Who Opposes Natural Gas Production?

A while ago I my mention of opposition to natural gas production was met with some skepticism and I’d like to take a little time to substantiate my claim. Several weeks ago Japanese scientists announced that they’d successfully extracted methane from “fire ice”:

Japan says it has successfully extracted natural gas from frozen methane hydrate off its central coast, in a world first.

Methane hydrates, or clathrates, are a type of frozen “cage” of molecules of methane and water.

The gas field is about 50km away from Japan’s main island, in the Nankai Trough.

Researchers say it could provide an alternative energy source for Japan which imports all its energy needs.

To clarify, that’s just another method of natural gas extraaction. Not every one was overjoyed at the news:

The complete folly of our current energy path was once again laid bare yesterday with the news from Japan that the state-owned oil and gas company JOGMEC had successfully drilled under the seabed into deposits of methane hydrate.

Methane hydrates are ice-like solids, a crystalline mix of frozen methane and water. They are sometimes known as flammable ice.

There are vast swathes of methane hydrates buried beneath the Arctic tundra – and there are also huge deposits to be found offshore in depths of 200 to 500 metres.

The US Geological Survey argues that methane hydrates offer an “immense carbon reservoir”, twice all other known fossil fuels on earth. That is potentially one huge amount of carbon that could be burnt or released into the atmosphere.

For anyone worried about climate change, the exploitation of methane hydrates is potentially disastrous news. For decades climate scientists have warned of the dangers of how a melting Arctic could lead to climate chaos, by releasing vast tonnes of methane – a potent greenhouse gas.

One component of theory of catastrophic global warming involves methane hydrates AKA “methane clathrates” in the “clathrate gun hypothesis“. Under this scenario global warming would induce the release of vast quantities of methane presently bound up as “fire ice”. The increased amounts in the atmosphere would in turn produce more global warming.

Those who are opposed to developing natural gas production are taking the position that any increased use of fossil fuels is bad, as mentioned in my previous post.

5 comments

Ways and Means for Reducing Carbon Output

Returning to a subject I touched on a week or so ago, I thought it might be interesting to explain why I believe what I believe. To recap, I believe that the only strategies that make any sense for reducing the amount of carbon we’re putting into the atmosphere are increased use of nuclear power and various engineering approaches for actively removing carbon from the atmosphere. Or, said another way, that the only way that conservation strategies or subsidies for alternative fuels make any sense are as ways of moving the Overton Window, i.e. setting the stage for other future strategies.

Let’s assume that everything that the global warming folks are saying is absolutely true. I recognize that a lot of people are hanging their hats on wondering whether global warming is actually happening, what role human action has on that, etc. I don’t want to talk about it at all. Just assume that global warming is happening and that we need to do something about it.

What’s the scope of the task? Well, according to the IEA in order to constrain the increase in temperature to 2°C we need to leave between 60% and 80% of proved fossil fuel reserves in the ground by 2050. Replacing that with other carbon-based fuel sources, e.g. biomass, doesn’t help. While constraining our use of fossil fuels we’ve got to rely on wind, solar, geothermal, and nuclear. Let’s also assume the larger, 80% figure.

The proved world fossil fuel reserves amount to about 22 quintillion BTUs. 20% of that (the most we can consume and meet the goal) is 4.4 quintillion BTUs. Divide that by 40 (the number of years over which we’ll be limiting our consumption in round numbers) gives us 110 quadrillion BTUs per year in consumption. Total world energy consumption is estimated at around 500 quadrillion BTUs per year and rising and most of that is in the form of fossil fuels, coal being the heavyweight champ. Nuclear provides a significant fraction. Wind, solar, geothermal and other low or no-carbon sources are tiny fractions of the whole.

Obviously, we can’t meet that goal by conservation alone. Over the last ten years Germany has only reduced its energy consumption by about 10%.

What would we need to do to reduce our consumption of fossil fuels to the target level? First, all of the countries in the world would need to participate including China and India. Otherwise anything we do will merely subsidize China and India’s consumption and they will just consume more.

Second, we’d need to stop selling and buying anything but hybrid or electric vehicles at all (hybrids actually appear to be stingier than EVs in terms of carbon production but that’s another subject). That really wouldn’t do much, at least not immediately. It would still take decades to reduce the number of gas-guzzling cars and trucks in the entire world fleet to the point at which we’ve really accomplished much (and remember: every year that goes by without actually reducing carbon production means we’d need to reduce carbon production by that much more in future years).

