Here’s an interesting study. Researchers dropped wallets containing various objects including money in cities around the world and kept track of how many were returned and whether the contents made a difference. It did. From Science:
Does temptation shape dishonesty? For example, when a person finds a wallet on the street and decides to return it to its owner, it may be because the contents of the wallet are not very tempting or, alternatively, because people care about complying with norms of good conduct, that is, civic honesty. Scientists commonly explore such questions about human honesty through artificial laboratory tasks, but such studies have not provided conclusive evidence about the extent to which people are honest in natural circumstances. Cohn et al. (1) describe a field experiment involving 17,000 people in 40 countries to provide a new measure of honesty. The results show just how prevalent civic honesty is, and they raise many questions, such as how environments can be designed to foster civic honesty.
The more money a wallet contained the more likely it was to be returned. The researchers attributed that to a combination of altruism and “theft aversion” (they didn’t want to feel like thieves).
The results varied by country, too, with the Swiss, Norse, Dutch, Danes, and Swedes the most likely to return the wallets (in that order) and the Chinese the least likely with the U. S. somewhere in the middle.
I also think that the results form a fair proxy for the degree to which people trust their governments and why. We have good reason to trust our government half as much as the Swiss do theirs.
At RealClearWorld Jeffrey Wilson warns of the risks of a “rare earths trade war”:
Rare earth minerals have emerged as the latest front in the escalating US-China trade war. Nearly a decade after the Chinese government controversially suspended rare earth exports to Japan during the 2010 Senkaku dispute, similar threats are now being made if the bilateral trade dispute with the US deepens.
How prepared is the global economy for another deployment of the so-called “rare earths weapon�
Rare earths are an ideal instrument for economic coercion. They are an essential input into a wide range of high-technology products, across the electronics, petrochemical, renewable energy and defence sectors. As there are few economically-feasible substitutes for their use, any suspension to rare earth value chains would have a disastrous impact on an economy’s technological ecosystem.
China also possesses an extraordinary degree of market power. While not strictly a “monopolistâ€, in 2017 it produced an estimated 79% of the world’s rare earth oxides. By comparison, OPEC – a longstanding and sometimes-feared energy cartel – accounts for only 41% of global oil output. Outsized market power gives the Chinese government considerable scope to use rare earths as leverage in diplomatic disputes.
How long could the U. S. military continue operations if the supply of rare earths were disrupted? It’s a serious question. What in the heck do we have a military that can’t continue operations for?
This is entirely a self-inflicted wound. The U. S. used to be the world’s primary supplier of rare earths. We stopped due to environmental concerns and China’s illegal subsidies to its own industries. At the very least we should be producing enough to supply our military.
That was my reaction to the news that Alderman Carrie Austin’s office on the South Side had been raided by the FBI. From the Sun-Times:
Ald. Carrie Austin (34th) was praising the Lord at a school event Wednesday morning, saying “today is a day truly that God has made because he made us the star of the show,†when federal agents a few miles away were thrusting her center stage into Chicago’s hottest criminal investigation.
While Austin was talking about a school mentoring program, alongside Mayor Lori Lightfoot at Percy Julian High School, FBI agents were raiding her ward office as part of the ongoing political corruption investigations of Chicago aldermen.
With the public raid, Austin, 70, joins the select company of veteran, powerful Chicago aldermen implicated in the investigations.
Speaking of what people deserve, I found the editors’ of the Washington Post’s umbrage over Congressional pay bordered on the unhinged:
Limits on lawmakers’ pay affect congressional staffers who are not allowed to make more than members, which, in turn, puts Congress at a clear disadvantage in competing for talent. Others who support a raise, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) and Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.), point to the effects of pay and financial pressures on those who serve. “I do not want Congress, at the end of the day,†said Mr. McCarthy, “to be a place where only millionaires serve.â€
Presently, Congress includes members who never earned more than $40,000 a year in their lives before getting elected to Congress and those who earned millions. I’m not as concerned about Congress being a place where millionaires serve as I am about the many Congressmen who became millionaires as a consequence of what is euphemistically called “serving”. The evidence that more pay would attract more talent is nonexistent. The sole talent required to be elected to Congress is a talent at getting votes. Is that really worth paying for?
How about this for a proposal for Congressional pay. Total income for a member of Congress should be limited to three times the median income of his or her district. At least that would align incentives in the right direction. Those earning more than that would have the balance taxed away; those earning less would have their incomes topped off.
While I’m on the subject, why is the federal government the only major organization in the United States that doesn’t do its business by teleconferencing? Being able to remain in their home districts would certainly take the pressure to maintain two residences away.
The New York Times considers the answers of the candidates seeking the Democratic presidential nomination the question “Does anyone deserve a billion dollars?” Some of the answers are, frankly, disqualifying. The correct answer is “I’m not the one to say”. Put another way does Beyonce deserve a half billion dollars? Does Taylor Swift deserve a third of a billion dollars? Those are their net worths. I wouldn’t give either of them a penny but it’s not for me to say. Lots of people think they are. Do they deserve that much money while the average musician earns $20,000 a year? Same answer: it’s not for me to say.
The question assumes that you believe in “true value” or that anybody deserves to receive the amount they need to live the lifestyle they desire. If that weren’t the case we’d never be giving benefits greater than were necessary to maintain a subsistence living in rural Mississippi.
