Desperately Seeking Reality

Writing at the blog of the American Enterprise Institute, John Makin is very concerned about the graph above, which illustrates the growth of federal spending and federal receipts over time:

The approach of the debt ceiling by late February, when the US supposedly can’t pay its bills, has brought the “man bites dog” attention seekers out of the woodwork. Former government lawyers write in the Wall Street Journal that concern is silly because the law mandates that revenues be used to pay interest on the debt first. True, but that means that most other programs are drastically cut — no social security checks, etc — while the economy, deprived of a quick $300 billion per MONTH (over 2% of GDP) goes into cardiac arrest.

and urges Americans to face reality rather than seeking out “gimmicks”, e.g. trillion dollar platinum coins.

Here’s another graph of federal receipts and expenses which to my eye illustrates the problem even more clearly:

That’s the same information from the same source, the St. Louis Federal Reserve, but it’s shown in log scale. Several different interpretations of that are possible but here’s mine. Federal revenues and expenditures grew approximately at the rate of inflation until the 1970s. Revenues fell during recessions; spending increased during recessions. In the late 1970s spending started growing a lot faster than revenues and that separation has continued ever since, expect for a brief, aberrant rejoining of their paths during the dot-com bubble.

Here’s what I think is the real, big question mark. Roosevelt, Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon, etc. all failed at extracting more than 20% of GDP in revenues over any extended period of time. Marginal rates, population, etc. made no difference. Occasionally, it would go over 20% very briefly and then decline again. Expenditures have exceeded 24% of GDP for some time. Under the most optimistic scenario those would fall to just over 22% of GDP. Under less optimistic scenarios they would remain at around 24% of GDP or even increase. Realistically, that means between $500 billion in annual deficit (the optimistic scenario) and $800 billion in annual deficit (the less optimistic scenario). It’s not difficult to imagine trillion dollar deficits extending into the indefinite future, especially if the economy slips into recession again, which seems more than likely over the next few years.

It’s mathematically impossible to make up that difference just by taxing the top 1% of income earners which seems to be the present plan. I don’t much care whether it’s politics, economics, psychology, or phrenology that makes it impossible to extract more than 20% of GDP as federal revenues. It’s never been done successfully over an extended period so, if that’s your plan, I want to know how you’re going to do it.

It seems to me that would take either a substantial sales job or enormously increased enforcement along with a broadening of the tax base to accomplish the feat. What’s your plan?

Alternatively, we can reduce spending. My candidate for doing that is, was, and always has been some combination of reduced defense spending and reduced healthcare spending. I don’t see any way to get where we need to go without reducing healthcare spending. Not reducing its growth; reducing the spending.

25 comments

The Faces

Writing at NationalJournal.com Jill Lawrence asks, sardonically, “What does a president have to do these days to get his face carved into a mountainside?” Equally sardonically, I would respond that being president when the carving got done would help.

The individuals who are immortalized on Mount Rushmore:

  • Fought a successful revolution, freeing the colonies that formed the basis for our republic, and set the foundations of that republic by leaving office when his term had expired.< ?li>
  • Wrote the Declaration of Independence and, when president, doubled the size of the territory of the United States.
  • Freed 1/7th of the population of the United States from slavery, saved the Republic, and added the last large chunk of territory to the United States.

You may lionize or demonize the incumbent. I don’t honestly see how anyone in his or her right mind could think that ensuring that 3% more people had healthcare insurance really fits into the same class of accomplishment as those above.

If aspirations are enough to fit the bill, shouldn’t Jimmy Carter’s face be carved into half the mountainsides in the country? Or LBJ’s?

Update

I have been reminded that work on Mount Rushmore didn’t begin until 1927 and T. Roosevelt was selected to balance the presidents depicted between Republicans and Democrats. My point remains: major accomplishment is really the criterion required for that sort of memorialization.

12 comments

The Dark Side of Globalization

In an op-ed in the New York Times Dan Fagin remarks on the history and present of potentially carcinogenic dyes in clothing:

The reality of 21st-century globalism, however, is that none of us can pretend that by pushing the chemical industry out of our communities we have stopped enabling its dangerous practices. The industry jobs that started in Basel, and then migrated to Cincinnati and Toms River, are now in Shanxi Province and other coal-rich areas of China. BASF alone now owns or invests in 45 Chinese ventures. Meanwhile, hundreds of smaller companies like the Tianji Coal Chemical Industry Group, whose Changzhi factory was the source of last week’s leak, are busy turning coal into aniline and a host of other chemical products.

