It Always Starts Humble

I won’t dissect Bret Stephens’s column in the Wall Street Journal, analyzing Paul Ryan’s foreign policy speech given before the Alexander Hamilton Society a year ago. There is so much of it that I find wrong, objectionable, or irritating I hardly know where to start. I’ll just mention this tiny snippet:

So what follows? “If you believe these rights are universal human rights . . . it leads you to reject moral relativism. It causes you to recoil at the idea of persistent moral indifference toward any nation that stifles and denies liberty, no matter how friendly and accommodating its rulers are to American interests.”

Note the consistency of the logic. Note the quality of the language. Note, finally, Mr. Ryan’s understanding that America’s real interests are derived from our deepest values. For most other countries, it’s just the opposite: The interests come first, and “values” are a synonym for justifications.

None of this means that Mr. Ryan is a foreign-policy crusader. He talks of a “healthy humility” about the degree to which the U.S. can “control events in other regions.”

George W. Bush, October 12, 2000:

If we’re an arrogant nation, they’ll resent us; if we’re a humble nation, but strong, they’ll welcome us. And our nation stands alone right now in the world in terms of power, and that’s why we’ve got to be humble, and yet project strength in a way that promotes freedom.

How has that worked out? We are in our eleventh year in a war in Afghanistan which accomplished as much as it was likely to accomplish roughly ten years ago. Our military budget is twice in real terms what Ike’s was at the height of the Cold War when he warned us of the dangers of the military-industrial complex. Gov. Romney has proposed increasing military spending. Do you see how I might be wary of talk of humility in our foreign policy?

I completely believe in American exceptionalism but I believe in both aspects of it. Not only is the United States different from other countries and that difference is good for us and good for the world. That;s just the one aspect. Here’s the other: the things that make us different can’t be transplanted and certainly can’t be imposed by force.

I think that we should be well-wishers to the freedom and independence of all but the champion and vindicator only of our own.

17 comments

Castles in the Air

The editors of the Washington Post have examined the fiscal policy proposals of the president and Gov. Romney and find them both not only wanting but dangerous:

The fundamental Republican myth is that the country’s fiscal problems can be tackled without new revenue — or, in the more sophisticated version of this argument, that they can be addressed by rejiggering the tax code in a way that would promote economic growth, and therefore produce additional revenue, without asking any households to pay a larger share of their income in taxes. In the Romney-Ryan version of the myth, marginal rates can be cut even further, eliminating popular deductions — deliberately unspecified — and counting on unduly optimistic projections to fill the gap. As the Tax Policy Center has demonstrated, that approach would “provide large tax cuts to high-income households, and increase the tax burdens on middle- and/or lower-income taxpayers.”

and

The fundamental Democratic myth is that the country’s fiscal problems can be solved by focusing on, and asking for sacrifice from, only a tiny, vilified slice of the population: the wealthy. The central promise of President Obama’s 2008 campaign, reaffirmed in 2012, was that he would not raise taxes on the middle-class, defined as households earning less than $250,000 annually. At the same time, Democrats want voters to believe that Social Security and Medicare can be fixed, to the extend they need fixing, barely touching ever-rising benefits.

In an op-ed in the New York Times David Stockman, director of Office of Management and the Budget under Ronald Reagan is equally harsh:

Mr. Ryan professes to be a defense hawk, though the true conservatives of modern times — Calvin Coolidge, Herbert C. Hoover, Robert A. Taft, Dwight D. Eisenhower, even Gerald R. Ford — would have had no use for the neoconconservative imperialism that the G.O.P. cobbled from policy salons run by Irving Kristol’s ex-Trotskyites three decades ago. These doctrines now saddle our bankrupt nation with a roughly $775 billion “defense” budget in a world where we have no advanced industrial state enemies and have been fired (appropriately) as the global policeman.

Indeed, adjusted for inflation, today’s national security budget is nearly double Eisenhower’s when he left office in 1961 (about $400 billion in today’s dollars) — a level Ike deemed sufficient to contain the very real Soviet nuclear threat in the era just after Sputnik. By contrast, the Romney-Ryan version of shrinking Big Government is to increase our already outlandish warfare-state budget and risk even more spending by saber-rattling at a benighted but irrelevant Iran.

Similarly, there can be no hope of a return to vibrant capitalism unless there is a sweeping housecleaning at the Federal Reserve and a thorough renunciation of its interest-rate fixing, bond buying and recurring bailouts of Wall Street speculators. The Greenspan-Bernanke campaigns to repress interest rates have crushed savers, mocked thrift and fueled enormous overconsumption and trade deficits.

