China As the New Rust Belt

Gordon Chang predicts that the United States will reclaim its lead in manufacturing (or hold it, depending on how you count things) relative to the Chinese:

Robotized production in China is no cheaper than robotized production in, say, Texas or California, where Foxconn maintains manufacturing facilities. And so it should come as no surprise that, as Foxconn replaces humans with machines, Apple CEO Tim Cook told NBC’s Brian Williams on Thursday that next year his company will manufacture one of its Mac computers in the U.S.

Even though Cook’s announcement could have been “political”—a “token gesture” as one observer in Hong Kong sniffed—it nonetheless is part of a broader narrative of factories fleeing China. After all, Apple is not the only company to recently announce it was “onshoring.” Lenovo, China’s largest maker of PCs, in October said it would move some computer manufacturing to its North Carolina facility, and General Electric has been transferring production back to Appliance Park in Louisville. Small- and medium-sized manufacturers are started to return to the U.S. as well.

American manufacturers, in short, are gaining on the Chinese. Boston Consulting Group has predicted that around 2015 it will become more economical to manufacture in the U.S. than China in seven industrial sectors. American workers are more productive and less likely to strike than their Chinese counterparts. Moreover, as suggested above, transportation costs are much lower and delivery times far shorter when goods are made here. And energy is substantially cheaper in America.

I’ve got it! Let’s reduce the productivity of American workers, encourage them to strike, and increase the cost of transportation and energy. Yeah, that’s the ticket.

55 comments

Is This Interview Self-Refuting?

This interview with Jan Hatzius, chief economist for Goldman-Sachs, is getting some attention. Here’s the headline takeaway from the interview:

Hatzius is bullish on the U.S. economy starting in the second half of 2013, because finally he expects private releveraging to occur at a nice clip, and to not be counteracted by a fiscal drag. Says Hatzius:

“If the business sector is basically trying to reduce its financial surplus at a more rapid pace than the government is trying to reduce its deficit then you’re getting a net positive impulse to spending which then translates into stronger, higher, more income, and ultimately feeds back into spending.”

He has a specific explanation and numbers in mind, to explain the private sector’s inclination to reduce its savings, and spend more.

“Since mid-2009, that surplus has gradually come down as businesses and households have gotten closer to where they need to be from a long-term balance sheet perspective. They’ve paid down debt, they’ve eliminated the excess supply of housing, and that’s basically allowed them to reduce the financial surpluses that they run. They’re still running large surpluses – still 5.5 to 7 percent of GDP, but they’re no longer as large. We expect those figures to come down as the balance sheet adjustment process makes further strides and that’s an underlying source of boost to the economy that’s happening on the one side.”

To my eye the balance of the interview is devoted to an explanation of why a marked expansion is unlikely to take place. GDP growth must, by definition, consist of increases in consumer spending, business investment, government spending, or exports or a decrease in imports. Most of the interview is devoted to explanations of why we’re unlikely to see increases in consumer spending, business investment, or government spending. Marked increases in exports would undoubtedly be met by counter-measures from our trading partners as would a sharp decrease in imports.

Perhaps someone can explain it to me but his viewpoint largely seems to consist of “We’re due”. This is a sentiment that any Cub fan can understand but it’s not particularly satisfying.

10 comments

New Businesses and Unemployment

There’s an excellent post from Carl Schramm at th 4% Growth Project on the link between high unemployment and decreased rates of new business formation:

Perhaps the single most important indicator of the level of entrepreneurship is the raw number of new firms being formed every year. Historically the number was largely a guess. With new data resources, however, it appears that the number of new businesses started in any year had been extraordinarily stable. For at least a decade, without apparent regard for economic contractions and expansions, the annual number stood at roughly 700,000. But in 2009 the number started to fall precipitously. It is now estimated to be about 500,000 starts per year.

This decline provides a very important new perspective on, among other things, economic recovery, because new firms are so important to the creation of new jobs. New firms, prior to 2009, routinely created approximately seven new jobs during their first year. In 2011, the number fell to roughly five. Were 2007 patterns to obtain today, America could have had at least 400,000 new jobs in 2012 that weren’t created because 200,000 fewer firms got underway.

The data also permit us to speculate about a very important question: Why are fewer people starting new firms? Let me propose a link between new firms and the general level of economic activity.

