The Full Limit of the Law

The way I read the Illinois Property Tax Law, the Chicago Public Schools may be hard put to increase taxes enough to cover the additional expenses it will incur under the proposed contract with the Chicago Teachers Union especially in consideration of the deficits in its budget that are already known. Those include its present $600 million some-odd deficit and next year’s $600 million some-odd deferred payment into the teachers’ retirement fund. It is my understanding that in order to increases taxes faster the CPS must seek approval in referendum from the voters of the district. Perhaps someone better informed than I on this subject could weigh in and correct or affirm my reading as required.

2013 may be an interesting year. Interesting in the “may you live in interesting times” sense.

Update

Maybe that’s a little too cryptic. Under Illinois law certain taxing entities like school districts, for example, are limited in how fast they can raise taxes. County assessors are instructed under the law to limit the amount taxes can increase to no more than a certain percentage over the previous year’s taxes. That can be overridden by referendum.

There are other complications. For example, cities over 500,000 in population (read: Chicago) may also have a School Finance Authority that has certain obligations. I don’t read that to remove the requirement for a referendum in order to increase taxes faster than the statutory limit, however.

They could always seek a remedy from the state legislature. That could be fun.

2 comments

The Deal

The Chicago Public Schools and the Chicago Teachers Union have arrived at a tentative deal:

Chicago Public Schools and the teachers union have reached a tentative agreement on a new contract and classes could resume for 350,000 students on Monday, according to school and union officials.

The union’s House of Delegates will review details Sunday and are expected to vote then on whether to end the 5-day-old teachers strike, according to Chicago Teachers Union President Karen Lewis.

She cautioned there is no contract yet, though a City Hall source said the school district and union have reached a “framework with all points resolved.”

Lewis said delegates at a meeting Friday afternoon did not receive a summary or any details of the agreement. But she said she was “very comfortable” with the terms.

“Our delegates were not interested in blindly signing off on something they have not seen,” she said. “We think it’s a framework that will get us to an agreement.”

Don’t let the pomp and circumstance fool you. Ms. Lewis wouldn’t submit the “framework” to the delegates if there were a chance that it would be rejected.

Make no mistake: the failure to reach an agreement with the teachers, at least in part due to his truculent approach, and the ensuing unnecessary teachers’ strike has revealed just how inadequate a mayor Rahm Emanuel is for Chicago:

On Friday, after spending more than a year attacking the teachers union, Emanuel sought to strike a conciliatory tone as word spread about the much-improved prospects for a deal.

“This tentative framework is an honest and principled compromise that is about who we all work for: our students. It preserves more time for learning in the classroom, provides more support for teachers to excel at their craft and gives principals the latitude and responsibility to build an environment in which our children can succeed,” Emanuel said in a statement.

The dialed-back rhetoric stands in contrast to what came before. Emanuel’s argument for a longer school day and year started out as an accusation, not a conversation.

In building his case, the mayor said Chicago Public Schools teachers had regularly received pay raises, the city had labor peace and students got the shaft. Emanuel’s contention, made last September shortly after his hand-picked school board took away half the teachers’ previously negotiated raise, implied that educators were lazy, resistant to change and didn’t have students’ best interests in mind.

It’s a classic Washington tactic: Define your opposition before they can themselves. It’s the kind of approach Emanuel perfected during his political upbringing in the nation’s capital as a congressman and veteran of two White Houses.

It also underscored the learning curve Emanuel has yet to master — an executive must have the ability to maneuver between dominance and persuasion.

“Well before the strike, there were a number of shots fired that were unwarranted, and it set the tone,” said Ald. John Arena, 45th. “The mayor has tended to be very one-dimensional in his tactics. This isn’t Congress anymore, or the backroom.”

He’s the Marshal Foch of American politics.

Attacking your opponents isn’t as good a strategy for a Chicago mayor as it is for a presidential chief-of-staff. Not only are those opponents Democrats, too, but they’re the very Democrats whose support you need to get anything done.

1 comment

Chicago Teachers’ Strike: Day 5

It looks like today will be the last day of the strike. The CTU is presenting the “outlines of an agreement” to its delegates:

The union representing striking Chicago teachers plans to present the “outlines of an agreement” this afternoon to its House of Delegates, which could vote Sunday on whether to end the strike, the union’s lawyer says.

“We have the outlines of an agreement on the major issues, but it’s not for this (negotiating) committee to decide if we have a deal,” said CTU attorney Robert Bloch. “It’s for the membership of the union to decide that, and it’s for the House of Delegates to determine whether we’ll suspend the strike.”

