Mahony and Curry Removed from Public Duties

The present archbishop of the Los Angeles archdiocese, Jose Gomez has announced that his predecessor, Roger Cardinal Mahony, has been removed from public duties and that the present bishop of the Santa Barbara diocese, Thomas J. Curry has stepped down:

Los Angeles Archbishop Jose Gomez on Thursday announced dramatic actions in response to the priest abuse scandal, saying that Cardinal Roger Mahony would no longer perform public duties in the church and that Santa Barbara Bishop Thomas J. Curry, has stepped down.

Gomez said in a statement that Mahony — who led the L.A. archdiocese from 1985 to 2011 — “will no longer have any administrative or public duties.”

Gomez also announced the church has released a trove of confidential church files detailing how the Los Angeles archdiocese dealt with priests accused of molestation.

Gomez wrote in a letter to parishioners that the files would be disturbing to read.

“I find these files to be brutal and painful reading. The behavior described in these files is terribly sad and evil. There is no excuse, no explaining away what happened to these children. The priests involved had the duty to be their spiritual fathers and they failed,” he wrote. “We need to acknowledge that terrible failure today.”

Gomez’s statement came a week after the release of internal Catholic church records. The records showed 15 years before the clergy sex abuse scandal came to light, Mahony and Curry discussed ways to conceal the molestation of children from law enforcement. Those records represent just a fraction of the files the church released Thursday. The Times is now reviewing those files.

I think that Cardinal Mahony and Bishop Curry and anyone else involved in child sexual abuse or its cover-up should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law and I think that many if not most other Catholics feel the same way. I think that such prosecutions should include prosecutions for conspiracy.

It is my understanding that the crime of conspiracy continues as long as the conspiracy is ongoing, which means that the statute of limitations does not apply until after the last overt act in the conspiracy was committed.

The church hierarchy is not above the law. They should be required to report all credible instances of child abuse, just as teachers or physicians are.

On the other hand I find the flood of Know-Nothing anti-Catholic sentiment that these terrible cases provoke very hurtful. Don’t condemn all Catholics for actions that they abhor as much as you do and which were beyond their control.

4 comments

Ed Koch, 1924-2013

Ed Koch, formerly mayor of New York City, has died:

Ed Koch, the three-term mayor whose irascible exuberance and “How’m I doin’?” tagline made him synonymous with New York chutzpah, died early Friday morning. He was 88.

He was a Damon Runyon character, larger than life, a fitting mayor for a city full of Damon Runyon characters.

1 comment

A Little Simple Arithmetic

Imagine that there are 12.3 million people who are unemployed. You want to cut that number in half without reducing the labor force participation rate. You want to accomplish this in four years. On average how many jobs must be created per month to accomplish that?

12.3 unemployed people/ 2 = 6.15 fewer unemployed people
4 years X 12 months per year = 48 months
6.15 fewer unemployed people / 48 months = 128,125 jobs per month

That’s in addition to the something between 120,000 and 150,000 jobs per month that must be created to provide for the “natural increase”. So something between 250,000 and 280,000 jobs must be created per month. Last month roughly 150,000 jobs were created.

For a graphical illustration of this see the Hamilton Project’s “Jobs Gap” reckoning.

42 comments

The Patterns of Mass Killing

If you were only listening to the political debate following the mass murder in Newtown, Connecticut, you might think that most such mass murders were perpetrated using “assault weapons” and that the murderers generally attacked strangers. That, apparently, is not the case:

The basic pattern found by the New Jersey DHS fusion center, and obtained by Public Intelligence (.PDF), is one of a killer who lashes out at his co-workers. Thirteen out of the 29 observed cases “occurred at the workplace and were conducted by either a former employee or relative of an employee,” the November report finds. His “weapon of choice” is a semiautomatic handgun, rather than the rifles that garnered so much attention after Newtown. The infamous Columbine school slaying of 1999 is the only case in which killers worked in teams: they’re almost always solo acts — and one-off affairs. In every single one of them, the killer was male, between the age of 17 and 49.

