It Depends on the Objective

At Bloomberg Ferdinando Giugliano casts some rain on the wealth tax parade. In reporting on the results of a conference whose attendees include Saez, Zucman, Lawrence Summers, and Greg Mankiw, he writes:

Overall, Saez and Zucman failed to make a convincing case for their proposal. Their eye-catching claim that the very richest now pay less tax as a proportion of their income than the poor is based on highly dubious assumptions. A wealth tax also suffers from a string of substantial practical and theoretical problems not shared by other ideas to reduce inequality, such as raising capital gains taxes or closing estate-tax loopholes. As Summers put it during the debate: “For progressives, to use their energy on a proposal that has a more than 50% chance of being struck down by the Supreme Court, little chance of passing through Congress and whose revenue-raising potential is very much in doubt, is to potentially sacrifice immense opportunities.”

The problem with the analysis offered by the Berkeley economists starts with their stunning finding that was recently advertised in a widely-shared column in the New York Times. Saez and Zucman claim that in 2018, the top 400 earners faced a lower effective tax rate, measured as a share of pre-tax income, than everyone else. This finding is only based on an estimate, since the actual data for 2018 are not yet available. Moreover, as noted by Wojciech Kopczuk, an economist at Columbia University, the result hinges on making some extreme assumptions on the incidence of taxation and the measurement of pre-tax income. As Kopczuk noted, their calculation is presented as a “fact” when it is not.

Of course, one can still believe that the rich should pay much higher taxes regardless of what exactly happened to their tax rate. Any policy-maker can legitimately prefer greater redistribution. The tax burden in the U.S. is significantly lower than in most other OECD countries. There is a good case to be made that the U.S. should increase revenues and spend more on education and infrastructure. The question, however, is which taxes are best suited for this aim.

Zucman believes that wealth taxes have several advantages. They allow one to overcome what he identified as the “Warren Buffet problem”, after the billionaire founder of Berkshire Hathaway, who once famously said he pays a lower tax rate than his secretary. Buffett’s annual income flows mainly from him selling a small proportion of his shares, on which he pays a capital gains tax. Capital gains taxes don’t take into account the enormousness of Buffett’s wealth, which would be taxed under Sanders’s and Warren’s plans. Moreover, unlike an estate tax, a wealth tax allows the state to obtain revenue immediately, rather than waiting until the death of a billionaire. Saez and Zucman believe that Warren’s plan — which would tax fortunes over $50 million at 2% annually, and those over $1 billion at 3% — would raise $2.75 trillion over the course of 10 years.

However, there are reasons to be skeptical of this number. For starters, you would expect billionaires to make different choices when faced with a wealth tax. They could donate much of their money to a charity, for example, or decide to spend more of it; a wealth tax could then end up encouraging lavish consumption. Mankiw outlined the paradox that a wealth tax would spare a wasteful top manager who spends all his income annually, while hitting a frugal one who saves a lot and perhaps invests in successful start-ups. Finally, a wealth tax is a form of double taxation, because the money was often taxed when it was earned, and because it would recur every year. (An estate tax, sometimes also called a form of double taxation, is at least levied only once.) As such, one wonders to what extent it is as fair as its proponents suggest.

There are also important practical problems: Billionaires’ wealth often stems from private companies. Private valuations of unlisted companies can often be spectacularly wrong. Zucman suggested that billionaire owners of private firms should be given the option of paying the wealth tax based on an estimated value or payment of shares. But the idea that the state would over time acquire significant holdings of some private companies is also problematic, as it would amount to — at least temporary and partial — nationalization.

Whether or not a wealth tax is a good idea or not depends somewhat on your objectives. If your objective is greater income and wealth equality, it’s not that great an idea. If your objective is class warfare or undermining the U. S. economy, it’s an excellent idea.

This seems like a good time for me to repeat my not particularly helpful suggestion that if you want greater income and wealth economy you should identify all the things that have been done since 1970 and do the opposite or, at least, change them so they push things more in the direction you’d like to see.

Immigration and free trade have been a bust as far as income equality is concerned, particularly the attempt at integrating China into the world economy (it’s been even worse for the environment). So have changing the rules to provide incentives for companies to provide compensation to their top management in the form of stock options and subsidizing the rich. Subsidies for the rich take all sorts of forms, from the forms of investment to which capital gains taxes apply to the home mortgage income tax deduction.

2 comments

What Form Would It Take?

A poll from Georgetown’s Institute of Politics and Public Service has found something rather disturbing: 2/3s of Americans think that a civil war is imminent in the United States:

WASHINGTON, D.C. – A majority of Americans believe political, racial, and class divisions are getting worse, according to the Georgetown Institute of Politics and Public Service Battleground Civility Poll, the second component of the Battleground Poll. This includes three-quarters or more of men and women; urban, suburban, and rural voters; approximately 7-in-10 or more voters in every age cohort; white, black, and Latinx voters; and nearly two-thirds of voters of all partisan stripes.

These observations contribute to the Civility Poll’s additional finding that the average voter believes the U.S. is two-thirds of the way to the edge of a civil war. On a 0-100 scale with 100 being “edge of a civil war,” the mean response is 67.23.

Consistent with the Civility Poll’s findings in April, this installment of the poll reveals significant contradictions within the electorate. Voters broadly agree with the premise that our political culture has become too uncivil and lacks a focus on solutions, and that common ground and compromise should be the goal for political leaders—while at the same time, equal numbers want leaders to “stand up to the other side” and stand up to “powerful special interests.”

or, in other words, people are actually fomenting the discord that they decry.

I’ve heard people scoff at the idea. Their arguments tend to run along the lines of what are a bunch of old white hicks spread across the country going to do?

I think this story, reported by Chicago’s WGN, might provide a hint:

CHICAGO — Chicago’s Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 7 board of directors has given police superintendent Eddie Johnson a vote of “no confidence.”

An FOP spokesperson said Johnson’s decision to skip President Donald Trump’s speech to the International Association of Chiefs of Police this coming Monday in Chicago was “the last straw.”

Imagine that when called to quell a violent rally, rather than arresting those participating in the rally, the police arrest the city’s officials. Imagine that when the National Guard is called in, the National Guard sides with the people against the officials. That’s how it could happen.

We have a situation no unlike that in the UK. Our leaders are in revolt against the people. I don’t know what will ultimately happen but the ratcheting up of tensions cannot persist forever.

4 comments

An Independent Justice Department?

Can someone help me out? Today I’ve read several complaints, pertaining to AG Barr’s investigations, of violations of the Justice Department’s independence. Where did the notion that the Justice Department was an independent branch of government come from? It’s not true. It’s a department of the executive branch. I don’t recall hearing such complaints about the DoJ during the Kennedy, Johnson, or Carter Administrations.

6 comments

Training vs. Education

In an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal Gus Hurwitz pronounces “gotcha” on Nate Silver:

Political data guru Nate Silver of FiveThirtyEight.com recently tweeted that Mark Zuckerberg’s comments about free speech were mistaken because “false statements of fact aren’t protected speech in the U.S.” That was a false statement—which, fortunately for Mr. Silver the First Amendment does protect. As the saying goes, the remedy for bad speech is more speech.

Those who want to purge “misinformation” from social media should learn from this incident. Mr. Silver is smart, thoughtful and well-educated. He’s an active participant in policy debates and has every reason to be familiar with the First Amendment. And the First Amendment isn’t an obscure area of law. Most Americans are broadly aware of it; it is constantly discussed and in the news and throughout the education system; it is foundational to our democracy. How can someone like Mr. Silver confidently misstate such a familiar part of U.S. law?

Actually, although I think he’s clever and skilled, I have seen few signs of education in Mr. Silver. Mr. Hurwitz is confusing education with training. Mr. Silver is not well-educated. He is well-trained like a competent blacksmith or weaver. As Plato wrote in Republic:

Education is not what the professions of certain men assert it to be. They presumably assert that they put into the soul knowledge that isn’t in it, as through they were putting sight into blind eyes…but the present argument, on the other hand…indicates that this power is in the soul of each and that the instrument with which each learns–just as an eye is not able to turn toward the light from the dark without the whole body–must be turned around from that which is coming into being together with the whole soul until it is able to endure looking at that which is and the brightest part of that which is

Education is something that emerges over a lifetime not something that is conveyed in a few short years. It is wide-ranging and brings with it an understanding, not just of current events but of the human heart.

Today’s emphasis on the relevant and job preparation followed by total pre-occupation with work and killing time is not conducive to education. It is, as Mr. Hurwitz notes, at odd with with views of the Founders:

Yet the idea that more speech is the remedy for bad speech assumes more than a polity of speakers eager to correct their peers. The cacophony is deafening, making it difficult to sort fact from fiction. More speech is only a cure in a polity of charitable listeners. Judge Learned Hand once observed that “the spirit of liberty is the spirit that is not too sure it is right.” If we don’t accept others’ good faith and the limitations of our own expertise—if we are so quick to attack others’ errors that we forget how often we too are wrong—the enterprise of free speech is fraught, and the spirit of liberty of which it is part is at peril.

1 comment

Making It Up As They Go Along

In her Wall Street Journal column Kimberley Strassel makes what is essentially the opposite argument:

Welcome to impeachment, Schiff-style. Democrats keep their witnesses locked behind secure doors, then flood the press with carefully sculpted leaks and accusations, driving the Trump-corruption narrative. And so the party goes, galloping toward an impeachment vote that would overturn the will of the American voters—on a case built in secret.

Conservative commentators keep noting that Mrs. Pelosi’s refusal to hold a vote on the House floor to authorize an official impeachment inquiry helps her caucus’s vulnerable members evade accountability. But there’s a more practical and uglier reason for Democrats to skip the formalities. Normally an authorization vote would be followed by official rules on how the inquiry would proceed. Under today’s process, Mr. Schiff gets to make up the rules as he goes along. Behold the Lord High Impeacher.

Democrats view control over the narrative as essential, having learned from their Russia-collusion escapade the perils of transparency. They banked on special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation proving impeachment fodder, but got truth-bombed. Their subsequent open hearings on the subject—featuring Michael Cohen, Mr. Mueller and Corey Lewandowski —were, for the Democrats, embarrassing spectacles, at which Republicans punched gaping holes in their story line.

Mr. Schiff is making sure that doesn’t happen again; he’ll present the story, on his terms. His rules mean he can issue that controlling decree about “only one” transcript and Democratic staff supervision of Republican members. It means he can bar the public, the press and even fellow representatives from hearings, even though they’re unclassified.

It means he is able to shield from scrutiny the whistleblower who prompted this impeachment proceeding. It means he can continue barring Republicans from calling opposing witnesses. It means he can continue refusing to allow White House counsel in the room to hear the accusations against the president.

Mr. Schiff apparently even believes his impeachment authority allows him to ignore longstanding rules. A recent letter from Republican members of the Intelligence Committee objected to Mr. Schiff’s new practice of withholding official documents. They listed nearly two dozen letters from the committee (to recipients ranging from Secretary of State Mike Pompeo to White House counsel Pat Cipollone) that had not been uploaded to the committee repository—which, they note, violates House rules. Republicans aren’t even allowed to know what questions Mr. Schiff is asking.

As I’ve said an open, factual, and impartial process will garner support while agonistic and partisan declarations will lose it. There’s a difference between a politically motivated investigation and a purely politically motivated investigation.