Business is booming. If you don’t believe me, head over to the Ocean County Mall in Toms River, where you can get a pair of jeans dyed just the right shade of faded blue, thanks to aniline-based indigo dye. They’re made in China, and they’re cheap — if you don’t count the long-term cost.

There’s pretty strong evidence of the dangers of aniline dyes to dye workers going back 150 years. Despite the alarmist tone of the op-ed, there is little comparable evidence suggesting that garments dyed with modern aniline dyes are hazardous to their wearers. The older literature in particular doesn’t distinguish between dermatitis induced by the dyes and dermatitis produced by the arsenic used in the production of the dyes.

There’s a big difference between the situation today and that of 150 years ago. The most important one is that it was 150 years ago. The dangers of aniline dyes to dye-workers was not known. They are now.

The other is that China does not have a robust system of civil law. Even 150 years ago Germany, France, and other European countries did. That’s why I’m skeptical of moving our dirty industries to China. And why I avoid wearing, sleeping on, or eating anything made in China or made with ingredients that were made in China. To be honest, it’s darned hard.

What’s the take-away from this op-ed? That we shouldn’t buy clothing made in China? That European companies shouldn’t own factories in China? That WTO membership should require adhering to basic safety standards for workers? Or that China needs a robust system of civil law?

1 comment

A Note on the Legal System

Recently, in both the professional journals of opinion and the blogosphere I’ve noticed arguments that are highly dependent on extremely narrow readings of federal law, often hinging on grammatical or stylistic errors. I was particularly shocked, for example, to read an article by Laurence Tribe on the likely constitutionality of a trillion dollar platinum coin. There was another article (I’ve forgotten the author’s name) whose argument hinged on the punctuation of the Second Amendment.

The problem with these analyses is that our legal system just doesn’t work that way. We have a common law system in which judges interpret the law every day. Their interpretations generally don’t hinge on punctuation. That might be the case in other legal systems but not ours. If laws were being interpreted that strictly our society would have collapsed a century ago.

In the particular case of the trillion dollar platinum coin, the law that people have been reading is a law about bullion coins. “Bullion coins” are coins sold, whatever their face value, for amounts based on the actual value of the metal from which they’re made. The one ounce American Gold Eagle, for example, has a face value of $50 and today sells for around $1,700, based on the value of the gold that’s in it. In my view the intent of Congress can reasonably be inferred from the law and its intent was not to empower the Treasury to mint a one ounce $1 trillion platinum coin. Astonishingly, Professor Tribe apparently thinks otherwise.

Could the Treasury mint a one ounce platinum coin with a face value of $1 trillion under present law? Would it? Would the courts uphold its use with a value of $1 trillion in payment of the bills that Congress is racking up? I don’t know the answer to any of those questions but I suspect that the answer to all of them is “No”.

10 comments

You Can’t Tell Him Much

Ann Althouse points out, succinctly, something I’ve noticed about so many Harvard grads:

You may think you’re smart, but it’s not smart to assume other people aren’t smart too. I recommend a working assumption that other people are smart, and when you think you’re reading something ridiculously stupid, go through the exercise of reading it with the thought that the writer is wonderfully clever.

Not unique to Harvard grads, of course.

The smartest guy I’ve ever known did not go to an Ivy League school. His dad worked on an assembly line in a factory. His mom was an ordinary housewife. Well, ordinary except that she managed to raise a large brood of very smart kids on the wages of a guy who worked on an assembly line in a factory.

The Harvard grads I’ve known were, mostly, smart enough. Not great mentalities but they didn’t drool. What they mostly were was connected and ambitious.

4 comments

Why Is Chicago’s Murder Rate Higher?

I’ve been wanting to write a brief post on this subject since I read this article, needling Chicago and its mayor, Rahm Emanuel, for Chicago’s very high murder rate:

Chicago is America’s third-largest city, and is one of its three largest convention cities. It has the nation’s second busiest airport. It has highly rated cultural offerings: the Chicago Symphony, a vibrant local theater industry, great museums. But in one area Chicago has clearly staked its claim to number one.

