More Questions for Brennan

Mary Ellen O’Connell follows up her op-ed on CNN.com with an op-ed in the New York Times. Here’s a snippet:

When Hellfire missiles were first used in drone strikes to kill outside a combat zone — in Yemen, in 2002 — six men died, including an American. A United Nations special rapporteur declared the action unlawful, but C.I.A. drone attacks have increased substantially since then: the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, a nonprofit news organization in London, estimates the number of persons killed in drone attacks at 3,000 to 4,500, including well over 200 children.

Today, the United States is involved in a true armed conflict only in Afghanistan. Yet drone attacks have been carried out in Yemen, Somalia and Pakistan and may soon begin in Libya, Mali and Nigeria. None of these countries have attacked America, so no right of self-defense can be invoked under the United Nations Charter, as the white paper asserts.

The Bush administration memos that attempted to justify torture, indefinite detention and illegal wiretapping have been widely rejected. How, then, can Mr. Brennan and other advisers to Mr. Obama (a former lecturer on constitutional law) condone this spurious effort to justify targeted killings?

Terms like “armed conflict,” “combat” and “battlefield” are integral to the proper functioning of human rights law and international humanitarian law, including the Geneva Conventions. Such definitions are well established and can no more be tampered with to suit the administration’s preferences than can the definition of torture. Sadly, the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, which under Mr. Bush drafted the notorious memo that narrowly construed torture as severe pain causing “organ failure, impairment of bodily function, or even death,” has now, under Mr. Obama, drafted the targeted-killings document.

Whether you agree or not, I think she’s raising some important issues.

My own view is that, first and foremost, the Patriot Act should be repealed. We must have limits to what is done in the name of national security and two successive administrations have stretched the provisions of the Patriot Act far beyond what I believe it was intended to accomplish. I’d like to see Congress exercising more scrutiny but when even bipartisan calls for more openness on the part of the administration and enhanced scrutiny are met with claims of partisan or even racial bias, it’s hard to envision that taking place.

6 comments

We Should All Be Issued Banjos

When I read this article:

From a small Spring Valley factory, the Deering Banjo Co. is having its best year ever, defying the U.S. skills gap and California’s manufacturing doldrums. It has expanded and trained its own workforce and expects to top $4 million in sales for the year ending June 30.

I immediately thought of these Peanuts cartoons:

I think a lot of us could use a banjo right about now.

12 comments

The 2013 State of the State Address

I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
I will not fisk Pat Quinn’s SOTS message…
…

Now that I’ve taken care of that, a few quick reactions. In a, roughly, 40 minutes speech Pat Quinn devoted less than a minute to Illinois’s public pension employee problem. Illinois has two problems of paramount importance: its Medicaid system and the public employee pensions problem. The state really needs a reset on its Medicaid system. Increasing the number of individuals eligible, as Rod Blagojevich did, was an error. However, in the final analysis the cost of Illinois’s Medicaid system is beyond its control. Unfortunately, the federal government, on which we must rely for solutions, has decided not to proffer any.

Illinois’s public employee pension problem is within its control. It’s just politically painful for our elected officials to do what needs doing and they’ve decided to hope it will all go away. That’s not nearly enough.

If Medicaid and public employee pensions devour all of Illinois’s budget, none of the other lovely aspirational things the governor mentioned in his speech will ever happen. First things first.

11 comments

Doing the Same Thing, Expecting a Different Result

We are taking very much the same approach to resolving our fiscal problems that continental Europe has and which is being referred to as “austerity”: increasing tax rates and making some half-hearted attempts at slowing the rate of growth of spending without actually reducing spending. Why will that work better here?

25 comments

Alumni Relations

I have one question about this:

Needy U.S. borrowers are defaulting on almost $1 billion in federal student loans earmarked for the poor, leaving schools such as Yale University and the University of Pennsylvania with little choice except to sue their graduates.

The record defaults on federal Perkins loans may jeopardize the prospects of current students since they are part of a revolving fund that colleges give to students who show extraordinary financial hardship.

Yale, Penn and George Washington University have all sued former students over nonpayment, court records show. While no one tracks the number of lawsuits, students defaulted on $964 million in Perkins loans in the year ended June 2011, 20 percent more than five years earlier, government data show. Unlike most student loans — distributed and collected by the federal government — Perkins loans are administered by colleges, which use repayment money to lend to other poor students.

