Who Pays for Sandy?

The political battle over who pays for the damage caused by Hurricane Sandy has begun in earnest:

Northeastern lawmakers are preparing to push Congress to approve extra spending to pay for repairing the damage wrought by Sandy, setting up a potential sideshow fight over resources as legislators return to Washington next week to consider spending cuts and tax increases to avoid the so-called fiscal cliff.

If approved, the extra federal funding would likely pay for work such as repairs to the electric grid, transportation network and housing. Congressional action isn’t urgent, since the Federal Emergency Management Agency has enough money to pay for immediate repairs.

But Washington has traditionally approved extra spending after major disasters such as the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks and Hurricane Katrina to help state and local governments recover. New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo said Thursday that the storm would add to a $1 billion hole in the state’s budget and estimated the economic cost to the region at $50 billion.

Both of New York’s U. S. senators think that Uncle Sugar should pay for 90% or even 100% of the damages:

Sen. Charles Schumer called the fallout from Hurricane Sandy a “national disaster” and called on a federal government to cover at least 90% of the costs.

“This is one of the biggest disasters to have ever struck this state and even this country,” Schumer said at an afternoon briefing with Gov. Cuomo. “The federal response has to measure that scope and be equal to that that scope.”

“We cannot cut corners. We cannot count nickels and dimes. This isn’t a New York disaster, a Connecticut disaster, a Jersey disaster. It is national disaster. It needs to be treated that way by every member of Congress, by all the members of the executive branch.”

My heart goes out to those who lost their lives or property or were injured by the hurricane. I absolutely think that New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut should receive emergency assistance from the federal government. I know it sounds Scrooge-like for me to say it but I can only think of one coherent (non-political) reason that the federal government should pick up the tab for all of the damage caused: unlike the federal government the states must balance their budgets.

The metropolitan area affected is the richest in the United States, with an aggregate GDP higher than all but a dozen or so countries. There is a tremendous difference between Hurricane Sandy and Hurricane Katrina. New York is one of the richest states in the Union; Louisiana one of the poorest. New York is the richest city in the country; New Orleans is one of the poorest. Much of the damage in New Orleans was arguably caused by the failure of levees that were the responsibility of the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers; much of the damage in New York was caused by inadequate sea walls or poorly designed and poorly maintained electrical infrastructure, solely the responsibility of New York.

If “making the rich pay their fair share” means anything at all, doesn’t it mean that rich New Yorkers should be paying for what they consume, i.e. New York? I think that the damage to New York should be paid for by a temporary increase in the New York city earnings tax.

I’m a reasonable person and open to persuasion. Can anyone make a good argument for why people living in rural Arkansas should be paying for infrastructure improvements in Manhattan? I mean an argument that doesn’t also argue that the federal government should be paying my heating bill.

Update

The largest concentration of multimillionaires, those with a net worth of $30 million dollars or more, in the United States is in the vicinity of New York. The state with the largest number of multimillionaires, not the state with the largest percentage but the largest number, is Connecticut. New Jersey is #3. New York is #11. Illinois is down at #18. New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut don’t need us to pay for improving their infrastructure. But they’d sure like us to do it. That’s how the rich stay rich, folks.

41 comments

Those Were the Days

Something written in comments took me back nearly 50 years. When I was in high school, back when other guys were forming garage bands and playing rock ‘n roll, a couple of high school chums and I had what might loosely be described as a “folk group”. Our music was an oddly eclectic mixture of traditional folk music, contemporary music in the folk style, and Mexican popular music of the 40s and 50s. Much of what we performed was stuff that had been popularized by Los Panchos, stars of the Golden Age of Mexican Cinema, as I learned many years later. All of us played guitar. We got a few paying gigs, maybe a half dozen.

One of our group was Colombian, another of Sicilian descent who spoke Spanish reasonably well. Then there was me—the only non-Latin. If you listen to the video above of Los Panchos performing Malagueña Salerosa, I sang the high descant solo line. Those were the days!

0 comments

What This Blog Is About

In a recent comment a frequent commenter characterized The Glittering Eye as being about foreign policy and economics. I think that’s a misunderstanding.

This blog is about the ideas and things that interest me. I have pretty far-reaching interests. I’m interested in the events of the day and I generally post almost obsessively on whatever I think the most important story is. In the mid-2000s I thought that was foreign policy and I posted hundreds of posts on foreign policy issues relating to Iraq, Iran, China, and any number of other countries.

Since the beginning of the Great Recession I’ve been posting a lot about business and economics. Until the passage of the PPACA (AKA “Obamacare”, a term I dislike since I see it as disrespectful of the president), I posted innumerable posts on healthcare policy.

I am much more interested in policy than politics.

