We’re coming down to the stretch in this presidential election (finally!) and by my reckoning the number of newspapers, magazines, and other publications endorsing Barack Obama’s re-election is 118 while the number endorsing Mitt Romney’s election is 105. The number of publications who’ve switched sides, i.e. that endorsed Obama in 2008 but are endorsing Romney now or that endorsed McCain in 2008 but are endorsing Obama now, are continuing to run 5:1 in Romney’s favor.
This is very clearly a different election than 2008. I continue to think that the advantage is with Obama but, truly, anything can happen. I don’t honestly see where those who are absolutely positive that Obama will win or absolutely positive that Romney will win are getting their confidence.
My gut-level feeling is that Americans are preparing to cast their votes for the status quo, Republicans in control of the House and Democrats in control of the Senate and White House. Like the Bourbons they have learned nothing and forgotten nothing.
Let me cut right to the chase: we hated the production of Simon Boccanegra (costumes, sets, and staging). We loved everything else: the story, the music, the singing, and, above all, the acting.
Last night we went to the joint Covent Garden-Lyric Opera production of Verdi’s 1856 open, Simon Boccanegra, the first production off our 2012-2013 Lyric Opera season. We were stunned to see so many empty seats in the orchestra section—at least one-third. I can’t imagine that so many people come in from the East Coast. Has Lyric really lost that many subscribers? Are Lyric goers so uninterested in any Italian opera other than Aida, La Traviata, La Boheme, Tosca, and Madama Butterfly?
The last time we heard Simon Boccanegra at Lyric was in 1995. I may have heard it in 1979—if so, I have no recollection of it. Those are gaps of 17 years and 16 years, respectively. Lyric is not exactly over-producing Boccanegra. The work is musically and dramatically sophisticated. Indeed, in many ways it’s more like a 20th century opera than nearly anything else written by Verdi.
It’s a prose work rather than a verse one. It has very few arias and, indeed, few set pieces of any kind. The duets, trios, and other ensemble sections are structured as dialogues, essential to the drama. The first act, for example, is composed of a soprano opera, duets for soprano and bass, soprano and tenor, soprano and baritone, and an ensemble piece. While not the continuous melody of Wagner and very clearly lyrical in nature, one does not exactly go out humming the themes.
Why did this production have such large, bare, drab sets? Vertical lines created artificial perspective but on the largely bare sets what purpose did they serve? Why was nearly everyone wearing muumuus? Why ensure that the soprano wears dresses that fade into the background?
Why, oh why, does Lyric have such clumsy crowd scenes? The mass of the chorus rushes on to the set, stands there, and sings. Why were women in the chorus brandishing swords? Between the swords and the shapeless dresses I was reminded a bit of the Two of Swords in the Rider-Waite tarot deck.
What the production lack was more than made up by the music—the music itself, the singing, and the orchestra. Sir Andrew Davis has never struck a better balance between orchestra and voices at Lyric. of the excellent principles soprano Crassimira Stoyanova was clearly the standout but this was truly an ensemble production: each of the principles was wonderful. I don’t think we’ve heard Frank Lopardo any better, particularly in his duets with Stoyanova—a beautiful, perfect blend.
I don’t know that I have the words for Thomas Hampson’s magisterial performance as Simon. It was a near-perfect example of the work of a great singing actor. His ability to adapt his voice from young “corsair” to older statesman to man taking his last breaths was remarkable to behold.
There are still two performances left. It’s likely to be fifteen years or more before Lyric gets another Simon Boccanegra. If Lyric is still around in 15 years.
The best advice for subscribers heading to the Civic Opera House between now and Nov. 9 is to ignore “Boccanegra’s” flaws and simply give themselves over to the magnificence of the work’s greatest scenes (which contain some of the mature Verdi’s finest dramatic music), along with the strong singing to be heard in Lyric’s revival of Elijah Moshinsky’s production.
Lyric has always harbored an unusual fondness for the work, having presented it on six separate occasions over its 58-year history, during which Tito Gobbi, Piero Cappuccilli and Sherrill Milnes have set their stamp on the troubled Doge of Genoa.
In the latest revival, the vocal strengths are well distributed from top to bottom of a cast that includes American baritone Thomas Hampson as Boccanegra, the superb Italian bass Ferruccio Furlanetto as his rival, Jacopo Fiesco, and the exciting Bulgarian soprano Krassimira Stoyanova as his daughter, Amelia Grimaldi, in her Lyric debut.