“If you borrow to go to school, it may not be just the government that ends up coming after you if you can’t pay,” said Deanne Loonin, an attorney with the National Consumer Law Center, a nonprofit advocacy group in Boston. “We offer credit very easily.” If the student doesn’t benefit financially from the education, “the government or the school comes after them very aggressively.”

Does increasing the amount of federal money available for student loans decrease or increase the likelihood of default?

This is another problem for which there is a workable solution: an online program offered at low or no cost that confers an associates degree.

It will never be adopted if only because such a program would reveal the intellectual bankruptcy of the idea of higher education for all.

12 comments

The Black Market for Labor

One of the things that strikes me about the public discussion going on about immigration reform these days is the failure to recognize that there’s a substantial demand for off-the-books labor and no conceivable immigration reform will address that. If you legalize all of the immigrant workers presently working here illegally and they all start paying taxes, having FICA deducted from their paychecks, etc. one of several things will happen.

The first possibility is that the workers will take the pay cut. How much are we talking about? Let’s use Illinois as an example. Here in Illinois the minimum wage is $8.25 per hour. If you’re an off-the-books worker receiving $7.25 per hour, you’re costing your employer $7.25 an hour plus some probably nominal amount of administrative overhead. There’s also a risk premium involved but the risks to the employer are so small that can probably be discounted. If the worker goes on the books and everything is on the up and up, all other things being equal the cost to the employer of that worker is $8.25 per hour plus 6.2% FICA, the “employer contribution”, and 1.45% for the employer contribution for the Medicare tax or an additional 7.65%. Total cost per hour borne by the employer will then be $8.88 per hour, $1.63 per hour (22%) more. We’ve already established that the employer is a scofflaw. Unless the penalties are increased substantially and the likelihood of discovery increased considerably, that employer has a powerful inducement to look for another, different worker who’ll work off the books. The new taxes being imposed for ObamaCare make legal employees that much more costly but I don’t even want to get into that here.

The situation for the employee is even worse. The newly on-the-books employee will have his or her pay increased by $1 but that pay will be reduced to $7.61 when Social Security and Medicare are deducted. In addition, there’s 10% withholding on the first $8,700 of income, 15% on the balance of annual income. That means the actual takehome pay for that employee will be $6.79 per hour. For the employee the net effect of legalization is a loss of nearly $.50 an hour. It’s estimated that at least 26% of illegal immigrants are illegally paid below minimum wage. That doesn’t even consider agricultural workers for whom the rules are somewhat different.

Clearly, these employees have a substantial incentive not to seek legalization. Legalization will get them a pay cut and may even cause them to lose their jobs.

The second possibility is that the employer will eat the difference. My little back-of-the-envelope example should be enough to convince you that will not be the case. Consider, too, how many businesses operate on very tight margins.

It seems to me that the third possibility is the most likely: legalization will incentivize hiring other, different, still-illegal workers.

There’s a solution to all of these problems: abolish FICA and don’t even require withholding or reporting for workers earning minimum wage. I’ll leave the calculations for what that would mean in lost revenue to the interested reader.

The bottom line on all of this is that there’s a substantial black market for labor in the United States, our system incentivizes it, and immigration reform is unlikely to change that.

6 comments

Fabricated Terminology

International legal scholar Mary Ellen O’Connell condemns John Brennan and the Obama Administration as being to targeted killings what the Bush Administration was to torture:

Four years ago, John Brennan withdrew from consideration for C.I.A. director because of his leadership role there while serious human rights violations were occurring, including waterboarding and secret detention. Mr. Brennan has said he regrets these practices. Yet he moved from the CIA to the White House, where he began to support a practice many consider worse than torture: targeted killing.

Brennan has been a champion and defender of attacks by C.I.A. drones that have killed thousands of people, including hundreds of children, far from any battlefield. These killings have occurred in Pakistan, Somalia and Yemen. Defense Secretary Leon Panetta has recently said the killing is likely to expand to Libya, Mali and Nigeria.

Panetta, Brennan and others in the Obama administration defended these lawless killings the same way the Bush administration justified the unlawful treatment of detainees. Officials in both administrations have sought to win public support and overcome opposition by repeatedly asserting that what they are doing is effective and lawful. The tactical parallels are striking.

To create an illusion of legality, both administrations coined new labels for unlawful practices. President Bush’s people coined the term “enhanced interrogation methods” to describe torture, and are still asserting that waterboarding is not torture but an effective, necessary tool to keep the country safe.

Brennan unveiled the phrase “hot battlefield” in a speech at Harvard Law in September 2011. A “hot battlefield” is the type found in traditional armed conflicts, where enemy fighters are killed without warning and it is permissible to also kill civilians, as long as their deaths are unintentional collateral damage and not disproportionate to the military objective.

