Sooner Than You Think

Do you remember when I asked when would be the first time that somebody was killed by a drone within the United States? It may be sooner than we think. In a report on the succcessful rescue of a child from a kidnapper following a lengthy stand-off with law enforcement officers there’s this snippet:

The FBI had borrowed from the U.S. military high-tech detection equipment similar to the technology used to discover homemade bombs in war zones, three Defense Department officials told CNN.

It was unclear whether the equipment, which is not readily available to civilian law enforcement, had been used by the FBI.

One of the defense officials said no members of the military were involved in the rescue. They would have been acting a technical advisers, the official said.

Earlier reports had suggested that a military drone had been used.

Note the key phrase, “which is not readily available to civilian law enforcement”. I think there are open questions. Is the equipment legally available to civilian law enforcement? Is making the equipement available a violation of federal law? From 18 U.S.C. § 1385 Section 15:

Sec. 15. From and after the passage of this act it shall not he lawful· to employ any part of the Army of the United States, as a posse comitatus, or otherwise, for the purpose of executing the laws, except in such cases and under such circumstances as such employment of said force may be expressly authorized by the Constitution or by act of Congress ; and no money appropriated by this act shall be used to pay any of the expenses incurred in the employment of any troops in violation of this section and any person wilfully violating the provisions of this section shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and on conviction thereof shall be punished by fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars or imprisonment not exceeding two years or by both such fine and imprisonments.

I find blurring the line between military and civilian imprudent to say the least even in a good cause.

7 comments

The Weather-Predicting Donkey

Back when I was a kid there was a novelty item you’d occasionally see at fairs or in souvenir stores—a “weather-predicting donkey”. Just a crude cut-out of a donkey, maybe a little paint for expression, and a piece of string attached to the hindquarters as a tail. The thing would be captioned:

Donkey’s tail dry: Sunny
Donkey’s tail wet: Rain
Donkey’s tail frozen: Cold
Donkey’s tail blows off: Tornado

I do not believe that the statistics produced by, for example, the Bureau of Labor Statistics are quite that crude. I do think, however, that there is an exaggerated sense of how precise the figures that they’re producing are. They might be accurate to the hundred thousand. Or maybe just within that order of magnitude.

There’s still no substitute for street smarts. If you know a lot of people who are unemployed or underemployed, there probably aren’t enough jobs in your neck of the woods whatever the aggregate statistics might say. If there are a lot of “For Sale” signs on your block, it’s a fair indicator of a weak housing market, at least where you live.

I no longer believe that the Dow-Jones Industrial Average measures anything in the real economy. I honestly don’t know what it measures any more.

12 comments

The Cost of an Unstable Dollar

One of the better arguments I’ve read against the Chartalists and Folk Keynesians lately is here. Here’s the conclusion:

American investors and businessmen do not have lower IQs today than they did in 1966. An unstable currency makes them stupid. An unstable dollar induces both short-term thinking and malinvestment.

The American economy will not grow normally, create jobs normally, and convert investment dollars into real assets normally until we once again have a stable dollar. Until then, our economic nightmare will continue.

I don’t think that a hard metal currency is necessary to have a stable currency. What you do need is commitment and that’s what’s lacking.

22 comments

Explain Japan

If fiscal stimulus is so effective in spurring economic growth, explain Japan.

18 comments

How to Spend Money We Don’t Have

Among the many well-intentioned but IMO ill-considered ways of stimulating the economy I’ve been reading about, one that I find particularly poorly thought out is to hire more teachers and police officers.

There is no straight line relationship between teachers and educational performance or police officers and public safety. There’s scholarship suggesting that cutting class sizes in half would improve educational performance but not much saying that reducing classroom sizes by one student results in improvement. Nobody is talking about cutting class sizes in half—they’re talking about reducing class sizes by a student or two.

If there’s a relationship between police officers and public safety it’s an inverse relationship. Chicago has the highest number of police officers per 100,000 population of any city in the United States. Higher than New York or Los Angeles or Philadelphia or Detroit and much higher than Dallas or Miami or, indeed, any southern city. It also has the highest intentional homicide rate among major cities and higher rates of violent crime, generally.

