What I Think About Drug Legalization

I’ve posted on this subject before but the topic has usually been embedded within a post about something else or within comments so I thought I put it here for easier reference. What always bugs me about the subject is that people are so unwilling to define their terms.

Let me do some defining. I think you can divide the subject into several different categories. I have no problem with legalizing the sale or use of marijuana. I think that legalizing the sale or use of all Schedule I drugs would be imprudent although I’m willing to listen to arguments over decriminalizing the use of Schedule I drugs. I think that making everything—not just “recreational drugs” but antibiotics, anti-depressants, antivirals, you name it—would be foolish.

I also think that many of the benefits touted by advocates of broad legalization would only be realized in the extreme case of all Schedule I drugs being completely legalized and unregulated or taxed. Cigarettes are legal but there’s a thriving black market because they’re regulated and taxed.

59 comments

The President’s Gun Control Proposal

This morning I listened to the president’s press conference on his gun control proposals. By and large I found his proposals inoffensive, commonsensical, and, unfortunately, unlikely to have much effect even if enacted in toto. The highlights of his proposal, at least to my ear, were:

  • Ban on assault weapons
  • 10 round limit on magazines
  • End the “gun show exception” and require background checks of anyone purchasing a firearm

I’m sure that many individuals, much more radicalized with respect to gun ownership than I am, will see those as intolerable assaults on basic freedoms.

As I’ve written before homicides using firearms can be divided into two broad classifications: the actions of “pseudocommando” spree killers like the murderer who killed 26 people in Newtown, Connecticut, and the sad, too ordinary murder of family members, coworkers, or members of competing gangs that goes in day-in, day-out. I care as much about the 20 young people who will be shot this weekend in Chicago, mostly poor, young black men, as I do about the 20 schoolchildren from prosperous families who were murdered at Sandy Hook School. Reducing or preventing those two different kinds of homicides using firearms require different strategies.

That brings me to the one thing the president said with which I disagreed:

Because while there is no law or set of laws that can prevent every senseless act of violence completely, no piece of legislation that will prevent every tragedy, every act of evil, if there is even one thing we can do to reduce this violence, if there is even one life that can be saved, then we’ve got an obligation to try.

The emphasis is mine. As a rhetorical flourish that’s fine. As the foundation of policy, I couldn’t disagree more.

If we were to forcibly institutionalize the mentally ill, those who had suicidal ideation, or who had thought about killing other people, it would almost certainly save more than one life. It would also be cruel, offensive to freedom, horrifically expensive, and probably counter-productive since it would discourage people who needed help from seeking it. Do we have an obligation to try to impose such a regime? I don’t think so.

One of the basic principles of optimization is to divide a process into its components, identify the requirements and costs of the parts, and develop ways of doing them more effectively and cheaper. It’s easiest to optimize where there’s something to optimize. You can’t get a dollar’s worth of cost reduction by optimizing the production of a $.25 part.

If you divide gun homicides into its components, about half of all gun homicides are committed by young, black men in cities. The victims, too, are mostly young, black men in cities. I recognize that some people find pointing that out reprehensible. To me it’s basic optimization. The one thing we should do to reduce the homicide rate is end gang violence.

In his talk the president referred obliquely to that when he spoke about putting more police officers on the streets. Unfortunately, there is no obvious inverse relationship between the number of police officers on the streets and the number of gun homicides. Chicago has the largest number of police officers per 100,000 population of any country in the nation. We also lead the nation among big cities in gun homicides. We need to think harder about this problem. Then we need to act.

48 comments

The Great Vacation

I must say that I disagree with Richard Vedder’s explanation for why fewer Americans are working than ever before. In essence he subscribes to the “Great Vacation” theory of decreasing labor force size and blames the following:

  • Food stamps
  • Social Security disability payments
  • Pell grants
  • Extended unemployment benefits

I think that those measures do have some effect but probably not more than few percent of those who’ve left the labor force have done so because those handout programs have made not working so darned attractive. I think that any of the following are probably more significant in explaining what’s changed:

  • The rise of temporary and part-time work, at least partially as a response to various government requirements
  • Transportation costs
  • Two (or more) job families
  • Regulation or fear of regulation inducing companies to move jobs that people are actually able to do overseas
  • Currency manipulation by foreign governments making imported goods cheaper than domestically-produced goods

That’s just off the top of my head. I also think there’s a larger factor. People today don’t realize how hard we used to work. I used to work 60, 70, or 80 hour weeks. I didn’t get paid overtime or even receive comp time. It was just what the job required so I did it.

60 comments

The Spending/Debt Ceiling Kabuki

How tired I am of the endless grandstanding over taxes, spending, the budget, and the debt ceiling! If the House had a lick of sense, they would put up a big thermometer in the Capitol with a line drawn at the amount of revenue they expected to receive or whatever percentage above that they found acceptable and just stop appropriating when they reached that line. They could go home. Since defense, Social Security, interest on the debt, and federal healthcare spending already amount to just about the amount of revenue we’re taking in, they could go home by the end of February.

