We Are a Pilgrim People

Via The Moderate Voice I ran across this interesting report on a study of the genetics of Ashenazic Jews:

Seeking new light in the argument, a study published in the British journal Genome Biology and Evolution, compares the genomes of 1,287 unrelated individuals who hail from eight Jewish and 74 non-Jewish populations.

Geneticist Eran Elhaik of the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health in Baltimore, Maryland, trawled through this small mountain of data in search of single changes in the DNA code that are linked to a group’s geographical origins.

Such telltales have been used in past research to delve into the origins of the Basque people and the pygmy people of central Africa.

Among European Jews, Elhaik found ancestral signatures that pointed clearly to the Caucasus and also, but to a smaller degree, the Middle East.

The complete study is here. Here’s its conclusion:

We compared two genetic models for European Jewish ancestry depicting a mixed Khazarian–European–Middle Eastern and sole Middle Eastern origins. Contemporary populations were used as surrogates to the ancient Khazars and Judeans, and their relatedness to European Jews was compared over a comprehensive set of genetic analyses. Our findings support the Khazarian hypothesis depicting a large Near Eastern–Caucasus ancestry along with Southern European, Middle Eastern, and Eastern European ancestries, in agreement with recent studies and oral and written traditions. We conclude that the genome of European Jews is a tapestry of ancient populations including Judaized Khazars, Greco–Roman Jews, Mesopotamian Jews, and Judeans and that their population structure was formed in the Caucasus and the banks of the Volga with roots stretching to Canaan and the banks of the Jordan.

The “Khazarian Hypothesis”, the notion that European Jews originated among the Khazars of the Caucasus, dates, to the best of my knowledge, to the 1950s and was popularized in the 1970s by Ernest Koestler. I think its intent was benign, to eliminate anti-Semitism by showing a common racial heritage between European Jews and non-Jewish Europeans.

This study, however, makes me sad. I strongly suspect that it will add fuel to the “they should go back to where they came from” views held, particularly, by Middle Eastern Arabs.

The reality is that we’re all ultimately from somewhere else. “Arabs” of the Middle East (more a linguistic distinction than a genetic one—Saudis are genetically quite different from, say, Moroccans although both peoples are thought of as Arabs), if they’re from anywhere in particular, are from farther south than Palestine. The Druze, at least from a genetic perspective, are from farther east, Iran or even India. I’ve seen studies that found that the Maronites of Lebanon may be the people most closely related to the inhabitants of Palestine of 2,000 years ago.

Although my ancestry is mostly Irish and Swiss, I live in America and I’m an American. It’s been 150 years since anyone in my family has considered themselves anything but American. We’ve never known anything else.

The “native Americans”, American Indians, didn’t originate here. Their ancestors came from East Asia. The most ancient populations in the world, the people of New Guinea or the aborigines of Australia, left South Asia millennia ago. They’re New Guineans and Australians now. The Australians whose ancestors left England in the 19th century or Greece in the 20th century are Australians, too.

There’s no going back. We’ve never known anything else. We are a pilgrim people. We left our previous homes decades, centuries, or millennia ago. Our new homes are our homes.

3 comments

Intentionally Misleading, a Sample Stump Speech

I carry no water for Mitt Romney. I didn’t vote for him and think he’s yesterday’s news. In a recent post James Joyner dings Romney for saying something on the campaign trail that was “technically true just intentionally misleading” and was named “Lie of the Year” by PolitiFact. I don’t know about y’all but around here a candidate can’t introduce him- or herself to prospective voters without being intentionally misleading. It’s a venial sin at worst.

In token of this I’d like to submit a snippet of a sample stump speech, including annotations to indicate the actual meaning.

Good evening, people of East Sasquatch1. My name is Joe Doakes2 and I’m running to be the next mayor3 of our fair city4. I’ve been involved with this town all my life5. My views on the issues that concern us6 are well known7 and I’ve been strong and consistent8 in them.

1You’re all a bunch of losers.

2My father/mother/father-in-law/aunt was the last mayor.

3I couldn’t care less about this office. It’s just a stepping stone and I really want to be president.

4Not good but fair.

5I haven’t even visited here for Thanksgiving since I went away to college. I have shaken some hands at a few bus stops, though.

