First, Launch All the Lawyers

Lawyers…In…Space…!

Ambulance chasing only gets you so far. Hitching a ride, metaphorically speaking, on rockets funded by private corporations seeking fortunes beyond Earth’s atmosphere is where it’s at for eager legal pioneers.

There are stellar opportunities for lawyers specializing in space exploration. Space law is quickly becoming an integral part of the evolving aerospace industry. These lawyers exist in a tightly knit industry that deals with all kinds of practical issues and some that seem cribbed from science fiction. Depending on whether the space lawyer is in private practice or academia, he or she could handle anything from liability laws pertaining to litigious space tourists to the legal framework surrounding human encounters with E.T.

“Space tourists are usually high-income earners whose survivors can use high-powered lawyers–insurability for private space travel flights is a big issue at this time,” says space lawyer Doug Griffith, a former Marine Helicopter pilot now working within the commercial space industry. Like him, lots of space lawyers are veterans. And nearly all of them are space and science geeks who found a way to combine their passion for outer space with legal practice.

Space lawyers even have their own legal journal and university programs. The marvelously titled Journal of Space Law is published by the University of Mississippi Law School’s National Center for Remote Sensing, Air, and Space Law. Articles in the current issue deal with, among other things, death liability in commercial space flight accidents, international law relating to suborbital flights, and mineral rights for lunar mining. Students interested in space law also have the option of studying in the Space, Cyber, and Telecommunications Law program at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln; other law schools also offer space law courses within larger programs.

1 comment

Eating the Seed Corn

Here’s an interesting article that highlights some points I’ve been making for some time, e.g. that government spending on engineering pays off and that our spending priorities are backwards:

David C. Morton and his team at the U.S. Army Research Laboratory faced a $4 million chemistry problem: Develop a glue that could survive the harsh conditions of semiconductor manufacturing—acids, etching, plasmas, and a vacuum—and then peel off like a Post-it note.

The glue anchored the creation of light, flexible displays to replace the fragile, heavy glass screens that soldiers use for everything from chemical and biological weapons detection to communications to X-ray detectors for examining potential bombs.

“The Army recognized that flexible displays were a useful technology, so we wanted to speed their development,” says Morton, who manages the Flexible Display Center at the Army’s lab in the Washington, D.C., suburb of Adelphi, Md. Developing that glue was just one step in the $94 million, 10-year project, which was run under a contract with Arizona State University with the participation of around 30 industrial partners.

The glue worked. As he shows off a flexible screen on the sleeve of a camouflage uniform, Morton estimates that the Army lab’s investment has sped development of the flexible displays by five years. “We are successful in the sense that there will be commercial technology this year that the Army will be able to buy,” he says.

That success is just the kind the Department of Defense seeks from its nearly $75 billion-per-year science and technology enterprise, which is larger than all other federal R&D programs combined. Its internal research labs and contracts with universities and industry all focus on developing the science and technology that the military will need in the future.

Military R&D is practically the only federal science spending that has really paid off over the years. The Internet, the printed circuit board, and the integrated circuit—all vital to our modern world—are largely the children of military R&D spending. So, what are we doing? We’ve cut military R&D, a spit in the ocean relative to total defense spending, 12% over the last four years in favor of other spending priorities.

2 comments

The War on Algebra

I see that the war on algebra continues, this time in the form of a post at RealClearMarkets from Jacob Vigdor of the American Enterprise Institute:

Unfortunately, the misguided transformation of algebra into a course for the masses has proven to be a cure worse than the disease. The transformation has resulted in a less rigorous course. Introductory textbooks have slimmed down considerably over the past century, omitting some subjects entirely. The primary victims of this dumbing-down are the elite students themselves. Among the most recent cohorts of college graduates, the proportion of male students majoring in math-intensive subjects has continued to hover in the 20% range. If we compare this to the historical 30% rate of two generations ago, we lose about 100,000 mathematicians, scientists, and engineers every year – enough to replace every American employee of both Microsoft and Google and still have tens of thousands to spare.

