Here We Go Again!

As should surprise practically nobody who visits this blog, U. S. GDP shrank in the fourth quarter of 2012:

WASHINGTON—U.S. economic momentum screeched to a halt in the final months of 2012, as businesses pared back inventories and government spending fell sharply, while lawmakers struggled to reach a deal on tax increases and budget cuts.

The nation’s gross domestic product shrank for the first time in three and a half years during the fourth quarter, declining at an annual rate of 0.1% between October and December, the Commerce Department said Wednesday.

It’s the first time the broad measure of all goods and services produced by the economy contracted since the post-financial crisis recovery began. Economists surveyed by Dow Jones Newswires had expected a 1.0% annualized growth.

The economy reversed from a 3.1% pace in the third quarter largely because federal government spending fell by 15% and private business inventories also decreased. Those drags and others were too much for solid consumer spending to overcome.

Consumer spending won’t recover until the process of deleveraging has run its course, which doesn’t look like it will happen any time soon.

I know! We can borrow a lot more to pay for college and grad school!

24 comments

Mort Zuckerman’s Solutions

Over the last few days I hope I have cast at least a little doubt on the effectiveness of infrastructure spending and education spending in revitalizing the U. S. economy. That, at long last, brings me around to a recent op-ed by Mort Zuckerman.

The entire thing calls for a fisking but rather than doing that I’ll just summarize his solutions to our societal woes: more immigration, more infrastructure spending, and more spending on education.

Will more immigration really solve our problems? It depends but I don’t think that a recent Pew survey on immigrants supports the claim. Note, in particular, the tables by region of origin and educational attainment and by region of origin and income. Short form: at least 90% of Mexican immigrants are earning below median income and fewer than half have a high school education.

Living in an American city like New York, Los Angeles, or Chicago is expensive. Based on the proposed $70.1 billion dollar Chicago budget and its 2.7 million inhabitants, Chicago costs about $25,000 per resident. That actually understates it a bit. It doesn’t include, for example, the cost of maintaining emergency rooms in non-public hospitals. Since emergency rooms are primary care for a lot of people, however that increases the cost of healthcare should be included in the cost of maintaining Chicago.

Said another way, anybody in Chicago who earns less than $25,000 which includes more than half of all Mexican immigrants, in effect consumes more than he or she produces. Yes, that’s an over-simplification. We’re trying to formulate policy not produce a financial report.

The reality of immigration is that its benefits accrue preponderantly to the highest income earners in the U. S. (Mort Zuckerman) and its costs are borne by lower income earners in the form of lower wages, greater competition for scarce jobs, and higher costs, generally.

Education spending has skyrocketed over the last twenty years. In real terms we’re spending a multiple of what we did twenty years ago, much of the additional spending on increased administrative costs. I look forward to somebody making the case that increased educational administrative spending is just what our economy needs to grow and prosper. That’s the net effect. If you favor more educational spending that is in fact what you mean. Everybody’s in favor of better education. It’s a lot harder to make a case for paying more for the lousy educational system we have.

I’ve already dealt with infrastructure spending so I won’t repeat my argument here other than to say that I don’t believe that building a 222nd bridge across the Mississippi will create a sudden cornucopia of benefits.

In my view what we really need is to get much more value for our spending than we are. We need smarter immigration policy, smarter education spending, and smarter infrastructure spending. Based on the policies I’m seeing proposed in all three areas it looks to me more like doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

Smarter policies require painful trade-offs and hardnosed decisions. Incumbent politicans are punished for making painful trade-offs and hardnosed decisions and rewarded for spending more and promising the moon. Which path do you think they’ll take?

31 comments

The Flawed Educational Policy

Yesterday it was suggested in comments that I was mischaracterizing or exaggerating the emphasis by the Clinton, George W. Bush, and Obama Administrations on higher education. I don’t think I am and I’ll give three quick examples.

Bill Clinton, June 4, 1996

PRINCETON, N.J. (AllPolitics, June 4) — President Bill Clinton, in a commencement talk at Princeton University today, proposed a tax break to finance two years of post-high school education. (224K WAV sound)

“It’s America’s most basic bargain,” Clinton told the graduating seniors. “We’ll help create opportunity if you’ll take responsibility.”

[…]

Administration officials say the president wants to “make clear that two years of college should be as universal as high school.”

George W. Bush, January 20, 2004

We must ensure that older students and adults can gain the skills they need to find work now. Many of the fastest- growing occupations require strong math and science preparation and training beyond the high-school level. So tonight I propose a series of measures called Jobs for the 21st Century. This program will provide extra help to middle- and high-school students who fall behind in reading and math, expand Advanced Placement programs in low-income schools, invite math and science professionals from the private sector to teach part-time in our high schools.

I propose larger Pell Grants for students who prepare for college with demanding courses in high school. I propose increasing support for America’s fine community colleges, so they can train workers for industries that are creating the most new jobs. By all these actions, we will help more and more Americans to join in the growing prosperity of our country.

Barack Obama, August 9, 2010

I’ve called for doubling our exports within the next five years, so that we’re not just buying from other countries, I want us to sell to other countries. We’ve talked about doubling our nation’s capacity to generate renewable energy by 2012, because I’m actually convinced that if we control the clean energy future, then our economic future will be bright — building solar panels and wind turbines and biodiesel. And I want us to produce 8 million more college graduates by 2020, because America has to have the highest share of graduates compared to every other nation.

But, Texas, I want you to know we have been slipping. In a single generation, we’ve fallen from first place to 12th place in college graduation rates for young adults. Think about that. In one generation we went from number one to number 12.

Now, that’s unacceptable, but it’s not irreversible. We can retake the lead. If we’re serious about making sure America’s workers — and America itself — succeeds in the 21st century, the single most important step we can take is make — is to make sure that every one of our young people — here in Austin, here in Texas, here in the United States of America — has the best education that the world has to offer. That’s the number one thing we can do.

Now, when I talk about education, people say, well, you know what, right now we’re going through this tough time. We’ve emerged from the worst recession since the Great Depression. So, Mr. President, you should only focus on jobs, on economic issues. And what I’ve tried to explain to people — I said this at the National Urban League the other week — education is an economic issue. Education is the economic issue of our time.

It’s an economic issue when the unemployment rate for folks who’ve never gone to college is almost double what it is for those who have gone to college. Education is an economic issue when nearly eight in 10 new jobs will require workforce training or a higher education by the end of this decade. Education is an economic issue when we know beyond a shadow of a doubt that countries that out-educate us today, they will out-compete us tomorrow.

The emphasis in each instance is mine. That’s not cherry-picking on my part. I just produced the first relevant quotes I could find. I could produce thousands of others and references to dozens of pieces of legislation over the period of the last two decades. I think it’s clear from the context that all three men are emphasizing the importance of higher education, something that’s not borne out by the facts.

I attribute this misunderstanding on their part to ignorance of statistics. They know that the average salary of college graduates is higher and conclude that higher education raises salaries, not understanding the the very high wages of a very small number of (mostly subsidized) professionals distorts the figures.

38 comments

The Remotest Place in the Lower 48

According to the United States Geological Survey’s NORM-ED database, the remotest place in the continental United States, the lower 48 states, is in the wilderness of Grand Tetons National Part. The blue dot shows you where it is. You can click on the image for a larger version. By my eyeball-o-meter it’s about 30 miles south of one federal highway and about 30 miles north of another federal highway. There’s an Interstate about 200 miles to the west. That’s the remotest place. To get there you’d take one of the highways, drive a few miles on what are probably gravel roads, and then backpack in. Basically a day trip, made more difficult by the altitude.

By comparison Motuo in China (Tibet) is a whole county completely inaccessible by road. They built a road back in 1993 but it fell into disrepair and is unusable. Any necessary food or medicine is carried in on foot.