6See above. I couldn’t care less.

7Nobody has the vaguest idea what they are.

8I’ve been all over the map—my views depend on the audience I’m addressing.

I could go on but you get the idea. I’ve heard that speech at least a dozen times in my life, including by several present state and local incumbents. If politicians were prohibited from being intentionally misleading, they’d have practically nothing at all to say.

3 comments

Your “Dog Bites Man” Story of the Day

Via Doug Mataconis: “Former New Orleans Mayor Indicted On Corruption Charges”. Now, “Former New Orleans Mayor Cleared of Corruption Charges”, that would be news.

4 comments

Asked and Answered

Mickey Kaus asks:

Did he really believe it?

That is, did Ezra Klein really believe that electronic medical recordkeeping would actually reduce healthcare costs?

I think he did. When you’re young enough, don’t actually know anything about the subject, don’t have the life experience necessary to distinguish between vapor and reality, and believing something will help you while questioning it will hurt you, you can believe darned near anything.

I sincerely believe that nobody in the healthcare field who wasn’t actually selling electronic medical recordkeeping systems really believed that such systems would lower costs.

9 comments

How to Persuade Me

Unlike far too many people I can, in fact, be persuaded. I am not absolutely set in my views. I respond to my experiences, new developments, things I learn.

I’m not easily browbeaten but I can be persuaded.

Passion doesn’t impress me a great deal. Evidence does.

It doesn’t actually happen too frequently, largely because people aren’t willing to take the time to convince, preferring to shame, intimidate, or pontificate. I actually wish it happened more frequently.

2 comments

Another Lance

I’ve been hearing the name “Lance” quite a bit in the last several days and weeks and it’s caused an old memory to resurface. One of my schoolmates was called “Lance”. His given name wasn’t Lancelot. It was Delancey.

He was one of the funniest guys I’ve ever known, bar none. I guess humor is a defense mechanism.

Haven’t heard from him in years but I’ve seen him on TV every one in a while.

1 comment

Justice, the Law, and Chicago

There’s a story that’s getting quite a bit of attention here in Chicago and I think it’s worth putting on the floor for discussion:

On the day that Chicago taxpayers got the bill for another $33 million in payouts for police misconduct lawsuits, Mayor Rahm Emanuel sought to reassure citizens that the city’s bleak history of lax police oversight came to an end when he was elected mayor.

But some aldermen and government transparency advocates questioned Thursday whether City Hall and the Chicago Police Department have done enough to identify and weed out the type of behavior that has made the city notorious for bad cop scandals.

As the settlements in two infamous cases moved through City Council votes this week, some aldermen made the connection between police accountability and the cost to taxpayers. Those frustrations reached a peak Thursday as the aldermen voted 49-0 to approve a $10.25 million settlement for a man wrongfully imprisoned for years and a $22.5 million settlement for a mentally ill woman who was left severely disabled after police released her in a high-crime area where she was attacked.

If my understanding is correct the first settlement is the case of a man who was tortured by the police into confessing to a crime he didn’t commit who served 26 years in jail before being exonerated. The second is the case of a mentally ill woman who was arrested at Midway Airport for making a disturbance and then released into the area of the Robert Taylor Homes, a notorious CHA housing project now closed and quite a distance from where she was apprehended. She was then raped at knifepoint by an unknown assailant and fell or was pushed from a seventh story window. She survived but sustained injuries that mean she will require round-the-clock nursing for the rest of her life.

I don’t think there’s any question that terrible injustices were done to both of these individuals. My questions are about the law and justice of the settlements.

To the best of my knowledge no police officer, city, or state official has ever been punished or even reprimanded in either of these cases. Some involved in on case or the other are still on the job. Richie Daley was State’s Attorney when the first case occurred and he’s just retired with a handsome pension.

What’s the law on this? It’s pretty clear that sovereign immunity has gone the way of the dodo. Shouldn’t the police violating official practice be an absolute defense for the city in both cases? Then there’s the justice issue. Do the settlements increase the total amount of justice? I don’t see how. They’re still injured. They haven’t been made whole. The guilty still go unpunished. More innocents, the people of the city of Chicago, are being punished. Spreading injustice around doesn’t produce more justice, it produces more injustice.