Third, we’d need to impose a carbon tax to incentivize conservation and the transition to new power sources and other transportation alternatives.

Fourth, we’d need to stop building coal-fired electrical power generation plants and phase out the use of the existing plants. As this article points out, the only real practical solution available now to satisfy those energy demands (also remember: all of those EVs will need more electricity than we can presently produce or transmit) is nuclear. The main barriers to bulding more nuclear power plants, at least here in the U. S., are regulatory and legal. There would need to be streamlined approval of new technologies, building sites, and reduced litigation. Even then the time constraints would present formidable problems.

In summary, that means that we’d need to do several things, none of which have proven politically possible to date, we’d need to do them immediately, we’d need to do all of them at once, and even if we did all of that it wouldn’t accomplish the objective.

The key resources required for all of this are money, time, and ingenuity. Under the circumstances all of those are limited. The question comes down to how much money are we willing to spend and how much time and effort are we willing to waste pursuing solutions that won’t work?

12 comments

Sauganash Coyote Watch

Around 4:00 in the afternoon yesterday as I was on my way to the grocery store I saw a coyote in the middle of downtown Edgebrook. Downtown Edgebrook runs along Devon Avenue for about three blocks and consists of a row of two-story buildings. They contain stores, restaurants, some storefront professional offices, a branch of the Chicago Public Library, and a Post Office. Traffic is brisk both on Devon and Central Avenues nearly 24 hours a day.

The coyote didn’t appear frightened but did give the general impression of a motorist who’d taken the wrong exit off the expressway into an unfamiliar and dicey part of town. The motorists didn’t react at all. Either they were accustomed to seeing coyotes in the middle of the day or, more likely, thought it was a dog.

I’m guessing that the coyote had strayed from the forest preserve a block or so south.

7 comments

Whose Ox Gets Gored

Just how comprehensive would “comprehensive immigration reform” be, anyway? Apparently, organized labor isn’t all that happy about the new proposals for immigration reform. They have proposals of their own:

The so-called Gang of 8 bipartisan negotiators were meeting late Thursday afternoon for the second time of the day, and were expected to work well into the evening. Sen. Charles Schumer, one of the leaders of the talks, indicated he hopes to have work on the bill largely wrapped up by Friday.

According to multiple sources, several parts of the worker visa plan laid out by labor, which is led by the AFL-CIO, are proving to be particularly contentious.

Among the problematic union proposals: a 10,000 annual cap on low wage work visas; barring work visas for any trade covered by Davis Bacon, a federal wage law that would encompass most of the construction industry; and creating an unemployment based trigger for work visas that would come into effect only when employment drops below a specific level, which sources said has been proposed at several levels including eight and five percent.

I guess it all depends on whose ox gets gored.

Ten thousand is an absurdly low number of low wage work visas. That’s what’s causing our illegal immigration problem in the first place. Fifty years ago we were issuing a half million work visas a year, almost entirely for low wage workers. What problems would a new immigration law along the lines proposed by the AFL-CIO solve? Wouldn’t it amount to an “amnesty only” bill?

1 comment

Could It Happen Here?

In reaction to the levy on deposits proposed and rejected in Cyprus a Missouri Congressman has submitted a bill in the House that would prevent the Congress from taking such a step here:

The measure from Rep. Billy Long (R-Mo.) was inspired by the banking crisis in Cyprus, which sent shivers through the markets this week when it considered assessing a levy against all bank deposits to help pay for a bailout of its major banks.

On Tuesday, Cyprus’ parliament rejected the idea of taking money from depositors, which some say could result in a quicker collapse of its banks.

Long said Wednesday that his resolution, H.Res. 129, was introduced to ensure the United States never considers a levy on deposits.

“The government should not tax people’s private savings accounts, which they have already paid taxes on, especially for the purpose of funding more bailouts,” Long said. “I was shocked by the news that some countries might be considering these kinds of taxes, and I think Congress should say that this kind of tax won’t happen in America.”

In my view this is solely a bit of political posturing, a useless and unnecessary waste of time. That, unfortunately, makes it very consistent with much of what the Congress does.

