The Only Thing

All that I can say about this complaint at Jacobin that Congressional Democrats, too, are climate deniers and must be forced to take drastic action is if the author is looking for sincerity, genuineness, public-spiritedness, or foresight in the Congress, he’s looking in the wrong place. The only thing that matters to the Congressional leadership, Republican or Democratic, is power.

There is no long term remedy for this. Voting the present scoundrels out will only vote new scoundrels in. The new scoundrels may seem good enough now but in a term or two they’ll be just as bad as the old scoundrels were.

2 comments

Should Government Shutdowns Be Prevented?

Here’s another question for you this morning. Should federal government shutdowns be prevented? If so, how?

I think they should be prevented by amending the Constitution to mandate that all bills enacted by the Congress should be limited to a single subject. Government shutdowns are an artifact, a political stunt. Continuing resolutions and omnibus spending bills are both undemocratic and corrupt. A frequently-mentioned remedy, an automatic CR, is even worse.

0 comments

‘Splain Me

I’m seeing a lot of bitter complaints on how the U. S.’s leaving Afghanistan will allow the entire country to come under Taliban control again. Can someone please explain to me what would have needed to happen for the Taliban not to be in a position to take control of Afghanistan? They are, in fact, a native Afghan movement after all.

Did they envision our continuing to occupy Afghanistan forever? How about Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Syria? Did they think that was acceptable to the American people? What gave them that impression?

2 comments

None of the Above

I am continuing to try to assess which Chicago mayoral candidate I will vote for. Here’s a list of Yes/No questions submitted to the candidates by WBEZ, our public radio station. The questions are not what I would have asked and I didn’t like all of the answers from any of the candidates. The candidates whose responses I liked the best, God help me, were Gery Chico, Bill Daley, and Willie Wilson.

0 comments

Help Wanted: Finn

How does an 80% labor force participation rate grab you? That’s what Finland will need in order to maintain its present welfare model. From Straits Times:

HELSINKI (BLOOMBERG) – Finland is ranked the world’s happiest country, but its population is ageing faster than most and that’s putting pressure on the government to get more people into jobs to help pay for those retiring.

Fixing the country’s labour market is likely to dominate the agenda when Finns go to the polls on April 14 to elect a new government.

The new administration will need to raise the employment rate to 75 per cent of working-age Finns by 2023, and to 80 per cent after that, according to a civil servants’ report published on Monday (Jan 28) that outlines the key challenges ahead.

The rate is now at 72 per cent, meeting a 2015 target set by Prime Minister Juha Sipila which back then was deemed borderline impossible.

That year, just 68 per cent of working-age people had jobs, the country was clawing its way out of a three-year economic slump – its second since the financial crisis – and the mood was grim.

Now with about 140,000 more people at work compared to when Sipila took office, roughly 150,000 more jobs are still needed to safeguard the northernmost euro member’s welfare model, the report said.

Sounds to me like the problem is that there just aren’t enough Finns. They’re not alone. It’s a problem for many small countries, particularly those with distinctive languages and cultures and at least one large country has it, too: Japan.

Immigration is not a great solution, either. Their system depends on strong social cohesion, Finnish is a tough language to learn and only useful in Finland, and so on. They’ve been receiving and accepting immigrants lately who’ve reported they like it but my guess is the number of people who want to learn Finnish is limited. The Finns are not particularly chatty and are notoriously stubborn.

3 comments

Ways and Means

I see that the professional punditry is catching up to where I was last week on the subject of a wealth tax. In his Wall Street Journal column James Freeman echoes the points I made last week:

There are excellent economic arguments against this new tax plan. But today this column would like to focus on the illegality of the Warren scheme. Ms. Warren seems to understand this problem as well. Typically lawmakers announcing new legislation don’t feel the need to simultaneously try to rebut anticipated claims that the bill is unconstitutional. But the Warren press release links to two letters on the subject, each signed by various law professors at famous universities.

No matter how many academics she persuades to sign on to this ideological project, the plain fact is that the founders specifically prohibited such a tax. A well-informed reader notes:

The 16th Amendment authorizes Congress to tax “incomes, from whatever source derived.” It does not give Congress the power to tax balance sheets as well.
At the Constitutional Convention, Gouverneur Morris explained in plain English what every delegate understood “direct taxation” to be: it is when the federal government attempts to “stretch its hand directly into the pockets of the people,” rather than acting through the intermediary of a state. Direct taxes, the delegates decided, would be authorized only if each state paid the same per capita amount – i.e., only if the taxes were apportioned to population. Warren’s proposal to stretch her hand directly into the pockets of the people would not be apportioned and so it would violate both the 16th Amendment (failing as an income tax) and Article I, Section 9, Clause 4 (failing because it is an unapportioned direct tax).
In NFIB v. Sebelius, Chief Justice Roberts got this point wrong and held that the Obamacare tax is not a direct tax… Notwithstanding Roberts’s obviously hasty and slipshod analysis (it’s all of a page), the facts of that case are unique (he claimed the tax was not on people or property but rather “it is triggered by specific circumstances.”) Warren’s tax is quite obviously a tax on property, which the courts have repeatedly held constitutes a direct tax.
Warren might want to characterize her wealth tax as an “excise tax,” since such taxes were held constitutional before the adoption of the 16th Amendment. But an excise tax is levied on a specific transaction or a specific activity (e.g., gambling; using a truck on a highway). Will she claim the excise tax is for the privilege of living in America as a rich person?