My interests aren’t limited to politics. I’m interested in dogs, family history, history, movies and television, archaeology (particularly the archaeology of the Near East during the late Neolithic and early Bronze Ages—right on the edge of when language was first written), opera and music, generally, languages, cooking and food, and antique glass, pottery, and furniture, just to name a few things. I’ve posted on all of these topics at one time or another. I probably should post about some of them more frequently just for my own mental health.

22 comments

It’s Not the Country…

…it’s the politicians who got small. The Wall Street Journal says much what I would say about the election:

Mr. Obama will now have to govern the America he so relentlessly sought to divide—and without a mandate beyond the powers of the Presidency. Democrats will hold the Senate, perhaps with an additional seat or two. But Republicans held the House comfortably, so their agenda was hardly repudiated. The two sides will have to reach some compromise on the tax cliff, the spending sequester and the debt limit, but Speaker John Boehner can negotiate knowing he has as much of a mandate as the President.

I genuinely wish the best for President Obama.

We need a man as big as the country. If he’s as small as he’s been since first being elected to the presidency, it’s going to be a long four years. Blaming everything on your predecessor may have been a working strategy for a while. We’ll see how long it continues to work.

The country now is very different from the one he saw when first elected. For each American who idolizes him there’s another who despises him and very few in between. 75% of Americans either strongly approve or strongly disapprove of the president with few in between.

We now have European levels of permanent unemployment without European-style social programs. The economy has no real growth—it’s been flat for years. We’ve been at war for ten years now. There are no booming developing economies to drive the global economy. All of the flagging economies of the world want us to pick up the slack. There is no other “us” we can depend on for economic growth.

As long as economic growth remains flat, interest rates will stay near zero and as long as that persists seniors will continue to see their savings erode. Baby Boomers have seen the values of their 401Ks decline, the value of their houses collapse, their savings eaten away, and there are enough of them to maintain political significance for the foreseeable future. Medicare and Social Security will probably begin their critical meltdowns within the next four years.

I wish the president luck. He’s going to need it. We all will.

32 comments

The Post-Election Day Collapse

As is usual for me after an election day, having worked the previous day for sixteen hours, eating poorly, and hardly even taking a potty break, I’m a wreck today. Yesterday’s election in Chicago was chaos. Even more than usual. The city had decreased the number of precincts as a cost-saving move and correspondingly increased the number of registered voters per precinct. Not only did that mean that we had more to do (which was good) but neither the space in the facility nor the materials we received were really adequate for the greater number of people. There were lines albeit not huge ones but even waiting more than 10 minutes means grouchy people.

A lot of voters only vote every four years—for president. That means that lots of voters have canvass challenges, have been canvassed out, people who’ve never bothered to register show up and insist they’re registered, and all sorts of other messes to clean up.

I’m physically and emotionally exhausted. I’ll be in and out all day.

The results turned out much as I expected them to, proving that strong partisans of both stripes were kidding themselves. I’ll try to post later on the things we’ve learned this cycle. My guess is not much.

2 comments

Last Call

Larry Sabato of the Center for Politics has made his final call before the election. That’s it, above.

It’s not far from the predictions I’m on record as making other than Iowa and New Hampshire. My reasoning on New Hampshire is the high proportion of tax refugees in the state. My reasoning on Iowa is that they’re just fed up.

This is the scenario I’ve been calling “rearranging the deck chairs”. Remember: every sitting Congressman will have won his or her own election and has his or her own constituents and, if he’s re-elected, the President Obama won’t be running again.

104 comments

The Choice

Yesterday on ABC’s This Week program I heard George Will make a remark to the effect that the presidential election presented a stark choice: one candidate advocates a larger, more activist federal government and the other candidate advocates a smaller, less activist one. Would that were true! The reality is that there is little choice.

Barack Obama will never be another FDR for a very simple reason. When Roosevelt took office total government spending at all levels as a percentage of GDP was 20% or less. Now it’s 39% or more. Simply stated Obama can’t make the dramatic changes to the shape of government in the United States that Franklin Roosevelt did because there’s just no room to do it in.

I think it’s self-evident that there’s some level of government spending at which the smart money is targeted in one way or another at manipulating the government rather than real entrepeneurialism and innovation. That can be by lobbying or influencing elections or just by investing in areas of the economy that are subsidized by the government. In my view we’ve already passed that level whatever it may be and increasing government’s role will only aggravate an already deteriorating situation.

Mitt Romney is not a bit better. The federal government can pretty much be summarized as transfer payments to pay pensions, income subsidies for healthcare providers, defense spending, interest on the debt, and everything else (with “everything else” being about 10% of the whole). Gov. Romney has an MBA from Harvard. Whatever he says in stump speeches he can tell a larger segment from a smaller one and optimization must focus on where there’s something to optimize. Of course the smallest 10% might be optimized a bit but there are no big savings in that direction. Gov. Romney has already expressed his determination not to reduce defense spending and there is no realistic prospect for his reducing the other segments of the pie, certainly not in the near term and probably not ever.