The problem, as I suggested yesterday, is that even extracting pain, however fairly distributed, isn’t enough. We need fundamental reforms to basic institutions and structures of government. Our greatest fiscal problems are, in order, healthcare spending, too much military spending, the inefficiency and obsolescence of our tax code, based as it is on the assumptions of a generation ago, and interest on the debt. As Mr. Stockman notes our biggest regulatory problem is the banking system. The two major political party tickets are united, shoulder-to-shoulder, in refusing to come to terms with any of these pressing concerns.

Over a period of thirty-five years I have arrived at the conclusion that we can’t cut costs in healthcare spending in the context of the fee-for-services system and the insurance system as its presently constituted. Military spending and, importantly, military commitments are so obviously beyond what is reasonably necessary to preserve our security I can barely see how the question is debated at all but, indeed, it’s a subject of bitter debate with the present Republican ticket taking the remarkable position that military spending should be increased.

In the face of such titanic dysfunction I have only a handful of alternatives. I could full-throatedly support one or the other of the two major party tickets, delusional as they both are. I could support a third party ticket in the full knowledge that the very best that will accomplish is the perverse result of injuring the major party ticket that I prefer. I could become a sociopath. I could become a psychopath.

Or, I could be a voice crying out in the wilderness, choose among frankly unhinged alternatives, and hope for the best. That’s my choice.

16 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

0 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Iran in the News

There are a number of stories about Iran in the news today. Some are troubling, some sad, some downright baffling. Together I think they paint a picture of a situation that is very dangerous, becoming more so, and which leaves no room for miscalculations or mistakes.

28 comments

What’s “Populist”?

PIMCO co-CEO Mohammed El-Erian remarks on the political situation here and in Europe:

Like an earthquake rocking a house, the 2008 global financial crisis exposed a shaky new foundation underpinning Western economies. Just look at Europe, where cascading debt crises have made paupers of once-proud countries, where long-term joblessness and high youth unemployment have dulled the hopes of both recent university graduates and those nearing retirement, and where unusually wide income inequality has heaped social unrest atop financial turmoil.

This is part of what my colleagues at Pimco and I labeled a few years ago as “The New Normal.” But something has changed as this crisis has continued. The systemic instability we saw then has continued to morph, fast and furious: The vicious feedback loops that turned bad economics into bad politics now convert bad politics into even worse economics, further threatening an already tenuous economic future.

and warns of an impending populist backlash:

Sadly, neither Obama nor Romney has yet offered a meaningful, forward-looking economic reform program to address problems such as a malfunctioning labor market, unsustainable public finances, a broken credit system, inadequate infrastructure, and a lagging education system. The risk for the United States, as well as the global economy, is that a lack of vision and political courage ends up leading to even greater economic disappointment and financial instability, bringing with it the social unrest we’ve seen in so many other countries over the past 18 months. Occupy Wall Street and the Tea Party may have somewhat fizzled, but populist anger could return with a vengeance.

I would genuinely like to know Mr. El-Erian’s operative definition of “populist”. I also wonder what form he thinks that a populist backlash could take in the United States.

I have no idea whatever about the political mood in Europe but here in the U. S. there are as yet few signs of any backlash. Mitt Romney, former Massachusetts governor and son of a former Michigan governor and presidential aspirant, is no populist. Neither is President Obama. At least not by any definition of populist that I understand. To me that implies that for the next four years at least there’s not much risk of a wave of populist fervor overcoming our political apparatus.

What does he envision? The Terror? I’m baffled.

36 comments

Quintessential Baby Boomer Humor

This is something I’ve been mulling over for some time, possibly in reaction to the relentless advertising lately for the rather transparently BB-targeted rom-com, Hope Springs. I think the attempt that it represents to draw Baby Boomers back into the theater will prove futile.

Here’s my question: what’s the quintessential Baby Boomer movie comedy? Let’s start by defining our terms. By “Baby Boomer” I mean an American born between 1946 and 1964. By “Baby Boomer movie comedy” I mean a movie written, directed, and starring Baby Boomers for mostly a Baby Boomer audience, generally from 1978 to 2000.

I think there are basically three strains of Baby Boomer movie comedies: Abrahams and Zucker; Landis, Ramis, and Aykroyd; and the Coen brothers.

