The Distribution

I found these figures, cited in Doug Mataconis’s post about the fallout from the second round of Democratic presidential candidates’ debates at Outside the Beltway, amusing:

In the candidate preference part of the poll, the numbers break down like this:

  1. Joe Biden — 33%
  2. Bernie Sanders — 19%
  3. Elizabeth Warren — 14%
  4. Kamala Harris — 9%
  5. Pete Buttigieg — 6%
  6. Beto O’Rourke — 3%
  7. Cory Booker — 3%
  8. Andrew Yang — 2%
  9. All other candidates under 2%

for a couple of reaons. First, that’s a clear illustration of the “long tail phenomenon”. Second, as I learned back in the graduate level microeconomics course I took all those years ago, that sort of power law distribution is the same distribution as generally emerges in the distribution of market share among the members of a cartel.

3 comments

The Second Best Outcome

As I read the interview with Josh Barro at New York Magazine on the “worst case scenario” in the trade war between the U. S. and China, it struck me that my idea of “worst” is a lot different than Mr. Barro’s. I think the worst case scenario is a return to the status quo ante. In that scenario China retains its position as the preferred vendor of low value-added goods, displaces the U. S. from its present position selling high value-added goods (that’s the purpose of the “Made in China” policy), and the U. S. continues its headlong rush to becoming a country whose economy consists of retail, fast food, and professional services (heavily subsidized by government at all levels). I think that’s a very bleak scenario.

When negotiating, you must consider several interrelated factors. First, what do want to accomplish? Second, what does your interlocutor want to accomplish? What’s the least you will accept? What’s the least your negotiating partner will accept?

I think we’ve been dealing with China wrong over the period of the last 40 years and the very least we should accept is for China to conform to its international agreements and institute a rule of law within China. Changing the balance of trade a little in our favor isn’t nearly enough. It continues to approximate the worst case scenario.

The least that China will accept is continued control by the Chinese Communist Party. Consequently, they won’t accept our sine qua non. That’s why I think that the second best scenario for us is not trading with China at all. If the Chinese people prefer the CCP and poverty over prosperity and being a responsible member of the world community, they’re entitled to their choice.

7 comments

Breaking Up Is Hard to Do

You might want to take a look at this conversation at FiveThirtyEight about breaking the United States up into different countries. Here’s a snippet:

I think it would depend on how elections go. If Trump wins reelection, it might be within 10 years. If Democrats win and Trumpism dies off and Republicans maybe try to build a bigger tent and try to win with more votes rather than with voter suppression, I think it could be staved off.

I’ve thought this since college and it’s not necessarily something that I want to see happen, but it’s kind of like the Old River Control system on the Mississippi River. It’s a control system — it keeps the Mississippi’s waters going down the Mississippi instead of going down the Atchafalaya River. But the river wants to go down the Atchafalaya, and the more they keep it from trying to do what it wants to do, the more pressure it puts on the Old River Control system. Eventually, it is going to go down the Atchafalaya. They can either slowly do it over the course of 20 to 30 years, and they can allow people to move their houses that are going to be underwater. Or they can just let it burst and watch the end of the Atchafalaya at Morgan City, Louisiana, be completely flooded and watch the Mississippi from about Baton Rouge on down completely dry up. So, the longer they put it off, the worse it’s going to be, and that’s how I feel about this. The longer we take the U.S. for granted and it’s too big to fail, the worse the failure.

This topic rears its head every so often. I think that what is really being asserted is the argument for federalism. As I’ve said before, I think that the House of Representatives should be greatly increased in size and there should be a systematic way of dividing states when they get too big.

It also reminds me of those who want to divorce Chicago from the rest of Illinois. They are presumably unaware of the fiscal realities of the state. Were such a thing to happen the rest of the state would immediately become insolvent. Chicago supports the rest of the state not the other way around. It isn’t just that Mississippi needs New York and California. California and New York need Mississippi in very much the same way that Germany needs Greece and Portugal.

