Scrooge of the Day

I think the “Scrooge of the Day” award has to go to Nicholas Eberstadt:

In recent years, the biggest increases in disability claims have been for “musculoskeletal” problems and mental disorders (including mood disorders). But as a practical matter, it is impossible for a health professional to ascertain conclusively whether or not a patient is suffering from back pains or sad feelings. The government’s disability-insurance programs were intended to address genuine need.

It might come as a surprise to Mr. Eberstadt but despite its expansion in recent years it’s pretty difficult to qualify for Social Security Disability. It would be nice if he treated us to some actual statistics on the rate of fraud and abuse in the program rather than smearing all recipients. Some people actually have “genuine need”.

31 comments

The Right Tack on Women in Combat

I think that Ralph Peters has it right on the recent move by the Department of Defense to open combat jobs to women applicants:

Our military is not going to collapse because more combat-related jobs will be opened to women. I’ve heard instant griping from old vets and talk-show pundits since this story broke, but the fact is that the gals with guns are already in the fight to a far greater extent than yesteryear’s rules foresaw. Defense Secretary Leon Panetta’s decision largely recognizes existing reality.

Anyway, it’s going to happen, like it or not.

So those of us who care about our military and its combat effectiveness need to stop wailing and start working to make sure the admission of women to more combat-focused military specialties is done right.

He also notes, appropriately, that resisting the pressure to reduce fitness requirements to allow more women to qualify will be difficult but caving in would be harmful—our soldiers aren’t fit enough as it is.

I think there’s another issue that will need to be handled carefully: pregnancy. Doing so will run headlong into the the absolutist predispositions of reproductive rights activists. If pregnancy is treated as a breach of discipline, it denies those women’s rights. If it is not, it denies their male squadmates’ rights.

In Israel which has allowed women to fill combat roles for some time only about 3% of the soldiers in such roles are women and I would be surprised if we exceeded that. 3% is unlikely to reduce readiness but I doubt it will increase the number of women qualified for the pool of general officers, drawn overwhelmingly from combat jobs, either.

1 comment

Hans Massaquoi, 1926-2013

Hans Massaquoi, former managing editor of Ebony Magazine, has died at 87:

Hans Massaquoi, a former managing editor of Ebony magazine who wrote a distinctive memoir about his unusual childhood growing up black in Nazi Germany, died in Jacksonville, Fla., on Saturday, his 87th birthday.

He had been hospitalized over the Christmas holidays, said his son, Hans J. Massaquoi Jr.

Inspired by the late Alex Haley, the author of “Roots,” Massaquoi decided to share his experience of being “both an insider in Nazi Germany and, paradoxically, an endangered outsider.” His autobiography, “Destined to Witness: Growing Up Black in Nazi Germany,” was published in the U.S. in 1999, followed by a German translation.

Mr. Massaquoi was the son of a German nurse and a Liberian diplomat. He grew up in Germany and remained there throughout the Nazi and war years, emigrating to the United States where he served in the U. S. military, used what he’d earned under the GI Bill to get an education, and worked for many years at Jet and Ebony Magazines.

His explanation for how he avoided the gas chambers was that Afro-Germans were so few in number and thought of as second class citizens of such a low priority that they just didn’t get around to them. Sometimes being at the back of the bus has its advantages.

What an extraordinary biography!

0 comments

How to Lower Healthcare Costs Without Cutting Providers’ Wages or Reducing Services

 
 
 

15 comments

The Not-Entirely-Carnivorous Dog

I think that this article, suggesting that dogs may have evolved from the wolves who were “able to scavenge and digest the food waste of early farmers”, isn’t quite as satisfying an explanation as others I’ve read for how dogs are different from wolves. However, I think it does explain why the domestication of dogs is so much more ancient than the domestication of cats. Dogs—socially, behaviorally, ecologically, and physiologically more similar to us than cats—were just easier to domesticate.

9 comments

Only Make Believe

Robert Samuelson takes note of the gap between rhetoric and the cold, hard, practical facts:

On the baby boom, Obama said: “We reject the belief that America must choose between caring for the generation that built this country and investing in the generation that will build its future.”

On climate change: “We will respond to the threat of climate change, knowing that the failure to do so would betray our children and future generations.”

Against this rousing rhetoric stand daunting realities.

The problem with the first issue is one well-known to most people who’ve taken an economics course: butter or guns? It is not merely that federal spending must be allocated. It is that labor, materials, and ingenuity are all finite commodities. Choices must necessarily be made.

The problem with the second is that we can’t solve the problem of climate change by any measures we take here up to and including huddling naked in fireless caves, eating our meat (or, presumably, grass) raw. The growing carbon production outside the United States ensures that:

On climate change, the difficulty is greater. Environmentalists argue that emissions from fossil fuels (coal, oil, natural gas) need to be cut 50 percent to 80 percent by mid-century to avoid a ruinous warming. The problem is that there’s simply no plausible way to get from here to there without, in effect, shutting down the world economy.

Consider a recent study by the International Energy Agency in Paris. Under current policies, it forecasts that world energy demand will rise 47 percent between 2010 and 2035 and the increase in emissions of carbon dioxide — the largest greenhouse gas — will be almost the same. Even when the forecast assumes greater energy efficiencies and a larger shift to wind, solar and other non-fossil fuel sources, energy demand grows 35 percent by 2035 and CO2 emissions 23 percent.

Virtually all the increases occur in China, India and other developing countries. By 2035, estimates the IEA, the number of passenger vehicles in the world will double to 1.7 billion. Electricity demand will surge, as industry expands, more people move into the middle class and many now without electricity (1.3 billion) receive it. American CO2 emissions are projected to stay roughly level by 2035, but even if they fell sharply, the declines wouldn’t offset increases elsewhere in the world.

Bjørn Lomborg makes a similar point this morning:

In the long run, the world needs to cut carbon dioxide because it causes global warming. But if the main effort to cut emissions is through subsidies for chic renewables like wind and solar power, virtually no good will be achieved—at very high cost. The cost of climate policies just for the European Union—intended to reduce emissions by 2020 to 20% below 1990 levels—are estimated at about $250 billion annually. And the benefits, when estimated using a standard climate model, will reduce temperature only by an immeasurable one-tenth of a degree Fahrenheit by the end of the century.

Even in 2035, with the most optimistic scenario, the International Energy Agency estimates that just 2.4% of the world’s energy will come from wind and only 1% from solar. As is the case today, almost 80% will still come from fossil fuels. As long as green energy is more expensive than fossil fuels, growing consumer markets like those in China and India will continue to use them, despite what well-meaning but broke Westerners try to do.

I think that Dr. Lomborg’s proposal, increased investment in research on “green energy” as opposed to production, is practically refuted by his own observation. If we absolutely must throw money at something it should be geoengineering—remediation rather than increased efficiency. At least it’s something effective we could do without international cooperation.

Neither electoral success nor even legislative success are enough. Even the best of intentions won’t cause make believe solutions to work.

27 comments

The Medium Is the Metaphor

In a post on the basic design conflicts between notebook computers and tablet computers

Laptop displays are generally at least 11.5 inches, and the 16:9 aspect ratio is almost an industry convention. That long rectangle gives us room to manipulate a windowed environment. Anything smaller requires voodoo to conjure a good experience out of the machine.

Tablet displays more or less max out at 10 inches, and the industry-leading iPad opts for a 4:3 aspect ratio. That lends itself to books, magazines, and Web pages.

With the Surface, Microsoft hedged its bet, and went with a 10.6-inch, 16:9 display.

That strikes the best balance we’ve seen yet between physical and digital usability, but it’s still far from perfect. Oversized tablets with a 16:9 aspect ratio feel awkward. Perhaps people have been conditioned to believe that words are best consumed in a space that feels like a standard, letter-sized paper page.

Aric Cheston, executive creative director at Frog Design, acknowledges an inherent tension.

“There’s a certain reality to be embraced about the legacy proportions,” he says. “You have to find a smart way of accommodating those.”

Adrian Covert doesn’t quite arrive at the most fundamental problem. The best metaphor for a consumer of written matter, the book, isn’t the the best metaphor for the producer of written matter, the scribe’s desk. Aric Cheston is wrong in dismissing these designs as “legacy proportions”. The different metaphors aren’t just what we’re accustomed to. They’re ergonomically optimum designs proven in the forge of thousands of years of experience.

A consumer’s needs are different from those of a producer. One size does not fit all.

2 comments

The State of National Politics

Sounds like a floor speech.

1 comment

Cold, No Snow

Today is the first truly cold day of the winter here in Chicago. When I rose this morning the temperature was -2°F with a windchill of -15°F.

My normal practice is to walk the dogs first thing in the morning. People in the neighborhood who don’t know me by name know me as “the guy who walks the white dogs”. Not today.

We have now gone for 327 days without an inch of snow—a record by a considerable margin. It’s cold and dry and there’s no real likelihood of snow in the next week.

5 comments

Why We Need Healthcare Reform

This graph is from the same Treasury report that I mentioned in my previous post. The scale on the left is the percent of GDP represented by the increasing Medicare expenditures over time. Three things to note:

  1. These are the projections under current law, i.e. with ObamaCare. Without ObamaCare the expenditures are estimated to be even higher.
  2. A large and increasing proportion of expenses are not covered by current levels of taxation.
  3. It assumes an average 5% per year per recipient growth in spending.

This reminds me of Elbert Hubbard’s (not to be confused with L. Ron) wisecrack: “No man needs a vacation so much as the person who has just had one.” Now that we have healthcare reform what do we need? Healthcare reform.

Does that seem more or less likely now than it did in 2009?

30 comments