Dave Schuler
July 17, 2012
Subsequent to Sen. Reid’s tirade about the U. S. Olympic Team’s uniforms having been made in China, all sorts of people are showing amusing, even unseemly concern about what Harry Reid wears. As Glenn Reynolds noted, a better complaint might be that they are lame.
However, this moved me to examine my own wardrobe. Most of my regular suits, shoes, shirts, and pants are made in the United States. That’s a conscious decision on my part. I have some T-shirts that were made in El Salvador and some polo shirts that were made in Turkey, Malaysia, and Indonesia. Interestingly, the polo shirts are different colors of the same style and size, bought at roughly the same time.
My underwear was made in Haiti. I think it’s practically impossible to get underwear that’s made in the United States.
I don’t feel embarrassed about the global character of my wardrobe. We have a comparative advantage in some things but not in others. That’s the nature of trade.
If China were to stop playing currency games, I’d probably buy more stuff made in China.
I ensure that a substantial portion of my wardrobe is made in the United States for the same reason that I go to small, local stores whenever I can: because I want neighbors who run small stores and, similarly, people in the clothing business. If I don’t, everyone in my neighborhood will be a commodities trader, a banker, a professional, an undertaker, or work for the government.
Dave Schuler
July 16, 2012
What if 80% of all medical studies were confabulated poppycock? That’s what the work of John Ioannidis and his colleagues suggests:
Ioannidis was shocked at the range and reach of the reversals he was seeing in everyday medical research. “Randomized controlled trials,†which compare how one group responds to a treatment against how an identical group fares without the treatment, had long been considered nearly unshakable evidence, but they, too, ended up being wrong some of the time. “I realized even our gold-standard research had a lot of problems,†he says. Baffled, he started looking for the specific ways in which studies were going wrong. And before long he discovered that the range of errors being committed was astonishing: from what questions researchers posed, to how they set up the studies, to which patients they recruited for the studies, to which measurements they took, to how they analyzed the data, to how they presented their results, to how particular studies came to be published in medical journals.
This array suggested a bigger, underlying dysfunction, and Ioannidis thought he knew what it was. “The studies were biased,†he says. “Sometimes they were overtly biased. Sometimes it was difficult to see the bias, but it was there.†Researchers headed into their studies wanting certain results—and, lo and behold, they were getting them. We think of the scientific process as being objective, rigorous, and even ruthless in separating out what is true from what we merely wish to be true, but in fact it’s easy to manipulate results, even unintentionally or unconsciously. “At every step in the process, there is room to distort results, a way to make a stronger claim or to select what is going to be concluded,†says Ioannidis. “There is an intellectual conflict of interest that pressures researchers to find whatever it is that is most likely to get them funded.â€
Perhaps only a minority of researchers were succumbing to this bias, but their distorted findings were having an outsize effect on published research. To get funding and tenured positions, and often merely to stay afloat, researchers have to get their work published in well-regarded journals, where rejection rates can climb above 90 percent. Not surprisingly, the studies that tend to make the grade are those with eye-catching findings. But while coming up with eye-catching theories is relatively easy, getting reality to bear them out is another matter. The great majority collapse under the weight of contradictory data when studied rigorously. Imagine, though, that five different research teams test an interesting theory that’s making the rounds, and four of the groups correctly prove the idea false, while the one less cautious group incorrectly “proves†it true through some combination of error, fluke, and clever selection of data. Guess whose findings your doctor ends up reading about in the journal, and you end up hearing about on the evening news? Researchers can sometimes win attention by refuting a prominent finding, which can help to at least raise doubts about results, but in general it is far more rewarding to add a new insight or exciting-sounding twist to existing research than to retest its basic premises—after all, simply re-proving someone else’s results is unlikely to get you published, and attempting to undermine the work of respected colleagues can have ugly professional repercussions.
Lest anyone think that medical research is unique in this regard the problem appears to be pandemic in the sciences, in everything from physics to economics.
I don’t believe that the solution to this particular problem is to fund more research. Quite the opposite, I think it’s to fund less research. The incentives have got to change.
Dave Schuler
July 16, 2012
I stumbled across a fascinating story. Apparently, there are a number of areas of coastal California that for some time have been experiencing “hot spots”, smoldering, underground fires:
Deep beneath the surface, a fire continues to burn and smolder years after authorities discovered the underground blaze. In August 2008, gusts of smoke broke through the ground, prompting firefighters to clear brush from the hot spot and call in experts for answers.
Geologists and other scientists investigated, trying find the cause of what officials first called “a thermal anomaly,” said Bill Nash, a spokesman with the Ventura County Fire Department.
