Van Dyke Sentenced

Jason Van Dyke, the Chicago police officer who murdered Laquon McDonald and whose actions were captured in a much-publicized video, has been sentenced to 81 months in prison following his conviction for murder with extenuating circumstances. From ABC 7 Chicago:

CHICAGO (WLS) — Jason Van Dyke, the Chicago police officer convicted of murdering 17-year-old Laquan McDonald, was sentenced to 81 months, or 6 years and 9 months, in prison and two years mandatory supervised release.

Judge Vincent Gaughan said he considered the most serious charge to be the second degree murder charge, not the 16 aggravated battery charges, and made his sentencing decision on that murder charge.

“I’ve been told time and time again that the citizenry of the county of Cook is not going to be satisfied with a sentence that’s anything south of 20 years,” said Pastor Marvin Hunter, McDonald’s great uncle. “However I want to say to everyone – everyone in the city of Chicago and across this country – that if they had sentenced him to 1 minute, it is a victory. It is a victory because what has happened in this courtroom today has never happened in the history of this county and it sets a precedent and it sends a strong message to unjust police officers that now you can and will go to jail if you’re caught lying, if you’re caught breaking the law.”

I found Pastor Hunter’s statement strong and reasoned but it’s not clear to me what would have satisifed Laquon McDonald’s family or, as he put it, “the citizenry of the county of Cook”. A maximum sentence? A death sentence? He may well have received that.

What concerns me about the entire sorry matter is that not enough attention has been paid to what motivated Mr. Van Dyke. Did he think he was invulnerable? Did he think he was defending himself? Is that, indeed, what he was trained to do? I think that much more has been on trial here than Jason Van Dyke and however harsh or lenient you may feel Van Dyke’s sentence has been the Chicago Police Department and the whole system of justice has been given a slap on the hand.

2 comments

If We Can Keep It

Do Congress and the president have an obligation to find a compromise to end the federal government shutdown? I think it can be argued that they do and that obligation transcends their obligations to their constituents, political parties, ideologies, or other agenda.

Article 4, Section 4 of the U. S. Constitution guarantees a republican form of government. It has been known for more than two millennia that republican government requires the possibility of compromise. If compromise has become impossible, that is inconsistent with republican government.

The dictionary definition of “compromise” is:

an agreement or a settlement of a dispute that is reached by each side making concession

and the compromise presently available has been obvious and proposed by practically every editorial page in the country.

I don’t believe that the actual substance of the disagreement between President Trump and Speaker Pelosi is what’s at stake. I think that both parties are trying to maintain a zero-sum game in which they win and the other side loses.

16 comments

Judge Finds No Conspiracy

Three Chicago police officers have been found “Not guilty” of conspiracy, obstruction of justice, and official misconduct in their actions following the murder of Laquan McDonald five years ago. NBC News reports:

Three Chicago police officers were found not guilty on all charges that they conspired to protect their colleague who shot and killed teenager Laquan McDonald in 2014.

Officer Thomas Gaffney, ex-Officer Joseph Walsh and former Detective David March were acquitted on charges of conspiracy, obstruction of justice and official misconduct by Cook County Judge Domenica Stephenson.

“This court finds that the state has failed to meet its burden on all charges,” Stephenson ruled. “Defendants are discharged.”

The defendants, who each faced up to five years behind bars, were all involved in the probe following officer Jason Van Dyke’s killing of McDonald.

The three officers opted against having a jury hear their case, and instead asked for a bench trial, leaving their fate in the hands of Judge Stephenson.

All that this really tells us is that it is very, very difficult to convict a police officer of anything in Chicago. One of the things it does not tell us is how the community will react. We’re probably lucky it’s predicted to be the coldest weekend of the year so far.

This will do nothing to improve the reputation of the CPD or improve its relationship with the community.

5 comments

The Economists’ Plan for Dealing With Climate Change

Here is the text of a statement by a panel of eminent economists on climate change, quoted from the Wall Street Journal:

Global climate change is a serious problem calling for immediate national action. Guided by sound economic principles, we are united in the following policy recommendations.

I. A carbon tax offers the most cost-effective lever to reduce carbon emissions at the scale and speed that is necessary. By correcting a well-known market failure, a carbon tax will send a powerful price signal that harnesses the invisible hand of the marketplace to steer economic actors towards a low-carbon future.