Here’s the question I would ask: does anyone deserve to earn a billion dollars based on rents, royalties, patents, government grants, professional licensing, or arbitraging any of the thousands of federal, state, and local laws and regulations? I don’t believe that anyone deserve to earn more than three standard deviations above the median income based on any of those things but it’s not for me to say.
I was very much struck by this analysis from Peterson-Kaiser comparing the quality of U. S. health care with that of other countries. It’s full of graphs and charts. I would summarize it as that care is better here but health is better in many other OECD countries.
Consider this graph, for example:
What it seems to say is that age-adjusted mortality per 100K population tracked pretty closely between the U. S. and other OECD countries until 1985. Since then the statistic has improved for both the U. S. and other OECD countries but it has improved less in the U. S. Why?
Okay, let’s do a little poll. Consider this description of a statement by European Central Bank head Mario Draghi, quoted by Ferdinando Giugliano at Bloomberg:
The ECB chief sounded particularly exasperated by politicians’ foot-dragging over the creation of a common budget for euro members, which would help them stabilize weaker economies if they faced a shock. Euro zone finance ministers announced the first steps toward such a fund last week. Draghi is justifiably unimpressed.
Which of the following is the best explanation for the problems of Europe’s economy?
Over the weekend I watched a Chinese science fiction movie, The Wandering Earth, streaming on Netflix. I’m told it’s the second-highest grossing movie in Chinese cinema history. It earned $700 million, most of it in China, interesting in its own right. Its plot resembles that of the movie Armageddon from a few years ago but the scale is enormously greater. The Sun is in the process of becoming a red giant and the people of earth have decided on the nutty strategy of moving the entire earth out of its orbit, ultimately to settle in another solar system. Like most sci-fi movies The Wandering Earth requires a willing suspension of disbelief. It requires a lot more of it than most. I don’t believe any aspect of the plan would work.
I found the picture mildly entertaining. It has plenty of action and roughly zero sex or violence (other than lots of things crashing). I would characterize it as “family friendly”. I’m a bit more tolerant of dubbing and corny movies than I think most Americans are so I’m not sure how other Americans will react to it.
Stereotypes abound. It included a number of what I think of as characteristically Chinese tropes. Attitudes between parents and children. The climax and ending of the picture (which I won’t reveal).
If you’re looking for something to stream with the kids, there are worse picks. Mostly, in fact.
I wish more people would pay attention to Henry Grabar’s post at Slate than probably will. It has quite a few important revelations. For example:
The collapse of manufacturing in the Mahoning Valley may have provoked a white identity crisis that the national media can’t get enough of, but the upheaval was more severe for black Americans. As Sherry Linkon and John Russo, onetime co-directors of the Center for Working-Class Studies at Youngstown State University, wrote in Steeltown U.S.A., their portrait of Youngstown after the fall: With less money saved, smaller pensions, and less valuable homes, black families, “suffered disproportionately when the mills closed.â€
And they keep losing ground. In 1980, according to data provided by Jacob Whiton at the Brookings Institution, the median black family in the Youngstown area made 18 percent less than the median black family nationally; today that family underearns by 35 percent. In 2017, the median black household in the city of Youngstown, where most of the region’s black population lives, makes $20,646—little more than half the income of the median black family nationally.
Youngstown’s blacks aren’t Republicans and the Democrats aren’t interested in them:
The bad news is that no one had voted in the city’s recent primaries for local elected office. Turnout was about 10 percent. Helen Youngblood, a longtime leader of the AFSCME local, remembered talking to a friend about this: “When I ask, ‘Why can’t we get these people out to vote?,’ the person says to me, ‘Helen, when you get up in the morning and you don’t know if your baby is going to have milk, then your priority of the day isn’t getting out to vote.’ †Poverty, she reasoned, was crushing people’s will to participate in the political process.
But several people I spoke to said there is also reason to blame Democrats, or as Sybil West called them when I paid a visit to her east side home on a recent afternoon, “the wimpocrats.†The party has been as absent here as Donald Trump is present, West told me, and the state’s GOP-led gerrymandering and poverty have further sapped people’s enthusiasm. “Most people are feeling apathetical,†she surmised, “because they’re saying, ‘It’s not going to do any good.’ â€
One of the effects of the collapse in manufacturing jobs in the United States is that it has concentrated black people in the cities. Black people moved from the South to Northern cities for jobs. Now that the jobs have vanished they’re more hesitant to move than their white counterparts.
In his newsletter, reproduced at the New York Times David Leonhardt seems surprised that blacks don’t overwhelmingly think that reparations is the measure most likely to help them:
In the poll, people were given a list of 14 economic policies and asked how much they thought each would help the black community. The list was full of progressive ideas: paid leave and better workplace benefits; a higher minimum wage; a federal jobs guarantee; stronger laws against discrimination; reparations for descendants of slaves; and more.
On a straight up-or-down basis, a majority of black Americans favored every one of the 14 policies. But there was a fairly wide gap in how much they thought each would help. At the top of the list were a higher minimum wage, stronger discrimination laws and better workplace benefits and training. About 70 percent of respondents said each of those would help “a great deal.â€
At the bottom of the list: Slavery reparations. Second to last: a federal jobs guarantee. Only about half of respondents said each would help a great deal.
What’s going on here? To me, it’s a reminder that black Americans, as a group, don’t have the same political opinions as the most liberal parts of the Democratic coalition. On many issues, black Americans are more moderate — or perhaps more pragmatic.
My own experience has been that blacks are more conservative and more religious than non-black Democrats and that the division is growing.