I agree with 21st Ward Alderman Howard Brookins, quoted in the article cited above: where does it end? When do we start punishing the people who are actually guilty?

9 comments

Distinguishing the Bad Guys

A comment made in another thread reminded me of a story which I may have told before. In St. Louis as in many other American cities, the Italian neighborhood was known as “The Hill” (previously something much less polite). St. Louis’s Hill has produced many famous baseball players including Yogi Berra and Joe Garagiola. The high school I attended was a just a couple of blocks from The Hill and some of my classmates were Berras and Garagiolas. The Hill still has some great Italian restaurants—it’s where fried ravioli originated.

Many years ago the owner of a construction company working on a project on The Hill had a problem with vandalism. Fences were being torn down. The windshields of some of his expensive equipment were being broken. Rather than hire security guards or complain to the police, he went to the parish priest and explained his problem. The next day the priest brought before the construction company owner two nine year old boys who confessed to causing the damage which amounted into the hundreds or even thousands of dollars, quite a sum at the time. The construction company owner put the two kids to work to pay off the debt incurred by their damages.

I have pretty good reason to believe the story is true—the construction company owner told it to me as true. He was Lebanese and we attended the same Maronite church. But that’s another story.

2 comments

Towards a Bibliography on Criminal Gangs

There are lots of reasons to write blog posts. One of the earliest reasons for blog posts or even web pages was for future reference, to serve as a place for useful links. Over the last several days I’ve been doing some research on criminal gangs and I’ve decided to put my best finds here in case I want to look at them again.

2011 National Gang Threat Assessment – Emerging Trends

This is a report from the FBI. Fundamental facts and figures.

Legalizing Drugs in the US: A Solution to Mexico’s Problems for Which Mexico Should Not Wait

This is a paper by Jonathan P. Caulkins and Michael Lee of Carnegie Mellon University.

The paper makes a number of interesting points:

We are willing to stipulate for the sake of argument that legalizing all drugs would in fact seriously weaken the DTOs, but nonetheless ask whether it is wise for Mexico to pin its hopes on the US taking such an action. This paper argues that five basic facts combine to answer this question in the negative; it is simply not in US interests to legalize the substances responsible for the bulk of the DTOs’ drug revenues. Since this conclusion favors a status quo that has become so intolerable from Mexico’s perspective, we close by speculating about some out of the box (“orthogonal”) ways for Mexico to think about its options.

The “five basic facts” are:

  1. Legalizing Marijuana Would Not Alter the Character of the Drug War
  2. Prohibition Drives Prices Up Far Above Legal Levels
  3. The Taxes Necessary to Prevent a Price Collapse are Uncollectable
  4. Drug Use Responds To Price
  5. Legalization Is an Irreversible Gamble

The whole thing is well worth reading.

DRUG BUSINESS IS NOT THE KEY TO GANGS AND ORGANIZED CRIME: WITH A PROGNOSIS FOR THE MEXICAN CARTEL WARS

This lengthy blog post, written by University of Pennsylvania sociologist Randall Collins, would be worth including if only for its substantial bibliography. His essential point is that there have been criminal gangs for centuries, predating the drug trade, and that criminal gangs are primarily social rather than economic in nature. They provide social affirmation, psychological support, and mutual defense. You can’t eliminate them by attacking their revenue streams but you might be able to by providing substitutes for the services they’re providing.

An Economic Analysis of a Drug-Selling Gang’s Finances

This is a rather famous paper produced by the “Freakonomics” guys.

I’ll include other references as I run across them.

11 comments

Something to Think About

My wife pointed this video out to me. I think that as art it’s quite beautiful and moving. It’s clearly agitprop and, as such, makes me a bit queasy which is why I haven’t embedded it here.

Here’s what I’d like to think about. The song in the video juxtaposes Rosa Parks, Martin Luther King, Jr., and Barack Obama. Am I over-analyzing this or is this a possibly too-true rendering of the history of the African American civil rights movement in the United States over the last 58 years?

Rosa Parks engaged in direct action. Martin Luther King, Jr. engaged both in direct action and in symbolic action. Barack Obama’s election to the presidency, a undeniably great achievement for him, is primarily symbolic for African Americans.

21 comments