It’s all about the grandstanding.

2 comments

Comparing Apples to Apples in Life Expectancy

Isn’t it just barely possible that the reason that Americans have life expectancies after 65 comparable to the French, Germans, Britons, and Canadians that Americans older than 65 are genetically more similar to the French, Germans, Britons, and Canadians than our younger population is? Only about 15% of all Americans over 65 are either black or Hispanic. I think that Harold Meyerson is using misdirection to argue for healthcare reform.

I’m completely in favor of healthcare reform. My opposition to the PPACA, “ObamaCare”, had two bases: a) it was obvious to me that its reform was phony, not the reform that we need and b) the history of healthcare reform in the U. S. is that after a major reform bill is passed a very long period, fifteen to 25 years, goes by before we have the stomach to tackle it again and I didn’t think that we could wait for the outcome of a useless reform to become apparent before reforming healthcare in a productive direction.

I can give you the formula for increasing life expectancies at birth in the U. S. in three words: end gang violence. Easy to write, hard to do.

I’m not as convinced as Mr. Meyerson is that increased spending on healthcare makes us that much healthier. I think lifestyle changes are more important. Said another way, I think that extraordinary spending on the elder sick results in days, weeks, or months of additional vigorous, productive life while healthier lifestyles result in additional months or years of productive life.

What are the implications of lower birthweight babies due to maternal drug or alcohol abuse for the life of these infants after 70? Assuming they make it to 70. That’s a greater problem here, too, as I’ve written before. I would presume that it isn’t nothing and a national health service would do very little about that but would spend a lot of money doing it.

U. S. per capita healthcare spending is twice that of France. We spend a higher proportion of GDP on healthcare and, if anything, we need to spend less. Of itself going to a single-payer system like Germany’s, a system like France’s, or even a full-on national health system like Britain’s won’t cut our spending. Only cutting our spending will cut our spending and until we develop the political will to do that all we will do is wait for the inevitable crash.

Meanwhile, if we keep doing what we’ve been doing, we’ll tax young blacks and Hispanics who won’t live to 70 to pay for the increasingly pricey healthcare of old, white people.

11 comments

What the American Dream Isn’t

You might want to take a look at Ramesh Ponnuru’s colum at Bloomberg, pointing out what should be obvious but, sadly, isn’t—that any discussion of wage stagnation that doesn’t include the change in total compensation as a result of rising healthcare costs into account is seriously flawed.

The column has one very good sentence in it: “The American dream isn’t to pay ever-higher health premiums.” As my pathologist buddy reminded me many years ago, for some people it is.

There’s another point that I think should be made that. It might be too subtle but paying more for healthcare insurance is different than other kinds of consumption. When you eat one more cookie or drink one more glass of wine or watch TV on a better set, you feel better. In economic jargon utility increases. When you pay an extra $1, $100, or $1,000 for healthcare insurance, you don’t feel better. You’re betting that you’ll get sick.

14 comments

Fairness, Efficiency, and the Tax Code

I’m not as outraged as the Wall Street Journal about plans to increase taxes. I think that eliminating or reducing deductions and simplifying the tax would, in general, be good things. What concerns me is that’s pretty darned unlikely to happen. What’s likely to happen is loopholes, i.e. deductions, closed for enemies, raised for friends, and the tax code will continue to expand and grow more complex and incomprehensible.

Just a little food for thought. A fair and economically efficient tax code could be written on the back of an envelope. The present federal tax code weighs in at around 74,000 pages. What does that tell you?

8 comments

Cheshire Cat Healthcare Reform

The editors of the Washington Post note the disappointing results of the move to electronic medical recordkeeping mandated by the PPACA, also known as “ObamaCare”:

It’s easier to identify factors that did not contribute to the downward bending of the cost curve. Health information technology is a case in point. At one time, its cost-cutting promise seemed immense. A 2005 Rand Corp. analysis estimated that the nation could save up to $81 billion a year by digitizing patient records and other data; best of all, it was said, more accurate, accessible information would also help improve patient care. All that stood in the way was the fact that doctors and hospitals had no incentive to invest in equipment that would save other people money. So President Obama’s 2009 economic stimulus bill allotted $27 billion in incentives to health-care providers who adopted electronic health records and showed they’re being used to improve patient care.

But as an article released Monday by Rand researchers argues, the subsequent investment has bought very little in the way of either improved care or lower costs. It’s possible that computerization may actually have increased spending. Between 2006 and 2010, Medicare payment to hospitals receiving federal dollars for electronic records grew faster than payments to hospitals that did not take advantage of the incentives, according to a Sept. 21 New York Times report cited in the new Rand article.

The editorial goes on to consider the problem of “interoperability”, making the cacophony of recordkeeping systems talk with one another. I can think of a half dozen different ways that could have been accommodated. Among them are standards, a centralized database along with an application programming interface for interacting with it in a secure manner, or a full-blown (and mandatory) practice management application provided at no charge. $27 billion is a lot of money.

