A while ago I my mention of opposition to natural gas production was met with some skepticism and I’d like to take a little time to substantiate my claim. Several weeks ago Japanese scientists announced that they’d successfully extracted methane from “fire ice”:
Japan says it has successfully extracted natural gas from frozen methane hydrate off its central coast, in a world first.
Methane hydrates, or clathrates, are a type of frozen “cage” of molecules of methane and water.
The gas field is about 50km away from Japan’s main island, in the Nankai Trough.
Researchers say it could provide an alternative energy source for Japan which imports all its energy needs.
To clarify, that’s just another method of natural gas extraaction. Not every one was overjoyed at the news:
The complete folly of our current energy path was once again laid bare yesterday with the news from Japan that the state-owned oil and gas company JOGMEC had successfully drilled under the seabed into deposits of methane hydrate.
Methane hydrates are ice-like solids, a crystalline mix of frozen methane and water. They are sometimes known as flammable ice.
There are vast swathes of methane hydrates buried beneath the Arctic tundra – and there are also huge deposits to be found offshore in depths of 200 to 500 metres.
The US Geological Survey argues that methane hydrates offer an “immense carbon reservoirâ€, twice all other known fossil fuels on earth. That is potentially one huge amount of carbon that could be burnt or released into the atmosphere.
For anyone worried about climate change, the exploitation of methane hydrates is potentially disastrous news. For decades climate scientists have warned of the dangers of how a melting Arctic could lead to climate chaos, by releasing vast tonnes of methane – a potent greenhouse gas.
One component of theory of catastrophic global warming involves methane hydrates AKA “methane clathrates” in the “clathrate gun hypothesis“. Under this scenario global warming would induce the release of vast quantities of methane presently bound up as “fire ice”. The increased amounts in the atmosphere would in turn produce more global warming.
Those who are opposed to developing natural gas production are taking the position that any increased use of fossil fuels is bad, as mentioned in my previous post.

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.