The delegates are meeting at 2 p.m. today for what is expected to be an informational session on where talks stand. Bloch said the contract outlines would be discussed at the meeting, but no vote was likely today.

If the union delegates agree to call off the strike Sunday, students could be back in class on Monday.

This is proceeding very much along the lines that I suggested the other day. Make no mistake: this is sounding very much like a complete victory for the union and Chicago’s teachers. There may be some face-saving by the mayor but he’s had his head handed to him.

Unanswered is how Chicago will pay for the new contract.

2 comments

The Bulldogs All Have Rubber Teeth and the Hens Lay Soft-Boiled Eggs

If you’d like a little light reading you might want to take a look at a free flight of fancy from Christian Schneider at City Journal:

The strike could also damage support for the teachers by drawing a clear contrast between heavily unionized public schools and union-free charter schools. Currently, Chicago has nearly 100 charter schools, and 52,000 of the students in those schools will be attending classes on schedule and outperforming public school students academically. A study by the Illinois Policy Institute examined the Chicago district’s open-enrollment, non-selective high schools and found that nine of the ten top performers were charters—all while the average Chicago-area charter-school teacher earns about $49,000 per year. Charter schools, of course, are also anathema to the CTU—but by walking out on the city’s schoolchildren, the unionized teachers are only reminding parents that another option exists, one that works better at lower cost.

It’s possible, of course, that the CTU could prevail in this dispute and win valuable concessions from Emanuel. But it’s also possible—if the mayor remains strong—that Chicago’s teachers have given Illinois the shove it needs to start moving toward the Wisconsin model.

For good or ill I see no signs whatever of that happening. The political dynamics in Illinois could hardly be more different from those of Wisconsin if they were in different countries. Wisconsin is a bit like Illinois without Chicago. The Illinois legislature and governor’s mansion are dominated by Chicagoans. Wisconsin has nothing comparable to the Chicago-downstate interplay that’s central to Illinois politics. The Chicago metropolitan area has nearly two-thirds of the state’s population and produces 70% of the income. There really is no comparison.

24 comments

Where Do You Come From? Where Do You Go?

I wanted to share a little back-of-the envelope calculation with you. The Chicago Public Schools receives about 40% of its revenues from local taxes, about 31% from the state, and about 24% from the federal government. The CPS receives that much money from the state and federal government largely because so many of the children enrolled are from poor families.

The total budget for the CPS is about $6.6 billion. That means that just about $2 billion of its revenues come from the state of Illinois.

The amount that Illinois received in income taxes was about $13 billion. That was up about 32% from 2010 after an increase in the income tax rate of 66%. I don’t think that bodes particularly well for future income tax increases as a means of generating additional revenue for the state but that’s a subject for a different post.

About 20% or $2.6 billion of those state income tax revenues comes from the city of Chicago.

Here’s my point. Unless Chicago is receiving a lot of money for something else from the state, enough to offset the difference and the other funds that Chicago sends to Springfield, I don’t see a big windfall to Chicago from the state of Illinois.

2 comments

Chicago Teachers’ Strike: Day 4

I had originally planned to use a somewhat more inflammatory title for this post but decided to stick with the more neutral title above. Negotiators for the administration and teachers say that they’re making progress:

Negotiators trying to settle the Chicago teachers strike say more than 350,000 students could be back in the classroom by Friday.

“We feel like we’re in a pretty good place, we’ve made a lot of progress today,” Chicago Teachers Union President Karen Lewis said as she left contract talks shortly before midnight Wednesday. “We spent a lot of time on evaluation. We still have a lot of work to do but it seems like we’re definitely coming much closer together than we were certainly this morning.”

Lewis said parents should not bank on classes Thursday but said, “Let’s hope for Friday.”

Chicago school board president David Vitale agreed significant progress had been made during talks Wednesday.

“We had really good discussions and proposals on the most difficult issues that we face,” Vitale said. “We’re hopeful we can actually come together around this.

“Unfortunately they’re not going to be back to school tomorrow, and we’ll hope for Friday.”

My off-hand guess is that the differences will not have been settled by the end of the day and that the strike will go on tomorrow.

Meanwhile, a strike by teachers in suburban Lake Forest is also making the news:

For the first time in the district’s history, teachers in Lake Forest High School District 115 went on strike today after failing to reach an agreement over salaries during negotiations that ended just before midnight.

The walkout affects about 1,700 students and about 150 teachers.

