Everything You Need to Know…

…you can learn from watching old movies. You know, as I looked up and embedded that clip from Rebel Without a Cause in the last post, it occurred to me that I could probably locate an old movie clip (or sample one from my collection) appropriate to practically any news event or topic. It would certainly change the look and feel of this blog.

How young everybody was! All of the principal players are dead now: James Dean, Sal Mineo, Natalie Wood, Jim Backus, William Hopper, and, just back in 2010, Dennis Hopper. Corey Allen (Buzz) died in 2010, too.

Just the other night my wife and I were talking about the teen and ingenue players of the early 1950s. Quite a few of them are still around: Debbie Reynolds, Jane Powell, Leslie Caron, just to name a few. Not too many of the men left: Sidney Poitier, Tab Hunter, and Russ Tamblyn were the only ones I could come up with off the top of my head. Maybe a few others.

5 comments

The Chicken Game

Keith Hennessey says that the president is bluffing about vetoing any resolution of the “fiscal cliff” that doesn’t include a tax increase:

  1. If there is no bill, the U.S. economy will probably dip into recession for much/most/all of 2013, and it’s impossible to predict whether such a recession would be short-lived.
  2. A 2013 recession would be terrible for the country and terrible for the Obama Presidency. It would limit the President’s options across his entire policy agenda, economic and non-economic. And it could define and dominate his entire second term.
  3. President Obama believes #1 and #2, and therefore avoiding the risk of triggering a recession with his veto is an even higher policy priority than his fiscal policy goal.
  4. The President wants to get things done. He cares more about his own chances for policy success (across the entire breadth of his agenda, whenever he figures out what it is) than he cares about relative political blame. A scenario in which Republicans get most of the blame for a veto-triggered recession is still a loser for him if it means he can’t accomplish his second term goals.

while Robert Reich thinks the Republicans are:

Obama’s only real bargaining leverage comes from the fact that when the Bush tax cuts expire at the end of December, America’s wealthiest will take the biggest hit. The highest marginal income tax rate will rise from 35 to 39.6 percent (for joint filers), and the capital gains rate from 15 to 20 percent.

This will happen automatically if nothing is done between now and then to change course. It’s the default if Republicans won’t agree to anything else. It’s Obama’s trump card.

In all honesty I don’t understand why the president is so insistent about the tax increase for the highest income earners. $40 billion in revenue will do almost nothing about a $1 trillion deficit. It won’t make it any more (or less) sustainable. It’s not a start, a downpayment, or blazing the trail forward. Fulfilling a campaign pledge? So what? He’s not running for anything.

Don’t get me wrong. I opposed the “Bush tax cuts” when they were enacted as cutting the wrong taxes at the wrong time. I opposed them in 2010 when they became the “Obama tax cuts”. Indeed, that made me ill because it indicated pretty clearly that the Congressional Democrats had just been kidding when they railed against them all those years. They didn’t really giveadamn.

The estimates I’ve seen are that the harm that letting the tax cuts lapse would be small and short-lived just as the benefit to the economy they provided was small and short-lived. As I’ve been saying all along. If you’re worried about taking that money out of the economy, enact more efficient tax cuts. I’ve suggested any number of them.

BTW, I think the video clip above has several morals. First, whoever isn’t bluffing is the one who dies going over the cliff. Second, if you’re going to play “Chicken”, don’t dress fashionably.

And it’s better to have dirt on your hands than blood on your hands.

16 comments

Adventures in Dentistry

The other day I went to the dentist. Not my dentist of many years but one of my clients in whom I have complete confidence and for whom I have considerable respect. That respect has been enhanced by my experience as a patient rather than as a consultant.

As it turns out my left mandibular first molar was cracked. Hard to tell if it was cracked clear through or just has multiple partial cracks. The imaging just wasn’t good enough. It actually stands to reason that tooth would have a problem. I had a cavity filled in that tooth ten years or so ago, the most recent one I’ve had. Prior to that I’d had a cavity filled perhaps 35 years ago. I don’t have a lot of fillings but as it works out two of them were in that tooth.

