Unfair Trade

Another random observation. The underlying problem with our foreign trade isn’t whether or how much other countries subsidize their exporters. It’s that we finance our government by selling bonds. There are multiple ways of not doing that but as long as we continue doing it we’re going to have a trade imbalance whether other countries subsidize their exports or not.

4 comments

Intervening

One of the things that I think is missed in the discussion of foreign policy is that whether you’re bombing another country, sending in flocks of Christian missionaries, or dispatching crowds of volunteers to foster educating women and birth control, you’re still intervening. In some ways the last of my examples might be harder to for the people of other countries to tolerate than being bombed from the air.

4 comments

It’s Not Poverty, Either

In his column today Eugene Robinson says we should stop blaming teachers and start blaming poverty:

It is true that teachers in Chicago have dug in their heels against Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s demands for “reform,” some of which are not unreasonable. I’d dig in, too, if I were constantly being lectured by self-righteous crusaders whose knowledge of the inner-city schools crisis comes from a Hollywood movie.

The problems that afflict public education go far beyond what George W. Bush memorably called “the soft bigotry of low expectations.” They go beyond whatever measure of institutional sclerosis may be attributed to tenure, beyond the inevitable cases of burnout, beyond the fact that teachers in some jurisdictions actually earn halfway decent salaries.

The fact is that teachers are being saddled with absurdly high expectations. Some studies have shown a correlation between student performance and teacher “effectiveness,” depending how this elusive quality is measured. But there is a whole body of academic literature proving the stronger correlation between student performance and a much more important variable: family income.

Yes, I’m talking about poverty. Sorry to be so gauche, but when teachers point out the relationship between income and achievement, they’re not shirking responsibility. They’re just stating an inconvenient truth.

According to figures compiled by the College Board, students from families making more than $200,000 score more than 300 points higher on the SAT, on average, than students from families making less than $20,000 a year. There is, in fact, a clear relationship all the way along the scale: Each increment in higher family income translates into points on the test.

Unfortunately, that’s circular logic. The emphasis on the importance of test scores in measuring teacher performance is an assertion about the effectiveness of their influence on cognitive development. The SATs are one measure of cognitive development but they’re not the only measure. The reason that cognitive development is being emphasized is that it’s relatively easy to measure.

There’s more than one developmental domain. There are, in fact, several: physical, cognitive, social, and emotional. Languge is another developmental domain. Of these the most important determinants of future success are the social and emotional domains. The SATs or math and reading achievement tests are not particularly good predictors for how well one will do in life.

And the most important factor in social and emotional development isn’t what you learn in school or how much money your family had or even how much education your parents had. It’s good parenting. Economist James Heckman has been studying this for years. Here’s a brief summary from a recent paper of his:

The returns to early childhood programs are the highest for disadvantaged children who do not receive substantial amounts of parental investment in the early years. The proper measure of disadvantage is not necessarily family poverty or parental education. The available evidence suggests that the quality of parenting is the important scarce resource. The quality of parenting is not always closely linked to family income or parental education. Measures of risky family environments should be developed that facilitate efficient targeting.

The emphasis is mine.

The reason we should be focusing our attentions on early intervention programs that target the development of non-cognitive skills (like, for example, the ability to defer gratification—a skill closely aligned with future success) is that the return on investment is so good. It’s about 10%.

Compare that with the very low return on investment in public job training programs, adult literacy services, prisoner rehabilitation programs, and education programs for disadvantaged adults, programs with an ROI that is notoriously low.

Note that these findings do not support Mr. Robinson’s claim but they do not support the Chicago Teachers Union’s claims, either. There is a finite amount of money. The more that is thrown away supporting the development of cognitive skills for kids who come to school without the social or emotional development that’s necessary to prepare them for learning, the less there is available for doing that preparation.

39 comments

Chicago Teachers’ Strike: Nervous

Will the delegates of the Chicago Teachers Union vote to end the strike today?

Chicago teachers were anxious this morning as they walked the picket line for the seventh day, worried whether union officials will decide today to call off the strike that has kept 350,000 students out of the classroom.

“I’m hoping the delegates come to their senses and know that our kids need us,” Mary Silva, a CPS social worker, said outside school headquarters.

The Chicago Teachers Union’s House of Delegates is to meet at 3 p.m. to go over a tentative contract reached during marathon negotiations last week. It could decide to end the strike while a ratification vote is taken among teachers in the next few weeks.

I think it’s pretty likely that they will and an editorial in the Washington Post explains why:

“THEY WANT TO know if there is anything more they can get.” That astonishing statement by the head of the Chicago Teachers Union tells you all you need to know about the reason for the continued strike of the city’s public schools. The no-end-in-sight teacher walkout is not about getting schools air-conditioned or lowering class size or any of the other platitudes that have been voiced at teacher rallies about wanting to improve education. It’s about the union thinking it can get “more” — and so what if the interests of tens of thousands of children are hurt in the process?