Recently many economists, helpless to explain how to get our economy growing again, have defaulted to what might be called the “tectonic-shift” thesis. As they see it, the whole economic landscape suddenly changed in 2008. They argue that we will never see full employment at 5% again. Get used to it — the 8% nominal rate is the “new normal.” (For readers not versed in economics, 5% unemployment is viewed as equivalent to full employment — at any given time, 5% of the working population is moving from job to job. This is known as “frictional” unemployment, and it is nothing to be alarmed about; it is indeed normal.)

This default thesis may explain the unprecedented casualness (at least in my view) with which politicians and economists have dealt with unemployment during the last four years. They behave as if 8% unemployment is “normal,” or at least not really so bad. The media have done a good job of telling people not to expect much better, ever again. Politicians appear to want to believe that the current nominal rate of 8% is really the new frictional rate.

But if we are trying to explain why fewer entrepreneurs are starting businesses, the difference between the old 5% rate and the “new normal” 8 percent rate tells all. Would-be entrepreneurs are particularly sensitive to the unemployment rate, more so than might have been imagined. Put differently, entrepreneurs — who are alleged to have more finely tuned market intuitions than other people who make their livelihood in business — appreciate that, if their new business fails, their personal economic risk increases exponentially as the unemployment rate goes up.

I’m not so sure that’s the determinating factor. High-impact new establishments tend to be started during economic slumps. During the 1930s the economy eliminated many businesses but lots of new ones started up, particularly new businesses that exploited the new technologies that were coming along. Effectively, the economy went on a diet, shedding fat and adding muscle.

I think today is very different. The sectors that are growing are the ones with the most government intervention. We’re adding fat at the expense of muscle, the opposite of what we need to be doing.

19 comments

Grot

In the second series of the old BBC television series, The Fall and Rise of Reginald Perrin, Reggie opens a store called “Grot”. Grot sells useless things—square hoops, undrinkable wine. Much to his dismay the store catches on, both as a curiosity and as the perfect place to buy a gift for someone you despise. If Philip Greenspun is to be believed, Windows 8 would fit perfectly into Grot’s product line:

Microsoft has had since October 2008 to study Android. It has had since June 2007 to study iPhone. It seems as though they did not figure out what is good about the standard tablet operating systems.

One thing that Android and iOS do not address is how to handle the requirement of offering a legacy Xerox Alto-style mouse-and-windows environment. Microsoft here integrates the tablet and the standard Windows desktop in the most inconvenient and inconsistent possible way. Due to the desperation of the average consumer to watch television at all times on all devices, the typical computer screen is fairly wide. One would think therefore that it would be possible to use traditional applications in the left-hand two-thirds of the screen while running a tablet environment on the right-hand one-third of the screen. Windows 8 does not allow this. It is either the old Windows XP desktop or the new Android-like tablet environment. As far as I can tell they cannot be mixed except that a tablet app can be set to appear in a vertical ribbon on the left or right edge of the screen.

A reasonable user might respond to this dog’s breakfast of a user interface by trying to stick with either the familiar desktop or the new tablet. However, this is not possible. Some functions, such as “start an application” or “restart the computer” are available only from the tablet interface. Conversely, when one is comfortably ensconced in a touch/tablet application, an additional click will fire up a Web browser, thereby causing the tablet to disappear in favor of the desktop. Many of the “apps” that show up on the “all apps” menu at the bottom of the screen (accessible only if you swipe down from the top of the screen) dump you right into the desktop on the first click.

I’m quite sure that Microsoft doesn’t care. It views its user base in the hundreds of millions as captives. We’ll go along whether we like it or not.

31 comments

Desperately Seeking Housing Recovery

Jonathan Miller says the Bll McBride is confusing housing finding a bottom with recovery:

I feel like I have to qualify myself as NOT being a housing bear (a distressed housing apologist) but I still can’t figure out the math: flat to falling incomes, high unemployment, rising taxes and tight credit = housing recovery? What’s missing?

I can’t figure out what people who foresee better growth in 2013 are looking at. Where’s the growth going to come from? Retail? Housing? Durables? I think that people will decide to keep their old cars, refrigerators, and washing machines a bit longer.

5 comments

The End of Social Security’s Cashflow Surpluses

Bruce Krasting has used the Social Security’s estimate of December 2012 benefits paid and taxes received to extrapolate what we’re likely to see when the Social Security trustees will say when they issue their annual report in six months. The news, as I reported a couple of weeks ago, is not good.