II. A carbon tax should increase every year until emissions reductions goals are met and be revenue neutral to avoid debates over the size of government. A consistently rising carbon price will encourage technological innovation and large-scale infrastructure development. It will also accelerate the diffusion of carbon-efficient goods and services.

II. A sufficiently robust and gradually rising carbon tax will replace the need for various carbon regulations that are less efficient. Substituting a price signal for cumbersome regulations will promote economic growth and provide the regulatory certainty companies need for long- term investment in clean-energy alternatives.

IV. To prevent carbon leakage and to protect U.S. competitiveness, a border carbon adjustment system should be established. This system would enhance the competitiveness of American firms that are more energy-efficient than their global competitors. It would also create an incentive for other nations to adopt similar carbon pricing.

V. To maximize the fairness and political viability of a rising carbon tax, all the revenue should be returned directly to U.S. citizens through equal lump-sum rebates. The majority of American families, including the most vulnerable, will benefit financially by receiving more in “carbon dividends” than they pay in increased energy prices.

The signatories of the statement are:

George Akerlof, Robert Aumann, Angus Deaton, Peter Diamond, Robert Engle, Eugene Fama, Lars Peter Hansen, Oliver Hart, Bengt Holmström, Daniel Kahneman, Finn Kydland, Robert Lucas, Eric Maskin, Daniel McFadden, Robert Merton, Roger Myerson, Edmund Phelps, Alvin Roth, Thomas Sargent, Myron Scholes, Amartya Sen, William Sharpe, Robert Shiller, Christopher Sims, Robert Solow, Michael Spence and Richard Thaler are recipients of the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.

Paul Volcker is a former Federal Reserve chairman.

Martin Baily, Michael Boskin, Martin Feldstein, Jason Furman, Austan Goolsbee, Glenn Hubbard, Alan Krueger, Edward Lazear, N. Gregory Mankiw, Christina Romer, Harvey Rosen and Laura Tyson are former chairmen of the president’s Council of Economic Advisers.

Ben Bernanke, Alan Greenspan and Janet Yellen have chaired both the Fed and the Council of Economic Advisers.

George Shultz and Lawrence Summers are former Treasury secretaries.

I have nothing to add to this other than to observe that it overcomes my biggest criticism of a carbon tax in Paragraph V and I think that Paragraph V is all but certain not to be implemented.

Update

Actually I do have something to add. In the absence of serious enforcement of a similar tax in China, their plan would lead to continuing deindustrialization of the United States with industry moving to China, India, Vietnam, etc. A border adjustment system would do nothing to mitigate that. How do they plan to impel China, India, and other countries that are the beneficiaries of this deindustrialization to adopt similar carbon taxes? If that doesn’t happen doesn’t that threaten to increase carbon emissions rather than decreasing them?

How do they plan to measure the results to determine when emission goals have been met?

Are they aware that carbon emissions in China, India, etc. do not stay in China, India, etc.? How do they plan to distinguish between American carbon emissions and Chinese carbon emissions?

Those are among the reasons I have long thought that capture was a better strategy.

5 comments

The Comebacks That Weren’t

In a piece at the Wall Street Journal Joseph Epstein provides a list of mildly amusing comebacks that were never made:

The first that occurs to me is Dan Quayle, the victim, in a 1988 debate with Sen. Lloyd Bentsen, of a notable put-down. Mr. Quayle compared his experience to that of John F. Kennedy, to which Bentsen famously replied: “Senator, you’re no Jack Kennedy.” I wonder if it might have occurred later to Mr. Quayle that he should have responded, “Then again, neither was Jack Kennedy.”

Elizabeth Warren might have saved herself much grief after Donald Trump mocked her as “Pocahontas” if, instead of running off to have a DNA test, she had offered a politically incorrect rejoinder: “Mr. Trump, I wish I were Pocahontas, so that I might have your preposterous scalp on my belt.”

When Joe Biden claimed, in response to Mr. Trump’s unfortunate remarks about grabbing women, that if he were in high school he “would take him behind the gym and beat the hell out of him,” Mr. Trump replied that if Mr. Biden, tried, he “would go down fast and hard crying all the way.” But how much better if Mr. Trump had said, “O.K. Let’s do it. Shall we say hair-spray at 20 paces?”