I would continue this post with a detailed comparison of the two candidates’ foreign policies but it would just depress me. President Obama’s foreign policy is incoherent. When you have reached the point that the only achievable objective in a military operation is withdrawal, continuing the operation is morally bankrupt. We are at that point now and have been for some time. Gov. Romney’s foreign policy is much the same as President Obama’s except that he promises to spend more, do whatever he does more forcefully, and aggravate people who can actually do something about it rather than people who can’t.

As I say, it’s just too depressing.

17 comments

President of All the People

There’s quite a bit of outrage being flung around about this post at Politico. Charges of racism, etc. Here’s the meat of the controversy:

If President Barack Obama wins, he will be the popular choice of Hispanics, African-Americans, single women and highly educated urban whites. That’s what the polling has consistently shown in the final days of the campaign. It looks more likely than not that he will lose independents, and it’s possible he will get a lower percentage of white voters than George W. Bush got of Hispanic voters in 2000.

A broad mandate this is not.

My remarks do not address the points made in the linked article directly. They are, as is frequently my custom, a riff on those remarks.

Despite America’s being highly diverse in race, religion, and ethnic origin, the electorate remains nearly three-quarters white. The president of the United States isn’t the white people’s president or the black and Hispanic president and should not even be seen as such.

Either that or change the motto on the Great Seal from E pluribus unum to Ad victorem spolias.

2 comments

Anything Can Happen

This week Anything Can Happen Day will fall on a Tuesday. Yesterday I heard pollsters and operatives making their predictions. The predictions included an Obama electoral landslide, a Romney electoral landslide, and all points in between. It saddens me to see so many intelligent people forming an opinion and backing a justification into it but that is, indeed, frequently the nature of models. It’s astounding to me how much confidence they assign to their predictions.

I put my own half-baked prediction in this post at OTB. I’m predicting, as I have for some time, a narrow Obama victory. As I wrote in the linked post, those of us predicting an Obama victory are predicting several events highly unusual in American politics right along with it. We are predicting that a president will be re-elected with an unemployment rate above 7% and not trending downwards and we are predicting that a president will be re-elected with fewer electoral votes than he secured to win the highest office in the land in the first place. Virtually no one is predicting that President Obama will secure more than 365 electoral votes.

How so many pollsters and pundits can make predictions of highly unusual events with the level of confidence with which they are doing so baffles me. I don’t believe, as they appear to, that all these factors are isolated and I don’t believe that voters behave like particles suspended in a solution which also appears to me to be an underlying assumption of so many predictions.

I honestly have very little idea of what will happen. I barely have an instinct.

0 comments

After the Storm

If you’ve wondered why I haven’t posted anything about Hurricane Sandy and its aftermath on the East Coast, here are my thoughts. Obviously, my heart goes out to all of those who’ve lost loved ones or their homes or otherwise been injured in the storm. New York is the richest city in the richest state in the United States. I have every confidence that its public officials will be able to cope with the problems the hurricane brought with it. The impression I’ve received from the recent remarks by New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo and New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg is that they are just now coming to a realization of the full scope of damage their state and city have sustained. I think they’re a bit late to the party but better late than never, I guess. Given New York’s status I think it’s pretty hard to make a case for substantial federal aid to New York after the initial emergency response.

New Jersey is another case. Much of northeastern New Jersey is a sort of bedroom community for New York. It’s not nearly as prosperous as its neighbor and there’s been an enormous of damage there. Being an elder in a high rise in New Jersey, never a bed of roses, is probably a pretty bad thing to be right about now. I wouldn’t be surprised if New Jersey is going to need considerable help to recover. New Jersey’s governor knows which side his bread is butter on and has been responding appropriately.

It’s hard not to sound like a Grinch in saying it but Sandy isn’t the worst hurricane ever to strike New York and New Jersey. It’s just the most severe hurricane that’s struck the Mid-Atlantic recently. The Long Island Express back in 1938 was a more severe storm with greater loss of life by an order of magnitude. Big, serious storms come along every couple of decades and have done for as long as anybody knows. The relatively mild weather of the last couple of decades has lulled people into a false sense of security but the reality is that nature is tremendously powerful and its power is always there.

I think the willingness of New York officials immediately to leap on the global warming band wagon over Hurricane Sandy is unbecoming and hysterical. Whatever the reality of global warming, big storms have happened before and happened long before there was any threat of global warming. I might add that Chicago has been getting more than 80% of its power from carbon-free sources for more than 30 years; New York gets 30% of its power from carbon-free sources. If New York’s governor is worried about releasing carbon into the atmosphere, he might think about starting at home.

58 comments