Let’s assume, just for the sake of argument, that the Congress is bound by the Constitution. I realize that’s a stretch. The Congress’s powers of direct taxation are actually quite limited under the Constitution, in Article I, Section 9:

No Capitation, or other direct, Tax shall be laid, unless in Proportion to the Census or Enumeration herein before directed to be taken.

amended by the Sixteenth Amendment:

The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

The Congress may also levy customs duties, excise taxes, and fees. Customs duties refer to imported goods. Excise taxes are collected at the time of sale as are fees, as when you purchase a stamp at the Post Office. Taxes on bank deposits don’t fit comfortably under any of those categories. I also think that such a tax would run afoul of the “Takings Clause” of the Fifth Amendment:

No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.

If, on the other hand, you hold to the view that the only limitation on the powers of the Congress are those of the imagination, the Congress could do anything it cared to, not only including a graduated levy on bank deposits but also ignoring prior laws against such actions. In either case the law would be meaningless.

24 comments

Asking the Important Questions

…to crib a line from Glenn Reynolds. io9 wonders “Can you live on beer alone?” Judging by the example of my freshman year roommate I would have thought the answer was “Yes” but, apparently, it isn’t. If the dehydration doesn’t get you, the scurvy will.

12 comments

The Ostrich Strategy

Here’s an interesting little factoid:

In theory, a new personnel system, a flatter hierarchy and the elimination of duplication and overlap should increase federal productivity. But Congress and the president will never know the savings unless they order the Bureau of Labor Statistics to start measuring federal productivity again. The bureau shelved its long-running productivity project in 1994 and has not added a data point since.

If you don’t keep track of it, that must mean that it’s just hunky-dory, no?

2 comments

Puzzled, Again

I’ve run across another diction that puzzles me. Does “unthinkable” mean that you should do everything in your power to avoid whatever it is or does it mean that you just don’t want to think about it and hope it all goes away?

Example: The sequester is unthinkable.

1 comment

Learned Nothing

There are different categories of wrongness. People can be wrong for the right reasons. They can be wrong for the wrong reasons. And, worst of all, they can be wrong without conviction because they benefit by being wrong.

Right now on its tenth anniversary we’re being deluged by analyses, apologies, and apologias of just how disastrous invading Iraq was. Some are heartfelt, like Andrew Sullivan’s, to his credit. Most are far from that.

In my view the worst of the worst, worse than the reviled neocons, worse than the ordinary people who just went along, are the members of the Senate Democratic Caucus. Every Democratic Senator who wasn’t in a safe seat and had presidential aspirations voted in favor of invading Iraq. I don’t believe for a moment their protestations that they were bamboozled by the Bush Administration. They knew what the Bush Administration knew. They made their decisions and I believe that they made them solely in the hope of political gain or the fear of political loss. They are schmucks. Two of the schmucks have since been appointed Secretary of State, presumably their consolation prizes for not becoming president.

Most of the major Left Blogosphere bloggers of the time supported the invasion of Iraq as I documented years ago. Josh Marshall. Kevin Drum. Matthew Yglesias. That brings me around to Ezra Klein:

I supported the Iraq War, and I’m sorry.

I have my excuses, of course. I was a college student, young and dumb. I thought that if U.S. President George W. Bush and Secretary of State Colin Powell and former President Bill Clinton and U.K. Prime Minister Tony Blair all thought it was necessary, then that was because they had intelligence proving as much. I thought there was no way the Bush administration would neglect to plan for the obvious challenges of the aftermath. I turned on the war quickly when I saw how poorly and arrogantly it was being managed.

Youthful folly can be excused. Outspoken youthful folly is hubris and is far more difficult to forgive. He has shown no signs of contrition other than verbal ones. Let me supply a less self-serving explanation for his change of view: his views changed when the positions of Democratic Party leaders did. He was just falling into partisan line. He’s been rewarded for his loyalty. He has learned nothing.

All signs suggest that Americans, generally, have learned nothing:

Opinions about the use of military action to prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons also have not changed much in recent years. Currently, 64% say it is more important to prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons, even if it means taking military action; 25% say it is more important to avoid a military conflict with Iran, even if it means they may develop nuclear weapons.

War is a dirty, ugly, horrifying, wasteful, vicious matter. There is no glory in it and it certainly should not be waged for gain—whether political, geopolitical, or economic. There is exactly one reason to wage war: because you have no other choice. Clearly, that’s a lesson we have yet to learn.

54 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments