There’s a kerfuffle going on, particularly in the Right Blogosphere, but extending beyond it into the media over this statement from a recent speech by President Obama:
If you were successful, somebody along the line gave you some help. There was a great teacher somewhere in your life. Somebody helped to create this unbelievable American system that we have that allowed you to thrive. Somebody invested in roads and bridges. If you’ve got a business, you didn’t build that. Somebody else made that happen.
The president’s opponents have been quick to leap on the last two sentences, sometimes in amusing fashion. The president’s surrogates and defenders say that he’s being quoted out of context and that he didn’t really mean what his opponents say he meant. James Taranto makes a pretty good argument that the president meant exactly what his opponents claim he meant.
I agree with Aaron Blake’s take in the Washington Post—the president has handed his opponents a club to hit him with. See also the graphs in Aaron’s post: dis-ease with the president’s views on the role of government is not merely a partisan talking point but a factor for independents as well.
That’s significant. The facts of American politics today are that presidential candidates are nominated by their most partisan fellow party members but elected by independents.
There’s an amusing speech uttered by Jimmy Stewart’s character in the movie Shenandoah, possibly the most impious grace in cinema history:
Lord, we cleared this land. We plowed it, sowed it, and harvest it. We cook the harvest. It wouldn’t be here and we wouldn’t be eating it if we hadn’t done it all ourselves. We worked dog-bone hard for every crumb and morsel, but we thank you Lord just the same for the food we’re about to eat, amen.
It’s possible that’s how some Americans see themselves in their imaginations. I think those who honestly see themselves this way are very few, indeed. The question is where do you draw the line?
President Obama isn’t a Little Red Book collectivist. Mitt Romney isn’t a rugged individualist, anarcho-capitalist, or even a minarchist. If anything Mitt Romney is as close to an old-fashioned Nelson Rockefeller Republican or country club Republican as you’re likely to find today. Neither Mr. Obama nor Mr. Romney are at the extremes at which their detractors would like to place them.
George Will once wisecracked that American politics was like a game of football played between the 40 yard lines. Although the transition from catch-all parties towards programmatic parties on the part of both the Democratic Party and the Republican Party has made that less true than it was, say, 20 years ago, I think it remains true. Still, I’d like to know where President Obama and Gov. Romney each draw the line on the role of the federal government. In this election which threatens to be one of solely negative campaigning under conditions in which many Americans fear for their futures, I doubt we’ll get that sort of substantive dialogue.