Landis, Ramis, and Aykroyd

Animal House (1978) is, arguably, the first break-out Baby Boomer comedy. The team of director, writers, and actors that made it went on to produce more than a dozen movies including Caddy Shack, The Blues Brothers, and Ghostbusters. Some of the team, Landis (1950) and Belushi (1949), are Baby Boomers, other are “Baby Boomer adjacent”, i.e. either they born just outside the timeframe of my definition or they’re Canadians. e.g. Dan Aykroyd (1952) and Harold Ramis (1944). This is the team that specialized in “slob humor”, sort of a combination of hipster humor with the Bowery Boys.

Abrahams and Zucker

Jim Abrahams (1944) and David Zucker released their breakout hit, Airplane! in 1980. These were followed by the Hot Shot and Naked Gun pictures and continue right to the present in the Scary Movie movies. These pictures are broad parodies, filled with movie references and sly humor.

The Coen Brothers

Joel and Ethan Coen released their first comedy, Raising Arizona, which starred Holly Hunter (1958) and Nicolas Cage (1964). Their comedies include Barton Fink, The Hudsucker Proxy, The Big Lebowski, and O, Brother, Where Art Thou?. Like the Abrahams and Zucker movies their pictures tend to be filled with references to movies, television, and popular culture but they’re generallya bit more sophisticated than the A&Z movies.

For my taste Raising Arizona is the acme of Baby Boomer humor and I suspect that their O. Brother, Where Art Thou? is probably the last great Baby Boomer movie comedy. It’s possible that someone may produce a great BB movie comedy about aging but, somehow, I doubt it.

This isn’t encyclopedic. I don’t consider Nora Ephron’s pictures to be Baby Boomer pictures. The actors who star in her pictures, e.g. Billy Crystal, Tom Hanks, and Meg Ryan, are Baby Boomers but she wasn’t and I think her humor and that of romantic comedies more generally hearkens back to older influences like Ruth Gordon and Garson Kanin.

Thoughts? What do you think is the best Baby Boomer comedy? What characteristics do you think typify Baby Boomer comedies?

Update

As I wrote above, this isn’t encyclopedic. I suddenly realized that I omitted a major strain: the Rob Reiner, Christopher Guest, Eugene Levy, Spinal Tap strain. While I think that This Is Spinal Tap, Waiting for Guffman, Best in Show, and A Mighty Wind are brilliant, these are mostly virtually cult pictures. Interestingly, I know a bit about the inner side of all of the subjects of these movies (except rock music, i.e. community theater, dog shows, and folk music) and for my money they’re slightly toned-down documentaries.

20 comments

Remarkable Stories

I found these stories of recovery from traumatic brain injury pretty inspiring. The first recounts the journey of Brian Boyle from “locked-in syndrome” to finishing in the Ironman World Championship in Hawaii:

On July 6, 2004, Brian Boyle left swim practice in Welcome, Maryland, with thoughts of a recent Independence Day cookout fresh in his mind. Under the red glare of fireworks, he’d shared his plans for college and training for the swim team with friends and family. He was 18 years old, a typical student, athlete, and “quiet guy.” And all his plans were about to be shattered.

As he drove across an intersection on his way home, a dump truck barreled into the side of Boyle’s car and crushed it beyond recognition. The impact was so severe, it shunted his heart to the opposite side of his chest. He suffered a concussion, lacerated liver, collapsed lungs, and shattered pelvis and ribs. His kidneys failed, and he lost 60% of his blood. Emergency medical personnel resuscitated him eight times, and nearly pronounced him dead at the accident scene, before Boyle was taken to intensive care by medevac.

Read the whole thing.

It is a sad but true reality that war causes some of the most dramatic developments in the treatment of traumatic injury or, in the case of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, in its treatment and diagnosis. Spurred not only by those wars and the money the VA will be pouring into the treatment of the men and women injured in those wars for many years to come but by the increasing recognition in the injuries sustained by the brains of athletes, particularly football and hockey players, TBI is a big story in rehab and will be for the foreseeable future.

1 comment

Things That Don’t Interest Me

I don’t generally post on things that don’t interest me. That explains my silence over the topic that’s dominating the political blogosphere, television pundits, and the opinion pages of the major newspapers: Mitt Romney’s selection of Paul Ryan as his running mate. It will have next to no influence over my decision on how to engage in the futile gesture of voting. Futile because I live in Illinois and there has never really been any doubt that Illinois’s electoral votes will go to Obama.