Why is the United States infrastructure always being compared with that of China, Russia, or Brazil? Below is a map, prepared by the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre as a graphic illustration of interconnectedness.

The lighter the color, the more interconnected. The darker the color, the less connected. As you can see, the eastern part of the United States compares favorably with Europe while the less-interconnected western part is still considerably lighter than vast areas of Russia, China, or Brazil that are contiguous with the main population centers of the country. Comparisons between the highly-developed United States and the BRIC countries is facetious. We don’t spend as much on infrastructure (definition: roads and bridges) as a proportion of GDP as they do because we don’t need to any more.

There are 221 bridges across the Mississippi, roughly one every 10 miles, from Minneapolis where you can jump over the river to its outlet in the Gulf where you can’t even see across it. Bulding one additional bridge won’t add to our productivity or competitiveness in the slightest. I would argue that it would actually decrease our productivity because a superfluous bridge would require maintenance and in the real world where resources are in competition with one another that means those resources wouldn’t be available for another, more efficient use.

28 comments

Enough With the Higher Education, Already

I wonder how you can reconcile the findings of this study with the insistence of the Powers-That-Be that education is the key to a bright economic future:

Nearly half of working Americans with college degrees are in jobs for which they’re overqualified, a new study out Monday suggests.

The study, released by the non-profit Center for College Affordability and Productivity, says the trend is likely to continue for newly minted college graduates over the next decade.

“It is almost the new normal,” says lead author Richard Vedder, an Ohio University economist and founder of the center, based in Washington.

The number of Americans whose highest academic degree was a bachelor’s grew 25% to 41 million from 2002 to 2012, statistics released last week from the U.S. Census Bureau show.

Presumably, they’ll say that cab drivers, sales clerks, and janitors with college degrees make better cab drivers, sales clerks, and janitors, an assertion for which I don’t see a shred of evidence. My experience in life is that people who like the jobs they have are better at them (as well as vice versa). I’m guessing that the people who racked up big debts paying for college educations didn’t expect to end up as cab drivers, sales clerks, and janitors and aren’t happy that’s what they were able to get. Do I need to add that cab drivers, sales clerks, and janitors who didn’t rack up big debts for college have more disposable income than those who did? That they can buy cars and houses and clothes and all of things that contribute to economic growth?

We’ve had three consecutive presidential administration that’ve followed the will o’ the wisp of higher education as industrial policy. Enough already. What we need is more jobs that require college educations for the people with college educations to do. Concentrate on that for a while.

23 comments

K. A. Applegate: 2013 Newbery Award Winner

Children’s and young adult author K. A. Applegate has been awarded the John Newbery Medal for 2013 by the American Library Association for her book, The One and Only Ivan:

Ivan is an easygoing gorilla. Living at the Exit 8 Big Top Mall and Video Arcade, he has grown accustomed to humans watching him through the glass walls of his domain. He rarely misses his life in the jungle. In fact, he hardly ever thinks about it at all.

Instead, Ivan thinks about TV shows he’s seen and about his friends Stella, an elderly elephant, and Bob, a stray dog. But mostly Ivan thinks about art and how to capture the taste of a mango or the sound of leaves with color and a well-placed line.

Then he meets Ruby, a baby elephant taken from her family, and she makes Ivan see their home—and his own art—through new eyes. When Ruby arrives, change comes with her, and it’s up to Ivan to make it a change for the better.

Congratulations, Kay!

Previous winners of this signal honor include Hugh Lofting, Lois Lenski, Joseph Krumgold, and Madeleine L’Engle. The list of winners is a pantheon of children’s literature.

Not to diminish her wonderful achievement, much deserved, but I consider this tremendous award her second greatest accomplishment.

Ms. Applegate has been married for many years to co-author and fellow children’s and young adult author Michael Grant.

19 comments

Rise of the Apparatchiks

There’s a term I’ve used around here from time to time which I suddenly realized I’ve never defined for you. “Apparatchiks”, a Soviet-era Russian term, means “party functionaries”, generally with lifetime tenure. Whatever the nominal job of an apparatchik, the apparatchik’s real job is to advance the policies and interests of the party, regardless of their pragmatic value or benefit to the people or country.

