AWS’s Market Share


To put a little meat on the bones of a comment I made in an earlier post, consider the graph above. Amazon’s share of the important web services marketplace is very nearly larger than the next 14 players put together, and not far from being larger than all of the other players put together.

And its market share is not decreasing over time. Most of the competition is among the players in the lower tier rather than between AWS and what you might think were its main competition, e.g. Microsoft, Google, IBM, etc.

Anyone who’s taken microeconomics courses beyond Econ 101 will recognize that as a classic structure of an oligopoly. Additionally, that Amazon is using its market power to extend its way into other markets is obvious, cf. home automation, advertising, artificial intelligence, even home cleaning.

3 comments

In Case You’ve Forgotten

In case you’ve forgotten just how awful the countries of the Gulf are, there are two stories that should remind you. The first is about Iran. Apparently, they’ve just publicly hanged a man for the crime of being a homosexual:

The Islamic Republic of Iran publicly hanged a 31-year-old Iranian man after he was found guilty of charges related to violations of Iran’s anti-gay laws, according to the state-controlled Iranian Students’ News Agency.

The unidentified man was hanged on January 10 in the southwestern city of Kazeroon based on criminal violations of “lavat-e be onf” – sexual intercourse between two men, as well as kidnapping charges, according to ISNA. Iran’s radical sharia law system proscribes the death penalty for gay sex.

while Saudi Arabia jailed and tortured a woman for advocating women’s rights:

M.B.S. isn’t a great reformer, and he isn’t coming clean about Khashoggi’s murder.

Nor is he releasing Hathloul, who, along with others, had peacefully and persistently campaigned for years to allow women the right to drive.

In 2014, she was arrested when she tried to drive into Saudi Arabia with a driver’s license from the United Arab Emirates, nominally valid also in Saudi Arabia. Then in 2015, Hathloul was one of the first women to run for a seat on a municipal council. (She lost.)

She moved to the emirates. But in 2017, Saudi security forces effectively kidnapped her and her husband and returned them to the kingdom. The couple have divorced, and while accounts differ, some believe this is because of pressure the government placed on the husband.

Shortly before women were allowed to drive last June, the government rearrested Hathloul, along with other women’s rights activists who had fought for the right the government was about to grant.

“She said she had been held in solitary confinement, beaten, waterboarded, given electric shocks, sexually harassed and threatened with rape and murder,” her sister, Alia al-Hathloul, who lives in Belgium, wrote in a searing Op-Ed in The Times this month, recounting what Loujain had told their parents when they saw her. “My parents then saw that her thighs were blackened by bruises.”

Presently, we reckon Iran as our adversary and Saudi Arabia as our ally. I don’t see a lot to choose between them. And it’s not just Iran and Saudi Arabia and it’s not just the countries of the Gulf. I could produce similar stories about just about every country from the Bosporus to the Pacific, from the Mediterranean to the Cape of Good Hope, and from the Rio Grande to the Cape Horn.

This sounds like a good opportunity to remind you of John Quincy Adams’s remarks on American foreign policy:

America, with the same voice which spoke herself into existence as a nation, proclaimed to mankind the inextinguishable rights of human nature, and the only lawful foundations of government. America, in the assembly of nations, since her admission among them, has invariably, though often fruitlessly, held forth to them the hand of honest friendship, of equal freedom, of generous reciprocity.

She has uniformly spoken among them, though often to heedless and often to disdainful ears, the language of equal liberty, of equal justice, and of equal rights.

She has, in the lapse of nearly half a century, without a single exception, respected the independence of other nations while asserting and maintaining her own.

She has abstained from interference in the concerns of others, even when conflict has been for principles to which she clings, as to the last vital drop that visits the heart.

She has seen that probably for centuries to come, all the contests of that Aceldama the European world, will be contests of inveterate power, and emerging right.

Wherever the standard of freedom and Independence has been or shall be unfurled, there will her heart, her benedictions and her prayers be.

But she goes not abroad, in search of monsters to destroy.