Then there were the Brett Kavanaugh confirmation hearings. Surely the highlight was Sen. Cory Booker’s “Spartacus moment.” The next day, when it was Mr. Booker’s turn to ask further questions, imagine if now-Justice Kavanaugh greeted the New Jersey senator with “Hail, Spartacus!” But, then, unless one is Oliver Wendell Holmes, I suppose one cannot exhibit wit and expect to be confirmed to a seat on the Supreme Court, too.

I think that practically all such comebacks are in fact L’esprit d’escalier, witty ripostes that might have been made but never were. Most public figures aren’t particularly witty and never has that been moreso than today with speech writers, political consultants, public relations agents and other hired guns? Who needs wit when you have wealth?

2 comments

The Portrait of Kamala Gray

The picture of Kamala Harris that emerges from Lara Bazelon’s New York Times piece is far from the lovely, sanitized one being promoted. To my eye it is of a dedicated statist that takes whatever position promotes her political career. I hope that’s not what Democratic voters are looking for.

3 comments

Vox Populi Suprema Lex

Megan McCardle remarks about Brexit in her Washington Post column:

For the record, I think the outcome of Brexit is likely to be quite unhappy for Britain and for the “Leave” voters who expect it to improve their lives. My support for following through with it rests entirely on H.L. Mencken’s bitter proverb, “Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard.”

Coldblooded, I know. But let me join May in asking: What’s the alternative?

To answer that question, consider the French “yellow vest” protesters revolting against President Emmanuel Macron’s bloodless technocratism — or look closer to home, where much of America’s educated professional class is in a perpetual stew about President Trump’s violations of democratic norms.

Frankly, I’m stewing about them myself — boiling over, really. But I’ve had to reckon with readers who support Trump and are unmoved by my pleas about the sanctity of democratic proceduralism.

To them, all those sacred procedures are the way that insiders rig the game against outsiders such as themselves. Insiders may throw around phrases such as “the rule of law,” but in the end, what constitutes a violation of those rules is decided by a tiny class of judges and politicians, abetted by professional commentators. Like any hometown ref, outsiders say, the insiders call all the close ones in favor of their own class — or, for the ones that aren’t close, the rules can be rewritten on the fly.

It’s hard to deny that the sentiment has a grain of truth. Not when those elites respond to populist insurgencies by questioning the legitimacy of a presidential election conducted under long-standing rules, or by threatening to hold Brexit do-overs until the voters fall in line. Call me naive, but I think that when a populist campaign against self-dealing insiders starts smashing up your politics, the most important thing those insiders can do is not prove them right.

I only have two things to add. There is a pattern we have seen over and over again in Illinois. An individual attends a mediocre law school, get himself or herself elected to public office while retaining a connection with his or her small undistinguished law firm, and holds elective office for twenty, thirty years, somehow emerging at the end of that process a multi-millionaire. I do not think it’s too much to suggest there’s something wrong with that picture. Political officeholders are political officeholders. They are not the best or the brightest. They are not “our betters”.

Second, the European Union is a fraud and always has been. It is primarily a means for subsidizing German manufacturers and French farmers at the expense of farmers and manufacturers in the other countries of the EU. Giving it credit for keeping the peace is arrant nonsense. Would that peace have existed without the U. S. military looming over it? I’m skeptical.

2 comments

The Case for Open Borders

In a column at the New York Times tech columnist Farhad Manjoo makes the argument for completely open borders in the United States:

There’s a witheringly obvious moral, economic, strategic and cultural case for open borders, and we have a political opportunity to push it. As Democrats jockey for the presidency, there’s room for a brave politician to oppose President Trump’s racist immigration rhetoric not just by fighting his wall and calling for the abolishment of I.C.E. but also by making a proactive and affirmative case for the vast expansion of immigration.

It would be a change from the stale politics of the modern era, in which both parties agreed on the supposed wisdom of “border security” and assumed that immigrants were to be feared.

As an immigrant, this idea confounds me. My family came to the United States from our native South Africa in the late 1980s. After jumping through lots of expensive and confusing legal hoops, we became citizens in 2000. Obviously, it was a blessing: In rescuing me from a society in which people of my color were systematically oppressed, America has given me a chance at liberty.