In a recent editorial the editors of the Wall Street Journal characterize Jack Lew, who will undoubtedly be confirmed as the next Secretary of the Treasury, like this:

There was a time when you had to be successful on Wall Street to become secretary of the Treasury. Now along comes presidential nominee Jack Lew, whose only business credential is a stint at the most troubled too-big-to-fail bank.

During the darkest days of the financial crisis Mr. Lew served as the chief operating officer of Citigroup’s Alternative Investments unit (CAI). When Mr. Lew took
this job in January 2008, the unit was already infamous for overseeing “structured investment vehicles” that hid mortgage risks outside Citi’s balance sheet. It also housed internal hedge funds that were in the process of imploding.

CAI no longer exists. At the end of Mr. Lew’s first quarter on the job, the unit reported a $358 million loss. Things got much worse after that but Citi stopped breaking out CAI results in its earnings releases. The unit was eventually shuttered and many of its assets were sold.

As you can see from the chart above, Citibank’s stock collapsed during Mr. Lew’s tenure there. I don’t think he’s to blame but I don’t think there’s much evidence that he actually helped much, either. In fairness to him, characterizing Mr. Lew, a lawyer, as a banker or a financier is, shall we say, an exaggeration. A bit like characterizing me as a dog handler.

Mr. Lew, like Steve Rattner (the Obama Administration’s “auto czar”) or Rahm Emanuel (now mayor of Chicago), had jobs with banks and investment companies connected to the Democratic Party without notable credentials for the jobs. They are Democratic Party apparatchiks. They were granted what were thought to be sinecures to rake in the big bucks before going back to their real jobs: advancing the policies and interests of the party. The banks received value for their money in the form of friends in high places. Can anyone reasonably doubt that Citibank exists only because of its friends? Keep this in mind when you hear DC-types talk about meritocracy. That’s what they mean.

In my view the principle problem with our politics is not the party rank and file or even the policies that our political parties nominally support. It’s the apparatchiks. Typically, they are more rabidly and mindlessly partisan than their corresponding party members who worked their way up the ladder of electoral politics. Why not? Their fortunes depend on it.

24 comments

When You’re Rich They Think You Really Know

Daidle deedle daidle, daidle daidle deedle daidle dum. Am I to be continually disappointed? It certainly seems so. The Wall Street Journal has re-published an annual letter from Bill Gates and given it the title “My Plan to Fix The World’s Biggest Problems”. I expected a plan to fix the world’s biggest problems. What I got was the prevailing wisdom of MBAs everywhere—the importance of measurement and a lengthy list of Mr. Gates’s foundation’s accomplishments:

In the past year, I have been struck by how important measurement is to improving the human condition. You can achieve incredible progress if you set a clear goal and find a measure that will drive progress toward that goal—in a feedback loop similar to the one Mr. Rosen describes.

This may seem basic, but it is amazing how often it is not done and how hard it is to get right. Historically, foreign aid has been measured in terms of the total amount of money invested—and during the Cold War, by whether a country stayed on our side—but not by how well it performed in actually helping people. Closer to home, despite innovation in measuring teacher performance world-wide, more than 90% of educators in the U.S. still get zero feedback on how to improve.

Let’s consider the program to eradicate polio, the subject on which Mr. Gates elaborates in the letter. After a multibillion dollar eradication program, polio remains endemic in just three countries: Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Nigeria. In recent years the project has actually lost ground in those countries:

Some Islamic clerics have even issued fatwas saying that any person who became paralyzed or died from polio would be given the status of a “martyr” for refusing to be duped by a western conspiracy.

Insurgents also claim polio vaccinators are spies.

In Pakistan, such beliefs gained particular credence after it emerged that the CIA used a fake vaccination team headed by a Pakistani doctor, Shakil Afridi, to collect information about Osama bin Laden.