Algebra remains a course that is simply too difficult for many students. With Duke colleagues Charles Clotfelter and Helen Ladd, I’ve recently conducted an evaluation of an algebra acceleration initiative that occurred about 10 years ago in the Charlotte-Mecklenburg school system. Students placed into algebra a year early ended up significantly less likely to complete a three-course college prep math curriculum – Algebra I, Geometry, and Algebra II by the time they completed high school.

So, in a nutshell, we have the story of Americas’ twin mathematics problems. Begin with a focus on inequality, and a mistaken premise that everyone could be another Einstein if they just have access to the right courses at the right time. You’ll soon be patting yourself on the back for closing the gap between the best and the worst, only occasionally reminded that neither your best nor worst students are doing all that well in absolute terms. You’ve fallen into what might be termed the “achievement gap trap.”

Unless I misunderstand what he’s writing, he’s advocating a tracking system along the lines of those commonplace elsewhere in the world in which preadolescents are assigned to specific academic tracks suitable to the roles they will fill later in life. “Elite” students who will go on to university take the more intellectually demanding courses, others are spared those courses and will become laborers or factory workers or members of the trades.

I have no idea how that system works in Germany or the United Kingdom or Singapore and, honestly, I don’t care. We have our own social conditions and I have pretty fair confidence on how such a system would work out here. Black and Hispanic students would routinely be deemed not appropriate material for more academically challenging courses. Kids whose dads were physicians or lawyers or bankers or whose dads owned big software companies, most of whom these days don’t live in the same neighborhoods or attend the same schools as kids whose parents aren’t in the upper income brackets, would be assumed to be appropriate for such material. Regardless of actual ability kids with better backgrounds would be “elite”; kids who weren’t would be tracked into non-academically challenging subjects which, essentially, did not lead to higher education. Kids with special educational needs would be warehoused. Unless, of course, their parents were lawyers or doctors or bankers or owned big software companies. In that case they’d receive every resource the public education system could offer.

Or, said another way, it would be system that prevailed here in the 1940s.

There’s one other thing in the article I’d like to comment on. This:

The pragmatic attitude towards mathematics for the masses gave way in the post-World War II era. Successive waves of curricular reforms sought to improve the mathematical skills of ordinary students. The “New Math” movement of the 1950s and early ‘60s tried to beef up the curriculum for all students, with disastrous results. By steering the curriculum away from practical application to a focus on fundamentals, new math managed to turn a generation of students off from math. Male college graduates raised in the new math era chose math-intensive majors at a rate of 20% — down a third relative to the prior generation.

is essentially hooey. What actually happened is that in the late 60s and early 70s the space program was wound down, engineering jobs became much harder to find, and the NSF cut funding for science and math education. “Progressive education” assumed increasing influence. Here’s a quote from the influential book, Summerhill, the bible of that movement, which should give you the general idea:

Whether a school has or has not a special method for teaching long division is of no significance, for long division is of no importance except to those who want to learn it. And the child who wants to learn long division will learn it no matter how it is taught.

Summerhill was required reading in many education programs in the 1970s. The people who took those programs are running school systems today.

10 comments

Lies, Damned Lies, and Stimulus

I agree wholeheartedly with just about one sentence in Doug Bandow’s op-ed in Forbes. The remainder illustrates the gulf that separates the two camps warring over the role, if any, for government spending in reviving our economy, now shambling along with little or no growth. On one side is Mr. Bandow, apparently arguing for “austerity”:

In July the New York Times published an unintentionally hilarious editorial contending that “Mr. Obama’s big mistake was to turn prematurely from the need for stimulus to a focus on cutting the budget.” The Times apparently missed the $1.2 trillion deficit the administration will run this year. Or the president’s future budget submission: the Congressional Budget Office estimated that the president’s program would raise accumulated red ink over the next decade from $3 trillion to an astonishing $6.4 trillion. Where is the radical budget-cutting in Washington.

A similar debate is occurring in Europe, with the contest presented as “austerity” versus “growth.” Yet many of the nations which practiced austerity have grown the fastest. Germany remains the continent’s powerhouse even though its post-2008 stimulus was far less relative to its GDP than in the U.S. and other European states. Both Germany and Sweden enjoyed strong growth as they brought their budgets into closer balance.

The balance of the op-ed consists of presenting the arguments against stimulus spending. The findings are generally summed up here:

Alas, the only thing that government “stimulus” stimulates is government. Valerie Ramey observed: “Increases in government spending do reduce unemployment. For all but one specification, though, it appears that all of the employment increase is from an increase in government employment, not private employment.”

For the counter-argument to Mr. Bandow’s case you can read just about any column or post by Paul Krugman.

I don’t find any general agreement on the meaning of the term “austerity”. In much of the Eurozone it appears to mean tax increases. For its advocates in the United States it appears that it means tax cuts and cutting government spending except military spending which should increase.

Both sides of this question distort, spin, and cherry-pick their findings to support their arguments. So, for example, proponents of stimulus point to the decrease in the number of state and local government employees as prima facie evidence for their case without acknowledging that the reason that these decreases are taking place is that by law their budgets must balance, that tax increases are becoming decreasingly efficient and/or politically possible, and that public employee employment contracts require them to increase employee pay. Their only real recourse is firing people. Additional federal stimulus spending will be used, then, for raises. That’s not an efficient stimulus.

Similarly, proponents of austerity assume that increasing GDP will lead to increasing employment. That has not been the case for years. Why would it become true in 2013?

Here’s the sentence I agree with:

Economic growth requires good spending, not more spending.

It would be nice if there were some agreement on what “good” spending is. That doesn’t seem to be the case. Additionally, I think that prescription applies to the private sector as well as the public. In theory, the private sector is compelled to make more prudent judgments than the public sector or lose their money. As Yogi Berra said, “In theory there’s no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is.”

Is buying a $25 million mansion in the Hamptons “good spending”? I seriously doubt that it does much to stimulate growth in the economy. Most of the money will just go to someone else who’s very wealthy. It’s just trading hats.

6 comments

Municipal Bankruptcy Watch: Poway, California

There’s been quite a ferment of commentary about the financing deal cut by the small city just outside San Diego of Poway, California:

New school, new library, new technology – just a few examples of the renovations and repairs made to Poway Unified School District’s 24 aging schools starting in 2001 under Proposition U.

To finish the job, Poway taxpayers passed Proposition C in 2008. Last year, as part of that bond, the district borrowed $105 million.

It won’t begin paying it back until 20 years from now.

With interest, that $105 million loan will end up costing taxpayers almost $1 billion over 40 years, according to our media partner, Voice of San Diego, who broke the story.

According to Poway’s 2007 financial statements the city had less than $80 million in revenues for that year. I suspect that, if anything, its revenues have declined since then. It had another, roughly $50 million in assets. It was running at a deficit.

The consensus view appears to be what were they thinking? That’s easy. They were thinking “I’ll be gone; you’ll be gone; it’ll be somebody else’s mess to clean up.” Poway is primarily dependent on property taxes. Even if Poway were to increase its property taxes beyond anything that can be reasonably imagined it would be hard-pressed to pay back what it’s borrowed and, given California state law, the increase would only take effect slowly, over time.

I think there are several questions raised by Poway’s case. It’s obviously a disaster in the making. Don’t the lenders bear some culpability in the fiasco? In what drug-induced hallucination did they believe Poway would be able to pay back what it’s borrowed?

And who at the state level oversees this stuff? California is a sovereign state. Cities and towns don’t get to do whatever they want. That’s under state control and oversight. Isn’t there some level of fiscal malpractice that’s just too far for California to tolerate?

Update

In the body of the post I have incorrectly given the impression that the city of Poway has the debt rather than the school district. However, the balance of my point remains: that the debt that has been incurred is too great for the district to repay, that the lenders should never have encouraged it, and that, regardless of the voters’ complicity, they should not be allowed to get themselves into such a mess.