She is the well-wisher to the freedom and independence of all.

She is the champion and vindicator only of her own.

As I have remarked and documented in the past when people come to the United States to live they may not bring their possessions but they do bring their political and social views.

I don’t care about the colors of the skins of the immigrants who will come here in the coming years but I do care about their political and social views. Most of the people coming here now aren’t “yearning to breathe free” but for a raise. Being human they will long to rebuild their old lives here. We need to be free to criticize those old lives without being charged with bigotry.

9 comments

Alive and Well

I actually liked a lot of what was in Anand Giridharadas’s sweeping criticism in the Guardian of the United States (not limited to the United States but actually extending to most of what is called “the West”). I presume it will cause smoke to come out of the ears of some readers. He opens with stating an apparent paradox. Here’s a snippet of it:

The tools for becoming an entrepreneur appear to be more accessible than ever, for the student who learns coding online or the Uber driver – but the share of young people who own a business has fallen by two-thirds since the 1980s. America has birthed both a wildly successful online book superstore, Amazon, and another company, Google, that has scanned more than 25m books for public use – but illiteracy has remained stubbornly in place, and the fraction of Americans who read at least one work of literature a year has dropped by almost a quarter in recent decades. The government has more data at its disposal and more ways of talking and listening to citizens – but only a quarter as many people find it trustworthy as did in the tempestuous 1960s.

It’s lengthy and bruising. I disagree with Mr. Giridharadas’s explanation of the reasons but it’s a strong criticism nonetheless. He’s on shakier ground when it comes to his remarks about “the new elites”:

This genre of elites believes and promotes the idea that social change should be pursued principally through the free market and voluntary action, not public life and the law and the reform of the systems that people share in common; that it should be supervised by the winners of capitalism and their allies, and not be antagonistic to their needs; and that the biggest beneficiaries of the status quo should play a leading role in the status quo’s reform.

This is what I call MarketWorld – an ascendant power elite defined by the concurrent drives to do well and do good, to change the world while also profiting from the status quo.

I am flabbergasted that he doesn’t recognize that these are the same neoliberal policies, dominant in U. S. thought over the period of the last 70 years, that have led to the situation in which we find ourselves now. Clearly, neoliberalism is alive and well.

What I think he misses and what all too many miss is that there are only two ways of allocating resources, whether they be raw materials, labor resources, or any other resource: a command economy or a market economy. Command economies have failed miserably wherever they have been tried.

Before you wrap yourself in the flag and rise in defense of our present system we do not presently have a market economy. We have a form of command economy known as “crony capitalism”. Between state socialism (what most of those presently mounting the rhetorical barricades advocate) and crony capitalism I don’t see a great deal to commend one or the other. They are both institutionalized corruption.

I think we need a major re-engineering of how we organize our affairs but I have no hope that the reorganizations that are likely to take place will be to the good. Command economies will continue to allocate resources inefficiently and (miraculously!) to benefit those in power. I am concerned that at the end of my life the United States will more closely resemble today’s Venezuela than it will today’s Switzerland.

4 comments

How the Trade War Ends

You might be interested in looking at this piece at Politico by Doug Palmer and Wendy Wu. After a substantial amount of build-up they finally get to the subject with these two paragraphs:

While China might be willing to agree to an enforcement mechanism as part of the deal, they “probably don’t want the United States to be judge and jury” of whether they have faithfully implemented the pact, said Scott Kennedy, a China expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

A more attractive alternative for Beijing would be for the agreement to be enforced through the World Trade Organization. But the United States might not be willing to accept that because the WTO dispute settlement process is notoriously slow.

I believe that the circumstances under which the so-called “trade war” between the U. S. and China ends depend upon what happens in 2020 and the Chinese are well aware of that. If President Trump is re-elected the negotiations will stretch on, a little insignificant sweetener added here, a bit of saber-rattling there, for the next four years thereafter. If President Trump is defeated, his tariffs will quickly be rescinded unilaterally and that will be that.