While I’m on the subject it is simply untrue that we’ve been skimping on healthcare or education or infrastructure over the last 30 years in the United States. That’s a lie. We spend more in real terms in all three of those areas than we did 30 years ago, in the cases of healthcare and education more per capita by a several multiples in real terms. Our problem in those areas is much more insidious: we’re not getting value for the money we spend.

The most significant reason that the federal government shouldn’t spend more to “put cops on the streets” or hire more teachers can be stated in one, simple question: what happens next year? Those cops and teachers have wages to pay, healthcare to support, the cost of which is not under control, and unaffordable pensions. Those pensions will need to be paid long after the federal appropriation runs out and when interest rates are much, much higher than they are now. How could they not be? What happens then? The cities are already strapped.

7 comments

CSI: Leicester

The human remains discovered beneath a parking lot in Leicester, England have been confirmed as those of the 15th century English king, Richard III:

A skeleton found beneath a Leicester car park has been confirmed as that of English king Richard III.

Experts from the University of Leicester said DNA from the bones matched that of descendants of the monarch’s family.

Lead archaeologist Richard Buckley, from the University of Leicester, told a press conference to applause: “Beyond reasonable doubt it’s Richard.”

Richard, killed in battle in 1485, will be reinterred in Leicester Cathedral.

Mr Buckley said the bones had been subjected to “rigorous academic study” and had been carbon dated to a period from 1455-1540.

Dr Jo Appleby, an osteo-archaeologist from the university’s School of Archaeology and Ancient History, revealed the bones were of a man in his late 20s or early 30s. Richard was 32 when he died.

His skeleton had suffered 10 injuries, including eight to the skull, at around the time of death. Two of the skull wounds were potentially fatal.

No hunchback or withered arm, as he’s been portrayed over the centuries, but he did have scoliosis. The cause of death was sharp force trauma.

Researchers are confident not only because of the carbon-dating and physical findings but DNA analysis as well.

1 comment

Zuckerman’s Retort

No doubt chastened by the tongue-lashing I gave his last op-ed, in his latest op-ed Mort Zuckerman fleshes out his ideas about spending on infrastructure and education a bit more:

  • Create a federal bank that would take advantage of the low interest rates to dramatically increase private and public capital for new construction. Repair the infrastructure we have. In effect, we must create a domestic Marshall Plan devoted to profitable investments in the national electric grid and fracking infrastructure; in high-speed Internet; in bridges, roads, and tunnels; in airports and high-speed rail; and in human capital. Such a program would increase employment because of the well-documented investment accelerator/multiplier effects.
  • Increase investment in education, especially vocational training and postsecondary education, strengthening science, technology, engineering, and math in high schools and at the university level.
  • Stop talking about tax reform, and do it! Broaden the base and get rid of the loopholes, deductions, and credits—and the inherent corruption related to them—so as to enable lower marginal tax rates.

I actually think that these ideas have merit if they could be realized. I don’t think they can and I’ll list some reasons why I don’t think we should expect them to be:

  • State and local governments already spend plenty on infrastructure maintenance. They spend even more on state employee wages, healthcare, and pensions. That pattern is likely to persist. Governments don’t maintain infrastructure because they’re too busy paying payrolls of present and past employees.
  • The federal government is much, much more likely to put lots of jack into highly visible infrastructure projects (roads and bridges) than it is to invisible improvements in energy and telecommunications infrastructure. Your Congressman wants to be able to point to a new expressway to show the voters how he or she “brings home the bacon”. You can’t point to system resiliency.
  • That private investors aren’t already building highspeed rail suggests either that a) they don’t think it’s a money-making investment or b) they expect federal, state, and local governments to do it for them.
  • China’s experience with highspeed rail should really give us pause. They’ve spent boatloads of money for a dangerous system that isn’t buying them much.
  • The pattern of the last 20 years (at least) is that most of the additional money we’ll spend on education will be spent on administrators. I know of no scholarship that suggests that spending more on administrators delivers more education.
  • College grads, including science, technology, and math grads, are having problems finding jobs. Graduating more to be unemployed does not sound like a good investment to me.
  • While there is some evidence that cutting the typical class size in half could improve outcomes, the evidence that reducing the typical class size by one or two students will improve outcomes is not particularly strong. There is no prospect whatever that we will spend the money to cut typical class sizes in half.
  • Every loophole, deduction, and credit has a constituency for which it is a matter of life and death and is already mobilized to defend it. That’s why we’re already a decade overdue for a major overhaul in the tax code.
2 comments

The Department of War

From 1789 to 1949 the United States had a Department of War. In 1949 the department was dissolved, the Navy was brought into a unified command structure with the Army and Air Force, and the Department of Defense was formed. 1949 was also the year in which George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty Four was published.

I think it would be beneficial to return the DoD to the old name: Department of War.

I’m at a loss to come up with a name for the Department of Homeland Security that would describe what it really does. Department of Security Theatrics?

I’m taking nominations for a renaming of the DHS.

8 comments

The End of U. S. Copyrights? Or the End of the WTO?

The headline is pretty dry: the tiny Caribbean nation of Antigua has won a settlement in its World Trade Organization case against the United States over Internet gambling. The nature of the settlement strikes me as a pretty Big Deal:

The islands of Antigua and Barbuda are threatening to strip intellectual property protections from American goods as part of a long-running trade dispute over the U.S. embargo on the tiny Caribbean nation’s online gambling industry.

U.S. officials say the proposed copyright haven – whose broad outlines were approved Monday at the World Trade Organization in Geneva – amounts to “government-authorized piracy.” But Antiguans, who’ve won a series of legal victories against the U.S. at the international trade body, reject any suggestion that they’re pirates.

“We have followed the rules and procedures of the WTO to the letter,” Antigua’s high commissioner to London, Carl Roberts, said in a statement Monday. “Our little country is doing precisely what it has earned the right to do under international agreements.”

The U.S. and Antigua have been tussling for years over the ability of Americans to use online casinos based in the Caribbean nation. U.S. laws have long been interpreted to mean that Internet gambling is illegal if it crosses state lines.

The World Trade Organization, however, has come down on Antigua’s side. In 2007, it allowed the islands to draw $21 million a year’s worth of “nullification or impairments” from the United States as a penalty for the continuing refusal of the U.S. to allow American customers to place their online bets in Antigua.

Does this case have the potential to nullify U. S. copyright law? Or could it bring down the WTO itself? I haven’t been able to locate the precise wording of the settlement but here’s the sort of scenario I’m envisioning.

Imagine that some gazillionaire or, possibly, a group of individuals with the appropriate mindset approach the Antiguan government. In exchange for $21 million a year paid to the Antiguan government they set up shop there. They then purchase legal copies of every American copyrighted item they can put their hands on, strip the notifications, and put them online, available for free download. No law will have been broken by anyone. Technically, there’s no piracy. As the lawyer for the Antiguan government put it: “It’s not piracy if you have the right to do it.”

The U. S. government might be able to enact laws prohibiting Americans from accessing the sites (imposing a competitive disadvantage on Americans that would be unenforceable outside the U. S.). I doubt that such prohibitions could be made effective. Such prohititions would also make American complaints about the “Great Firewall of China” ring pretty hollow.

An important question: does the settlement pertain only to copyrighted materials but to patented ones as well? If the latter, the damage that would be done to the U. S. pharmaceutical industry could be substantial. Lots of pharmaceutical companies set up shop here because of robust U. S. intellectual property law. If the law becomes highly porous, that incentive could vanish.

Worse, every country that won a trade settlement against the U. S. would want the same deal.

I’ve made no secret of my dislike for United States’s present copyright laws. I wouldn’t want them to be subverted in this way. Even if the U. S. knuckles under to Antigua’s demands on Internet gambling that wouldn’t end the matter. As I wrote above, every country would want the same kind of deal. As I see it the solution is to make U. S. intellectual property law a less attractive hostage.

3 comments

About That GDP Decline…

As has been reported, U. S. gross domestic product declined by .1% in the fourth quarter of 2012. Some of the decline has been dismissed as being a result of decreased defense spending. For some reason I don’t recall the people who are making that particular argument as dismissing third quarter 2012 GDP growth as being a result of increased defense spending.

Probably just a trick of the mind.

7 comments