The conventional treatment for a cracked tooth is a cap and I’ve now got a temporary cap. The permanent cap will be the newish ytterbium-zirconium oxide kind. Much superior to the old porcelain caps with metal substrates. Or even the old-fashioned gold caps.

We’re keeping our fingers crossed about the pulp (nerve) of the tooth. So far, so good. The tooth feels odd and a bit uncomfortable but I experience no pain when chewing and it’s not sensitive to hot or cold. I have some degree of pain on that side but that may be because of the work that was done or, typical for me, pain memory. I’m still taking NSAIDs although I really dislike taking pain medication or any kind.

A couple of interesting things. When I received the dental anaesthetic my shoulders began to twitch. I suspect that was a result of the epinephrine. Today I have an ache behind my left shoulder blade that I suspect is related to the adrenal gland there. It’s my understanding that adrenergics stimulate the adrenal gland and my lethargic, old adrenals aren’t used to the work.

Also, since the procedure I’ve been sleeping through the night, something that’s been pretty rare for some time. That makes me wonder if late at night I hadn’t started grinding my teeth and, when I encountered severe pain, awakened.

This is the first major dental work I’ve ever had. Nothing more prior to that than a very few fillings and most of those were fifty years ago. It’s unknown territory for me.

I’m pleased to report that the other day was the best dental experience I’ve ever had including ordinary cleanings. I told the dentist so and he was visibly pleased.

20 comments

Look Out Below!

I have a question. What would be worse? Going off the fiscal cliff (see the Wikipedia article for a summary of what that would entail) or the worst possible non-going over the cliff resolution of the matter? What’s the worst case scenario (other than going over the fiscal cliff)? What would the best case scenario be? What’s the likely resolution?

I think the most likely resolution is a tax increase on the highest income earners, punting on spending cuts, kicking the can down the road a bit farther, and putting together another blue ribbon commission, this time to look into entitlements, particularly Social Security. Unfortunately, Medicare is the actual problem.

IMO that’s a pretty good approximation of the worst case scenario.

20 comments

Deleveraging

The question that occurred to me in reading Bill McBride’s most recent post in which he noted a report from the NY Fed that indicated that consumer indebtedness had declined .7% from the second quarter of 2012 to the third quarter of 2012 was is that good news or bad news? You be the judge.

I did a little back-of-the-envelope calculation and found that, if consumer indebtedness declines at that rate until it reaches its level in the first quarter of 2003, that would take 57 quarters, just shy of 15 years. A quick check of the history suggests that we have never experienced a decline of that length. Indeed, the history of the post-World War II United States, the period of our greatest prosperity, is one of ever-greater expansion of consumer indebtedness.

Now, admittedly, my model is pretty simple. I’m ignoring things like inflation and the effects of future recessions.

However, if what we’re experiencing is a balance sheet recession, household indebtedness declines at the rate that it did in the report, and the magic target number is the level of indebtedness we had in 2003, it looks to me as though we have a problem. The problem is that much bigger if the magic number is the level of, say, 1993. Or 1983.

40 comments

The Major Entitlements

One more thing while I’m still thinking about the history of the budget I mentioned in the previous post. According to the Social Security and Medicare Trustees’ most recent report, the Social Security “trust fund”, the stack of IOUs the system has accumulated over the years, will be exhausted in 2033. Medicare’s HI trust fund will be exhausted in 2024. I think that both of those estimates are highly optimistic. If recent trends continue, I believe the Social Security trust fund is likely to become insolvent by 2020 and the HI trust fund shortly thereafter. It may actually be somewhat sooner than that depending on the timing and depth of the next recession, something almost certain to occur within the next five years.

The Chief Actuary of the Social Security Administration is already on record, questioning the Trustees’ assumptions along much the same lines as I am. He has further gone on the record in predicting that when the trust funds are exhausted, outlays will not decline to meet receipts but, unless the law is changed otherwise, will be augmented by payments from the general fund. I think that’s a correct political calculation.