The two situations, Lake Forest and Chicago, are not at all comparable. In Chicago the median household income is around $38,000. In Lake Forest the median household income is around $150,000. It’s a wealthy community. I honestly don’t know how Chicago will afford the agreement that will eventually be agreed on. Chicago’s problem is “can’t afford it”. I can only assume that property taxes will rise substantially. Lake Forest has repeatedly rejected plans to increase taxes in order to pay teachers more. There it’s a case of “don’t wanna”.

So far Chicago has avoided urban decay of the sort that has reduced Detroit or Pittsburgh to shadows of their former selves. Detroit and Pittsburgh didn’t collapse because they didn’t pay teachers enough. They collapsed because people couldn’t afford to live there any more. No jobs is one way that can happen but it’s not the only way. Just being too darned expensive is another.

I’m guessing we’re going to see a 20%-30% increase in property taxes in Chicago even as property values continue to fall. That won’t just affect homeowners but renters as well. There’s no way that incomes will rise to cover that. As to what effect that will have on the city, we’ll just need to wait to find out.

0 comments

Chicago Teachers’ Strike: Day 3

There seems to be a difference of opinion on how close the Chicago Public Schools is to arriving at an agreement with the Chicago Teachers Union.

Rahm Emanuel:

“I am disappointed that we have come to this point, given that even all the other parties acknowledge how close we are, because this is a strike of choice,” Mayor Rahm Emanuel said late Sunday. “Because of how close we are, it is a strike that is unnecessary.”

Karen Lewis (head of CTU):

“To say that the contract will be settled today is lunacy,” union president Karen Lewis told the cheering crowd of teachers, whom she addressed as “brothers and sisters.”

and

“The Chicago Teachers Union has 49 Articles in its contract (and) to date we have only signed off on six of them,” said union spokeswoman Stephanie Gadlin. “The Chicago Public Schools has made proposals to change nearly every article. It is not accurate to say both sides are extremely close. This is misinformation on behalf of the board and Mayor Emanuel. We have a considerable way to go. This is a fact they cannot deny.”

If anything, it sounds to me like the two parties are farther apart than ever:

With more than 350,000 children from kindergarten to high school age out of school, the patience of parents and labor negotiators began to fray as hopes of a quick resolution to the biggest U.S. labor strike in a year were dashed.

“There’s frustration on both sides,” Jesse Ruiz, vice president of the Chicago Board of Education, said on Wednesday. “There’s got to be give and take.”

Talks are scheduled to resume on Wednesday. Emanuel on Sunday called the strike “unnecessary” and said a deal was close. But fiery union president Karen Lewis, who has called Emanuel a “liar and a bully,” on Tuesday said the two sides had agreed on only six of 49 provisions of a new contract.

An exasperated Chicago School Board President David Vitale said he would not go back to the negotiating table until the union made a comprehensive proposal to resolve the strike.

I don’t usually see name-calling as a sign of progress.

As I said yesterday, I am increasingly seeing the dispute as being an interpersonal conflict—Rahm Emanuel vs. Karen Lewis. I don’t think that they like or respect one another.

I’m beginning to wonder about the underlying story in all of this. One explanation I’ve heard for the dispute is that Rahm Emanuel has been deputized by the national Democratic Party to forge a new dynamics in the relationships between public employees’ unions and big city governments. As evidence for this see stories of how the dispute is being widely scrutinized by public officials in surrounding cities, states, and all over the country. They’re not hard to find.

I don’t believe that explanation. I think that Emanuel is eager to carve out a name for himself and picked the negotiations with the CTU as his target. Unfortunately, he’s got a lot of other things, many not related to Chicago, on his plate and he does not seem to be a small print kind of guy. This is a small print kind of situation.

Well, fortunately for Rahm Emanuel he’s got quite a long time until the next mayoral election and there’s, essentially, no way for Chicago to get rid of him before then by which time, with his luck, Chicagoans will have forgotten all about it. Maybe he’ll be ready to run for president by then.

7 comments

People, Wealth, and Taxes in Illinois

I plan to post another update on the ongoing Chicago teacher’s strike but I’m a bit rushed for time this morning. To tide you over I thought I’d post the very interesting graphic I stumbled across last night. There’s a widespread folk belief in Illinois that Chicago doesn’t pay its own freight. I think this graphic might illustrate the reality a little better.

I don’t have ready figures for how much the Chicago Public Schools receives from the state. As I’ve previously posted Illinois is dead last among the states in its percentage of funding for public education at 18%.

My view: Chicago pays the state plenty in taxes. Is the state treating Chicago fairly?

