Not If But When

When do you think the first homicide from an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) will take place in the United States? They don’t need to be guided using a satellite, you know.

17 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Why We Won’t Be Leaving Afghanistan Any Time Soon

Whether counterinsurgency, counter-terrorism, or targeted drone strikes are the preferred strategy, their requirements and the political risks of complete withdrawal from Afghanistan mean we won’t be leaving there for the foreseeable future.

0 comments

The Answer

In answer to the question “How do you know that you have the flu?” the physician being interviewed on the radio said “You have a headache, aches and pains all over, a cough, and you feel just terrible.”

Well, that explains that. I’ve had the flu for the last twenty years.

2 comments

Then and Now

My looks are nothing to write home about but I’m fortunate in that although a bit grayer I look very much the same as I did thirty years ago. Not everyone is so blessed and NBC Los Angeles has assembled a montage of pictures of rock stars, now mostly in their 60s and 70s, as they appeared at the height of their fame and as they look now, that illustrates that pretty well. In the picture above on the left is Grace Slick in her Jefferson Starship days and on the right as she is now.

Coco Chanel once said that at 50 you get the face that you deserve. She also said that nothing is ugly as long as it’s alive. As refutation of that claim, I submit The Rolling Stones. If anybody looks more like Dorian Gray after the portrait he had hidden is destroyed, I don’t know who that might be.

Browse through the montage at the link. It’s interesting in a Grand Guignol sort of way.

46 comments

The Three Major Sources of Jobs

Think of it this way. There are three major kinds of employers: the public sector, the private sector, and the “private” sector. That last is the one that’s been growing:

This morning’s jobs report shows that the economy’s subsidized private sector (industries like health care services that receive big government subsidies) is back as a major source of new hiring. If a stronger but sustainable U.S. recovery depends on reinvigorating industries not heavily dependent on government largesse, then this hiring out-performance by the subsidized private sector is a bearish indicator.

More encouragingly, manufacturing gained 25,000 jobs in December, and the November figure was revised from a 7,000 loss to a 5,000 gain.

The subsidized private sector created 65,000 net new jobs in December. This means that preliminary figures for hiring improvement last month for the real private sector (where output and employment levels stem overwhelmingly from market forces), totaled 103,000, not the 168,000 reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. As a result, government-supported private sector jobs fueled 38.69 percent of all total nonfarm job growth in December – way up from the downwardly revised figure of 12.33 percent in November. (All data are seasonally adjusted.)

The real private sector generated 66.45 percent of all net new nonfarm jobs in December – .lower than an 88.36 percent figure for November that itself was revised down slightly.

Subsidized private sector job creation in December, therefore, mirrored its hiring record throughout the current economic recovery. Since the recession technically ended in June, 2009, these industries have generated fully 38.43 percent of total employment gains in the nonfarm sector (the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ U.S. jobs universe).

Such subsidized private sector job creation represents major out-performance, since these industries’ share of total nonfarm employment was only 15.32 percent in December.

If that’s a sustainable pattern, then the Soviet economy should be the strongest in the world. The problem with what Dr. Tonelson, quoted above, is calling the “subsidized private sector” and what I’m calling the “private” sector is that the subsidies are distortionary. Not only do the amounts of the subsidies make those enterprises look stronger than they actually are but if the subsidies are large enough and go on for long enough those enterprises attract private investment they would not otherwise attract. Everybody loves a sure thing. That’s a substantial drag on investment in the non-subsidized economy.

If, in addition, the enterprises that are being subsidized are characterized by a relatively small number of very highly compensated workers and a much larger number of poorly compensated workers, like, say, the healthcare sector, increased employment in that sector drives income inequality. Lose-lose!

11 comments

Losers

Al Hunt states the case that Republicans, Democrats, and the White House alike lost in the deal for avoiding the “fiscal cliff”:

The bottom lines: The White House believes Republican leaders privately realize that holding the nation’s full faith and credit hostage to cutting popular programs is a loser. Congressional Republicans dismiss Obama’s lines in the sand, saying he invariably backs down and that any economic fallout ultimately hurts his presidency.

Both points are persuasive.

I certainly lost. I hold the unpopular position that the Bush tax cuts should have been eliminated in toto. Fortunately, I’m accustomed to being lonely. Now those cuts have been made permanent for 99% of taxpayers.

It seems self-evident to me that if you’re anti-tax you’ve also got to be anti-spend. The line drawn by Democrats is that they’re opposed to raising the taxes of 99% of taxpayers. Mathematically, that should mean that they’re willing to limit their spending demands, too, since you can’t spend what they want to spend just by taxing the top 1% of income earners. The numbers just don’t add up.

