Dave Schuler
June 25, 2012
This morning or, possibly, Thursday the Supreme Court is expected to render its decision in the cases against the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act AKA Obamacare. The decision is likely to be long and convoluted, possibly with complete concurrence on some aspects of the case and narrow majorities on others. The most likely possibilities for the final decision would appear to be:
- The Court upholds the PPACA in its entirety.
- The Court strikes down the individual mandate but holds that severable from the remainder of the law.
- The Court strikes down Title 1 of the act, the portion dealing with private insurance, but upholds the balance of the law.
- The Court strikes down the PPACA in its entirety.
The question is not whether a hypothetical Court could uphold the PPACA but whether this Court is likely to support the expansion of Congress’s powers under the Commerce Clause that the PPACA represents. I suspect that the answer to that question is No but I honestly have no idea on how the Court will rule. If I had to make a WAG, I would predict alternatives 2, 3, 4, or 1, in that order.
When Congress initially enacted the PPACA I was as mad as a wet hen. I thought that it was a byzantine, tortured half measure. It arranged to cover a few more people who presently don’t have insurance without covering everybody and do so in a way that was vague, maximized uncertainty, and maximized the bureaucracy that would be required to administer it. It only pretended to address the most pressing problem of our healthcare system (increasing costs) in order to grant insurance coverage to a relatively small additional number of people. Additionally, it assumed that Congress would tinker with the law in continuing approximation, fixing the unworkable or contradictory parts of the law, repeatedly, an assumption that flies in the face of the history of healthcare reform in the United States.
One aspect of this whole sorry mess that I do not believe has been adequately discussed: it highlights the problems inherent in prolonged incumbency. The members of the Congress have had the same arguments with the same people over such a long period of time that the discussion has solidified behind slogans. For the progressive caucus that comprised the Congressional leadership at the time the PPACA was passed the slogans were guaranteed issue and community rating. They had persuaded themselves that those two things would solve the problems with our healthcare system. Ironically, their implementation surrenders the fiction that healthcare insurance is insurance at all.
To satisfy that Congressional leadership guaranteed issue and community rating were the sine quae non. Everything else was persiflage.
The present Republican Congressional leadership has its own slogans: market-based and health savings accounts chief among them. The notion that those things can be implemented in such a way as to solve the problems we actually have is just as fictional as the progressives’ solution.
Dave Schuler
June 24, 2012
Bruce Krasting presents an example of how Fed policy actually retards job growth:
The idea that lower interest rates are hurting savers is an old one. The question is, “How significant are the negative consequences of low interest rates?” The multi-decade efforts in Japan to reflate an economy with low interest rates is a shining example of policy that has not worked.
I’ve not seen any discussion that attempts to quantify how large a drag on economic activity low rates are. I know that some of the folks at the Fed will read this; my request/challenge to them is that they respond with an answer. If the Fed did a fair job of looking at this, and took into consideration all of the consequences of the prolonged zero rate policy, it would be forced to conclude that it is now causing more harm then benefit.
Read the whole thing.
Dave Schuler
June 24, 2012
I’ve got a question for you. If German economic growth is the result of German prudence, frugality, and hard work relative to the periphery countries, e.g. Greece, Ireland, what is the cause of Germany’s economic downturn?
What the Euro did was create a bubble in peripheral countries that allowed for mass consumption of German goods. Relatedly, Germany benefited from the fact that the Euro was cheaper than the Deutsche Mark otherwise would have been, thus giving it an export boost.
Again though, the German line will be that its practiced austerity and engaged in labor market reforms that would work for everyone else, if only they would bite the bullet.
The truth of the matter is that not only has the Euro been a perfect form of stimulus for Germany all these years, it has also benefited from more explicit forms of public stimuli.
Take a look at the linked post over at Business Insider. Related and worth mentioning: China’s peg to the dollar created a bubble in the U. S. that allowed for mass consumption of Chinese goods. The hard landing of the Chinese economy, now very clearly in progress, won’t be much fun either for us or the Chinese.
Dave Schuler
June 24, 2012
In response to a discussion of wisdom in comments, I sincerely doubt that wisdom will ever catch on in the curriculum. Confucius taught that there were three sources of wisdom: contemplation which is the noblest, imitation which is the easiest, and experience which is the most bitter.
Young people have a predisposition towards action and experiencing new things. They generally lack the patience required for contemplation and imitation has fallen from favor as irrelevant, the province of dead white guys.
Wisdom gained through experience is the distilled essence of pain and regret, filtered through time, reflection, and compassion. It will never be popular.