Whether or not you agree with the effectiveness or necessity of a wealth tax, it is vital that we follow the proper processes and above all that means following the law. It is not enough to point to a need or our own good intentions. Backing constitutionality out of your preferred policies because they’re you’re preferred policies is not helpful.

24 comments

Illinois Isn’t the Only Corrupt State

Illinois’s primary competition for the unsought-for title of “Most Corrupt State” comes from New Jersey and Louisiana. The editors of the Wall Street Journal provide a glimpse of what’s been going on in New Jersey:

Over roughly a decade and a half, New Jersey’s Economic Development Authority has approved—though mostly not yet paid out—$10.9 billion in tax incentives tied to 161,804 new jobs and 80,027 retained jobs. But “key internal controls were lacking or nonexistent for the monitoring and oversight of recipient performance,” the audit says. As a glaring example, the development authority relied on jobs figures provided by the businesses receiving tax credits without verifying the data.

One company won $29 million in incentives even as its “statewide employment actually declined during the award performance period,” says the audit. Another company didn’t submit timely annual reports, and the state didn’t notice until alerted by the comptroller’s office. A third “hired six individuals in the last two weeks of its reporting period presumably to meet the number of employees required by its award agreement.”

The audit closely inspected a sample of 48 projects that the authority had certified as hitting their targets, accounting for 8,713 promised new jobs and 6,657 retained jobs. Nearly 20% of those claimed employees couldn’t be substantiated: 726 didn’t appear in the wage data reported to the state’s labor department; 261 did not seem to be working full time; 644 were counted by two incentive programs simultaneously; and 1,362 didn’t have enough information to be verified.

To put the dollar figures in perspective, New Jersey’s corporate tax produced about $2.1 billion in revenue in 2017. Individual and corporate tax rates were raised again last year, after the Democratic Governor struck a “compromise” with the Democratic Legislature. Businesses are taxed at a top rate of 11.5%, the second highest in the nation. That’s one reason New Jersey has ranked dead last, for several years running, in the Tax Foundation’s index of state business climates.

Rather than emphasizing the need for cutting taxes as the editors do, my reaction is that good intentions are not nearly enough, most of the time the intentions aren’t that good, and policies to promote growth need to be followed up with actual difficult, grueling, unrewarding work by state bureaucrats. That almost never happens.

3 comments

Left Behind

Touting the upcoming report from the Aspen Economic Strategy Group, Hank Paulson, Erskine Bowles, and Melissa Kearney have an op-ed in the Washington Post on the steps we need to take to keep Americans from “being left behind”. In my estimate they’re whistling past a graveyard:

First among them is a commitment to truth, which must be rooted in rigorous analysis. There can simply be no good policymaking without first establishing a common set of facts about what is happening in the world and what any given policy or proposal will likely accomplish.

Second, good policymaking requires that lawmakers trust one another. This takes time, the ability to convene in confidence and a mutual commitment to shared goals. This is precisely how, in 1997, President Bill Clinton, Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott (R-Miss.) and House Speaker Newt Gingrich (R-Ga.) negotiated the first balanced-budget agreement in a generation, and how, in 2008, a bipartisan majority in a Democratic-controlled Congress gave President George W. Bush the unprecedented powers necessary to stem the financial crisis and prevent another Great Depression. And both Bush and his successor, President Barack Obama, had the courage to take highly unpopular actions to save our economy, resisting pressure from their base to put the national interest ahead of partisan politics.

Third, our leaders must be willing to make principled compromises. Finding the middle ground has never been easy, and nobody wants to lose a negotiation. But today, our leaders are equating compromise with moral failure, making it that much harder to begin a discussion, much less reach agreement.

In a day in which everyone has their own facts, slogans are more important than an understanding of basic principles, and politics is strictly zero sum, I see no prospect for any of those guidelines being followed either in this Congress or probably the next. However in the interest of bonhomie here are my prescriptions:

  1. We should adopt a point system for immigration like those of Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.
  2. We should expand the number of H2-B visas available.
  3. We should adopt a system of reciprocity with respect to trade.
  4. We should start phasing out the subsidies we’re providing to so many industries.
  5. We should stop using the tax system as a device for promoting social change or influencing economic behavior. It should have no purpose other than raising revenue.
  6. Congressmen should be required to spend at least half their time in their home districts and/or home states to be eligible for re-election.
  7. The power of the Congressional leadership should be decreased.
  8. We need to control prices in health care. The mechanisms for doing that are less important than the fact of it.