The line drawn by Republicans is that they’re opposed to raising the taxes of the top 1% of income earners. Hardly a populist position. I can only speculate that they’ve convinced themselves that if only you cut the taxes of the highest income earners enough it will produce a huge surge of economic growth. I just don’t see the evidence of that. If you don’t believe me, look at the minimal, short-lived effects of the tax cuts in 2002 and 2003.

The big winner is cognitive dissonance.

1 comment

In the Interest of Fairness

While we’re on the subject of Illinois’s public employee pension debacle, this might be an opportune time to remind our state legislators that any solution other than letting school districts bear the full freight of teacher retirement continues an injustice. Chicago residents pay the pensions of retired Chicago Public School teachers through Chicago’s CTPF, separate from the TRS that funds the pensions of other Illinois teachers’ pensions. Chicago residents also fund the state’s contribution to the TRS through their state income taxes. We take a double hit.

I’ll repeat my modest proposal to resolve the issue. Failing pushing the full freight of teachers’ retirements to their home district or absorbing the CTPF into the TRS, rebate to Chicago residents that portion of their Illinois personal income taxes that go to pay the TRS. It’s basic justice.

I also predict that if the full freight of teachers’ retirement are placed on their home districts we will see a wave of bankruptcies, unlike anything ever seen in any state. Local governments just don’t have the power to raise the revenue needed.

1 comment

We Don’t Have a Medicare Problem

The editors of the Washington Post come out in favor of a number of reforms intended to reduce Medicare costs. After noting that the structural reforms that might actually be effective are presently politically impossible, the reforms they endorse include raising the premiums paid by beneficiaries to cover 35% of costs, introducing a copay for home health care, reducing reimbursements to providers for patients’ unpaid deductibles, reducing the overcompensation of teaching hospitals for treating Medicare patients, and replacing administered pricing for durable medical equipemnt and, perhaps, testing with competitive bidding. The total savings: $460 billion over ten years, quite a bit less than 10% of Medicare’s total budget. Is that all there is? (remembering Patti Page) The editors conclude:

We’re loath to let Washington off the hook for a more permanent, fundamental Medicare fix. But given the uncertainties, political and economic, of that endeavor, pursuing specific incremental reforms is a plausible second-best solution. It won’t be painless, but neither is inaction.

One of the things perennially omitted from the discussion of saving money on Medicare is that one man’s spending is another man’s revenue. When you propose incremental non-structural approaches to healthcare reform, as the WP editors do or as are embodied in the PPACA, you must believe one of two things (or some combination): a) that providers will willingly take a pay cut or b) that they won’t make the billing up in some other way, either negating the savings you’ve projected or pushing them into some other component of the healthcare system, e.g. Medicaid or private insurance.

Rising Medicare expenses may be a disaster looming for the federal government but Medicaid is bankrupting the states and rising healthcare insurance costs is wreaking havoc with the budgets of businesses, individuals, and local governments alike. As I’ve published here before, absent healthcare spending costs Cook County doesn’t have a budget problem at all. With healthcare spending, it’s approaching insolvency with no clear way to solve its problems.

There is no incremental non-structural solution to the problems with our healthcare system. We don’t just have a Medicare problem. We have a healthcare system problem. Every solution that anybody proposes, whether it be a single payer system, a full-on national health system along the lines of BNH, or a more market-based system presupposes reducing providers’ incomes, either their height or their breadth or both.

That will require basic, structural changes.

For those of you who believe that over-utilization is the sole source of healthcare cost increases, let me propose a straightforward five-year pilot program. Change Medicare from a first-dollar program as it is now. Make seniors pay the first $5,000 of their healthcare spending each year. Over the $5,000 leave the system as it is now. Create a new category, seniors with incomes of less than $50,000 per year. For them reimburse a portion of the five grand on a sliding scale, i.e. 100% for those in the lowest income brackets, less for those higher up. I predict that such a program will incentivize seniors to reduce utilization, i.e. defer treatment, and that over the five year period it will, if anything, increase Medicare spending.

44 comments

Lie to Me

Illinois’s legislators are struggling with the challenge of Illinois’s underfunded public pension system, showing few signs of any results:

On Saturday, Democratic Gov. Pat Quinn and the four legislative leaders met for two hours in Chicago to discuss an outline of pension reform proposals but came to no agreement. That makes it questionable whether senators will return before the clock runs out Wednesday.

Democratic House Speaker Michael Madigan of Chicago called the meeting “productive” and said work would continue to try to meet the Wednesday deadline, but acknowledged serious differences remain. Asked why he thought progress was made, Madigan joked, “Well, we weren’t throwing punches at each other.”

Several major hurdles remain in trying to quickly put together a comprehensive pension overhaul before a new General Assembly is inaugurated — not the least of which is how a Democratic-led state government would alter benefits for members of unions that traditionally are powerful Democratic allies.