Dave Schuler
June 23, 2012
In his most recent op-ed in the Washington Post Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz presents his prescription for reducing income inequality in the U. S.. Imagine my disappointment but, uinfortunately, not surprise when I found that, like most analysts, he is much longer on diagnosis than on prescription:
If we want recovery, there is no choice but to rely on fiscal policy. Fortunately, well-designed spending can lead simultaneously to more employment, growth and equality. Further investments in education, especially aimed at the poor and middle, from preschool to Pell Grants, would stimulate the economy, improve opportunity and increase growth. Spending a fraction of the money the federal government gave to the banks to help underwater homeowners — or extending unemployment benefits for those who have long searched but failed to find a job — would simultaneously ease the burden of those suffering from the recession and help bring the recession to an end. This higher growth would, in turn, lead to higher tax revenue, improving our fiscal position. Plenty of investments would pay for themselves.
The emphasis is mine.
Now, I agree with his third prescription—I think more attention should have been devoted to address the problems of borrowers and the steps taken to aid lenders should have had many, many more strings attached. And, despite Robert Barro’s findings that continuing unemployment insurance is a substantial contributing factor to the ongoing high level of unemployment, I’m not sure we have any other alternative but to extend unemployment benefits. But I want to examine his second prescription more closely.
The United States:
- Spends the most overall and per capita on education of any major country while having the greatest income inequality of any major country.
- Has increased real per student spending by several multiples even as income inequality has increased.
- Has seen the on-time high school graduation rates for many urban school systems remain stubbornly at less than 50% over the period of the last half century.
- Is already among the countries with the highest rates of post-secondary education.
- Has more than 50% of recent college graduates unemployed or underemployed.
Under the circumstances I think it appropriate to ask Dr. Stiglitz exactly how more education will reduce income inequality? Quite to the contrary I think that he has the causality almost exactly backwards. It is reasonable to believe that people with professional degrees and doctorates have higher incomes because they’re receiving subsidies from governments at various different levels. If that’s the case and the solution why not just eliminate the educational middleman and extend the subsidies?
In a famous episode of the prime time cartoon program South Park tiny gnomes have come up with an ingenious business plan:
- Collect underpants.
- ???
- Profit!
To my eye Dr. Stiglitz’s plan seems to be:
- Spend more on education.
- ???
- Income equality.
Dave Schuler
June 23, 2012
Yesterday evening around seven my wife turned to me and said What were you doing at this very minute 27 years ago today? I responded unhesitatingly, I was being pulled over by the California Highway Patrol.
Yesterday was our 27th wedding anniversary. After a morning wedding at my wife’s parish church in Southern California and a delightful brunch reception at a local restaurant, we hopped on a plane for San Jose and rented a car to drive to a quick honeymoon in Carmel before driving my wife’s truck, her pet rabbit, and her possessions back home to Evanston. The Highlands Inn is idyllic, by the way.
My wife drove from the airport to the Inn. She generally drives when we’re in the car together. Thirty or forty minutes from the airport we were pulled over for speeding by a female California Highway Patrol officer. My wife turned to me, angry at herself, and said This is a great way to start our married life. The CHP officer asked You were just married? Show me your rings. They’re too shiny! She let us off with a warning.
Dave Schuler
June 23, 2012
While I have no doubt that the motivations of the House Government Reform and Oversight Committee are mixed in going hammer and tongs after Attorney General Eric Holder, I am genuinely astonished at some of the arguments that intelligent people are making about the underlying facts of the case. To the best of my knowledge there is no question that one of the guns used in the murder of agent Brian Terry was supplied by the BATF, that the BATF had an expectation that the gun would be used in a crime (indeed, the entire operation would have been meaningless otherwise), and that they did not intervene to report the transfer of the gun or otherwise prevent its use.
So, for example, when Steven Taylor argues:
If the specific gun in question had not been allowed to walk, would the agent in question be alive today? This strikes me as unlikely, as it isn’t as if Mexican cartels are known for having a hard time acquiring guns.
it is simply irrelevant. That would certainly make a revolutionary defense in accessory law. Imagine, for example, a getaway driver arguing that there were plenty of other people who could have driven the bankrobbers from the scene of the crime and that bankrobbers, generally, don’t have a problem escaping from the banks they rob. It doesn’t matter. All that matters are there is an underlying crime (the murder of Brian Terry), that BATF supplied the gun, and that BATF had knowledge that the gun would be used for a crime. It also appears to me that BATF acted with recklessness and negligence.
I don’t much care who benefits or is hurt politically. I think that our law enforcement organizations need to be much more cautious in employing sting operations, particularly when the operations can put lives at risk.
Dave Schuler
June 22, 2012
Much of the argument about what is causing the persistent unemployment following the recession that ended in 2009 has been over whether it is cyclical unemployment or structural unemployment. Cyclical unemployment is unemployment produced by fluctuations in demand induced by the business cycle. Structural unemployment is usually induced by technological change. The rise in popularity of the automobile lead to a decline in the demand for buggywhips and, consequently, reduced demand for buggywhip makers.
Economists who are advocates for the view that the unemployment bedeviling us today is cyclical include Paul Krugman and Brad DeLong. Economists who are advocates for the view that structural unemployment is what we’re facing include Narayana Kocherlakota, Arnold Kling, Tyler Cowen, and, perhaps, Joseph Stiglitz. Bond fund manager Bill Gross has also suggested that structural problems are the main ones we’re seeing.