Among his findings and conclusions are that:

  • Benefits paid increased by 6.9%
  • Taxes received increased by 6.5%
  • Interest received decreased by 1.7%
  • There was a cashflow shortfall of $46.7 billion in 2012
  • Social Security will never see a cashflow surplus again

The implication of that is that interdepartmental debt will be decreased to pay for the shortfall and debt owed to the public will be increased. He estimates that the shortfall will reach critical mass in about five years. I think the wheel will really hit the road in about eight years when the trust fund runs dry, receipts are sharply below outlays, and the Congress will be left with two very unpalatable alternatives. Either they can allow the benefits they pay to fall or they can just pay the full benefits anyway, rapidly increasing debt owed to the public and/or sucking up an increasing amount of the total budget.

13 comments

Donizetti’s Don Pasquale at Lyric Opera (2012-2013)

It has been 17 years since we’ve seen Donizetti’s delightful 1843 bel canto comic opera, Don Pasquale, at Lyric Opera. It’s been too long a wait but I am happy to report that the production we saw last night was worth waiting for.

I loved practically everything about last night’s production from the charming period Covent Garden sets and costumes to the staging. And the voices! For me tenor René Barbera as Ernesto and soprano Marlis Petersen as Norina were the standouts. It’s been a long wait but, mirabile dictu, we’ve now heard actual bel canto soprano and tenor singing bel canto soprano and tenor roles.

I do have a few quibbles. As with Simon Boccanegra too frequently the costumes faded into the sets and backdrops. I thought that in the first act Ildebrando D’Arcangelo as Pasquale had some difficulty coordinating his stage business with his singing. I also thought he shouted a bit too much in the first scene of the first act, relaxing a bit as the opera progressed. But these are quibbles. Overall I found his Pasquale funny and balanced, even touching.

That’s the key to Don Pasquale, something that sets it apart from other opera buffa of the period, and one of the things that makes Don Pasquale the greatest of bel canto comic operas. It’s not just broad comedy. Pasquale is not just a buffoon who gets his just deserts at the end. We are fond of Pasquale, we sympathize with him. All he wants is a family and his wastrel nephew, Ernesto, has refused to give him one so he sets about making one for himself.

As the curtain goes down Pasquale has his family, although not in the way he’d thought—Ernesto and Norina will marry.

I understand why it’s been so long since we’ve heard Don Pasquale at Lyric: it’s difficult to sing. You can’t just belt out a few famous arias and have a hit. Yesterday evening’s cast was a young one: Ildebrando D’Arcangelo is just 43, Marlis Petersen is 44, René Barbera is even younger. Their marvelous vocal and acting skilles give me hope for the future. I hope we don’t have to wait another seventeen years to hear it again.

My ratings so far: Don Pasquale, Simon Boccanegra

The Critics

John Von Rhein saw the same things as I did:

Lyric Opera has done well by Donizetti’s endearing opera buffa, which opened Sunday afternoon at the Civic Opera House. The show really shouldn’t have worked as well as it did, given the curious casting, the ancient production and the fact that three of the four principal singers were making role debuts. But it came off as a winning team effort, with everyone including the orchestra and chorus under conductor Stephen Lord proving once again the durability of this 169-year-old sitcom.

although he says it with more flair than I did.

So does Andrew Patner, who draws attention to the timeless qualities that gives Don Pasquale its enduring appeal:

On paper, the scheduling of Donzetti’s 1842 opera buffa “Don Pasquale” in a theater’s season can conjure ideas of cost-saving (there are only four solo roles, and basic sets and costumes are readily available), soprano du jour promotion (the Metropolitan Opera has featured Anna Netrebko in two recent revivals) or indifference in the pit and focus on broad comedy on stage.

Instead, the Lyric Opera of Chicago production that opened Sunday afternoon qualifies as the fourth superb season installment in a row at the Civic Opera House this season. A strong and well-balanced cast including a soprano known more for connoisseurs’ work is a full partner with guest conductor Stephen Lord and the excellent Lyric Orchestra in demonstrating what a superbly crafted and complex score this work has. And in his Lyric directorial debut, veteran English baritone Thomas Allen stages the work to match the score as well. Never failing to be funny or fun, Allen’s vision never stoops to low comedy or exaggeration. There’s a reason this work has endured for 190 years: It’s a serious examination of the human comedy.