I’m under no illusions. None of my prescriptions will be implemented. But none of the Aspen Economic Strategy Group’s recommendations are likely to be implemented, either, so we’re even.

1 comment

Islam in Secular States

In an op-ed in the New York Times Algerian Kamel Daoud asks an important question? Why doesn’t France produce its own imams?

PARIS — What to do about Islam in France? Considering Islamist terrorist attacks, communalism and the international manipulation of Muslim communities, the matter is pressing. But it’s contentious, because managing Islam seems to go against laïcité, France’s staunch version of state secularism, and a 1905 law that mandates the separation of church and state.

Wouldn’t revising that law be an admission that secularism is bowing to Islamism? On the other hand, if the law isn’t revised, or if the French state cannot find other ways of monitoring and steering Islam, then Islam in France risks falling under the control of foreign states or the influence of radicals. That is already the case, actually: Since laïcité prohibits the French authorities from using public funds to build mosques or train imams, Algeria, Morocco, Turkey and Saudi Arabia have stepped in. According to the newsmagazine L’Express, 70 percent of imams practicing in France are not French.

In the United States it is estimated that 80% of imams are foreign-born and most of those are Wahhabis from Saudi Arabia. That suggests that the lack of native imams has nothing to do with U. S. or French policy but with Muslim preference. Indeed, in the U. S. polling has suggested that American Muslims don’t trust American-educated imams.

In order to be an effective imam you must speak Arabic, preferably the dialect of Arabic spoken in Saudi Arabia because that is closest to the classical Arabic of the Qur’an.

My answer will probably sound harsh to many. Modern Islam is, as it has always been, a stalking horse for Arab cultural imperialism. It does not thrive in contact with the secular Western world without being replenished from the source. That we tolerate the funding of mosques and imams by foreign governments is one of the unhinged things about our modern life.

6 comments

Defending Montenegro

Montenegro is a country on the eastern side of the Adriatic. It has a population about the size of Tucson and an area about the size of Connecticut. The primary languages of its people are Serbian and Montenegrin, a dialect of Serbian. Serbian is sometimes referred to as “Serbo-Croation”. The primary difference between Serbian and Croatian is orthography—Serbian uses Cyrillic while Croatian uses Roman. Other languages spoken by Montenegrans include Croatian and Bosnian, also dialects of Serbian, and Albanian which isn’t.

Montenegro was formerly a Yugoslav republic which made sense and is now a member of NATO which doesn’t. On its own Montenegro could not defend itself against a concerted attack by Serbia let alone by Russia. Montenegro’s NATO membership increases Montenegro’s security while decreasing that of the other NATO members.

Neither the Soviet Union nor Russia has ever attacked Montenegro or, indeed, Yugoslavia. NATO has and without UN Security Council authorization. Over the period of the last 30 years NATO has attacked two countries without provocation: Yugoslavia and Libya. During the same period Russia has attacked none. The diction used to characterize Montenegro’s admission to NATO is “to deter Russian aggression”. The most effective way to deter whatever Russian aggression there might be would be to discourage another NATO member, Germany, from cozying up to Russia. That is more of a threat to NATO members than Serbia attacking Montenegro or whatever threat Russia poses to Montenegro.

That’s the context of the editors of the New York Times’s full-throated defense of NATO:

The Democratic-led House on Jan. 22 voted 357-22 for a bipartisan bill that would tie Mr. Trump’s hands by refusing him any federal money to pay the costs of leaving the alliance.

The Republican-led Senate should quickly follow, either approving the House measure or a separate bill proposed by a bipartisan group of senators that requires Mr. Trump to obtain approval from two-thirds of the Senate to “suspend, terminate or withdraw U.S. membership in NATO.” If the president refused to abide by a Senate vote preserving NATO membership, the bill would then prohibit the use of federal funds for withdrawal.

It seems obvious that leaving NATO would be a foreign policy debacle, eroding American influence in Europe and emboldening Vladimir Putin, the Russian leader, who wants to weaken NATO so he can expand his political and military sway.

Despite all that, there is no sign that Mitch McConnell, the Senate majority leader, would stop such a move if Mr. Trump were to make it, as he has repeatedly threatened to do.

The actions most necessary to preserving NATO cannot be taken by the United States and will not be promoted by admitting new members to NATO. They would be for France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy, and other NATO members to increase their military readiness. I do not know whether that would require 2% of their GDPs, 5% of their GDPs, or 10% of their GDPs. Of them only France remains at the highest level of readiness and that diminishes by the day. If there is a threat, they should act more like there is. If there is no threat, why should we act as though there were?

0 comments