31 comments

The Triffin Dilemma

I rejoice in learning something new every day. Today I learned about the Triffin Dilemma. The Triffin Dilemma, first posed by Belgian-American economist Robert Triffin, is the idea that there’s an intrinsic conflict of interest between a country’s national interest and a country’s international interests that arise from that country’s currency also being the international reserve currency. The country must be willing to provide for the world an extra supply of its currency which, in turn, inherently produces a trade imbalance for that country.

I think that can only work as long as a) the country’s ability to produce new jobs as a result of technological, educational, and social development exceeds the jobs it loses due to the imbalances that are created and b) other countries don’t game the system to accelerate the process to their advantage.

As I’ve been trying to explain for some time, my view of the economic problem we face is that our inability to create enough new jobs has been masked for decades by a series of bubbles which have now collapsed and exposed the long term problem. The Triffin Dilemma fits in nicely with that notion.

20 comments

With the Aid of a Computer…

…you can make an error that would have taken you years to do by hand. Did a software problem clobber Knight Capital?

In early July, the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) received SEC approval for a new program called the Retail Liquidity Program (RLP). The program, which was slated to kick off on August 1st, would allow retail traders to get access to better pricing on stock. The specification for the programme had been around for less than a year but a lot of wall street firms had planned for its implementation.

There was some controversy when the announcement was made but all market makers started preparing for the launch, realizing that this may be another tool to fight the competition and that those who were not ready by launch time could risk losing out precious advantages in the market.

Knight Capital, as one of the largest players in the market, decided that it would provide that capability to its customers as soon as it became available and that it would take advantage of the price differential for its own trading. With only a few weeks from the announcement to the release, internal development teams must have burned the midnight oil to get this in place by the August 1st deadline.

But on Wednesday morning, Knight Capital may have made a mistake that could cost it its exis­tence. According to reports, the company had just finished upgrading its software to the newer version, allowing it to take advantage of the RLP.

When the NYSE opened, trades on as many as 114 companies started running at higher than expected volumes. Here’s how the New York Times describes what happened next:

A New York Times analysis of New York Stock Exchange volume on Wednesday morning showed that during the first minute of trading there was 12 percent more trading in all stocks than there had been on average during the previous seven days. By the third minute of trading there was 116 percent more trading than the previous week’s average. The differ­ence reached a peak at 9:58 a.m., when the volume was six times greater. After that, trad­ing volume fell off sharply, nearing the recent average at 10:15 a.m.

[…]

Once the problems began, many traders said it would have made sense if the firm’s employees had not caught the problems for the first minute or so, given the speed at which Knight’s program was firing off orders. After that, though, the problems were visible for all to see.

In under an hour, the company had lost $440 million, $75 million more than all the cash it had in its reserves, or more than it had made in profit for the previous year. Customers, wary of suffer­ing from the bug, decided to start trading through other firms. By Thursday, a number of broker­ages and broker-dealers (TD Ameritrade, Scott Trade, Fidelity Investments, Vanguard Group, E*Trade and Pershing LLC, a division of BNY Mellon) suspended routing trading orders through the company. A few came back but not all.

4 comments

When Is a Loan Not a Loan?

Well, when it’s a grant, a payoff, or a mechanism for recycling the loan funds into political contributions. Bruce Krasting examines the activities of the Federal Financing Bank and comes up with a lot of questions that you’d think more people would be asking:

This will sound “good” to Obama’s supporters. But the questions are,

(1) who is getting rich off of this lending, and

(2) what is this going to cost the taxpayers?

The answer to #1, is that big shots are getting rich. Guys like Warren Buffett have a winning ticket. Many of the “winners” are connected back to Obama.

It all reminds me of a wisecrack of Dan Rostenkowski’s: “Never take a bribe. Just hand ’em your business card.”

Here’s how it works. So and so puts in an application for a loan. At some point there’s scuttlebutt or even a direct phone call or memo from some White House flunky (or even, just to pick a functionary at random, a White House Chief of Staff) to the effect that “So and so is a good guy”. So and so gets the loan. Coincidentally, So and so is a bundler or has made substantial political contributions in the past and, equally coincidentally, makes more political contributions. His ROI on these contributions is about 10,000%. Around here we call it “pay to play”.

Technically, it may not be corrupt but in reality it’s as corrupt as the dickens.