The CIA is killing civilians away from “hot battlefields,” but according to Brennan, there are other types of battlefields that are not “hot” but nevertheless lawful places to intentionally kill targets and unintentionally those nearby.

Read the whole thing.

Mary Ellen is an old, old friend. Haven’t seen her for years. Very smart woman. Judging by the picture she’s holding up pretty well.

She deals mostly with the legal and moral issues. For curmudgeonly pragmatist old me the question of effectiveness is also important. I see very little evidence that targeted killings are effective in making us more secure other than in a tiger repellent sort of way.

Unfortunately, the American people have already expressed their opinion on this subject. Whichever candidate won the election, the killings would have continued regardless of demonstrable effectiveness. Haven’t seen any tigers, have you? It must be working!

27 comments

Shorter CBO

The comedy writers at the Congressional Budget Office have produced an economic projection for 2013 to 2023. Let me summarize it for you: we’re due.

For me the biggest knee-slapper is illustrated in the chart above, depicting annual GDP growth. Let me translate it for you. They’re projecting that economic growth from 2014 to 2018 will proceed faster than it did from 2000 to 2006 and faster than it did for much of the 1990s. Here’s their explanation:

After the economy adjusts this year to the fiscal tightening inherent in current law, underlying economic factors will lead to more rapid growth, CBO projects—3.4 percent in 2014 and an average of 3.6 percent a year from 2015 through 2018.

Why? Underlying economic factors or, said another way, we’re due.

I’m tempted to make a list of the questionable assumptions they’ve made. It would be hard to know where to stop. Let me just give a few:

  • Faster economic growth from 2014-2018 than was experienced from 2002-2006.
  • No recessions from the present until 2023.
  • If there is a recession during the period, it will not be met with fiscal stimulus (otherwise their deficit projections fall apart).
  • Between 2014 and 2017 roughly 250,000 new jobs will be created per month (we haven’t seen anything like that for decades).

For me the most striking prediction: they’re predicting the longest expansion in U. S. history. These guys just slay me.

Of course, if GDP just proceeds along the line we’re on now, all of their other projections collapse, especially debt to GDP and employment. When you predict more of the same, you don’t need much to justify it. When you’re predicting a stunning, history-making boom, I think you need more than “we’re due”.

26 comments

I Wonder…

how you say “rosy scenario” in Mandarin? China’s National Bureau of Statistics is receiving even more criticism:

BEIJING — When China announced better-than-expected trade numbers last month, the statistics were met with outright suspicion from international powerhouses such as Goldman Sachs, Swiss financial firm UBS and Australian bank ANZ. The disbelieving scoffing only mounted days later, when the government unveiled numbers showing yet another positive trend — a narrowing income gap between China’s rich and poor.

Numbers in China have long faced suspicion, from optimistic recordings of visibly hazy air to the age of its Olympic gymnasts. But the credibility of its economic data is now coming under particular scrutiny, at a time when China’s growing global role weighs on investors, analysts and governments worldwide, even as the country’s economy is slowing after years of unbridled growth.

It isn’t merely foreign economists who are skeptical:

Even the man taking over China’s economy — incoming Chinese premier Li Keqiang – supposedly disparaged his government’s Gross Domestic Product figures, calling them “man-made,” according to a leaked U.S. diplomatic cable from 2007, and saying he too relies on rail-cargo, bank-loan and power-consumption data.

When you start relyng on power-consumption data, they’ll start to cook that.

It seems to me that there’s quite a bit of distance between “trying to do your best” and “trying to preserve your life and livelihood”. My guess is that if that were made into a numeric scale from to 10 the NBS is probably around an 8. Whatever the case I strongly suspect that a lot of the problem can be boiled down to incentives. Local officials have incentives to report better results than are actually the case (which is why the local reports never sum up to the national totals). National officials have incentives to report a brighter picture to their bosses than is actually the case (just like here).

When I say that China’s internal contradictions will create a barrier to its development, this is exactly the sort of thing that I mean.

0 comments

Scofflaw

Scofflaw, noun

A person who flouts the law, esp. by failing to comply with a law that is difficult to enforce effectively.

There’s something that’s been puzzling me. How effective is a law likely to be in changing the behavior of someone who is, by definition, a scofflaw? I.e., membership in the class of individuals whose behavior you’re trying to change implies that the individual is a scofflaw; they can’t be included in the class without being one.

2 comments