The Wisconsin Mulligan

On June 5 Wisconsin voters will go to the polls to take a mulligan on the 2010 gubernatorial election, a choice between the incumbent Gov. Scott Walker and his 2010 opponent, Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett. The outcome isn’t predetermined but, judging by the results of the primaries, Walker has a good chance of retaining his seat.

There are two numbers that stand out in the primaries. The first is 626,538, the number of votes cast for Scott Walker in the non-competitive Republican primary. That’s roughly equal to the number of Democratic primary votes cast in toto and significantly more than the number of votes that Tom Barrett received. If Republicans can turn out all of their primary voters to vote for Walker and Democrats can turn out all of their primary voters for Barrett, Barrett wins. If Walker primary voters turn out for Walker and only Barrett primary voters turn out for Barrett in the general election, Barrett loses.

The second number is 900,000. That’s the number of petition signatures collected by recall organizers to force the recall election. Presumably, Walker primary voters don’t account for much of that total. Why the discrepancy between turnout in the primaries and recall petition signatures? Several possibilities come to mind:

  • Having somebody standing on your front stoop and shoving a petition under your nose or buttonholing you as you go into the grocery store is one thing, showing up at the polls is another.
  • The heat of the moment has passed.
  • There may have been a substantial number of non-Wisconsin voters who signed those petitions.

None of those bodes particularly well for Tom Barrett. What amazes me about this whole sideshow is how little there is to gain in the recall and how much to lose. Regardless of who sits in the governor’s chair in July 2012 Wisconsin’s state government will have all of the same problems it has now and restraining the growth in total public employee compensation will be part of any effective solution whether there’s a D or an R after the name of the governor. When the Massachusetts votes, as it did, to restrict collective bargaining rights on the part of public employees, it’s reasonable to argue necessity but a lot less reasonable to argue that it’s an ideologically-driven radical Republican move.

I’ve already made my views on this clear. Given the federal government’s refusal to control the healthcare monster that it created nearly a half century ago, state and local governments have little recourse but to limit the compensation paid to their employees. Healthcare reform could have taken a lot of pressure off state and local governments.

However, imagine if Walker prevails. The Wisconsin public employees will have done their worst and proven unable to remove him. Now that’s a mandate.

I think that this entire debacle is part and parcel of what James Carville is warning about on the national level which can be summarized in just three words: don’t get cocky.

4 comments

The End of the Affair

The whole sad issue of Greece’s fiscal problems seems to be coming, slowly and painfully, to a denouement. I won’t bother linking to any of the many articles on the subject. I’m afraid that what many of the American commentators, both in old media and in the blogosphere, are failing to take into account in their complaints about austerity is that the Greeks don’t have a lot of options. The Greek people are no happier about austerity than American economists with newspaper columns. Less so if anything.

Essentially, the Greeks can:

  • Raise taxes which they won’t be able to collect and cut spending which will speed the fall of the present political coalition enough to please the German, French, and Luxembourger banks they owe so that they’ll roll over their current debt and, maybe, lend them more.
  • Accept Greece’s status as a sort of permanent theme park, in Europe but not of it, somewhat resembling American Indian reservations or the now-defunct South African “Bantustans”, in perpetuity. The Greeks want a “European” lifestyle that their own economic resources won’t support and they don’t have the social or economic resources to make the changes that would be needed to grow into the lifestyle they aspire to.
  • Leave the euro.

The prevailing wisdom is that the current government will fall soon and the new one will exit the euro. The biggest losers in this process are likely to be the Germans who currently have an enormous trade deficit in their favor with Greece which would be all but certain to decline and Italy, whose trade deficit with Greece is only slightly less than the Germans’. If Greece’s exiting the euro causes severe economic problems in Italy which may well be the case, it’s unclear to me how the monetary union can survive.

Germany and Italy aren’t the only countries at risk. There’s a sort of trickle-down in the Balkans. Greece has substantial direct foreign investment in Macedonia, Serbia, and Bulgaria which would unquestionably decline, at least in purchasing power, with the return of the drachma. The whole apple cart is likely to be upset.