In Pakistan’s North Waziristan tribal area, local Taliban leaders have also issued a fatwa banning polio vaccinations until the United States ceases drone strikes in the area.

In enforcing these bans, militants have killed scores of foreign and local humanitarian aid workers. In the past week, gunmen in Pakistan killed eight polio vaccination workers. In Afghanistan on December 1, gunmen killed a 20-year-old Afghan woman who distributed polio vaccinations in the eastern Kapisa Province.

This spate of violence has coincided with growing cases of polio in Afghanistan and Nigeria — and threatens to stifle recent progress toward defeating the disease in Pakistan.

In Afghanistan, an polio-prevention campaign involving thousands of volunteers and a number of international agencies almost wiped out the deadly disease in 2010.

The Afghan government registered only 25 polio cases that year, but that figure tripled to 76 last year. Afghan President Hamid Karzai blamed the Taliban, demanding that they allow teams of vaccinators to administer antipolio drops to children in areas under their control.

Meanwhile, the cancellation of the immunization programs in Pakistan on December 19 due to the recent violence threatens to reverse recent gains toward eradicating polio in that country. Some 56 polio paralysis cases where reported in Pakistan this year, down from 190 cases in 2011.

In Nigeria, attempts by Islamic extremists to ban a United Nations immunization campaign have resulted in the infection returning to eight previously polio-free countries in Africa, according to the UN. Last year, Nigeria recorded 43 cases of polio, compared to just 25 cases the year before.

As Jonathan Swift wrote, “reasoning will never make a man correct an ill opinion, which by reasoning he never acquired” and I doubt that better measurements will convince Pakistani clerics who are opposed to vaccination as a Western plot otherwise.

Throughout his career as CEO of Microsoft, Mr. Gates made a practice of solving 90% of a problem and then proclaiming it 100% solved. I sincerely hope he’s not applying the same standard to the “world’s biggest problems”.

As to education in the United States, please reflect on this question. Is our problem that we don’t have enough measurements or that the measurements don’t reflect well on those whose job it is to solve the problem and, consequently, go unheeded?

8 comments

Why Is Indiana So Different From Illinois?

Dana Milbank muses over the way Congressional Republicans (mis)behave compared with the way that Republican governors perform:

For a dozen years, Paul Ryan and Mike Pence were Republican colleagues in the House of Representatives and fellow soldiers in the conservative movement. This week, they parted ways: one toward temperance, the other toward extremism.

Pence chose the sensible path. Elected governor of Indiana in November, he delivered his first State of the State speech Tuesday, describing his proposed budget that, though a fiscally conservative plan, increases funds for education, job training, transportation, veterans, child-protective services, and health care for the poor.

Perhaps the answer lies where where Milbank places it: a party in power behaves differently from the same party out of power.

I’m actually more interested in something that’s only peripherally related to Mr. Milbank’s ponderings. Why is Illinois so different from Indiana? Of Illinois’s last six governors, four, three Democrats and a Republican, have been convicted of crimes after serving their terms of office or, in Rod Blagojevich’s case, having been removed from office. You have to go back to 1924 (Warren T. McCray) to find an Indiana governor convicted of a crime. Illinois governors tend to serve longer than do Indiana governors. Indiana has had ten governors over the same period during which Illinois has had seven.

Illinois’s credit rating is the lowest of any state. Indiana’s finances are on surer footing—possibly the soundest in the nation.

Illinois has the largest number of independently taxing government entities of any state. Nearly all taxes in Indiana are state taxes or, at least, specifically authorized by the state.

Geographically, economically, and demographically the two states are quite similar. Their histories are quite different.

Why is government in Indiana so sound and government in Illinois so awful? I don’t think party politics can be totally to blame. Chicago?

I’m hoping that someone who lives in Indiana or who formerly lived in Indiana can chime in and comment on the remarkable difference between the two states.