Illinois is in serious need of a mulligan. The problems with Illinois’s public employee pension funds are not that Illinois’s taxpayers didn’t pay the taxes they were supposed to or that Illinois’s public employees failed to make the contributions required of them by law. It is not because the public pension benefits are overly generous. They’re comparable to those in other large states including New York, which doesn’t have the public employee pension crisis that Illinois does. The problem with Illinois’s public employee pension system can be summarized in two words: Rod Blagojevich.

In his first term as governor Blagojevich expanded the state’s Medicaid roster and benefits and increased the state’s spending on education, as well as a number of other, smaller benefit programs. Whatever the merits of doing so, he did so without raising taxes by deferring the state’s contribution to the public employee’s pension plan.

Illinois state expenses are growing rapidly, far faster than its population. Since 2000 Illinois’s population has increased about 5%. Over the same period its Medicaid roster and spending have roughly doubled. The spending for pensions is skyrocketing—from $19 billion in 2002 to $30 billion this year.

There’s no obvious way for the state to increase its revenues. Despite a 66% increase in the state personal income tax rate in 2011, the state only realized a roughly 10% increase in revenues from personal income taxes. That does not suggest that further increases in the personal income tax rate will result in the revenue that the state needs to pay its bills. Sales taxes are already high here—Chicago’s sales tax is the highest of any major city in the nation (a federal sales tax would probably bankrupt Illinois but that’s a subject for another post).

I honestly don’t see any way for Illinois to dig its way out of the hole dug for it over the last decade other than to reverse the decisions that have been made over that decade. That means reducing compensation for state employees, reducing its Medicaid benefits, and shrinking its Medicaid roster.

At this point the only Illinois population that’s not being asked to sacrifice in the name of righting Illinois’s fiscal ship is the population most responsible for Illinois’s fiscal problems: state legislators. Here’s my modest proposal. Until Illinois budgetary problems are corrected the salary of Illinois legislators should be reduced to $1 per year and budgets for offices and staffs should be eliminated.

I wish that the people of Illinois would show more interest in pragmatic, workable government when they go to the polls. So far that has not been the case. Voters are much kinder to politicians who lie to them. The incentives have got to change.

1 comment

Our Dysfunctional Politics

Yesterday, in comments, one of the long-time commenters here made this remark:

We have a minority party absolutely devoted to a completely outdated notion of governance.

going on to castigate the manifest failings of the Republican Party. What struck me about the comment was how well it characterized both of our major political parties.

Both of our major parties are minority parties. According to the most recent Gallup poll on party affiliation, neither party commands the membership of a majority of the electorate (Republicans 29%; Democrats 31%). Indeed, even if you include those who “lean Republican” or “lean Democratic”, neither party commands an outright majority (Repubicans 44%; Democrats 46%).

That may even overstate the actual party support. 37% of those polled identified themselves as independents and there’s no category for “leans independent”.

If we had a parliamentary system, neither Republicans nor Democrats would be able to form a government. Either party would need to make common cause with other parties including some who disagreed pretty vehemently with their programs. There’s really no way to tell what sort of government would result.

But it’s not just in their mutual minority status that the two parties are lacking. The Republicans, as has been pointed out, are divided between reformers and rejectionists (the Tea Party supporters). The rejectionists do not yet recognize and may never recognize that most Americans simply don’t want the sort of country they’re proposing. Most want the catastrophic and inherently conflicted status quo: a superpower military combined with social spending that we either can’t or won’t pay for.

However, Democrats are similarly divided. Divisions include the one between the Clintonians and the Deaniacs or the technocrats and the progressives. From my vantage point many but not all Democrats envision policies along the lines of those of European social democrats. The problems with this are pretty obvious—European countries are backing off from their social programs even as we’re embracing them. Sweden’s social insurance program, for example, is less munificent than ours. Most American progressives would probably reject it if it were proposed without the “Swedish” label. The Swedes are moving towards a “fee for service” system in their healthcare system even as we begin to move away from ours. France has recently constrained its own healthcare system. Under the parcours de soins coordonné there is an attempt at constraining visits to specialists in an effort to control costs. The long and the short of it is that healthcare costs are rising everywhere and the French don’t find their system any more affordable than we do ours. Their system would be completely unworkable if they were paying American prices.

Thinking that Americans will accept the very high levels of taxation that would be required for a French-style healthcare system (particularly one with American prices) is just as lunatic as believing that we can afford an ever-growing military along with our present social safety net while keeping taxes at their 2012 levels.

In my view European social programs depend upon European levels of social cohesion and we just don’t have them. Can we get them? Should we? I have no idea.

When I stand back and look at our political parties I don’t see a sane party and a crazy party. I see two crazy, dysfunctional parties. One holds the White House, the other one doesn’t.

21 comments