Also as I’ve said before President Trump is not handling the situation as I would have done and, frankly, I really don’t understand his thinking. The Democrats should hope he continues so fecklessly.

2 comments

About Those Closed Door Hearings

The editors of the Washington Post remark on the complaints about the “Star Chamber hearings” regarding the Houses “impeachment inquiry”:

Lawmakers lack a voluminous investigative record like independent counsel Kenneth W. Starr’s 1998 report. They must do their own basic investigating, which is why it makes sense to hold some hearings behind closed doors. Investigators don’t want witnesses to play for the cameras or dishonestly align their testimony with that of earlier witnesses. Classified material may be discussed. Republicans, in their incessant and fruitless investigations of Hillary Clinton and the 2012 Benghazi attacks, held many closed hearings — and insisted they were the most useful.

Moreover, Republican legislators are present at all of these closed-door sessions and are free to pose questions. In fact, the rules allowed many of those who stormed Wednesday’s testimony to enter the room in a civilized fashion if they so chose. The impression Republicans tried to convey, of Democrats cooking up an illegitimate indictment of the president while locking all others out of the room, is a partisan fantasy.

Marginally more persuasive was a memo Senate Republicans released Thursday complaining that the full House had not formally voted on conducting an impeachment inquiry and that Mr. Trump is not allowed counsel in the room. Neither is required by the Constitution or House rules. But holding a vote would add legitimacy, and, more to the point, the sooner House investigators move from closed hearings to open ones, the better. Citizens should learn the scope and gravity of the president’s misdeeds so they can form their own conclusions. House leaders should release transcripts of closed hearings, consistent with the protection of classified material, as soon as possible.

which approximates my view. Even if a full vote of the House on the inquiry is not required it would be prudent. The more open, methodical, and non-agonistic the House Democrats are in their inquiry, the more likely they are to garner support and the less likely they are to ensure what is, presumably, the opposite of what they want—that President Trump remain in office rather than being removed from it.

3 comments

Christmas Rush

I see that Daniel Henninger in his latest Wall Street Journal column has lurched uncontrollably onto the interpretation of events that I have been suggesting:

Mr. McConnell reportedly wanted it all over by the end of the year, but what’s the rush? The Trump trial could run through January—31 priceless campaign days before the Democratic Party’s intensely competitive primaries. The Iowa caucus vote is Feb. 3, then comes New Hampshire’s primary on Feb. 11; Nevada’s caucuses are Feb. 22; and the crucially important South Carolina primary arrives Feb. 29.

Instead of competing for their party’s nomination, Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, Amy Klobuchar, Kamala Harris, Cory Booker and Michael Bennet will spend invaluable campaign time planted on Capitol Hill during the days that the Pelosi-Schiff Trump trial drones on. Sens. Sanders and Harris can’t call Mr. Trump the “most corrupt president” in the history of the country and then skip out on the trial of public enemy No. 1 to campaign in a downstate Iowa diner.

Joe Biden, Mayor Pete, and Hillary’s new friend Rep. Tulsi Gabbard get to romp daily through the primary states, but who’s going to notice with the Trump impeachment trial siphoning away the nation’s media’s attention?

or, alternatively, the Democratic senators bying for their party’s nomination could just elect to skip the trial, casting doubt on the great moral imperative to remove Trump from office for his crimes.

6 comments

Bombshells or Fizzles?

The editors of the Wall Street Journal look askance at the advance of the impeachment inquiry in the House:

This requires more transparency and public scrutiny than Mr. Schiff’s unprecedented process of secret testimony, followed by selective leaks to the friendly media to put everything in the most anti-Trump light, in order to sway public opinion. If the evidence against Mr. Trump is so damning, then why not make it all public now so the American people can judge for themselves?

Trying to paint the WSJ editors as reflexive Trumpkins is a stretch. They support Trump policies that they like and criticize those they don’t. They like his tax policy; they dislike his foreign policy. IMO their reactions are fair.