I’ll only add one observation that I’ve already made over at OTB. In nominating Paul Ryan Mitt Romney is doubling down on Americans’ disinterest in foreign policy. Paul Ryan is the epitome of Congressional Republicans’ strategy in domestic policy. I don’t think that policy is vile but I do think it’s objectively incorrect. I.e., I don’t think that cutting taxes for those who actually pay taxes (the rich) will create jobs, I don’t think that nudging heatlhcare towards privatization will induce its costs to decline, and I don’t think that the majority of Americans have the material capacity to save for their own retirements and even if they did some sort of minimum elderly income subsidy would continue to be required.

34 comments

Pauline Kael Lives!

As an illustration of just how divided the U. S. is, both ideologically and geographically, consider the two mutually exclusive points of view.

Barack Obama will win in a landslide:

Liberals don’t want to jinx it. It terrifies the right. And the press would prefer a nail-biter. But the fact is that finding Romney’s path to victory is getting harder every day.

There’s a secret lurking behind everything you’re reading about the upcoming election, a secret that all political insiders know—or should—but few are talking about, most likely because it takes the drama out of the whole business. The secret is the electoral college, and the fact is that the more you look at it, the more you come to conclude that Mitt Romney has to draw an inside straight like you’ve never ever seen in a movie to win this thing. This is especially true now that it seems as if Pennsylvania isn’t really up for grabs. Romney’s paths to 270 are few.

Mitt Romney will win in a landslide:

Yes, Barack Obama is ahead in some polls. And, yes, it looks like a neck-and-neck race. But that is because the President is spending everything that he has right now in a desperate attempt to demonize Mitt Romney, and it is because Americans are not yet paying attention. Obama’s support is a mile wide and a quarter of an inch deep.

Of course, if Romney were a corpse as yet unburied on the model of Bob Dole and John McCain, he would lose. If you do not all that much care whether you win or not, you will lose. But Romney wants to win. He is a man of vigor, and he has a wonderful case to make. He is a turn-around artist, and this country desperately needs turning around. Barack Obama has no argument to make. He can only promise more of the same — yet another stimulus and higher taxes on the investing class. All that Romney has to do if he wants to win is to make himself presentable, and that should not be hard. He is handsome, tolerably well-spoken, and accomplished. If, in the debates, he stands up to the President, he will seem the more presidential of the two – and that will do the trick, as it did in 1980.

A more balanced view can be obtained by looking at this electoral map, courtesy of Larry Sabato’s Crystal Ball:

Add to that the following. Many of the states that the president carried in 2008 were carried by only a percentage point or two. If the election is a wave election, not only could Romney carry the states that are solidly Republican, likely Republican, or leans Republican, and the states that are too close to call but the states that lean Democratic as well. We won’t have any real idea of whether that has any likelihood at all until much, much closer to the election itself.

Basically, the election is too close to call and will remain that way for some time.

I believe that the only way you can believe otherwise is to be sealed in an ideological bubble as I gather that both of the authors cited above are. That’s the reason for the title of this post. In the aftermath of the 1972 presidential election NYT critic Pauline Kael was quoted as saying: “I can’t believe that Nixon won. I don’t know anybody who voted for him”. What she actually said was, apparently, more like:

I only know one person who voted for Nixon. Where they are I don’t know. They’re outside my ken.

There is a real, legitimate, genuine difference of opinion in the country today. There are millions of people who cannot imagine voting for Mitt Romney any more than they could imagine voting for Richard Nixon. Or Attila the Hun, for that matter. But there are also millions of people who cannot imagine voting for Barack Obama and are skeptical that anyone could see things differently than they do.

Many members of each of these groups live in states, towns, or neighborhoods in which everybody they know believes what they believe and have preferences similar to their own and, consequently, they overestimate how universal their views are. In my view that’s how fundamentalism of any stripe survives.

18 comments

The Subsidization Paradox

I urge you to read this post by solar entrepeneur David Bergeron, explaining why if you are in favor of alternative energy you should oppose subsidizing it:

Here is the real problem: Subsidies make solar appear viable today, so where is the motivation for an entrepreneur to risk money, or even focus on developing real energy alternatives when solar is “almost” there? How can an inventor justify striving with the effort it takes to really develop something great when he is competing against a straw man technology which can provide power at almost the same cost of traditional power sources today? But of course it really doesn’t.

The answer is he can’t justify the effort, so the next great thing is not developing, at least not with the sense of urgency it should be. Why enter a contest when you are competing against someone with an unfair advantage? You may be the faster swimmer, but your competitor is using flippers.

Read the whole thing.

32 comments