They’ve flexed their muscles. They’ve put Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel in his place. So far they’ve enjoyed a certain amount of public support. That support is unlikely to grow as the days of the strike increase.

1 comment

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

2 comments

Wrong Again

Well, I was wrong. Again. Based on the RealClearPolitics average of polls President Obama is up three points over Gov. Romney. That’s nearly the opposite of what I’d predicted (small bump for Romney, none for Obama). Other than Rasmussen which tends to be an outlier none of the major polls shows Romney ahead.

I’m still trying to puzzle it out. I don’t think it’s possible for anyone to have suddenly made up their minds about the president. If anything, he’s over-exposed. It may be that the more voters see of Mitt Romney the less they like him.

It also could be due to more strategic factors. The Obama Campaign has been advertising heavily throughout the conventions and in their immediate aftermath. The Romney Campaign has quite a fund-raising advantage over its opponents so I presume we will very shortly seen an enormous deluge of pro-Romney or anti-Obama television spots (particularly if “we” is defined as people living in the handful of battleground states, e.g. Ohio, Virginia, Colorado, etc.)

I wonder what they’re waiting for. Obviously, these are tactical decisions on the parts of the respective campaigns but at this juncture it really doesn’t look like the Romney Campaign’s gamble is paying off.

74 comments

The Limit

Just in case I haven’t made my views clear, I don’t think the Chicago Public Schools has the dough to pay for what it’s already agreed to and under Illinois it doesn’t have the authority to raise revenues as fast as it must to get into the black. The CPS is required by law to run a balanced budget. To do that it will need to appeal to the state of Illinois, either for more money or the power to raise taxes faster or both. Whatever the state may do, I strongly suspect that the matter will end up in and ultimately be decided by the courts.

If the Illinois Republican Party had a lick of sense, this whole mess would become a major campaign issue here. Not a “hate Chicago” issue or even a “hate unions” issue but a matter of government being required to act within its limits as defined under the law.

Fortunately for Illinois Democrats the Illinois Republican Party went off the rails years ago.

1 comment

Chicago Teachers’ Strike Enters Second Week

The strike by Chicago teachers has entered its second week. Mayor Rahm Emanuel says he’s taking the Chicago Teachers Union to court to end what he’s now characterizing as an “illegal strike”:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel is threatening to go to court today to end the Chicago teachers strike after union delegates decided to extend the walkout at least two more days while they review a tenative deal.

Emanuel called the walkout “illegal” and pledged late Sunday to seek an injunction in court to force an end to the city’s first teachers strike in a quarter century leaders and return more than 350,000 students to the classroom.

Delegates had met with Chicago Teachers Union president Karen Lewis for nearly three hours Sunday to review a tentative contract that had been brokered after months of negotiation, but decided to extend the strike.

“They’re not happy with the agreement. They’d like it to be a lot better for us than it is,” Lewis said. “This is the deal we got. This is not a good deal by any stretch of the imagination, not (compared) to what our members are (used) to having.”

Both of Chicago’s major newspapers have editorialized against the teachers continuing their strike.

Chicago Tribune:

In an earlier news conference, a grim Lewis ticked off a long list of concerns that her members mentioned about the contract. She said “the big elephant in the room” is CPS’ plans to close upwards of what she said could be 200 schools. Teachers are “extraordinarily concerned about that,” she told reporters. “It undergirds everything they talked about” in the House of Delegates meeting.

Yes, CPS could be looking at closing and consolidating schools. The real elephant in the room: CPS is exhausting its reserve funds this year and faces an estimated $1 billion budget deficit next year with a massive pension payment hike.

And yet CPS is promising to hire more teachers and spend more money on salaries in this contract. CPS says that if the contract runs four years, the district will spend $295 million to hire new teachers and give all teachers guaranteed raises. That is money the district doesn’t have. The front page of Sunday’s Tribune neatly summarized the district’s financial straits in a single sentence: Since 2001, the district has seen its net assets plummet from $1.2 billion to negative $1.2 billion, a decrease of 200 percent.

As difficult as this contract negotiation has been, much more difficult work lies ahead to keep Chicago’s schools operating. That’s going to require the cooperation of teachers, parents and school administrators.

Teachers, it’s time to go back to work.

Chicago Sun-Times:

The board signed on to a big raise and still must figure out how to pay for it. But the cost is worth it to honor teachers. CPS is already in a deep fiscal hole; this just digs it in a little deeper. The raise puts that much more pressure on the board to rein in spending, including moving ahead with painful school closures and dramatic pension cost cuts.

Teachers, take a day if you must. Then grab this deal while you still have it.

The Wall Street Journal notes that the CTU doesn’t seem to be content with success:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel did win a longer school day—to seven hours from five hours and 45 minutes. But the city had already agreed to a union demand to hire 500 additional new teachers to help fill the longer school day, and the average teacher will work a mere 15-20 minutes more per day.