I grew up within walking distance of a Civil War battlefield. You could still see bullet holes in walls and, if you dug down a little, could dig bullets out of the ground. I knew people whose great-great-grandfathers literally shot at each other during the War. Three, maybe four of my great-great-grandfathers fought in the war, all for the Union.

We really don’t want the states to go their own ways. It would be disastrous.

10 comments

In Saner Times

I want to draw your attention to a snippet from this column at the Chicago Tribune from John Kass:

In other, saner times, leveraging the political persuasions of absolute madmen against a political opponent would be a signal for a gentleman to rise from the table and leave the room without comment. But now it is the blood of our politics.

Yet whenever I feel that our politics and culture are beyond redemption, someone comes along to prove me wrong, like U.S. Army Pfc. Glendon Oakley Jr. He was at that Walmart in El Paso when the shooting began. Oakley, who has a concealed carry license, ran toward the sound of gunfire, to save as many children as he could. Later, talking about what happened, he sought to direct the media spotlight away from himself and toward the grieving families. And he began to weep.

“I want to look out to the families that were lost and families that lost their children,” he said in El Paso, “because the focus should not be on me, it should be on what happened in Ohio, and what happened in Chicago and what happened yesterday.”

But the focus is not on them. And unfortunately, it is not on the moral courage of Pfc. Oakley.

I wish I had a solution to the problem infecting the United States today. I don’t. I suspect that Trump is a symptom more than the disease. I don’t understand the thinking of anyone who believes that winning an election by 50%+1 votes will cure the disease.

6 comments

We Are Losing All Sense of Proportion

If we ever had one. I am finding it difficult to comment on anything I’m reading today because a) I don’t want to defend Trump; and b) I will not defend real white supremacists.

Yes, mass shootings are sometimes domestic terrorism. Sometimes they’re just crazy people, of whom we appear to have a bumper crop these days. DAESH murdered tens or hundreds of thousands of people, burned cities to the ground, beheaded, and enslaved people. Sheesh.

13 comments

Catching the Car

In the wake of the most violent weekend year-to-date in Chicago in her column in the Chicago Tribune Kristen McQueary declaims:

In addition to millions spent annually in local, state and federal budgets on crime reduction, taxpayers in Illinois fronted more than $50 million toward anti-violence programs in 2010, right before the gubernatorial election during a time when the state couldn’t pay its existing bills. Gov. Pat Quinn scraped together millions in taxpayer resources, and repeatedly during the next four years, to combat violence in Chicago.

That effort resulted in no measurable reduction in violent crime — and a federal criminal probe — after an audit revealed the money went wildly unaccounted for. It was largely misspent and wasted. It went to political cronies and clouted organizations. Today, the state and the city of Chicago still spend millions on anti-violence efforts. How’s it working out?

Without getting to the root causes of violence — poverty, abuse, family breakdowns, addiction, lack of personal responsibility and illegal use of guns — Chicago will continue to be a city thrashing. Lightfoot can’t snap her fingers and solve it. But enough has been studied to point her in the right direction. She needs Pritzker’s help. The state still has more heft to drive existing resources to some of these communities than the city can alone.

Through data-driven information-gathering, the experts know where the violence persists, where gang members loiter, where mental health services are nonexistent, where foreclosures abound, where schools are underperforming, where violence is life. If the city wants change, it could start by microtargeting those ZIP codes. Break down the silos of government that make it impossible for the most vulnerable to access existing programs. Get state and city resources under one roof or at least on the same block for mental health services, for job training, for trauma counseling, for help.

Pick a ward. Pick a five-block radius. Try.

Gary MacDougal is a mostly-retired, successful businessman and onetime leader of the Illinois Republican Party who has spent years studying the causes of violence and trying to get government to be responsive and efficient. His advice is a full-throated effort with the mayor and the governor tasking it as a top priority, every day. Every. Single. Day.

I can’t say I know a better idea. I can’t say we need more money or higher taxes or more cops or more marches.

What I can say, living on Chicago’s South Side for nearly 20 years, is that what we’re doing is not working. It’s not even close.