Chicago producers and audiences love this otherwise too little heard work. Although this is Lyric’s first staging in 17 years, it’s the company’s seventh outing with this opera, which tells of an early Renaissance pirate turned Doge of Genoa, guilt-ridden by his checkered love life and parental irresponsibility. Since 1959, Tito Gobbi took the title role for three runs (and even directed), and Piero Cappuccilli, Sherrill Milnes and Alexandre Agache followed, with such other renowned singers as Richard Tucker, Renata Tebaldi, Ruggerio Raimondi, Martina Arroyo and Kiri Te Kanawa taking other key parts here.
This time, it’s Thomas Hampson’s turn. At 57, the American baritone is at the height of his acting and characterization powers, even if an unannounced indisposition Monday limited some of his high notes and caused vocal strain at times. This is a dark and inward work, introduced in Venice in 1857 to puzzled response and successfully reworked by Verdi almost a quarter-century later, for La Scala in 1881. At every moment, Hampson makes it clear this is a man struggling with the questions of morality, leadership, aging, service and heartache.
The remarkable Italian bass Ferruccio Furlanetto is Fiesco, Boccanegra’s sworn enemy, the father of the Doge’s dead and disgraced lover, and grandfather of his lost child. Now 63, Furlanetto had to wait until last season to make his Lyric debut, as a highly praised Boris Godunov. Furlanetto alone invests so much humanity into his part — not to mention strength and warmth throughout its wide range — that the idea that Verdi is only about blood vengeance is pushed far out of mind. Furlanetto’s performance as he handles the old man’s many changing moods and encounters is like a great master class.
Muti introduced Bulgarian soprano Krassimira Stoyanova to Chicago in his remarkable CSO “Otello†two seasons back. As Maria/Amelia, Stoyanova was vocally admirable at every turn but lacked the theatrical abilities of her male elders. American tenor Frank Lopardo gave one of his finest Lyric performances as Adorno, Amelia’s suitor, and Simon’s eventual ally and successor.
A bigger breakout came from former Ryan Center baritone Quinn Kelsey as Paolo, the courtier who is so purely bad that even he seems puzzled as to why. Kelsey’s voice, color and phrasing were clear, dark and exciting. Furlanetto told Opera News recently that Kelsey could become the Verdi baritone we’ve been waiting for for years. Current Ryan members bass Evan Boyer, tenor Bernard Holcomb and mezzo J’nai Bridges acquitted themselves admirably, as did the Lyric Chorus under its new chorus master Martin Wright, whose direction toward subtlety matched that of the singers in their many ensembles.
Music director Andrew Davis had his best evening in the Italian repertoire that I’ve heard, and in a work without big, known “numbers,†the orchestra and its depiction of mood and coastal geography is key. Director Elijah Moshinsky was at his best here, too, staging as if we are witnesses to an actual human drama. Michael Yeargan’s Covent Garden sets, almost historic by now, appear to have been buffed back into freshness, as have Peter J. Hall’s period costumes, out of a Genovese painting. Duane Schuler’s lighting, re-created by Jason Brown, made darkness illuminating.
This is Verdi for the ages. So leave prejudices and questions at home and turn yourself over to a chapter in the story of music.
Mr. Patner’s reaction to the production is closer to mine than Mr. Von Rhein’s.
Here’s another of the several referenda on which the voters of my area will be voting on Tuesday:
Shall there be established, pursuant to the Community Mental Health Services Act (405 ILCS 22), to serve the territory commonly described on this ballot or notice of this question, a North River Expanded Mental Health Services Program, to provide direct free mental health services for any resident of the territory who needs assistance in overcoming or coping with mental or emotional disorders, where such program will be funded through an increase of not more than .004 of the real estate property tax bill of all parcels within the boundaries of the territory (for example, $4 of every $1,000 you currently pay)?”
This is another example of a measure in which the precise wording of the actual final measure makes all of the difference between getting my support or not. For example, would the NREMHSP refuse services for non-residents? If it did not, would the city reimburse the taxpayers of the territory for the cost of the services provided? My concern is that my area would find itself financing mental health services for the entire city of Chicago. I’m also concerned about the possibility that my area would become a magnet for mentally ill persons from all across the city. I presume that’s not the intention but if some areas approve of such a measure while others don’t that could be the upshot.
My concern is heightened by the phrase “direct free mental health, etc.”. I presume “free of charge to those receiving the services” is meant rather than actually free services, presumably donated by mental health professionals. As it stands, it’s sloppy diction. Advocacy posing as legislation.
Bottom line: I think this measure needs to be something city-wide unless the services provided are limited by residency, something I’m skeptical of actually taking place.
Yesterday evening my wife asked my opinion of the several referenda we’ll be voting on in the election next Tuesday. I did so and thought I might do so here as well. Here’s one of them:
“Shall the U. S. Congress pass a bill, to be duly ratified by three-fourths of the states, adopting an amendment to the U. S. Constitution empowering the federal government and states to regulate and limit political contributions from corporations?”
As stated I would oppose such an amendment but a great deal depends on the specific wording of the proposed amendment. If it were structured so as to empower the federal government and the states to regulate and limit political contributions from all group entities not limited to corporations but including partnerships, labor unions, not-for-profit organizations not organized as corporations, and all other similar organizations other than individual living, breathing, human beings, I would favor it.
Note that if you look at a list of the hundred largest contributors to political campaigns and politics, generally, labor unions and not-for-profit organizations are among the very largest contributors. Considering the symbiotic relationship between those organizations and government at various different levels, I find that troubling. I do not generally believe that tax dollars should be recycled into political contributions unless it is done on an even-handed basis without regard to affiliation. Otherwise it is a license to steal.
The map on the left above depicts the 2008 electoral vote distribution by state. The cartogram on the right resizes areas to correspond to population and depicts the county-by-county results of the 2008 election. Different, aren’t they? I think they form a nice illustration of the point that I was making in my “There Are No Red States. There Are No Blue States” post of last week. The image is sampled from a very interesting post at Reason.com.
The sharp edges of the map on the left are artifacts accompanied by a loss of precision. The cartogram is a more precise reflection of the reality of American politics but it isn’t precise, either. Real opinion is much more diverse and much more broadly distributed across the country than even the swirls of the cartogram reflect.
Did history begin in 2008? Why not take 2004 or 2000 as our benchmark? Here’s Robert Vanderbei’s animated graphic of presidential election results by county from 1960 to 2004:
You can click on the image for a larger version.
If there is an inexorable flow in human affairs, it is not discernable in the short term.
The Washington Post takes note of an interesting statistic. According to a recent poll three-quarters of Americans strongly favor or strongly oppose President Obama:
According to a new poll from National Public Radio, three-fourths of Americans feel either “strongly favorable†toward President Obama (37 percent) or “strongly unfavorable†(39 percent). And the rest of the men on the two major parties’ presidential tickets aren’t far behind, with 64 percent feeling strongly favorable or strongly unfavorable toward both Mitt Romney and Vice President Biden and 62 percent feeling strongly about Paul Ryan.
That mirrors what I’ve seen in the American political blogosphere. Increasingly, the conversation has been dominated by Left Bolsheviks on the one hand and Right Bolsheviks on the other. Neither side talks with the other and there’s only a tiny, embattled middle ground.
Meanwhile, I can only think of Plato’s observation that moderation is the singular quality most essential to a republic.
Why do the results of the national opinion polls on presidential candidate preference differ from the results of the state-by-state polls? That’s the question Sean Trende addresses in a recent RCP post which I commend to your attention. The national polls indicate a slight advantage for Romney in the popular vote while the state-by-state polls indicate a slight but statistically significant advantage for Obama.
Using a variety of approaches Mr. Trende attempts to square the circle. Here’s his conclusion:
How do we resolve this? Which will be correct? My best answer is “I don’t know; it is a source of uncertainty in projecting the election.†I suspect one group of polls will converge upon the other in the next week, and we’ll get a better idea.
Historically, the national polls have actually been more accurate than the state-by-state polls. Next Tuesday we may know.
My guess at this point is that Romney will win the popular vote while Obama takes the electoral vote and, consequently, is re-elected. But it’s no more than a guess. It’s just too close to call. I just don’t believe the folks who are predicting a Romney landslide or an Obama electoral landslide and there are both.
