyner points out something of which I was unaware or at least have no recollection of knowing—the Trump Administration’s failure to pay exempted federal employees is a violation of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938:

The partial government shutdown caused by President Trump’s bizarre insistence on more than $5 billion being budgeted for a border wall is now in its 22nd day, breaking the record set by the 1996 shutdown. Additionally, those in affected agencies missed their scheduled payday yesterday, creating a violation of Federal law for exempt workers ordered to work.

Government Executive‘s Eric Katz explains (“Saturday, the Shutdown Becomes the Longest Ever. And Illegal“):

The missed pay brought the shutdown further into new territory: it is now illegal. That is according to a precedent set by a federal court after the 16-day 2013 shutdown, in reference to many of the “excepted” or “exempted” employees who are forced to work during the lapse with only the promise of retroactive pay once their agencies reopen. A group of those workers sued the government after that lapse; 25,000 workers ultimately signed onto that lawsuit.

In 2014, Patricia Campbell-Brown, a judge in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, ruled the government violated the 1938 Fair Labor Standards Act when employees worked without receiving immediate pay. While the government sought to argue the delay in payment was not “egregious,” the judge said a violation occurred under the FLSA as soon as the checks were not delivered on time. She also rejected the government’s argument that any financial hardship occurred only because of federal workers’ “poor financial management decisions.”

My preferred solution to this is for each side to allow the other to save face but, as I noted earlier, the main purpose of the shutdown is to embarrass the other side so that’s unlikely to happen.

By my calculation these exempt employees have now missed exactly one paycheck and that by one day. There’s an obvious resolution to this technical violation of the court’s decision: pay the exempt employees.

However, I do have a question. With all due respect to Judge Campbell-Smith (the snippet quoted above is in error—the deciding judge was Patricia Campbell-Smith), does the Congress actually have the authority to micromanage the executive at this level? Do the courts? I’m skeptical. I would think that a reasonableness standard would apply. Perhaps someone can enlighten me on this.

9 comments

Heads I Win

At The Conversation academic Parker Ellen uses his study of the science of negotiation in considering a way out of the impasse between President Trump and the Democratic-led House:

Although the current political climate clearly amplifies both sides’ competitive approach and hinders a shift from positions to interests, that is the most productive path to an agreement. Unfortunately, we have seen only hints of a discussion of interests to date.

To end the shutdown, both sides should find a way to make that shift. For example, Trump could do more to acknowledge the Democrats’ interest in fair treatment of those who want to enter the United States. Schumer and Pelosi could put more emphasis on the importance of Trump’s desire for increased border security.

And most importantly, both sides should present proposals to end the crisis that satisfy the other party’s legitimate interests. It’s a difficult task, but it’s the only way both sides, and the country, can win.

Hat tip: The Moderate Voice

I don’t think he quite apprehends the present situation. In this instance the actual material of the positions is overwhelmed by the interests at stake and the primary interest is for the other side to lose. Trump must get his wall. The House Democrats must refuse it. There is no middle ground. They are completely incompatible.

In a purely rational world without political considerations a resolution along the lines produced by pundits of both parties would have prevailed. But it’s not a purely rational world without political considerations and the political considerations have overflowed their banks and are threatening to drown the negotiation.

1 comment