But why had I deserved that chance, while so many others back home — because their parents lacked certain skills, money or luck — were denied it?

The answer to his question is complicated and various but I’ll summarize it this way. Open borders do not provide a system of universal peace, prosperity, and brotherhood but rather war and misery without limits. No right of immigration is recognized under that most expansive document of human rights, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. There is a right of self-determination which means we have a right to limit immigration. There is no moral obligation to take immigrants in. Mass immigration tends to destabilize both the sending and receiving countries socially and politically.

Expect to hear Mr. Manjoo’s argument with greater ardor and vehemence in the coming years.

0 comments

Brouhaha du Jour

Today’s brouhaha du jour reminds me that not only does running for political office not require one to understand the U. S. Constitution it does not require that the seeker have read it and the situation is even worse for pundits. Here’s the issue as presented by Chris Cilizza of CNN:

Sometimes the best power moves in politics are conveyed in the most mundane language.

“Sadly, given the security concerns and unless government re-opens this week, I suggest we work together to determine another suitable date after government has re-opened for this address or for you to consider delivering your State of the Union address in writing to the Congress on January 29,” wrote Speaker Nancy Pelosi to President Donald Trump on Wednesday.

Make no mistake: Pelosi’s decision to disinvite Trump from delivering his “State of the Union” address to Congress is a total power play designed to remind Trump that a) Congress is a co-equal branch of government and b) his willingness to keep the government shuttered until he gets money for a border wall is going to have impacts on him, too.
Just in case you missed that message, Pelosi delivered it again in an interview with CNN’s Ashley Killough. “This is a housekeeping matter in the Congress of the United States, so we can honor the responsibility of the invitation we extended to the President,” said Pelosi. “He can make it from the Oval Office if he wants.”

and here’s Article II Section 3 of the U. S. Constitution:

He shall from time to time give to the Congress Information on the State of the Union, and recommend to their Consideration such Measures as he shall judge necessary and expedient; he may, on extraordinary Occasions, convene both Houses, or either of them, and in Case of Disagreement between them, with Respect to the Time of Adjournment, he may adjourn them to such Time as he shall think proper; he shall receive Ambassadors and other public Ministers; he shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed, and shall Commission all the Officers of the United States.

The Congress does not have the authority to invite or disinvite the president to anything. If that is the custom, it is a courtesy not a requirement. It has generally been held that it does not even have the authority to issue a subpoena to the president.

Now I happen to think that the practice of delivering the State of Union message publicly in person should be abandoned. I think it’s a custom unbecoming of a democracy and only began with Woodrow Wilson as a tool for rallying support. But not only does the president not require an invitation from the Congress to deliver it he or she can actually summon both houses of the Congress to deliver it.

11 comments

Carol Channing, 1921-2019

I was remiss in not mentioning that another Broadway great, Carol Channing, has died at the age of 97. From Variety:

Larger-than-life musical stage personality Carol Channing, who immortalized the characters of Lorelei Lee in “Gentlemen Prefer Blondes” and Dolly Gallagher Levi in “Hello, Dolly!,” has died. She was 97.

Channing died Tuesday of natural causes at her home in Rancho Mirage, Calif.

Her publicist B. Harlan Boll confirmed the news. He wrote, “It is with extreme heartache, that I have to announce the passing of an original Industry Pioneer, Legend and Icon — Miss Carol Channing. Saying good-bye is one of the hardest things I have ever had to do, but I know that when I feel those uncontrollable urges to laugh at everything and/or nothing at all, it will be because she is with me, tickling my funny bone.”

Channing won a Tony as best actress in a musical in 1964 for Jerry Herman’s musical version of Thornton Wilder’s “The Matchmaker.” Until then she had been closely identified with the gold-digging Ms. Lee in the 1948 musical adaptation of Anita Loos’ flapper-era novel.

Her larger-than-life personality did not lend itself to film but on stage she was magic. I saw her in Hello, Dolly! and she was wonderful. (I have also seen Ginger Rogers, Ethel Merman, and Pearl Bailey playing Dolly Levi. The Pearl Bailey-Cab Calloway all-black production of Hello, Dolly! was incomparably great.)

I don’t think we’ll ever see her like again. It is a different, smaller world.

5 comments