There’s a great irony in all of this. Right now Springfield is solidly in the hands of Chicago pols. If Chicago isn’t being treated fairly by Springfield, I wonder what the state legislature’s priorities actually are?

13 comments

Update on Chicago Teacher Salaries

Dylan Matthews over at The Washington Post has done some digging and come up with better figures than I was able to on what Chicago teachers earn. I’m going to take the liberty of quoting a larger snippet than would normally be my practice:

Luckily, we don’t have to guess, since CPS publishes median salary statistics (see page 198 in this pdf). As is often the case with stats like these, the median salary is below the mean: for the 2010-11 school year, the most recent year for which data is available, the median salary was $67,974, as opposed to the mean of $74,236 that year (as reported, pdf, by the Illinois State Board of Education). That mean is slightly different than the one reported by CPS because it relies on more recent ISBE data.

Some of that salary has to go to pension contributions. Teachers are required to contribute 9 percent of their salary to their pensions, and support personnel must contribute 8.5 percent, as opposed to 6.2 percent if they were part of the Social Security system. But the Chicago Public Schools system pays for 7 percent of the employee contribution. So the more relevant comparison is a 1.5 to 2 percent contribution for CPS employees compared to 6.2 percent for private sector workers paying Social Security tax. So the median after-pension income is $66,614, which a private sector employee on Social Security would need to earn $71,017 a year to make. So a median of $71,017 (or a mean of $77,560) is the most relevant number for comparing Chicago public school teachers to other workers.

What about the longer school day that Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel is implementing? The school day is increasing from five hours and forty-five minutes for elementary school and seven hours for high school, to seven and seven and a half hours, respectively. Isn’t an increase in hours of that scale effectively a wage cut, in per-hour terms?

Not a big one. Under a deal reached by Emanuel and the Chicago Teachers’ Union in July, almost 500 new teachers will be hired to enable the new schedule, and while high school teachers will have to work another 14 minutes every day, elementary and middle school teachers’ hours won’t change at all. So the overall effect on per-worker hours is minimal.

None of this is to say anything about whether the average teacher’s salary is at the right level. It’s just to say that a fair read of the numbers suggests that $71,017 is a much more accurate estimate of what a typical Chicago public school teacher makes than $56,720.

Based on a lower median wage than I had previously found quoted, I can say with confidence that my previous calculation of half of Chicago teachers being in the top 10% of income earners residing in the city of Chicago was not correct.

However, the balance of my point remains. Chicago only has two means of raising revenues: property taxes and sales taxes. Both are regressive. Chicago already has the highest sales tax of any major city in the United States. The last time the sales tax rate was increased revenues did not increase by the amount of the increase in the tax (as I had predicted) due to lost sales.

Chicago’s only remaining practical recourse is to increase the property tax. Even without an increase in teacher salaries the CPS is already in the red by at least $600 million and, all other things being equal, will be in the red by another $1 billion. That’s going to fall pretty heavily on people on a fixed income.

Update to the Update

According to the NEA Illinois ranks dead last among the states in the percentage of public school revenues that come from the state—a measly 18%. That’s why I keep harping on what increases mean to Chicagoans. Chicagoans carry nearly all of the freight for CPS. That’s dramatically different from New York, Texas, or California. The situations are simply not comparable.

Chicagoans are responsible for paying the pensions of retired CPS teachers, too. Chicago is the only city in the state for which that’s the case.

3 comments

Yes, It Can Happen Again

I’ve struggled with myself all day over whether to write a post that at least acknowledges the attacks on September 11, 2001. This will be brief: no “where were you when…”, etc. It may be a bit brutal.

Since the attacks we’ve killed a lot of people, had a lot of our own killed, and spent a lot of money. What we haven’t done is interrupted the critical success factors that lead to the original attack.

Any activity has critical success factors. Those are the factors or activities that make it possible for an organization or operation to accomplish its mission.

We’ve accomplished a few things. We’ve hardened jet cockpits. We’ve driven Al Qaeda from its stronghold in Afghanistan. I don’t happen to think that stronghold was a critical success factor for the attacks. They now have a stronghold in Pakistan. We’ve killed a lot of Al Qaeda leaders including Osama Bin Laden. I don’t think they were critical success factors, either. I believe that reasonable people can differ on that.

We’ve made counter-terrorism a more attractive career choice for people in the FBI. As far as I can tell that’s resulted in “sting” operations that haven’t actually done a great deal to make us more secure. The experts say that we’ll never know about the real successes, only the failures. They would say that, wouldn’t they?

So, yes, it can happen again.

37 comments