In my view the way this particular negotiation is being conducted is wrong. It is being assumed that it is a Dutch auction when the opposite is the case. Our issues with China are increasing not decreasing and the consequences should be increasing as well. China’s WTO membership should be put on the table. We should be talking about increasing and extending the tariffs or even embargo.

The Chinese authorities are the world’s heavyweight champions at waiting out their opponents or announcing concessions that are never actually implemented. We should be talking about decreasing or removing tariffs after whatever measures China puts into place are implemented and not a moment before and settle for not a whit less than China living up to its international obligations fully.

1 comment

Why the State of the Union Message Should Be Abandoned

In an op-ed in the Washington Post Mitch Daniels explains why we should do away with the State of the Union message. He covers many of the bases: it has an inherent propensity to become a “throne speech”, as Jefferson noted when he demurred from delivering a SOTU message, it’s a public relations opportunity from a presidency that no longer needs them, the “shout outs” that have become a standard part of the SOTU since Reagan are undignified. Its increasingly participatory quality lacks the energy and honesty of the British Parliament’s “question time” which is a daily event and is highly staged. Its institution matches the growth in the “imperial presidency”, something that should be diminished, if anything.

Under the Constitution the president’s power is supreme in conducting foreign policy, with respect to the military, and in the day to day management of the executive branch of government. Recent court decisions limiting those should be thrown out as the trash that they are.

Under our system as defined the president’s power is limited and narrowly defined. The real power is in the hands of the Congress. What makes the president powerful is Congress’s deliberate abrogation of responsibility. Steadfastly refusing to do anything means you won’t be blamed for anything other than doing nothing nothing which the members of Congress seem to be able to survive better than angering their constituents by doing things they dislike.

Congress is furiously busy in idleness but make no mistake—its members are idle. Work is defined in terms of motion. This is not new. As some of you may recall I’ve been listening to old Burns and Allen radio programs. In one exchange between George and Gracie, Gracie urges George to run for Congress:

George: I can’t run for Congress. I don’t even know what a Congressman does. I’d be sitting there twiddling my thumbs.

Gracie: And you say you don’t know what Congressmen do.

and then there was Sam Clemens’s remark: “There is no distinctly native American criminal class save Congress” or Will Rogers’s wisecracks “Papers say: ‘Congress is deadlocked and can’t act.’ I think that is the greatest blessing that could befall this country” and “The rest of the people know the condition of the country, for they live in it, but Congress has no idea what is going on in America, so the President has to tell ’em”, in direct reference to the State of the Union message. A better way for the members of Congress to be informed about the condition of the country would be to return to their constituencies.

Since its very earliest days Congress has been crude, crass, and fractious. There is a reason that Congress conducts so little of its business in public. If it were to do so, people would lose respect for it which in my opinion would be all the better.

0 comments

The Plan Is Working

I was pretty amused by this piece at Ozy by Claire Jones and Valentina Romei. It seems that Germany’s export business is slowing down:

Alexander Hinterkopf, a maker of digital industrial printers, built his business through regular trips from the company’s German headquarters to big markets around the world. But in recent months his travels have been less fruitful.

“The environment can be summed up in one word — uncertainty,” says the Baden-Württemberg-based businessman. “Uncertainty is never a good thing in business, it means you always postpone decisions. Since the summer, I’ve been to China three times, and each time customers come up with another reason to postpone.”

After a decade of boom, a darkening political climate is beginning to cloud the international economic outlook. The global economy is forecast to grow less than 3 percent for the first time since 2009 in 2019, according to Consensus Economics, which polls economists worldwide. Germany, the world’s fourth-largest economy, with an export machine of 1.6 trillion euros a year, is among those most exposed.

First off Germany’s imports from China are growing faster than its exports to China. That’s not hard to understand. China doesn’t need Germany any more to build its factories for them which is what a lot of Chinese-German trade has been. The Chinese can build their own factories now. And the Chinese authorities manage their trade so as not to import too much. Welcome to the club, Germany.