There are several problems with that prediction. Among them are that no president has ever won re-election with the economic trends—not just the raw statistics but the trends—as weak as they are now. Presidents re-elected with high unemployment rates had unemployment rates that were notably trending in the right direction. Another is that there is a general tendency for presidents to be re-elected with larger numbers of electoral votes than they had the last time around. If they get smaller number of electoral votes than they did when first elected, they tend to be defeated.
There’s a campaign spot for President Obama’s re-election, narrated by actor Morgan Freeman, that’s getting quite a bit air time here which, frankly, makes me queasy. Here’s the section I’m talking about:
Every president inherits challenges. Few have faced so many. Four years later, our enemies have been brought to justice, our heroes are coming home, assembly lines are humming again. There are still challenges to meet: children to educate, a middle class to rebuild. But the last thing we should do is turn back now.
The part I question is “our enemies have been brought to justice”. The details that have emerged of the killing of Osama bin Laden have suggested that of the five individuals killed in the operation only one was armed and it wasn’t Osama bin Laden. Essentially, bin Laden was assassinated.
I can see how one could argue that it was expedient or operationally necessary or politically necessary or that he deserved it or that bad things happen in war or that revenge feels good. I have difficulty in seeing it as justice. Compare that with the arrest of Hermann Goering:
I took my sedan, a jeep with my aide-de-camp, Captain Harry Bond, and a half-platoon of our Division Reconnaisance Troop in their jeeps and reconnaisance cars. Colonel von Brauschitz led the way in his German touring car. We passed through the American Lines near Kitzbuhel and very shortly ran into German road blocks and sentries. When von Brauschitz explained the situation, they made no difficulty and we continued on, over the Pass of Thum and down into the valley of Brucht, perhaps 25 miles.
Near this small village, there was a gateway to a driveway leading up to a modest country estate. On arrival at the house, we were met by Waffen S.S. officers, a Colonel and a Major; one looked like a gangster and the other like a pervert. The manor was occupied by the remains of the Florian Geyer S.S. Division which had been badly mauled in Russia. It was here for rest, recuperation and replacement. The S.S. Colonel was Chief of Staff of this division; it’s generals were probably on leave. But no Goering.
When von Brauschitz asked about Goering, the S.S. Colonel said he knew nothing of his whereabouts.
When von Brauschitz explained our purpose was to accept Goering’s surrender, the Colonel said he knew nothing of any surrender plans and certainly his division was not going to capitulate. Their discussion was becoming heated when I told my Sergeant-Interpreter to interrupt them, tell them I wanted to bottle of wine right now, and some lunch as soon as it could be prepared.
Speaking German, I had understood their argument and I know the best way to handle Germans is to get “tough” with them; — give them orders, make demands on them. The wine was brought by an orderly and the S.S. Colonel departed to see about lunch. Von Brauschitz found some telephones and began trying to locate Goering. We had lunch and hours went by but the German telephone system was in such bad shape that he was unable to contact Goering.
Finally, about 5.00 P.M., I became exasperated and asked him if he knew where Goering might be, or his intended route. He said “Yes”, so we started on the probable route. I left the half-platoon of the 36th Reconnaisance Troop at the manor and took only my aide’s jeep and my sedan. Von Brauschitz rode with me as his German touring car had “conked out”. We drove southeast over another mountain pass down into Radstaat, (probably). Here we found hundreds of Allied Prisoners of War whose guards had left them. I told them to stay put, that United States troops would be there in two days. I also told them I would be returning a little later with a German convoy and that they must not touch these Germans or the vehicles as they were mine.
We drove on another 5 miles or so through many German troops bivouacked alongside but off the road. We finally came to a detachment of about 25 vehicles, halted on the road and facing in the direction from which we were coming. This was Goering’s personal convoy. He had with him his wife, his sister-in-law, his daughter, General von Epp, (the Gauleiter of Bavaria), his chef, valet, butler, aides, headquarters commandant, guards, etc, — altogether about 75 persons.
He and I got out of our vehicles and von Brauschitz introduced us. Goering gave me the old German Army salute, not the “Heil Hitler,” and I returned it. I asked him if he wished to surrender unconditionally and he said “Yes” but that he would request my promise that his family would be brought inside the American lines. I hoped we would all get back inside United States lines so I agreed. We talked through my Sergeant-Interpreter although Goering said he spoke English but that he had not had much practice in the last five years. He did not wish to speak English as he might misunderstand or be misunderstood. His wife was crying so he comforted her saying everything was all right now as this was an American General.