The proceedings and revelations certainly haven’t covered President Trump or his administration in glory. Their conduct has certainly not been good or right. Whether they’re damning or not we should wait to assess.

2 comments

Maybe Not So Big a Mystery

In his Washington Post column this morning Robert Samuelson muses about the mystery of low inflation:

From 2010 to 2018, the CPI has increased only about 2 percent annually. In turn, the collapse of inflation has transformed political debate. We have gone from worrying about “stagflation” — the coexistence of high inflation and high unemployment — to arguing about economic growth and inequality. On the whole, this is a better place to be.

Recall the “misery index.” It combines the unemployment rate and inflation. In 1980, the index was 19.6 percent (7.1 percent unemployment rate and 12.5 percent inflation). In 2018, it was 5.8 percent (3.9 percent unemployment and 1.9 percent inflation). There won’t be much anti-inflation rhetoric in the 2020 campaign. Indeed, low inflation is one reason the current economic expansion is the longest in U.S. history. Despite the running feud between President Trump and the Federal Reserve, there has been no sharp increase in interest rates to dampen the recovery.

But there is one gaping hole in this otherwise happy story: We don’t know what has caused inflation to drop so low and to stay there. It’s a “puzzle,” as economist Janet Yellen, former chair of the Fed, recently put it at a Brookings Institution conference on inflation. The explanation matters. If we don’t fully understand low inflation, we may misinterpret its consequences.

The inflation mystery poses a simple question: Why haven’t wage gains increased faster as the economy has approached “full employment,” which is crudely put between 4 percent and 5 percent? Expressed technically, the question becomes: Why isn’t the Phillips Curve working? That’s economist A.W. Phillips, who argued in the 1950s that, as unemployment fell, wage gains would rise. Firms would have to pay more to attract workers. Some wage gains would feed into higher prices, a.k.a. inflation.

I don’t think it’s that big a mystery. Mr. Samuelson points to globalization, monetary policy, and a misinterpretation of the labor force as potential explanations and I think that’s partly right. My explanation would include four factors:

  1. An enormous proportion of the economy is either grey or black and not included in the official statistics. When you have an illegal population as large as we do—officially about 14% of the population but actually possibly much higher—the statistics are just wrong.
  2. For the last couple of decades China has been exporting goods and deflation and importing employment and inflation. There’s lots of inflation but in a globalized economy you can’t see it if you only look at one country.
  3. The CPI is broken. It represents the economy of 50 years ago not the economy of today. The problem may well be in the weighting. In particular now that health care is a sixth of the economy and education (public and private) may be as much as 10% of the economy is that reflected in the CPI? Keep in mind that not only health care and education but military spending, police and fire, and other components of government spending including public pensions, particularly at the state and local level, are consumption and that spending is increasing at a ferocious rate. There may be lots of inflation; it just isn’t reflected in an obsolete CPI.
  4. Monetary policy is working. It’s creating enormous inflation in the prices of equities. Evidence for that are the price/earnings ratios, unlike anything seen in the past. That’s also reflected in sharp increases in things closely tied to the prices of equities, e.g. executive compensation.
4 comments

Creative Accounting

Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot has presented her budget for the city of Chicago which closes Chicago’s nearly $1 billion deficit. The Trib reports:

Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot offered an $11.65 billion budget plan for 2020 on Wednesday, laying out a path to dig the city out of a daunting $838 million deficit without relying on steep property tax increases.

Lightfoot’s plan hinges on getting help from the General Assembly, which enters its fall veto session next week.

This is basically a “Hail Mary”. To the best of my knowledge the state has never ponied up money for Chicago unless it was sued for it.

The new taxes she’s proposing as well as the ones have been left unstated fall most heavily on the poor. Expect the exodus from Chicago to accelerate. Just in time for the decennial census.

If you go back to the cow too many times, it eventually runs dry. That’s true of cash cows, too.

3 comments