“We’ve met with a number of people on it, really trying to figure out what it is,” he said.
They prodded and tested the ground and the smoke and decided the fire likely started in an oil seam. What exactly ignited the blaze and how long it will last are less clear.
“It’s been there for a long time, and it’s just something we’re going to have to continue to monitor,” Nash said.
It’s not the only one under Ventura County. In 2004, a patch of land northwest of Ojai grew hot enough to start a brush fire, burning 3 acres in the Los Padres National Forest. The spot has since been cooling off.
“It was hot enough to actually ignite some of the local vegetation there,” said Scott Minor, a researcher with the U.S. Geological Survey in Denver. “When the firefighters came in to put it out, they realized it wasn’t just wood burning. It was actually this hot gas coming out of the ground, which could not really be put out.”
I’m no petroleum engineer but it seems to me that any patch of oil or gas that can burn continuously for four years should be investigated thoroughly and, possibly, removed for, er, safekeeping. If it’s a NIMBY issue it’s a very strange one. It’s already in their backyard. The question is whether it will burn uncontrolled, possibly springing up in inhabited areas to burn homes and businesses, or burn under more controlled conditions.
Dave Schuler
July 15, 2012
In downtown Edgebrook, about a mile from where I’m sitting, there’s something that’s a member of an endangered species: a small, independent coffee shop. Just a lunch counter with a couple of stools, maybe a small table or two.
A while back I saw this sign in their window:
Open for Breakfast and Lunch.
Make Your Own Damned Dinner.
Dave Schuler
July 15, 2012
Here’s a sample from a conversation I had with my wife, while watching TV.
Me: “I wonder how many women have said that?”
Her: “What?”
“‘I always knew that someday Mother would do something terrible.'”
“Probably not as many as would tell you about the terrible things their mothers had already done to them.”
Dave Schuler
July 15, 2012
Broadway star, Oscar-winning actress, and television perennial Celeste Holm has died at the age of 95:
NEW YORK – Celeste Holm, a versatile, bright-eyed blonde who soared to Broadway fame in “Oklahoma!” and won an Oscar in “Gentleman’s Agreement” but whose last years were filled with financial difficulty and estrangement from her sons, died Sunday, a relative said. She was 95.
Holm had been hospitalized about two weeks ago with dehydration after a fire in actor Robert De Niro’s apartment in the same Manhattan building. She had asked her husband on Friday to bring her home, and she spent her final days with her husband, Frank Basile, and other relatives and close friends by her side, said Amy Phillips, a great-niece of Holm’s who answered the phone at Holm’s apartment on Sunday.
Holm died around 3:30 a.m. at her longtime apartment on Central Park West, Phillips said.
“I think she wanted to be here, in her home, among her things, with people who loved her,” she said.
In a career that spanned more than half a century, Holm played everyone from Ado Annie — the girl who just can’t say no in “Oklahoma!”– to a worldly theatrical agent in the 1991 comedy “I Hate Hamlet” to guest star turns on TV shows such as “Fantasy Island” and “Love Boat II” to Bette Davis’ best friend in “All About Eve.”
She won the Academy Award in 1947 for best supporting actress for her performance in “Gentlemen’s Agreement” and received Oscar nominations for “Come to the Stable” (1949) and “All About Eve” (1950).
Holm was also known for her untiring charity work — at one time she served on nine boards — and was a board member emeritus of the National Mental Health Association.
A great talent and a great-hearted woman.
Dave Schuler
July 14, 2012
There’s been a discussion in comments of how small businesses are financed. As it turns out the Atlanta Fed has looked into this and here’s what they’ve found:
| |
|
Average Success of Firms Applying (1 = None, 2 = Some, 3 = Most, 4 = All) |
Median Age of Firms Applying |
Equity finance |
Angel |
1.6 |
3 |
| Venture capital |
1.6 |
3 |
| Friends/Family |
2.0 |
4.5 |
| Other |
1.6 |
26.5 |
Vendor Trade Credit |
|
2.9 |
9 |
| Credit Card |
|
2.1 |
4 |
| Loan or Line of Credit |
Large National Bank |
1.5 |
6.5 |
| Community Bank |
2.4 |
15 |
| SBA |
1.0 |
6 |
Let me put this into words. Businesses that are just starting out from scratch typically finance themselves out of the pockets of their founders or from informal (or even formal) loans from family and friends. While it’s possible for a business to secure venture capital or an angel when it starts out, it’s unlikely. Watch Shark Tank for some suggestion of why this is the case.