60 comments

Winter Comes to Chicago

After a prolonged period of really quite mild weather, winter has come to Chicago in earnest. Temperaturs have dropped into the teens, single digits, even, briefly, below zero. After eleven months without snow, Chicago’s “snow drought” has been broken. There’s about an inch of snow on the ground here.

The snow drought was always actually a precipitation drought. In each month of 2012 Chicago’s precipitation for the month came very close to the driest on record. Precipitation is far below average.

On Tuesday Chicago conducted its Point-in-Time Homeless Count. Squads of volunteers and city employees combed Chicago’s streets and alleys, canvassing the city for homeless people sleeping in the street despite this coldest weather of the year. Chicago is estimated to have under 2,000 unsheltered homeless people, roughly a third of Chicago’s homeless. It’s not that there are no shelter berths available for them. They sleep on the street for their own reasons whether because they’re afraid of the shelters, lack the mental capacity to find shelter, or simply prefer to sleep outside to their other alternatives. In doing so they put themselves at risk of death from hypothermia.

According to the Centers for Disease Control, fewer than 700 deaths per year are hypothermia-related in the United States. Of those roughly half are out-of-doors, with the greater number being in Alaska, Wyoming, and Montana. Deaths of the urban homeless due to hypothermia are actually quite rare in the United States.

Typical scenarios for death due to hypothermia in the United States are

Case 1. In December 2003, a man aged 69 years with dementia was reported missing from his residence in Vermont. Despite extensive searches, his body was not found until March 2004 in the backyard of a nearby home. During that period, outdoor temperatures ranged from -14°F to 57°F (-26°C to 14°C). Descriptions and photographs of the scene suggested that the man had tried to cover himself to keep warm. Cause of death was reported as hypothermia, with dementia as a contributing factor.

Case 2. In February 2004, a male aged 16 years was found dead 40 yards from a road in a rural park in northwestern New Mexico. He had last been seen alive the previous day when he was dropped off at high school. The boy was found wearing damp, light clothing; his jacket and neck chain were recovered a short distance away. Temperatures in this region ranged from 11°F to 42°F (-12°C to 6°C) on the day he was found. An autopsy identified minor abrasions and contusions on his face and extremities. His blood alcohol concentration (BAC) was 0.15 g/dL, nearly twice the state legal limit of 0.08 g/dL for drivers. Toxicologic analysis of blood and urine also revealed 2 ng/mL of delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) and 50 ng/mL of delta-9-carboxy-THC, both active ingredients in marijuana that suggest recent or chronic marijuana use. The cause of death was certified as hypothermia from cold exposure, with alcohol and marijuana intoxication as contributing factors.

Case 3. In February 2004, a man aged 18 years was found dead near a creek in southeastern Alaska. He was dressed lightly for winter conditions. The man had been missing for approximately 1 day, during which temperatures had ranged from 39°F to 45°F (4°C to 7°C). Toxicologic testing revealed a BAC of 0.18 g/dL, twice the state legal limit of 0.08 g/dL for drivers, and a urine ethanol concentration of 0.28 g/dL. The cause of death was listed as combined effects of alcohol intoxication and hypothermia.

The primary risk factors for death due to hypothermia, considered a preventable cause of death, are advanced age, mental impairment, and substance abuse.

Deaths of homeless persons due to hypothermia have declined in recent years due to a variety of local, state, and federal programs. Federal programs include the Homelessness Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing Program and the Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to Housing program. In total several billion dollars are spent per year combating homelessness.

I wrote this post for several reasons. The first, obviously enough, is that it’s cold here in Chicago. The second reason was in response to a particularly stupid comment to this post at OTB. The reason that homeless people die of the cold in the United States is not, in general, that we “don’t give a damn”. We’re doing what we reasonably can. Essentially, it’s for cost-benefit reasons. Greatly reducing the number of such deaths below their present very low numbers would require measures we abandoned years ago, e.g. forcible involuntary institutionalization of the mentally ill. We have made trade-offs and, sadly, any trade-off will come at the cost of some lives.

11 comments