They also don’t have military training. Veterans are justifiably angered by the Hollywood-driven meme of the unhinged vet who takes out his battlefield stress on his fellow Americans. (Thanks, Rambo.) In only four of the 29 cases did the shooter have any affiliation with the U.S. military, either active or prior at the time of the slaying, and the fusion center doesn’t mention any wartime experience of the killers. Yet the Army still feels the need to email reporters after each shooting to explain that the killer never served.

It’s harder to construct patterns around shooter motives, the report notes, since in most cases the killer takes his own life or gets killed by law enforcement before publicizing his reasons for violence. But DHS warns that “indicators of potential violence” include a worker’s abrupt and persistent absenteeism; “escalation of domestic problems into the workplace; talk of severe financial problems”; a notable decline in “attention to appearance and hygiene”; unsolicited empathy with the perpetrators of mass violence; and vocalized musings about suicide. The fusion center doesn’t offer more granular data.

The weapons in question, semiautomatic handguns, are also the weapon of choice in gang slayings so you might think that a coherent policy would target those weapons. The emphasis on “assault weapons” suggests otherwise.

Something we should keep in mind: even in the United States the number of these mass killings is actually quite small. It’s difficult to come up with robust findings from such small datasets. It is, however, easy to make political hay over tragedies so who cares whether the bills that will eventually be based will actually accomplish anything?

19 comments

Things to Come: ObamaCare Edition

Whatever your view of “ObamaCare”, I think this article, on the problems posed by a “glitch” in the law, should prove interesting:

WASHINGTON (AP) – Some families could get priced out of health insurance due to what’s being called a glitch in President Barack Obama’s overhaul law. IRS regulations issued Wednesday failed to fix the problem as liberal backers of the president’s plan had hoped.

As a result, some families that can’t afford the employer coverage that they are offered on the job will not be able to get financial assistance from the government to buy private health insurance on their own. How many people will be affected is unclear.

The Obama administration says its hands were tied by the way Congress wrote the law. Officials said the administration tried to mitigate the impact. Families that can’t get coverage because of the glitch will not face a tax penalty for remaining uninsured, the IRS rules said.

“This is a very significant problem, and we have urged that it be fixed,” said Ron Pollack, executive director of Families USA, an advocacy group that supported the overhaul from its early days. “It is clear that the only way this can be fixed is through legislation and not the regulatory process.”

[…]

The problem seems to be the way the law defined affordable.

Congress said affordable coverage can’t cost more than 9.5 percent of family income. People with coverage the law considers affordable cannot get subsidies to go into the new insurance markets. The purpose of that restriction was to prevent a stampede away from employer coverage.

Congress went on to say that what counts as affordable is keyed to the cost of self-only coverage offered to an individual worker, not his or her family. A typical workplace plan costs about $5,600 for an individual worker. But the cost of family coverage is nearly three times higher, about $15,700, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.

So if the employer isn’t willing to chip in for family premiums _ as most big companies already do _ some families will be out of luck. They may not be able to afford the full premium on their own, and they’d be locked out of the subsidies in the health care overhaul law.

I fear that this is a vision of the future for the rest of my life: trench warfare over minutiae in inherently unworkable plans. When something is poorly designed, patching it doesn’t improve the design. Debating over how to make good plans better may be frustrating but worthwhile. Debating over how to keep inadequate plans from collapsing is just depressing.

More evidence for my “Cheshire Cat” theory.

17 comments

The Rebuttal

Keith Hennessey provides a rebuttal argument to Jay Carney’s damage control on the bad news about GDP growth of yesterday, the basic contours of which have become today’s talking points. Note the guest appearance in Mr. Carney’s remarks of folk Keynesianism, about which he appears to be somewhat confused. The only way that the president’s plan can count as stimulus in that view is if you assume that the president’s lying about offsetting spending cuts and tax increases. Note that I don’t make that assumption but Mr. Carney apparently does. With friends like this, etc.

To repeat my basic position: GDP decline bad. At this point in the business cycle I’m relatively indifferent to why it went down. Any decline at this late phase of a phlegmatic recovery could kick its wobbly legs out from under it.

22 comments

Is Stagnation the New Normal?