2 comments

It’s a Floor Wax and a Dessert Topping

Paul Krugman takes to his New York Times column to urge more federal spending:

Let’s get one thing straight: America is not facing a fiscal crisis. It is, however, still very much experiencing a job crisis.

It’s easy to get confused about the fiscal thing, since everyone’s talking about the “fiscal cliff.” Indeed, one recent poll suggests that a large plurality of the public believes that the budget deficit will go up if we go off that cliff.

In fact, of course, it’s just the opposite: The danger is that the deficit will come down too much, too fast. And the reasons that might happen are purely political; we may be about to slash spending and raise taxes not because markets demand it, but because Republicans have been using blackmail as a bargaining strategy, and the president seems ready to call their bluff.

I fully endorse Dr. Krugman’s concern about the lack of jobs. We are experiencing the sad fruit of a grab bag of economically inefficient policies imposed by a triumphant Democratic Congress in 2009.

Over the period of the last 60 years we have never paid down debt. We have grown past it. We have rarely cut real spending. We have relied on growth to buoy us. What policies will produce the level of growth necessary to grow past the level of debt we’ve incurred over the last several years? As a consequence of feckless policies over the period of generations we have a jobs crisis and a fiscal crisis.

Dr. Krugman gives a nod to the Chartalists:

Remember, the U.S. government can’t run out of cash (it prints the stuff), so the worst that could happen would be a fall in the dollar, which wouldn’t be a terrible thing and might actually help the economy.

How fast can the dollar fall without a loss of confidence in it? That’s a question not an answer. Isn’t there some level? What is it? If you don’t know, I think that caution is advised. I think it’s also worth mentioning that rising prices hurts the poor most. The worst case scenario is no jobs with rising prices and without great care that’s exactly what Dr. Krugman is proposing.

Here’s my proposal: stop doing things that are inefficient in favor of doing things that are more efficient. Examples: Davis-Bacon rules, agricultural subsidies.

63 comments

What Should We Remember?

Today is the 71st anniversary of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor that precipitated U. S. entry into World War II. The median age of the American veterans of that war is now over 90 and there are fewer of them alive every year—fewer than 1.5 million as of last count. Soon there will be no Americans who remember that war let alone took part in it.

In commemoration of the day I’ve been seeing newspaper editorials, op-eds, and blog posts urging us to remember the lessons of that day. What are they? I’m sincere: what are they?

I think it’s reasonable to remember and honor the sacrifices that our parents and grandparents made for their country. That may be the only lesson worth remembering: the number of Americans who stood up and were willing to die for something larger than themselves.

The country that they fought to defend no longer exists and, frankly, many of us today would not consider it worth defending. Consider the lives of women, African Americans, and homosexuals in that country. There was no problem of the homeless—they were beaten up by the police and dropped off at the edge of town. Children with mental or physical defects were institutionalized. Healthcare was inexpensive but it was also ineffective. Jobs were scarce and life was hard for people without jobs.

If we had fought the Japanese and Germans the way we have fought radical Islamists, we’d probably still be fighting them. I’m not suggesting that we should have. The honest truth is that we weren’t fighting Japanese militarists or the Nazis. We were fighting the Japanese and the Germans. If we fought violent radical Islamists the same way we fought the Japanese and Germans, we would be at war with nearly a billion people and there would already have been hundreds of millions of innocents killed.

So, are there lessons to be learned from Pearl Harbor? And what are they?

56 comments

They’ve Got To Be Carefully Taught

The editors of the San Francisco Chronicle take note of a video posted on the site of the web site of the California Federation of Teachers:

The upshot of the video is that greedy rich people should be blamed for everything because their love of money trumps any concern for the rest of us. Apparently the federation thought its mallet-to-the-head tone throughout was too subtle some folks – so it included a scene of a fat cat urinating on working people.

Hypocrisy, anyone? It accused the rich of buying elections: “They spent so much money on politics, they elected people who like what they liked” – translated as tax cuts for them and less spending on schools and roads. Never mind that teacher unions are far and away the biggest contributor to California campaigns and that their return on investment in 2012 included defeat of a measure (SB1530) to streamline the process for firing teachers in cases involving sex, drugs or violence against students.

Read more: http://www.sfgate.com/opinion/editorials/article/Crass-warfare-by-teachers-organization-4095004.php#ixzz2EHcXPfmw

File this under the Department of the Pot Calling the Kettle Black.

22 comments