3 comments

The History of Us

I want to draw your attention to a fascinating, information-dense document: the historical tables of the budget of the United States government for 2013. It’s a detailed history of federal receipts and outlays from the beginnings of the country to the present. A few quick observations.

First, with the possible exception of 2012 the future projections contained in the document are wholly fictitious. There are assumptions being made which are so unlikely as to be fantastical, particularly on the revenue side.

Second, over the period of the last 20 years real declines in spending have been scarce. I count twice over the period: in 1993 and, remarkably, in 2007. That last makes me wonder if more federal spending in 2007 might have resulted in a shallower trough in the economy.

Third, I see no pragmatic reason that any item in the budget should have a permanent claim on a fixed or, indeed, increasing percentage of GDP. Do our defense needs increase because our production increases? I don’t see it. Or is the calculation that greater production means a greater willingness to pay? That’s even more striking when you consider the sharply rising percentage of GDP that the Department of Health and Human Services (read: Medicare) is consuming. I find blithe assertions about rich countries being willing to spend more on healthcare unsatisfying. I think that everybody would prefer to spend less on healthcare. It’s more a “market will bear” situation than one of preference.

18 comments

The Good News in Thanksgiving Weekend Retail Sales

According the the National Retail Federation Thanksgiving weekend retail sales are up sharply relative to last year:

Washington, November 25, 2012 – The New England Patriots and the Washington Redskins weren’t the only winners this Thanksgiving Day as more than 35 million Americans visited retailers’ stores and websites Thursday – up from 29 million last year – scoring deals on everything from hot electronic items to cashmere sweaters and toys. According to a National Retail Federation survey conducted by BIGinsight over the weekend, traffic and spending grew over the entire weekend*. More people than ever before also shopped online and in stores on Black Friday, as 89 million shoppers braved the crowds, up from 86 million last year.

According to the survey, a record 247 million shoppers** visited stores and websites over Black Friday weekend, up from 226 million last year. Making sure to take advantage of retailers’ promotions to the full extent, the average holiday shopper spent $423 this weekend, up from $398 last year. Total spending reached an estimated $59.1 billion.

“From green beans to great deals, millions of Americans found time this Thanksgiving to make the most of retailers’ promotions and enjoy a special family holiday,” said NRF President and CEO Matthew Shay. “To keep their customers excited about holiday shopping, retailers will continue to offer attractive promotions through December, and provide strong consumer value with low prices, enhanced mobile and online offerings, and unique product assortment.”

If that pattern holds good throughout the holiday season during which retailers expect to do 50% of their annual sales, it will be very good news for the economy. However, I think we should temper our reactions a bit until the end of the year for a couple of reasons. First, the percentage of total retail sales done during Thanksgiving weekend has increased enormously since 2006. It’s increased almost three whole percentage points to 11.1% of all holiday sales taking place during that single weekend.

Second, buyers are being attracted by deep discounts (or, at least, the perception of deep discounts). It’s possible that retailers may experience higher sales volume while making lower net revenue.

We won’t really know what happened until after the first of the year. If there’s a wave of bankruptcies among retailers, we’ll know that the increased Thanksgiving weekend sales weren’t nearly enough. Keep your fingers crossed.

66 comments

How to Spur Hiring?

I’ve had a toothache for the last couple of days, am on pain meds (a very great rarity for me), and am a bit out of it. I’ve got a dentist appointment later today and I expect the whole thing to be resolved one way or another in the next day or so.

While that’s the case I want to put a topic on the floor. What policies can be adopted that will spur hiring? My interpretation is that the position of the Obama Administration is to spur hiring by a combination of subsidies to encourage the specific businesses that receive the subsidies to hire and ordinary Keynesian pump-priming via what are broadly referred to as “infrastructure spending”. Whatever your ideological or philosophical position I think you’ve got to acknowledge that what’s been done to date has been inadequate. There are still at least 15 million people who are unemployed and underemployed plus the additional millions who’ve given up looking for jobs and, consequently, no longer are counted in the official reckonings.