The district also won more autonomy for principals to hire teachers, though they will have to first interview from the pool of union teachers laid-off at public schools.

Teachers won big, however, on what they really care about (other than money), which is limiting the degree to which student test scores count in teacher evaluations. Student performance will count for only 25% starting this year, moving up over the next two years to 35%. This leaves the rest of the evaluation to the kind of subjective judgment that has long kept the worst teachers firmly in place.

The union nixed merit pay—everyone has to move in lock-step, you know—and teachers that do somehow get a ranking of “needs improvement” suffer no consequence in the first year. After a repeat of that ranking, they move into a category of “unsatisfactory,” which means they get 90 days of remediation to shape up. If they don’t, they are then put on a path to dismissal, which in the past has taken from two to five years but which Chicago Board of Education President David Vitale says will now take about nine months.

The bottom line on this whole thing is that the teachers have received a whopping raise—no cost of living increase but one substantially beyond the local increases in prices and kept teacher evaluations within the limits required by the state of Illinois. An additional 500 new union members will be hired while the official workday for Chicago teachers remains among the shortest in big school districts.

Here’s what I think has happened. I think that Karen Lewis got a deal with the CPS that gave her practically everything she was looking for and which she thought was about as far as the CPS would go. I further think that she was genuinely surprised that the union delegates rejected the deal or, at least, are temporizing. Months of insults and hardball on the mayor’s part have taken a toll. This is personal and the CTU is determined to let the mayor go back with as little as possible out of the deal. You voted for him, Chicago.

Will the teachers get a sweeter deal from extending the strike a few more days? Or just extract more pain?

4 comments

It’s No 1939

I’d meant to post about this earlier but better late than never, eh? Hollywood is having a terrible, horrible, no good, very bad year:

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) – The North American box office hit a slump at the weekend, with top earner “The Possession” taking in less than $10 million and what could be the gloomiest overall haul since the aftermath of the September 11, 2001, attacks on New York and Washington.

With only a couple of new releases to tempt movie fans, horror movie “The Possession” pulled in an estimated $9.5 million in the United States and Canada.

That’s the first time since 2008 that no film took $10 million or more at the domestic box office.

Early September is historically sluggish. After blockbuster releases over the summer, Hollywood studios reserve their big films for the November and December holidays.

But revenues for the three-day movie-going weekend were particularly low, with the total gross for all films expected to be $65-$68 million.

If the numbers hold when final figures come in on Monday, it could make the weekend the worst since September 21-23 2001 – two weekends after 9/11 – when revenue topped out at $59.7 million.

“It is pretty scary when the top movie comes in at only $9.5 million,” said Paul Dergarabedian, box office analyst at Hollywood.com.

“This is one of the worst-grossing weekends of the last 10 years. In the summer, single movies had opening weekends bigger than this entire weekend gross,” he added.

However, Dergarabedian said hope was on the way next week with the next installment of the “Resident Evil” horror franchise and the re-release of Disney/Pixar’s 2003 family film “Finding Nemo,” this time in 3D.

This weekend’s lows follow a mixed summer that saw blockbusters like “The Dark Knight Rises” and “The Avengers” but a number of flops that led to a 5 percent drop in summer ticket sales in North America compared to summer 2011.

But in the year to date, the domestic box office is up more than three percent in revenue compared to the same point in 2011 and currently stands at $7.7 billion, with a 2 percent increase in attendance.

Up 3% is “no growth”. The big blockbusters that have provided that much revenue are getting more expensive every year. Last year’s champ, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 cost an estimated $125 million to make. This year’s box office king, Marvel’s The Avengers came in at nearly twice that at $220 million. The studio will make pots of money on it since the gross receipts are an astonishing $1.5 billion but the ROI isn’t as good and without The Avengers things would look even worse for already than they already do.

According to Box Office Mojo the top 10 grossing films of 2012 so are are:

  1. Marvel’s The Avengers
  2. The Dark Knight Rises
  3. The Hunger Games
  4. The Amazing Spider-Man
  5. Brave
  6. Ted
  7. Madagascar 3: Europe’s Most Wanted
  8. Dr. Seuss’ The Lorax
  9. MIB 3
  10. Ice Age: Continental Drift

or, said another way, they’re all based on comic books, toys, dystopian futures, fairy tales, or are animated cartoons. Or some combination. And half of them are sequels or reboots. It’s not exactly 1939.

2 comments

Headline of the Day

I don’t think I ever thought I’d see these words strung together. From Discovery News:

Alien Snakes Help Spiders Overrun Guam

The article is actually a fairly interesting one. Non-native snakes have destroyed the native bird population and, since birds are the primary predators of spiders as well as competing with them for prey, the spider population on Guam has increased sharply.

2 comments