Credit cards are an extremely common form of financing for new businesses.
More established small businesses can routinely secure trade credit from vendors, usually in the form of payment terms. Very established small businesses can usually secure loans from community banks. Small business frequently have difficulty in getting loans from large national banks. This falls under my rubric of “big businesses like doing business with big businesses”.
The SBA? Fuggedaboutit.
Dave Schuler
July 13, 2012
There’s also a good sentence in this post from Also Sprach Analyst on why we should be cautious about taking too much solace in China’s GDP statistics:
if a country is directing resources into investing something that cannot generate return in excess of the cost of funding, the country as a whole will be destroying economic value even though the country is generating GDP.
to which I would add that when that tactic is used over time the distortions it produces are likely to obscure the price signals that enable you determine whether what you’re doing is destroying economic value. You may think you’re increasing real GDP when you’re actually reducing real GDP and you can’t even determine that’s what’s happening.
As I said before in the context of income tax policy as economic policy, it’s a tactic that might work in combination with a broader economic plan. I think it’s just barely possible that China’s leaders could do that. I doubt it but I think it’s just barely possible. I think there’s no possibility whatever that we would do that here. We do tactics. We don’t do strategies. Indeed, our tactics have a remarkable way of becoming strategies, cf. cutting taxes.
We don’t have an economic strategy, a foreign policy strategy, an energy strategy, a transportation strategy, or any other kind of strategy. That’s worked for us pretty well so far. Not only have we enjoyed tremendous prosperity over a very long period of time, we’re the only major power that has the same government as we did 75 years ago. Germany, France, Russia, China, Japan, and Italy all have different governments than they had 75 years ago. Not just different administrations. Different governments. I guess it’s arguable that Britain has the same government as it did 75 years ago but 75 years ago Britain was a world-spanning empire governing nearly a half billion people—a quarter of all of the people in the world at that time. Now it’s a prosperous island. That sounds different to me.
What we have had is something better than a strategy. What we have had is an emergent phenomenon of the competing and even conflicting interests of the people of the United States. That has proved enormously durable. As I say, it’s worked pretty well so far but that’s no guarantee that it will continue to work as well for us forever. However, I strongly suspect that whatever we might adopt in its place will inevitably be worse.
Dave Schuler
July 13, 2012
There’s a good sentence in Menzie Chinn’s post comparing effective tax rates for the different income quintiles that I wanted to bring to your attention. Here it is:
there is no obvious correlation between the tax rate applying to the top quintile and per capita GDP growth.
I believe that to be true. I strongly suspect that Dr. Chinn intends that as part of an argument to increase the tax rates of the highest income earners but I think it needs to be emphasized that the finding cuts both ways. “No obvious correlation” is no obvious correlation, neither a positive nor a negative correlation. We didn’t get faster per capita GDP growth by cutting taxes and we won’t get faster per capita GDP growth by raising them. I can’t tell you how often I’ve heard and read the claim by PhD economists (including some Nobel prize winners) that the higher tax rates that prevailed during the Clinton Administration caused the faster growth during the Clinton Administration, a claim I have always found absurd.
We might get faster per capita GDP growth with either a tax cut or a tax increase if it were part of a greater, longterm strategy for doing that but we really don’t do strategy in this country. We do tactics and adjusting the income tax is a weak tactic for improving GDP growth and an awful strategy. More on the tactics/strategy issue later today if I get around to it.
Dave Schuler
July 13, 2012
A more humane Mikado never
Did in Japan exist,
To nobody second,
I’m certainly reckoned
A true philanthropist.
It is my very humane endeavour
To make, to some extent,
Each evil liver
A running river
Of harmless merriment.
My object all sublime
I shall achieve in time —
To let the punishment fit the crime —
The punishment fit the crime;
And make each prisoner pent
Unwillingly represent
A source of innocent merriment!
Of innocent merriment!
Check out the graph at Barry Ritholtz’s place illustrating the relative incomes of companies and the punitive damages imposed on them for transgressions. Note, especially, the cases of financial services companies and oil companies.
For something to be a deterrent there are several factors that need to be in place. First, there must be an expectation of discovery and punishment. Second, the punishment must be sufficiently grave. Otherwise the punishment will merely be seen as an acceptable risk, a cost of doing business.
I don’t think it helps that most of our legislators and judges haven’t taken a math course since junior high (and that was forty years ago). I genuinely believe that they have no internalized sense of the differences between a million, a billion, and a trillion.
None of the infractions illustrated in the graphic were mere regulatory transgressions; they were all malum in se. Shouldn’t these be treated much more seriously than they apparently are?