If you think that the only problem with those policies is that not enough has been spent, I think there’s another question you’d need to address. Isn’t there some level of government spending that actually results in reduced total economic activity? That has, in fact, been the case in every fully planned economy like Soviet Russia or pre-1979 China. Government spending at one level or another accounts for about 40% of GDP right now. What’s the level of government spending at which it becomes counter-productive. Clearly, something between 0% and 100%. 40%? 60%?

The policies I’ve advocated here have been very much the opposite of what has been adopted by the Obama Administration. I think we need to encourage more business investment, more new business formation, and more hiring by removing the barriers and disincentives to them. Measures that might be adopted that I’ve suggested in the past include abolishing the payroll tax and corporate income taxes (and, presumably, FUTA as well). I’ve also suggested encouraging the states to produce a common set of regulatory requirements, analogous to the UCC, to reduce the overhead that businesses, particularly small businesses, face.

I also think that we need to encourage freer trade in a very hardnosed manner. I’ve suggested reciprocity under the assumption that countries that export to us are more dependent on us than we are on them. I’m not under any illusion that’s the case with all products and services so, clearly, no blanket policy is possible. I’ve also advocated abolishing our agricultural subsidies on economic efficiency grounds. I’ve also advocated immigration reform to emphasize economic efficiency which would really be a drastic change from present policy.

What else should we be doing? Or not doing?

35 comments

A Tax Cut Republicans Don’t Like?

Ross Douthat comes out on the side of the angels in proposing the abolition of the Federal Insurance Contributions Act tax, the “payroll tax”:

The payroll tax holiday that passed Congress in the winter of 2010 was a rare exception to this pessimistic rule. Cutting the payroll tax was good short-term politics for both Democrats and Republicans: it was a tax cut that liberals hoped would double as stimulus, and a boost to the middle class that conservatives could support without embracing new federal spending. But more important, it opened the door to what would be good long-term policy as well — because more than almost any feature of the American tax code, the payroll tax deserves to be pared away into extinction.

But now Washington is in danger of practicing payroll-tax bipartisanship of a more destructive sort. While the White House and Congressional Republicans wrestle over where to set income tax rates and how and whether to cut spending, the payroll tax holiday has been orphaned. Lacking noisy champions and press attention, it’s in danger of expiring at the end of the year out of political indifference.

That outcome would be unfortunate. Payroll taxes are a relic of New Deal Machiavellianism: by taking a bite of every worker’s paycheck and promising postretirement returns, Franklin Roosevelt effectively disguised Social Security as a pay-as-you-go system, even though the program actually redistributes from rich to poor and young to old. That disguise has helped keep Social Security sacrosanct — hailed by Democrats because it protects the poor and backed by Republicans as a reward for steady work.

A general rule of thumb, based on straightforward principles of supply and demand, is that, if you tax something, people will produce less of it. The payroll tax is a tax on jobs and income, particularly on jobs and income where the wage is less than the FICA maximum limit, presently $100,100. Do we really want fewer jobs and less income? FICA falls particularly hard on workers at the lower end of the payscale. Because of its maximum limit it is a regressive tax.

The Social Security retirement payment plan is not now a “pay as you go” system. For the last several years revenues have fallen below mandated disbursements. The difference is made up out of the general fund (essentially, 40% of that is borrowed). One of the ironies of the frequent longing citation of progressives over the Swedish welfare system is that Sweden’s social insurance system is a pay as you go system. Disbursements are limited to revenues, something I strongly suspect would dismay its American fans if it were implemented here. If it were implemented here, the Social Security system would become permanently solvent with the swipe of a pen.

When you combine the FICA tax liability with costs incurred as a result of working and decreasing eligibility for various benefits with increasing income, a significant number of people are actually discouraged from working. This is a perverse result and we should eliminate it.

Eliminating FICA is a good first step in that direction. It would have the additional beneficial effect of reducing the bookkeeping requirement for businesses and individuals. Have you noticed how many nominees to appointive office fall afoul of paying taxes on behalf of their domestic employees? That’s not because they’re cheap or, at least, not just because they’re cheap. It’s because it’s arduous.

13 comments