J. B. Pritzker and Lori Lightfoot chased the car and they caught it. They won their elections. Now it’s their turn to take ownership of what’s going on in Chicago. They can’t solve Chicago’s problems by throwing money at them. For one thing the cupboard is already bare. For another Chicago already has more police officers relative to population of any other major U. S. city, a typical Chicago cop gets a total of more than $100K per year, and previous increases have not reduced violent crime.

Chicago already had among the nation’s toughest gun laws. They were struck down by the Supreme Court.

Not to put too fine a point on it but Rahm Emanuel’s apparent strategy was to drive as many poor blacks from Chicago as possible while funding amenities for well to do Millennials. We’ll know just how well he succeeded when the results of the 2020 census are made known. I’m betting it will reveal that Houston has overtaken Chicago in population.

0 comments

What’s Next For Hong Kong?

China perma-hawk Gordon Chang, observing the escalating situation in Hong Kong, declaims at The National Interest:

Sefying stern warnings from both the local government and Beijing, people in seven districts in Hong Kong—most notably teachers, airport workers, and civil servants—participated in a general strike Monday, shutting down portions of the territory. For instance, more than a hundred flights were cancelled.

The strike followed weeks of sometimes violent protests in the territory, a semi-autonomous region of the People’s Republic of China. Youthful demonstrators over the weekend surrounded and attacked police stations, and enraged residents drove riot police from their neighborhoods.

Roving protesters, dressed for urban combat, created a series of confrontations across the territory, even closing the main tunnel linking Hong Kong Island with the rest of the territory. A beleaguered police force, demoralized and fatigued, was unable to keep up with the mobile bands of radicalized youth.

Some of the protest messages were impossible to miss. In Wanchai’s Golden Bauhinia Square, a magnet for tourists from other parts of China, kids spray-painted a statue with provocative statements such as “The Heavens will destroy the Communist Party” and “Liberate Hong Kong.”

In Hong Kong, revolution is in the air. What started out as an unexpectedly large demonstration in late April against a piece of legislation—an extradition bill—has become a call for democracy in the territory as well as independence from China and the end of communism on Chinese soil.

Here are my questions. How long will the Chinese authorities tolerate the situation in Hong Kong? For that matter how long will they tolerate “one country two systems”? What should the U. S. position be? What will the U. S. position be?

7 comments

The Changing Job Market

Conor Sen points out at Bloomberg that, if those pushing for a $15/hour minimum wage intended to kneecap the growth of low wage jobs, they’ve succeeded beyond their wildest dreams:

Even if the rate of U.S. job growth is slowing this year, there’s encouraging news hidden in that overall number.

A large chunk of the deceleration is attributable to a near halt in the growth of lower-paid jobs, despite those positions continuing to show strong wage growth – a sign that perhaps for lower-paid workers we are seeing dynamics approaching full employment. At the same type, the continued steady growth in higher-paid knowledge jobs should embolden those who believe this expansion can continue for quite a while longer. And along the way, more Americans in both categories are finding decent-paying jobs.

When people talk about the labor market slowing, what they’re really referring to is the past six months. The recent peak in the year-over-year pace in jobs growth occurred in January at 2.82 million. Since then it has slowed somewhat, largely shown in the weak jobs reports in February and May, in which both months resulted in fewer than 100,000 jobs being added in the economy.

But as the economic cycle has become more advanced, the composition of the labor market continues to change. Nowhere is this more evident than in the lowest-paid industries – retail and leisure/hospitality. From January 2011 through January 2019, those two industries added on average 600,000 jobs per year, or 50,000 per month, with the pace of growth beginning to slow noticeably in 2017. In the past six months, however, those industries have shown no growth. If they had grown at a similar pace as they did in 2017 or 2018, overall job growth would have shown very little deceleration.

I wanted to accomplish the same things with a tightening labor market, which I considered a more humane of accomplishing it, but it looks like setting prices by fiat works, too. It should also be noted that when “lower-paid workers” compete with “higher-paid knowledge jobs” something disastrous is going on. It’s probably more likely that the workers seeking jobs in the first group will have seriously straitened circumstances.