1 comment

A Little Inspirational Viewing

A propos of a discussion going on in comments.

Music by Hoagy Carmichael, words by Johnny Mercer, direction by Howard Hawks, singing (and vamping) by Lauren Bacall, ogling by Humphrey Bogart.

7 comments

Due for Rehabilitation

For many years Lyndon Johnson was “he who must not be named”. His name was, literally, not mentioned by Democrats. Before him Harry Truman had that status until his rehabilitation and after him Jimmy Carter has held something of that status, a treatment that is only slowly abating.

I think that LBJ is due for rehabilitation. I never liked him but I do feel he was the most masterful president of my lifetime. I suspect it will take another couple of decades and the passing from prominence of the Baby Boomers who demonstrated against Johnson in the streets before the corrective reassessment takes place.

You could do worse than reading Richard Cohen’s column today to understand why I think as I do. I don’t think that we need experts for presidents. I think we need people who want to do the dirty, nitty-gritty work of being president.

37 comments

Just the Facts, Ma’am

The other day over at OTB, James Joyner posted on facts, the credibility of evidence, and how social relations and preconceptions affect our perception of the credibility of evidence:

Krugman leads us to some research which explains why this tribalism is so pervasive. Partly, he attributes this to what Richard Dawkins terms “argument from personal incredulity,” a refusal to accept facts that don’t jibe with their personal experience. For example, “Our intuitions about how business-y stuff works come from businesses or households selling their goods or labor to an external market. In such situations spending less is a sure-fire way to reduce debt, cutting your price or your wage demand is a sure-fire way to sell more. But in the economy as a whole, your spending is my income and vice versa; my wage matters only in comparison to your wage; and so on. This changes everything, which is why we have paradoxes of thrift and flexibility.”

A lengthy comment thread followed which wandered from the existence (or non-existence) of God, Pascal’s wager, scientific fact, and points east.

I think that the word “fact” is bandied about a bit too much and said so in a comment. Another commenter replied with an example cited as a fact:

It is a fact that water melts at 0 degree c (at standard pressure).

He never defined what he meant by “fact” so let’s see what we can infer what he means from his example.

What is water? The easy explanation is that it’s a substance composed of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom. Other than at the molecule level that doesn’t exist in nature. When you turn your tap what pours out is not water. It’s a mixture of any number of substances including water and which we hope has water as its primary component. Even the purest water has some level of contamination.

Invariant temperature (the implication of the phrase “0 degree c”) does not exist in nature, either. And how would you know? The finest tools for measuring temperature have some level of inaccuracy. A good resistance temperature detector is accurate to .03°C or, said another way, it is approximate.

Finally, invariant standard pressure doesn’t exist in nature, either. “Standard pressure” is defined as the pressure that will support a column of mercury 760 mm high at sea level and 0 degrees centigrade. It is, by definition, 101.325 kPa. Note a couple of things about the definition: a) it relies on temperature—it’s circular; b) it relies on measurements more precise than real world measurements; c) it relies on perfect substances.

Or, in other words, a perfect substance under perfect conditions will behave in such and such a way. Does that comport with your intuitive definition of a fact?

I think there’s a great misunderstanding including on the part of far too many scientists about what science actually is. Science is not about identifying facts and then defending those facts against attack. It is about collecting data, constructing models based on the data, and adjusting the models as new data comes along that contradicts your old model. But the territory is not the map. Only the territory is the territory.

Engineering, on the other hand, is about making things work. It is informed by science but every engineer I know is painfully aware of the perversity of nature.

52 comments

My Trip to Rochester

Over the weekend I went to Rochester, New York to attend the graduation of one of my nephews. He received his doctorate in pharmacy.

The keynote speaker, apparently a last minute replacement for the chap who was scheduled to be the keynote speaker, was the senior senator from New York, Charles Schumer. He was a confident and reasonably entertaining speaker. Mostly he talked about himself, not terribly surprising for a U. S. senator.