Anybody who had real life experience might have mentioned to those planning the PPACA something that is very well known: the problem in electronic medical recordkeeping is not capital investment. It’s compliance. Look at it this way. Assume an average wage of $200,000 for a physician, 2,000 billable hours per physician, and five minutes per billable hour spent by the physician in additional recordkeeping to fulfill a system of electronic medical records. That means that $100 per hour would need to be billed just to pay the physician. Using the rule of thumb to relate wage rate to billing rate that means a billing rate of about $300 per hour. Five minutes then costs roughly $25 or $50,000 per year. For a half million physicians that comes to about $25 billion per year. So, we’re going to increase costs by $25 billion to save a maximum of $81 billion. Not a great bet. You might lose money on it and almost certainly will in the short run.

And it’s a bet that isn’t panning out. As I predicted and pretty much anyone reasonably well-informed on the subject might have.

ObamaCare’s promise of universal healthcare coverage has evaporated (see also here). The savings expected from electronic recordkeeping are vanishing.

Piece by piece the benefits of the plan are disappearing, like the Cheshire Cat, until nothing is left but the smile.

20 comments

Why Is the Debt Limit Redundant?

It seems like practically every day something comes up that I just don’t understand. With all of the hand-wringing that’s been going on over the next reaching of the debt limit, it occurred to me that I really didn’t understand much of the discussion. You don’t need to look very hard to find an op-ed, editorial, blog post, or even a pronouncement by a high-ranking government official that the debt limit can just be ignored.

Here’s what puzzles me. Why isn’t the converse equally true or even truer? That is, that in appropriating spending beyond the debt limit Congress is exceeding its authority and the appropriation is illegitimate and should just be ignored.

It seems to me that’s actually the better argument. The 14th amendment guarantees the debt not appropriations. An appropriation is just a federal law. The Congress can reduce the appropriation or eliminate it altogether just by passing another law. The debt on the other hand is beyond the power of Congress to abrogate or reduce other than by appropriations to do so.

I know that there are people who believe that the federal government as a monetary sovereign does not have debts. They’re confused. The Treasury issues bonds and bonds are by definition debt instruments. It would be more accurate to say that the federal government as a monetary sovereign does not require debt to finance its operations. I have my doubts about even this since I wonder to what degree the federal government is actually a monetary sovereign. The federal government and the Federal Reserve are not synonymous and the Federal Reserve is a public/private hybrid, not a government department.

The Treasury can certainly always print more money. However, it can’t force the Federal Reserve to honor its checks. To me that implies limits to the federal government’s monetary sovereignty. But back to the original question.

So, help me out here. Why is the debt limit redundant?

5 comments

The Scraps

Yesterday evening I saw the matchbook at the left on my kitchen counter and it brought back a flood of memories. In the 1960s, 70s, and early 1980s The Rib Cellar was the best restaurant in Huntsville, Alabama. Maybe the best restaurant ever in Huntsville, Alabama. It was a tone-y, white glove steak and seafood place and definitely targeted at the expense account crowd. It was located in the Huntsville airport in the JetPlex, a building with something of the futuristic, Jetson quality of some of the building of forty years ago. Those were the days when Huntsville was on the NASA contactors circuit along with Houston, Melbourne, Florida, and Washington, DC, and there was definitely expense account money to be had back then. It’s peculiar when the past is more futuristic than the actual future that emerged.

Thirty some-odd years ago I spent the summer in Huntsville. I’d fly in from Chicago on Sunday evening or Monday morning and fly out again on Friday evening. Southern Airlines, in the days when flight attendants were exclusively attractive, young women who wore uniforms tailored in the extreme. The service and food were excellent and you got the impression that the people who worked for the airline were happy in their jobs and glad you were giving them your custom, something rare nowadays.

Ten weeks went by that way. Up on Monday, back on Friday. Working ten or twelve hour days during the week. During those ten weeks I ate at The Rib Cellar possibly two or three times. It was good, not great, but certainly the best that Huntsville had to offer in terms of fine dining.

Every morning I ate at a little better-than-average diner called The Dwarf on Governor’s Parkway. The Dwarf’s coffee was good and its baked goods excellent. This was before franchises ruled the world and baked goods weren’t all made from mixes. The Dwarf was the sort of place where every breakfast came with a side of grits. For some of my associates “Hold the grits” became their most-used phrase.

The best place I found for lunch was a cafeteria in a shopping center. Huntsville is in the Cafeteria Belt. I don’t know if it’s still the case (I suspect not) but once upon a time there was a swathe of the country extending from Oklahoma to Georgia where some of the best food around was in cafeterias. Miss Hullings in St. Louis was an exemplar of that time. The tiny cafeteria in a Huntsville shopping center was another. I’ve never had better fresh strawberry or peach pie. There is no doubt whatever in my mind that the cooks were black.

None of these places exist anymore other than in the memories of the people who used to frequent them. They’re fond memories. Odd, isn’t it, how little scraps like this can remind us of places and things of long ago?

7 comments