But it’s not just China that poses a problem for Germany’s export-driven prosperity. Fellow EU members are tapped out, largely due to German policies. They can’t borrow any more to import more from Germany.

When you take a “beggar thy neighborh” approach to trade and your neighbors become beggars, doesn’t that mean that your plan is working?

0 comments

Funk

I’m in kind of a funk right now. I like the project I’ve been working on for the last six months but I don’t much care for the company for which I’m working. The project will probably be extended for another six months but what happens to me after that is unclear. My impression is that I’m sort of a square peg in a round hole. I am more capable, more self-sufficient, and more expensive than my employer is comfortable with. I’d like another job but I’m realistic enough to recognize that new jobs are becoming increasingly difficult for me to find. One of the things holding me back is that my present job title doesn’t actually represent what I do—it’s about three notches below my actual responsibilities.

On another realistic note I probably wouldn’t think much of any company I worked for unless I was running it and maybe not even then.

5 comments

Après moi, l’ennui

In a piece at the Star-Tribune Fareed Zakharia remarks on what apparently was a pretty lugubrious meeting of the World Economic Forum at Davos:

The leaders of several smaller countries (all of whom insisted on staying off the record) described the world as adrift and lacking in any collective purpose, with only voices about narrow self-interest and conflict being heard. “When the Americans are engaged, we have a sense of direction,” one of them said to me. “We might disagree on some points, but at least there is a larger conversation, some efforts at cooperation. Now the only energy is negative — worries about retreat, trade wars. That’s not a world in which it is easy for us to move forward. We are all stuck.”

This, then, is the post-American world. Not one marked by Chinese dominance or Asian arrogance. Not an outright anti-American one, but in fact, one in which many yearn for a greater U.S. presence. One in which countries are freelancing, narrowly pursuing their own interests, and hoping that the framework of international order remains reasonably stable. But with no one actively shoring up the international system, the great question remains: In a world without leaders, will that system over time weaken and eventually crumble?

Once again, the irony seems to be lost on Mr. Zakharia. Can you think of any example over the period of the last 25 years in which the world has followed the lead of the United States on anything? I can’t. To my eye for European countries the U. S. has mostly served as a foil and now it’s not even that.

Since the end of World War II, the United States has divided the world into two camps: enemies and friends. Enemies are to be opposed or subverted with economic, diplomatic, and military power. Friends are weak and passive. The great exception to that strategy is frenemy China. China won’t let itself be weak and passive but it also is not being opposed. There’s just too much good money to be made from cozying up to it.

We are seeing the fullness of the strategy of infantilizing your friends. At first it was okay. Then they became like a bunch of rebellious teenages—openly defiant but still happy for three squares and a roof over their heads. Now they’re like a group of seven year olds on a rainy day.

0 comments

A Winner Defeated

I also wonder how a man who unquestionably thinks of himself as a winner will deal with what certainly seems to be a defeat? That regardless of how the government shutdown was resolved it would have been portrayed as a defeat for Trump is irrelevant. At this point it is a defeat. I suspect we haven’t heard the end of Trump’s wall. As George Santayana said, only the dead have seen the end of war.

The entire notion of a government shutdown is an artifact, a political strategy. Without omnibus spending bills or continuing resolutions there would be no government shutdowns. We should amend the Constitution to prohibit omnibus spending bills or continuing resolutions and to mandate single-subject bills written in plain language. Anything else is a formula for corruption.

10 comments

A Week of Ironies

I wonder if the dreadful irony of people celebrating Martin Luther King’s birthday by judging people based on the color of their skin rather than the content of their character is lost on people? And we’ve had an awful progress in humor over the years. First, irony became the only recognized form of humor. Now we’re incapable of recognizing irony and humor is virtually being driven away.

There’s an old story about a comic who tells a friend that he’s started seeing a psychiatrist. On their first appointment the psychiatrist tells him to lie down on the couch and tell him what’s bothering him. The friend asks “Did it do you any good?” The comic responds “I haven’t been able to get another appointment since. He’s doing my act in Philadelphia.”

7 comments