There is a third form of unemployment that I haven’t seen mentioned nearly often enough and which I believe merits further consideration as at least a contributing factor to the persistently high level of unemployment: frictional unemployment. Frictional unemployment is usually defined as the transitional period between jobs but I think that we might consider a broader definition. Consider the following examples:
- A young person cannot find work doing something that he or she cares to do or paying a wage that he or she cares to earn. He or she goes to school to earn an associates, bachelors, masters, doctorate.
- A woman in Akron loses her job. She cannot find any kind of work in Akron. She cannot leave Akron because she needs to look after her elderly mother.
- A man in Omaha loses his job. His wife is employed. He cannot find a job that pays more than the amount he is receiving in unemployment benefits plus the cost of child care. As long as he continues to receive unemployment benefits it makes financial sense for him to remain unemployed.
- A woman in New York loses her job. She is hired by a company in Fargo. She cannot leave New York because she is underwater on her mortgage and has no way of settling with the bank to whom she owes money other than default (which would threaten the job in Fargo).
- An electrical engineer loses his job. He cannot find a job as an electrical engineer. If he took a degree/certification course he could qualify as a medical technician, a field in which he can find a job. He can’t get into the degree/certification course because there aren’t enough slots.
I don’t think that any of these examples fit handily into either the category of cyclical or structural unemployment but could reasonably be considered frictional. I would further suggest that as our society becomes more complex the role of this kind of frictional unemployment will tend to rise beyond its heretofore minor role.
I read Robert Barro’s findings on the role of unemployment insurance in raising the rate of unemployment as an indictment of just this sort of frictional unemployment.
Dave Schuler
June 21, 2012
Here’s a novel explantion of the tremendous increase in the willingness to pay for higher education:
My hypothesis is that it is precisely the dumbing down of U.S. education over the last decades that explains the increase in willingness to pay for education. The mechanism is diminishing marginal returns to education.
Typical graduate business school education has indeed become less rigorous over time, as has typical college education. But typical high school education has declined in quality just as much. As a result, the human capital difference between a college and high-school graduate has increased, because the first increments of education are more valuable on the job market than the later ones. It used to be that everybody could read and understand something like Orwell’s Animal Farm, but the typical college graduates could also understand Milton or Spencer. Now, nobody grasps Milton but only the college grads can process Animal Farm, and for employers the See Spot Run–>Animal Farm jump is more valuable than the Animal Farm–>Milton jump.
That’s consistent with a point that I’ve made here from time to time: that what was expected of an eighth grade graduate a century ago was tremendously greater than what is expected now.
I would also propose a demographic explanation. The cohorts that follow the Baby Boomers are significantly smaller than the Boomers and, since they’re younger, less experienced. More higher education, certifications, etc. enables them to compete for the relatively few jobs that are being created with more experienced competitors.
Hat tip: Tyler Cowen
Dave Schuler
June 21, 2012
For as long as I can remember practical power generation using nuclear fusion was just around the corner. Is it reaching the last corner?
Believe it or not, America is nearing the threshold of a fusion future. By the end of 2012, scientists at the National Ignition Facility in Livermore, California plan to fire the most powerful laser ever constructed into a small chamber with pea-sized fuel pellets inside. The fusion fuel contained within the pellets, two isotopes of hydrogen — deuterium and tritium — will fuse together, producing helium, a free neutron, and massive amounts of energy in the form of heat. If all goes to plan, about ten to one hundred times more energy than the amount used to ignite the fuel will be unleashed.
With this monumental breakthrough achieved, construction could begin on a fusion power plant capable of producing 400 megawatts of base-load power, with a target completion date in the early 2020s. Capital costs would roughly be the same as a current nuclear fission power plant, between $6 and $7 billion. It’s a daunting cost to be sure, but one well worth funding. Besides providing a blueprint for future fusion plants, investment in such a facility will drive innovation in multitudes of fields ranging from optics to materials science.
After the completion of the fusion test plant, construction of commercial facilities producing between 1,000 and 1,500 megawatts of fusion power can get underway. These power plants will produce electricity that’s hard to find fault with. The energy will be base-load — always available. It will be clean — there will be no carbon dioxide emissions or hazardous waste. It will be cheap — early estimates show fusion power to be cost-competitive with coal, even without a carbon tax. It will be nearly limitless — up to 30 million years of fusion fuel exists on Earth. And most importantly, it will be made in America — Laser Inertial Fusion Energy (LIFE) has been produced entirely within the United States.
Generating electrical power from nuclear fusion would be a gigantic breakthrough, a gamechanger. Not only would it generate inexpensive electrical power but it would do so without the security problems and environmental hazards presented by nuclear fission although fusion would not be completely without environmental issues.
However, I’ve been disappointed before. We’ll see.