He told us that his first job was operating a mimeograph machine in a very small, closed room. I think this may explain a lot. If you’re old enough to remember mimeographs, you probably know what I mean.

He also explained that he couldn’t hack it as a lawyer so he became a politician. I’m paraphrasing but that was the upshot of what he said. I think that’s something worth remembering. Although most senators are, by education, lawyers, not all of them are good lawyers. Not all of them are successful lawyers. There are some successful lawyers, e.g. John Edwards had been a very successful plaintiff’s attorney before he went into politics. But many of the senators and representatives who are nominally lawyers did not attend top law schools, passed the bar but never practiced law or practiced only briefly (ask a lawyer: you don’t learn to be a lawyer at school), and are actually career politicians.

BTW, the upstate New York countryside is beautiful at this time of year and increasingly dotted with small wineries. Some day I hope to take a more leisurely trip and check some of them out.

7 comments

About That Employment Situation Report

You must certainly have heard or read about the Bureau of Labor Statistics’s disappointing Employment Situation Report by now. Disappointing because not only did the number of payroll jobs only increase by 115,000, generally considered below the “natural increase”, but the number of those looking for work declined. That’s the slowest level in seven months and should squelch whatever talk there was of robust recovery.

For the last several years we’ve seen a pattern in these numbers: strong growth during the winter months, sluggish growth in the spring and, frankly, I find that a bit puzzling. Counter-intuitive. I would think it should be the other way around.

I’m open to suggestions for an explanation. My working hypothesis is that it’s an artifact, i.e. that the actual real not-easily-measured number of jobs added is very low, indeed, and that the various fudge factors, e.g. seasonal adjustment, birth/death ratio adjustment, etc., are overwhelming reported figures. As I say, I’m open to suggestions for an explanation.

I’m sure that somebody somewhere is pointing out that increases in private sector employment are being offset by declines in public sector employment. Most of those declines are from the states and the fact of the matter is that the states are choosing to increase the compensation of their employees and, since they are in general required to balance their budgets, cut the number of employees to make up the difference.

Add to that that much of the growth in “private sector employment” is in the healthcare sector and approaching 70% of that is de facto public employment. That states are just choosing healthcare jobs over other sorts of jobs.

The decline in the “participation rate”, the proportion of people who are working, which has been declining since the start of the recession and which is wholly responsible for the misleading decrease in unemployment rate which otherwise would be in the teens has other implications as well as miserable people who have given up looking for work. For one thing it means that FICA revenues are decreasing which will speed up the point at which the SSTF goes TU. That’s the case because the amount of income subject to the tax is capped—high income individuals making more money doesn’t bring more money into the fun.

9 comments

Winners and Winners

There’s a sentence in George Will’s column about his son, Jon, that bears some contemplation:

Two things that have enhanced Jon’s life are the Washington subway system, which opened in 1976, and the Washington Nationals baseball team, which arrived in 2005. He navigates the subway expertly, riding it to the Nationals ballpark, where he enters the clubhouse a few hours before game time and does a chore or two. The players, who have climbed to the pinnacle of a steep athletic pyramid, know that although hard work got them there, they have extraordinary aptitudes because they are winners of life’s lottery. Major leaguers, all of whom understand what it is to be gifted, have been uniformly and extraordinarily welcoming to Jon, who is not.

Read the whole things. There are different kinds of winners.

13 comments

Whose Foreign Policy?

Yesterday as I was driving around on my appointed rounds, I listened for a while to the wonderful NPR program, Fresh Air. The show’s host, Terry Gross, interviewed Steve Coll, former managing editor the Washington Post, presently a staff writer for The New Yorker, and who has written a book on ExxonMobil:

In Private Empire, Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative journalist Steve Coll investigates how ExxonMobil has used its money and power to wield significant influence in Washington, D.C., particularly during the Bush administration.

Executives at the company maintained close personal connections with members of the Bush administration — but Coll says the “cliched idea that Exxon-Mobil was just an instrument of the Bush administration’s foreign policy — a kind of extension of the American government during the Bush years — is just wrong.”