3 comments

Post Hoc Propter Hoc

Whatever your beliefs about the efficacy of fiscal stimulus, I think you’d have to go a bit to find an analysis of the ineffectiveness of fiscal stimulus more superficial than Arthur Laffer’s:

Policy makers in Washington and other capitals around the world are debating whether to implement another round of stimulus spending to combat high unemployment and sputtering growth rates. But before they leap, they should take a good hard look at how that worked the first time around.

It worked miserably, as indicated by the table nearby, which shows increases in government spending from 2007 to 2009 and subsequent changes in GDP growth rates. Of the 34 Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development nations, those with the largest spending spurts from 2007 to 2009 saw the least growth in GDP rates before and after the stimulus.

The four nations—Estonia, Ireland, the Slovak Republic and Finland—with the biggest stimulus programs had the steepest declines in growth. The United States was no different, with greater spending (up 7.3%) followed by far lower growth rates (down 8.4%).

There are several problems with this. First is that not only did countries with the largest spending increases show sharp declines but so did countries with among the lowest increases in spending, e.g. Germany (spending increase of 4.6%, change in real GDP -11.6%) and Sweden (spending increase of 3.8%, change in real GDP -13.6%). Or, in other words, either high increases in spending or low, both profligacy and austerity can be associated with large declines in real GDP.

More importantly isn’t it barely possible that countries in which they foresaw larger declines, depending on the political winds in those countries, engaged in more vigorous measures to address them? I.e. that the causality goes the other way around?

4 comments

The Marilyn Monroe Anniversary

Today is the 50th anniversary of the death of Marilyn Monroe. The news media are full of, mostly, gushing commentaries about her.

Ms. Monroe’s reputation as a movie star is based upon just ten movies made between 1953 and 1961, beginning with Gentlemen Prefer Blondes and ending with The Misfits, her last completed movie. At her death she entered the pantheon of “too much, too soon” actors and actresses, at whose summit is James Dean. I think there’s a notable difference between Dean and Monroe: Dean died at the pinnacle of his career; at the time of her death Monroe’s career was, arguably, in decline. She was 36 years of age, an age at which actresses who’ve achieved fame as sex symbols frequently see the offers of juicy roles becoming fewer and farther between. Of course, since they both died we have no way of knowing for sure.

Of the ten films Marilyn Monroe’s most iconic roles were in two films by Billy Wilder: The Seven Year Itch and Some Like It Hot. That alone should be enough to give us pause. IMO Wilder had only one overriding theme: sexual transgression. That wasn’t unique in the 1950s and 60s. In France it was personified by Brigitte Bardot; in Italy by Sophia Loren.

There is a notable difference, however. Bardot and Loren were symbols of female sexual power, joyful and exhilarating. Contrariwise, Marilyn Monroe, particularly in her two iconic Billy Wilder roles, was too depersonalized. She had no names. In The Seven Year Itch she was “The Girl”; in Some Like It Hot she had only a stage name.

I have never cared much for Marilyn Monroe’s pictures. They are too leering, too, as I say, depersonalized. One factor behind my dislike may be what might be deemed a flaw of mine: the personalities of actors and actresses invariably come across the proscenium at me. I always see the underlying person in any performance. To my eye Marilyn Monroe was not vulnerable, the term usually applied, but damaged. She’s too sad for me to watch.

My favorite performance by Marilyn Monroe was in Bus Stop. In Bus Stop that damaged quality is front and center. In Bus Stop it works. Similarly, the damaged quality is central to her character in The Misfits. The Misfits is just too dark for me to take much pleasure in watching it.

I think there’s one thing was should be concerned about in the popular image of Marilyn Monroe: the romanticization. Today’s young women, most of whom have never seen any of her pictures, know her only from stills or short clips. They see the beauty, the voluptuousness, the evening gown, and that she never gets old. What they don’t see is the damage from mental illness, sexual abuse, a string of failed marriages, and the hard, grueling slog climbing the ladder in the movies under what we can only imagine what circumstances, never to receive much respect as an actress during her lifetime.

7 comments