2 comments

Who’s Winning the Trade War?

At The National Interest Salvatore Babones argues that, while the United States may not be winning the present “trade war”, the Chinese are definitely losing:

Trump’s aggressive push on tariffs has thrown the country’s expert class into a tizzy, with pundits predicting a severe shock to the American economy, blaming the trade war for every blip in stock prices, and warning of the potential for runaway inflation as consumers pay the price for Trump’s tariffs.

Meanwhile the economy is employing record numbers of people, inflation is running well below the Fed’s target rate, and stock markets are slightly up since the beginning of the “trade war” in April. The data simply refuses to satisfy the pundits’ appetite for economic carnage.

With the economy refusing to cooperate with their “gloom and doom” narrative, America’s pundits are now arguing that economic pressure is no way to get a trade deal from China. When a Chinese Communist Party newspaper tells them that “China will never give in to pressure,” they believe it.

And who knows? Maybe they’re right. But if China doesn’t give in to pressure, then its manufacturing base will continue moving to Vietnam and India. Less labor-intensive assembly work will move to Mexico, which has now displaced China as America’s top trade partner. China will lose its unique position at the center of global production networks, and with it much of its leverage over global politics.

Read the whole thing. Some of which you should be aware is that Dr. Babones’s field of study is the frequently counter-productive if not self-destructive role of experts nowadays.

All other things being equal I’m an enthusiastic supporter of free trade but all other things have not been equal. The Chinese leadership has been very successful at using a combination of subsidies, trade policy, currency manipulation, and espionage to undermine the United States. The U. S. has been a big loser under the neoliberal policies that have led to China’s rapid rise.

But it hasn’t been the biggest loser. I would give that laurel to Mexico which prior to China’s rise was poised to play a major role in global manufacturing. Since I’m completely in favor of improving economies in Mexico, Vietnam, and India, I applaud present developments.

11 comments

What Is This “White Supremacy”?

We’re hearing a lot of complaints about white supremacy these days, to the extent that I’m becoming confused. As usual in reflecting on this subject, I’d like to start with a definition. What is meant by “white supremacy”?

The dictionary definition is:

a person who believes that the white race is inherently superior to other races and that white people should have control over people of other races

That itself is a bit loaded. Superior according to what metrics?

I certainly don’t want control over anyone else, whatever their race might be. Lord, let this cup pass from me.

I believe that races exist. Since you can test for race in a lab without ever seeing an individual it’s pretty hard to deny. I don’t believe that any race is categorically superior to another. I think the variances within the races are much more significant in determining “superiority” (whatever that means) than the variances between the races.

“Whiteness” is something entirely different. Many, many Hispanics (“white Hispanics”, oddly enough) think of themselves as white, other Americans think of them as white, and they will increasingly be considered white by everybody here. Maybe it’s just me but I consider Hispanics, Arabs, and East Indians to be white. I imagine that would have horrified my great-great-grandparents.

I would rather live in the United States than in Mexico or China or Italy or Ghana. I would resist efforts to render the United States more like Mexico or China or Italy or Ghana. I don’t think we need to exclude people from Mexico, China, Italy, or Ghana to keep the United States being the United States but I do think that we should be cautious about whom we accept to live here and I certainlty don’t think we have some sort of obligation to allow just anyone who wants to to live here. Does that make me a “white supremacist”?

I believe in linguistic relativity, AKA the weaker version of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis. I don’t believe in linguistic determinism (the stronger form). Said another way I think that in order to participate in our culture on an equal basis you should speak English fluently. I don’t think it’s impossible to do so without speaking English fluently but I do think it’s extremely difficult. Does that make me a “white supremacist”?

I don’t think that English is a superior language, just the language of the dominant culture here. I actually think that many other languages are superior in some ways to English. However, there are some concepts to which being a native speaker of English predisposes one which a native speaker of, say, Russian or Chinese are less likely to embrace as easily. It’s not that they can’t comprehend them. It’s just that it takes a lot more effort for them to comprehend them. Words are like hooks on which you hang concepts.

12 comments