In 2012, Chicago recorded 505 murders. That may not sound all that bad, since in some years in the past two decades the city had over 900 murders (1991, 1992, and 1994). But it looks like a terribly high number when compared to New York (which recorded 414 murders in 2012) or any of the other ten largest cities in America, because Chicago is not only the murder capital of America in terms of experiencing the most murders. It also has, by far, the highest murder rate among America’s ten largest cities.

New York has a population more than three times as large as Chicago’s population: 8.175 million according to the 2010 Census, versus 2.696 million for Chicago. In New York, the number of murders in 2012 equates to 1 in every 19,747 residents. In Chicago, the rate is 1 murder for every 5,338 residents. If 2011 population data were used, the comparison would be even starker, since New York’s population was estimated to have grown by 74,000 from 2010 to 2011, while Chicago’s grew only 11,000 in that period.

If there is one number to think about, it is this: Chicago is 3.7 times more dangerous than New York when it comes to murder, which is obviously the most serious crime with which mayors and their police forces need to be concerned.

Rather than dwelling on the manifest inadequacies of the article including its dismissive tone, let’s zero in on the key question: why is Chicago’s murder rate so high? Why is Chicago’s murder rate higher than New York’s?

Both Chicago and New York have stringent gun laws so that can’t be the problem.

I think I can explain some but not all of the difference. Chicago is blacker than New York and Cook County is less equal than New York County (all of the really rich people live outside the county). According to the Census Bureau, New York African American population is about 25% while Chicago’s African American population is around 33%. The homicide rate plus income inequality makes or a noxious mix. Where it’s particularly telling is in Los Angeles County. It has a lower murder rate than Chicago with even worse income inequality but it’s only 10% black.

Despite my raising the issue of race, my claim isn’t a racial one. The black rural homicide rate is roughly equal to the white rural homicide rate. It’s the black urban homicide rate that’s dramatically higher. My speculation is that a large, segregated black population plus urban setting plus income inequality equals high homicide rate.

It might be claimed that the War on Drugs is a critical component, too. For me to accept that I’d need to see a sharply rising homicide rate among urban African Americans after 1970 and I haven’t been able to establish it.

I’m open to other explanations. Why is Chicago’s homicide rate so high?

79 comments

Soft Science

I see that Anne Applebaum has stumbled into something i’ve been stressing here for some time, that economics is a science of human behavior, that preferences matter, and that preferences may differ from country to country for a wide variety of reasons:

Anyone making economic recommendations, whether in the pages of a newspaper or directly into President Obama’s ear, should remember this: The viability of an austerity policy — or a fiscal stimulus — in the United States might also depend on the political climate in which it is introduced, the mood of the nation at the time and — who knows! — maybe the behavior of our celebrities too.

One size does not fit all. Human beings are not completely independent entities. They live within cultural contexts. They aren’t like atomic particles or perfect spheres. History matters. What the neighbors do and think matters. What their favorite actors or sports figures do (as well as say) matters.

18 comments

From the Department of Foreseen Unforeseen Consequences

I’m receiving rumors of well-established California medical practices closing quite suddenly as of the end of last year, a consequence of ObamaCare and California’s increasing taxes. Can anyone confirm that?

7 comments

Emergency Aid, ¡Si!, Subsidies for the Rich, ¡No!

The editors of USA Today see things very much as I do with respect to the aid bill for the states hit by Hurricane Sandy that’s making its way through Congress:

The spending least worthy of an emergency loophole is the billions the bill demands for projects to protect against damage from future storms. Most or all of this spending makes sense. Protecting subway tunnels from flooding could save millions in the next storm, for example, and coastal communities behind sand barriers weathered the storm much better than those that elected not to build them.

The question is who should pay, and how. The Sandy bill unwisely changes the traditional cost-sharing formula that requires state and local governments to put up 35% of the funding for such projects, dropping that to just 10%.

Working-class towns might not be able to afford the tens of millions it costs to build sand barriers, but New York and New Jersey, for all their own budget woes, are relatively well-off states. It’s a matter of priorities.

Yes, we’re one country. What I’m curious about is why a non-emergency subsidy for Greenwich, Connecticut, for example, is more worthy of support than aid for poor kids in inner city Chicago? Aren’t they part of that “one country”, too?

15 comments

Another Question: Is the NFL Doomed?

I’m just full of questions today. What effect do you think that the spate of cases of chronic traumatic encephalopathy, brain damage due to repeated blows to the head, will have on the NFL? I doubt that public outcry is the biggest danger to the organization. I think that liability suits are.

19 comments