Coll has written extensively about Afghanistan and Pakistan and the uses of government power. But in Private Empire, he turns his attention to ExxonMobil, one of the largest private corporations in the United States.

Exxon, which merged with Mobil in 1999, descends from John D. Rockefeller’s Standard Oil Co. and has ranked as one of the country’s most profitable companies for the past 60 years. Each year ExxonMobil makes about $450 billion in revenue, exceeding the great majority of countries.

Coll says ExxonMobil executives “see themselves — ExxonMobil — as an independent sovereign with their own foreign policy,” he says. “Sometimes their interests ally with the United States government, sometimes they find themselves in opposition to the United States — and sometimes they try to stay out of the way.”

That took me aback. I don’t ever recall hearing anyone complain that “Exxon-Mobil was just an instrument of the Bush administration’s foreign policy”. I think the complaint was almost exactly the reverse: that the Bush Administration’s foreign policy was just an instrument of ExxonMobil’s foreign policy, which is quite a different thing. Am I misremembering?

I also recall wondering myself whether it was the right time to have an oil man as president, not because there’s anything inherently wrong with oil men but because he would necessarily bring prejudices along with him that might not really be in the country’s best interests. Said another way, I don’t think that ExxonMobil’s interests are necessarily those of the United States of America.

7 comments

Looting

The pension deal that former Chicago Mayor Richard M. Daley worked out for himself is quite the cause célèbre here. Tribune columnist John Kass comments:

While many taxpayers are worried about bleak retirement futures, Mayor Richard Daley is cashing in on a quiet and outrageous political maneuver from years ago that allows him to collect a fantastic public pension of more than $180,000 a year.

And as your lips tingle, consider this.

As he left office last year, Daley was smooched repeatedly by official Chicago and many in the news media as the city’s benevolent father figure. It was an orgy of public love as the self-avowed champion of taxpayers reminded us that the cost of government was too high for the people to bear.

What we didn’t know then was that Daley was running from the barnyard with meat in his teeth.

He did that pension deal on the sneak, just a couple of years into his mayoralty. Though he’d been out of the Legislature for a decade, he was allowed to quietly re-enter the legislative pension plan for a single month. This cynical maneuver boosted his pension by about $50,000 a year and allowed him to avoid paying $400,000 into the plan, Tribune/WGN-TV investigators found.

If you think people are merely angry, you’re wrong. They’re seething. The cops and the teachers, the firefighters and the city workers, and the taxpayers who bankroll it all — they consider him a hypocrite.

“People are raw with anger, that’s all they’ve been talking about is the Tribune story,” said a lobbyist who’s been working at City Hall for decades. “They’re just raw with it. It’s like the parking meter deal. $180,000 a year pension after all the money the Daleys made? For life? That’s overkill.”

No, it’s looting. I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again: if I were king the Illinois legislature would not have the power to vote pensions for any elected or appointed Illinois public employee and the Congress would not have the power to vote pensions for any elected or appointed federal employee. The mayor of Chicago’s salary would be capped at three standard deviations above the median Chicago wage and all other Chicago public employees would receive less than the mayor by statute; the governor of Illinois’s salary would be capped at three standard deviations above the median income in the state and wages for all state public employees would be receive less than that by state; the president of the U. S.’s salary would be capped at three standard deviations above the median U. S. wage, etc.

Without his family connections and the political clout that went along with them and not being a graduate of a top law school Richie Daley would have been lucky to have topped out at $50,000 a year as a lawyer. That he should receive $180,000 per year, year in and year out, in a city where the median family income is $38,000 is unconsionable. It’s unsupportable. It is offensive.

Note that I have no objection to the mayor making $1 million a year or more. But it should be by bringing the city along with him in growing wealthy rather than by looting it.

While I’m on the subject, how do people think that Illinois will escape its fiscal mess? Since passing the tax hike last year, the number of people employed in Illinois has dropped sharply. Total incomes are still rising but not as fast as taxes are, cf. here and here. Are more taxes really the answer? Or is the only solution a change in the way the state does business?

27 comments