Economic Indicator

If my time record is any gauge whatever, there’s a mini-recovery in progress right now. I’ve been busier for the last four days than in any comparable period in years. Yes, I work weekends.

On the other hand, historically, my business has tended to be counter-cyclical. I’m a bit like Nanny McPhee—when you don’t want me but need me, I must stay. When you want me and don’t need me, then I have to go.

45 comments

Resolving the Fiscal Mess

The Christian Science Monitor notes that the International Monetary Fund, no stranger to countries in fiscal crisis, has proposed the a solution to U. S. fiscal problems which, at least, provides some idea of the scope of the problem:

One estimate, made by the International Monetary Fund, is that fixing America’s fiscal imbalance will require a one-third cut in government benefits and a one-third rise in tax revenues. The IMF should know. Its job for decades has been to force overspending nations to set their finances in order if they want its seal of approval for more foreign loans and investment.

The IMF’s tough love has worked pretty well in many nations to get them to fess up to past profligacy and then sign on to a measured pace of budget cuts, better regulations, and new revenue. Much of Latin America and parts of Asia and Africa have seen that light.

America’s current debate would benefit from the IMF’s main lesson about the future promise of fiscal discipline: A nation that takes its lumps quickly won’t regret it. Or rather, the admission of past errors and embrace of temporary sacrifice will bring out the fatted calf of economic growth.

To place that in perspective, since spending presently exceeds revenue by about 40%, the IMF’s formula would mean that 40% more of the reductions would come in the form of spending cuts than additional revenue.

There is no way that our fiscal problems can be resolved just by taxing the top 1% of income earners. The proposed increase in marginal rates would realize something between $40 billion and $80 billion in additional revenue per year. That’s a tiny fraction of the $1 trillion by which spending exceeds revenues.

What marginal rate would be required to balance the budget based on taxing the top 1% of income earners alone? I think that’s an unanswerable question. The question is what effective tax rate would be necessary? The answer to that is roughly 33%. Since the top 1% of income earners earn about 20% of the total national income and the total national income is approximately $15 trillion, one third of their gross incomes would need to go to taxes.

There are some who say that of course that can be accomplished. History suggests otherwise.

That means that either you’ve a) got to start seeking revenue from income earners below those rich 1%-ers, b) got to cut spending, c) just issue the credit for the difference, or d) some combination of the above. The president has rejected (a), the Senate Democrats have rejected (b), and (c) risks hyperinflation, IMO too big a risk to take. My preference is some reasonable combination of those measures but all reason is fled.

12 comments

Reflection on Irony

Dismissing 47% of the people, whether they’re the 47% that doesn’t pay income taxes or the 47% that voted for Mitt Romney, does not lay a foundation for good governance.

0 comments

A Difference of Opinion on Negotiating

On the one hand Joe Klein, whom I strongly suspect has never negotiated anything in his entire life, possibly including his own salary, says that asking for the moon in your opening offer is the way negotiation is done:

The Republicans are, reportedly, outraged by President Obama’s opening bid in the fiscal cliff talks. Republicans always seem to be outraged. It’s getting boring. They need to step up and make a counter-offer.

That’s how people negotiate. In this case, they need to be specific about the spending cuts they want. When their specific initial offer is on the table, then you can haggle. (Of course, it’s entirely possible that all this is a smokescreen and actual haggling is taking place privately, between John Boehner and the President.)

I agree with him that the Congressional Republicans should get specific. I disagree that what’s happening is how people negotiate. It’s how unprincipled people negotiate.

Alana Goodman, on the other hand sees it differently:

Presenting a ridiculous first offer — especially after Republicans indicated they were willing to compromise on tax revenues — is not the way to kick off the process. It is the way to insult the recipient, create an adversarial environment, advertise your lack of seriousness, and potentially shut down any hope of reaching a deal acceptable to both sides.

That’s the way to negotiate if your objective is both to ensure you get what you want and to ensure that the other guy doesn’t get anything.

I’d like to see the best possible deal negotiated with the greatest possible likelihood of future agreements. Does what’s happening look to you like the way to accomplish that?

11 comments

Advice on Butter-Making

Glenn Reynolds calls attention to this article on the evolution of the technology of butter churns. He closes with the following:

Now I’m thinking I should buy it and make some homemade butter.

One bit of advice. If you decide to try making your own butter, don’t use anything that’s labeled “Ultra-Whipped” or that contains carrageenan or other gelling agents. However it’s labeled, it’s not whipping cream. It’s “cream-like product”. It won’t turn into butter when you whip it the way real heavy cream does.

Hereabouts Dean’s Heavy Whipping Cream, the stuff in the purple container, is the most readily available version of real, honest-to-gosh whipping cream. I don’t use anything else. It’s a bit more expensive than the “cream-like product” but it’s worth it. If it has any ingredients other than cream in it, don’t buy it.

And you can, in fact, make butter by whipping it.

