I don’t think that in his New Yorker piece John Cassidy has entirely put his finger on the reasons that there’s been a resurgence of interest in the United States in a political-economic theory that’s been on life support for 30 years—state socialism. I think he’s got this part right:
In retrospect, a key moment for the revival of American socialism was the Wall Street bailout of 2008 and 2009, when taxpayers were forced to rescue the very rogues who had helped bring about the financial crisis, even as many ordinary families were being evicted from their homes for failing to service their mortgages. From an economic perspective, there were some sound reasons to prevent the financial system from collapsing. From a political perspective, the decision to save the banks persuaded many Americans—on the left, center, and right—that the political system had been captured. There is a direct linkage from the Wall Street bailout to the Occupy Wall Street movement, the Sanders campaigns of 2016 and 2020, and to the Presidential campaign of Elizabeth Warren, who made her reputation as a vocal critic of rapacious and irresponsible financiers.
Our present crony capitalist system should be condemned loudly and often. It is at odds with liberal democracy.
It astonishes me that he has apparently never heard of Fabian socialism. Fabian socialism is a gradualist approach to socialism (rather than by revolutionary overthrow) that largely came to rely on control of the primary means of production—money. Bernie Sanders likes to cloud the issue by calling himself a “democratic socialist” but he’s actually a Fabian socialist.
Socialism is a completely inadequate way of characterizing the states that he and those who proclaim themselves democratic socialists claim to admire. Christian-ethnic democracy would be better. Everywhere that cradle-to-grave welfare states were adopted were tiny, Christian, and ethnically homogeneous. Religion is a key component. The countries of Scandinavia were all Lutheran and 90% or more Danish, Norse, Swedish, or Finnish when their welfare state systems were adopted. That they are abandoning their welfare states as they become more diverse is prima facie evidence for my case.
Whenever multi-confessional, multi-ethnic empires (like the United States) have adopted socialism it has been Stalinist state socialism. You may not like that it has been the case but it has been the case.
That’s what drives my hypothesis about why state socialism has survived despite its failures. It’s about power. There will always be people who want to control the rest.