I disagree with David Harsanyi’s observation that under President Obama stagnation is the new normal. However, I do think that if you view every economic transaction as exploitation, stagnation is the best case scenario.

18 comments

The Triumph of Folk Keynesianism

If you want confirmation of the point I made in my previous post, you need look no farther than this column by Michael Kinsley. Here’s the critical quote:

Peterson wants a balanced budget and only grudgingly acknowledges the need for stimulus. Krugman wants the stimulus and only grudgingly acknowledges that there are limits: You can’t borrow forever. Nevertheless, the two men — representing opposite ends of the spectrum in this debate — agree on how we should proceed.

There’s just one problem: The plan they agree on is impossible. Well, let’s say close to impossible. Miracles do happen.

Step No. 1 of the Peterson-Krugman plan is working well enough. We’ve all done a great job of barely cutting spending, barely raising taxes, not reforming entitlements, and all told spending about a trillion dollars a year more than we bring in. Plenty of stimulus (though stimulus hawks like Krugman wanted more).

But is there a shred of evidence that the citizenry and our political leaders are ready for Step No. 2? That’s where everyone agrees to enough spending cuts and tax increases to close the budget gap. I’ll believe that when I see it.

Just for the record I suspect that what Lord Keynes actually proposed for dealing with cyclic downturns would work if a) we made him world dictator and b) he directed the operation personally. Paul Krugman is not John Maynard Keynes and we’re not going to make him world dictator.

2 comments

They’re Deaf in One Ear

Former director of the Office of Management and Budget in the Obama administration Peter Orszag has an op-ed at Bloomberg that has parts or movements. The first movement is slow, meticuluous, and sobering, the second light and fanciful. In the first part Dr. Orszag makes a very convincing case that economic growth in the United States will be very much slower for the foreseeable future. That movement closes with this passage:

Even without long-lasting effects from the crisis, the official projections may be on the rosy side. An analysis by John Fernald, a senior research adviser at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, is largely agnostic about whether the impact from the financial crisis will last. But Fernald also raises another troubling point: that productivity growth had been slowing even before the crisis hit in 2007.

Fernald estimates that, as a result of the slowdown in productivity growth (along with an aging population), in the long run we should expect annual growth to average only 2.1 percent. Yet government forecasts are higher. The White House is projecting long-term growth of 2.5 percent per year, and the CBO puts it at 2.4 percent.

These differences may seem small, but don’t forget the power of compound interest (which has large consequences for income) or the budget deficit’s sensitivity to growth (which is surprisingly acute). Over the next decade, if Fernald is right, the deficit will be about $1 trillion larger than official projections suggest. Keep in mind, his analysis takes a benign view on whether the crisis itself will further diminish income in the long run.

Very slow real economic growth has a number of implications. For example, it casts real doubt on the 8% nominal growth assumed by many public pension plans. Most of all very slow real growth, at or near zero, means that cuts mean real reductions. The customary Washington usage of cuts meaning “reductions in the rate of growth” won’t work.

Here’s the allegro giocoso:

Which brings me back, once again, to the idea of a barbell fiscal policy. Policy makers in Washington should couple substantial upfront stimulus spending with even bigger, but delayed, deficit reduction. Both ends of this barbell are crucial: The stimulus can help to reduce the lasting effects of the crisis, and, given that the official deficit projections may be too sunny, the austerity will help prevent a future fiscal crisis. Furthermore, the combination is more politically feasible than either component alone.

I think that Dr. Orszag forgets that politicians are deaf in one ear. With their good ear they’ll hear “upfront stimulus” but “bigger, but delayed, deficit reduction” will fall on the deaf ear because, as noted above, in a period of very slow or no growth, cuts mean actual cuts.

What’s the solution? As I have been saying for some time, we need stimulus without deficits as proposed by Paul Samuelson many years ago, effected by replacing relatively nonproductive spending on agriculture, defense, healthcare, and education with more productive stimulus. I’ll leave what those might be to the reader but my favorites are things like energy production, improvements to the power grid, and telecommunications improvements, measures that will aid the economy of the future.

7 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

0 comments