4 comments

How Not to Negotiate

The most recent status report on the negotiations over the “fiscal cliff” certainly doesn’t give much reason for optimism:

(CNN) – House Speaker John Boehner painted a bleak picture Sunday when talking about fiscal cliff negotiations between the White House and Republicans.

“Right now I would say we’re nowhere. Period. We’re nowhere. We’ve put a serious offer on the table by putting revenues up there to try to get this question resolved, but the White House has responded with virtually nothing,” Boehner said on “Fox News Sunday.”

My understanding is that the president’s proposals rest on three legs:

  1. Raise taxes on the highest income earners while leaving the remainder of the “Bush tax cuts” intact.
  2. Leave Social Security and Medicare alone.
  3. Make raising the debt ceiling automatic.

I wasn’t entirely surprised at Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell’s reaction (he broke out laughing). My immediate reaction was that the president had opened with the insult price.

I must say that the entire proceedings in these negotiations look very childish to me. They’re a caricature of negotiations. Good faith negotiations, the kind that are intended to arrive at a resolution, aren’t the same as imposing terms on a vanquished foe. After all, Speaker Boehner won his own election. The president defeated Mitt Romney not the Republican Party.

The Harvard Negotiation Project outlined the following components of a successful, principled negotiation:

  • Separate the people from the problem.
  • Focus on interests, not positions.
  • Invent options for mutual gain.
  • Insist on using objective criteria.
  • Know your best alternative to negotiated agreement.

They’re doing the opposite of this. To my untutored eye it looks as though both sides are approaching the negotiations as though the only way to win is for the other side to lose.

33 comments

What Happens…?

Menzie Chinn projects that, if the “Bush tax cuts” are allowed to elapse in full, it means no growth in 2013 relative to 2012. Sounds about right to me. He goes on to say:

I much prefer the President’s proposal (described here), which includes letting the rates rise on the top bracket (as I outlined in this post). But EGTRRA and JGTRRA (aka the Bush tax cuts) have constrained our fiscal policy for a decade, and as Jeff Frieden and I discussed in Lost Decades, contributed to the financial crisis of 2008. With ever greater impact on tax revenues going forward, these provisions should end (although I would prefer to delay rate increases on middle incomes).

I would very much like to see a one paragraph quantitative statement of how much the tax cuts have constrained federal spending. What would it have been without them?

I certainly don’t see it. It’s possible we’d have less debt on the balance sheet but I haven’t seen a great deal of spending restraint by either party over the last decade.

11 comments

One of These Things Is Not Like the Others

The chart above illustrates national healthcare spending as a percentage of per capita GDP for OECD countries. The discrepancy between U. S. healthcare spending can’t be explained by the differences in income or better outcomes.

There are several schools of thought on why healthcare spending in the U. S. is so high. One school believes that we pay higher prices because we don’t have a single payer or other nationalized system. My view is closer to believing that a single payer or other nationalized system would be unaffordably expensive in the United States unless we are willing to pay less for healthcare.

Said another way, it’s the prices, stupid.

9 comments

Striking Against the Wrong People

My immediate reaction when I read this article about fast food workers wanting to unionize and striking against the stores that employ them was “I wonder if they realize that they’re striking against the wrong people?” Most McDonalds stores are franchises, owned and operated by the franchisees. Here’s a typical income statement for an average McDonalds store, compiled by Janney Montgomery Scott restaurant analyst Mark Kalinowski:

As you can see it’s a high volume/low margins business. If the workers are striking for just a 10%, an $.80 an hour, raise, that’s a third of the present operating income. $1.60 would be two-thirds. Obviously, the only way for the franchises to raise wages is to raise prices, too, which in turn means that the volume will probably go down. Since fairness seems to be the watchword these days, what’s fair?

The people making money are the McDonalds Corporation and, probably, the landlords.

172 comments

GDP Growth

The Bureau of Economic Analysis has reported that the gross domestic product grew by 2.7% in the 3rd quarter of 2012:

Real gross domestic product — the output of goods and services produced by labor and property located in the United States — increased at an annual rate of 2.7 percent in the third quarter of 2012 (thatis, from the second quarter to the third quarter), according to the “second” estimate released by the Bureau of Economic Analysis. In the second quarter, real GDP increased 1.3 percent.

The GDP estimate released today is based on more complete source data than were available forthe “advance” estimate issued last month. In the advance estimate, the increase in real GDP was 2.0 percent (see “Revisions” on page 3).

The increase in real GDP in the third quarter primarily reflected positive contributions from personal consumption expenditures (PCE), private inventory investment, federal government spending, residential fixed investment, and exports that were partly offset by negative contributions from nonresidential fixed investment and state and local government spending. Imports, which are a subtraction in the calculation of GDP, increased slightly.

That’s certainly better than shrinking or growing more slowly but it’s about average for the U. S. economy from an historical standpoint. It’s not nearly as high as predicted by the Obama Administration back in 2009 and it’s not fast enough to bring the millions of people who are unemployed, underemployed, or discouraged back to work. We need to do better.

Unfortunately, I just don’t see any proposals on the table that would result in significantly faster growth.

2 comments