On Sept. 11, 1945, nine days after Japanese officials surrendered, Gen. Douglas MacArthur ordered Tojo’s arrest. He had gone into seclusion, but proved easy to find for then-25-year-old Lt. Wilpers and the rest of the small Army counterintelligence detail sent to arrest him: American newsmen had picked up Tojo’s trail and were already camped outside his house in suburban Tokyo.
“The best way of finding Tojo was to find our own U.S. newspaper people, because they were there well ahead of us,” Wilpers recalled.
Through an interpreter, Tojo was told he was being taken into custody by the Americans. After appearing at a window, Tojo ducked back inside. Soon after, a gunshot was heard. Wilpers kicked open the door to Tojo’s room and found him lying on a small couch, blood splattered on his white shirt and a pistol still clutched in his right hand.
“I was trying to keep one eye on him and one on the pistol,” Wilpers said.
He had tried to shoot himself in the heart, but only managed a severe wound. Reporters piled into the small room behind Wilpers and photographers began snapping pictures. One of the best-known photos, taken by a correspondent for Yank magazine, shows a uniformed Wilpers aiming his sidearm at the wounded Tojo as he picks up the man’s gun with his other hand.
News accounts reported that Tojo’s house staff and a Japanese doctor summoned to the home apparently were inclined to let him die from the self-inflicted gunshot. According to the reporters and photographers on the scene, that didn’t sit well with Wilpers.
“We managed, at gunpoint practically, to get a next-door neighbor to get a doctor, and he was forced to come down and treat him,” Wilpers told the AP on Friday.
An American Army doctor and medical staff eventually showed up and kept Tojo from dying.
in World War II.
Have we become so calloused, perverse, or cowardly over the period of the last 70 years that we think of what happened as justice? Clearly, our views used to be very different. The very idea taints everything in which the word is used: Justice Department, system of justice. If we were to say that we wanted Gov. Rod Blagojevich to be brought to justice does that mean that we want to see him executed without trial? What is justice?
I honestly don’t understand what the kerfuffle is over what Nate Silver has been doing at his 568 blog at the NYT. Here’s one side of the story:
On MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” today, Joe Scarborough took a more direct shot, effectively calling Silver an ideologue and “a joke.”
“Nate Silver says this is a 73.6 percent chance that the president is going to win? Nobody in that campaign thinks they have a 73 percent chance — they think they have a 50.1 percent chance of winning. And you talk to the Romney people, it’s the same thing,” Scarborough said. “Both sides understand that it is close, and it could go either way. And anybody that thinks that this race is anything but a tossup right now is such an ideologue, they should be kept away from typewriters, computers, laptops and microphones for the next 10 days, because they’re jokes.”
For those new to this, Nate is a sports statistician turned political statistician, who has been maintaining a model that takes lots and lots of polling data — most of it at the state level, which is where the presidency gets decided — and converts it into election odds. Like others doing similar exercises — Drew Linzer, Sam Wang, and Pollster — Nate’s model continued to show an Obama edge even after Denver, and has shown that edge widening over the past couple of weeks.
This could be wrong, obviously. And we’ll find out on Election Day. But the methodology has been very clear, and all the election modelers have been faithful to their models, letting the numbers fall where they may.
Yet the right — and we’re not talking about the fringe here, we’re talking about mainstream commentators and publications — has been screaming “biasâ€! They know, just know, that Nate must be cooking the books. How do they know this? Well, his results look good for Obama, so it must be a cheat. Never mind the fact that Nate tells us all exactly how he does it, and that he hasn’t changed the formula at all.
The definition of “objective” is that something is not based on feelings or opinion. Are Nate Silver’s results objective? I honestly don’t know. To the best of my knowledge he hasn’t shared the details of his model with us, just the results. That he expresses those results in numbers does not make them objective. That’s what’s been referred to as the “illusion of accuracy”.
Perhaps someone can explain it all to me. I really don’t understand.
There’s one thing I think we can have very high confidence in: one candidate or the other will be elected. There’s a 100% expectation of whoever wins winning and the other candidate losing. The result will be the result.