The Search

Like many people last night my wife and I watched the live television coverage of the capture of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, the younger of the two immigrant Chechen brothers suspected of being behind the bombs that killed three and maimed and injured so many more at the finish line of the Boston Marathon earlier this week:

The surviving suspect in the Boston Marathon bombing remained hospitalized with serious injuries this morning as the hunt for answers goes full tilt to discover why the alleged terrorists turned against a country they once embraced.

Police captured Dzhokhar Tsarnaev Friday night, ending a tense, five-day drama that gripped Massachusetts with fear and rekindled the specter of terror across the nation. He and his brother Tamerlan Tsarnaev, killed in an earlier gun battle with police, are Chechens who came to the U.S. and – for a time – seemed to want to succeed in America.

“I’m in complete shock,” said Rose Schutzberg, 19, who graduated high school with Dzhokhar and now attends Barnard College in New York. “He was a very studious person. He was really popular. He wrestled. People loved him.”

Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, 19, was found about 8:45 p.m. holed up in a covered boat stored in the backyard of a Watertown, Mass., residence. He was led to an ambulance and driven to a hospital, where he is listed in serious condition.

Although at a thousand miles’ distance the evidence against the surviving brother looks pretty damning we don’t know whether he was, in fact, responsible for the bombs, whether he and his brother were the only ones involved in the attack, or, if they were those solely responsible, why they did it. The search for answers goes on.

For some that the two brothers were, evidently, devout Muslims is explanation enough. Or that they were ethnic Chechens and that Chechnya has been wracked by war, extremism, and terrorism for decades. The Wall Street Journal explains their actions this way:

But the patriarch of the family, a talented auto mechanic named Anzor Tsarnaev, struggled to make a living. Tamerlan, his eldest son, failed to make a career out of boxing, dropped out of community college for lack of money and struggled to find work.

Living on public assistance in a multifamily house in Cambridge, the family began to fray, friends said. The parents separated. Anzor Tsarnaev returned to Russia, battling illness.

Along the way, Tamerlan’s attitude seemed to sour. “I like the USA,” he told the Lowell Sun newspaper in 2004 while competing in a boxing tournament shortly after arriving in the U.S. “America has a lot of jobs.” But a caption accompanying an online photo of him a few years later reads: “Originally from Chechnya, but living in the U.S. since five years…I don’t have a single American friend, I don’t understand them.”

Ruslan Tsarni, an uncle of the two brothers, told reporters outside his Maryland home Friday that his nephews were “losers” who were unable to settle into American life “and thereby just hating everyone who did.”

In the words of the WSJ, their lives unravelled. If lives that have unravelled are a sufficient explanation for committing gruesome acts of terrorism, we’re in a world of hurt. Today millions of Americans have had their lives unravel.

It has emerged that the older of the two brothers had been questioned by the FBI for his ties to terrorism, motivated by tips received from a country that has not been identified (I suspect Canada) and that an arrest for domestic violence was sufficient grounds for his deportation. If this case does not figure in our deliberations over immigration reform, we really need to question our priorities. I think that an immigration policy should be tailored to the needs of the American citizenry rather than the needs of the immigrants. Present policy does not do this.

Yesterday the city of Boston was, literally, shut down by the manhunt for Dzhokhar Tsarnaev. Today the search goes on. Now we’re looking for answers.

56 comments

Noah, This Is the Lord

“How long can you tread water?”

Chicago is having a rainfall of historic proportions:

The Chicago region was pounded by rain overnight, with as much as one inch per hour falling, flooding underpasses and closing major roadways.

“Unfortunately it looks like we’re going to be stuck in this (weather) pattern through the morning and possibly into the afternoon,” said Kevin Birk, a National Weather Service meteorologist.

The nearby Edens Expressway is flooded; cars stalled in the underpass are completely under water. Our backyard is covered with between one and five inches of water. When we awoke at 4:00am in front of our house the street was completely filled with water, the sidewalks were covered, and the water had risen to cover portions of our front lawn.

One of our cars started fine; the other won’t turn over. I’m guessing an alternator problem. It’s just too darned wet.

I am now going to walk the dogs. I may wear a lifejacket.

20 comments

Looking Out for #1

or Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

Cruise on over to Politico and read the email from a “television industry executive”. Is it really true, as he claims, that the Twitterverse, blogosphere, etc. are just looking out for themselves while the Old Media are selfless custodians of the public good(“watchdogs of the Republic”)? I think the problem is that the Old Media are practically indistinguishable from New Media. That’s the price of up-to-the-minute news coverage with inadequate local resources to do real reporting. You pays your money and you takes your choice.

As in any other war you become your enemy.

0 comments

Blaming the Tools

One more thing about this post. I think I’ve mentioned before that back when I was in grad school I occasionally tutored social science grad students in probability and statistics. I was appalled at how weak their understanding was and it was clear to me that the level of proof required in the social science had already become or would soon become whatever was produced by SPSS (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, a computer program in common use by social scientists at the time and, for all I know, still used).

Not only has this prediction come true but clearly the standards for everything these days are whatever the tools produce. The standard for a good economics proof is what’s produced by Excel, the standard of a good paper, book, etc. is what’s produced by Word (in mathematics if my eyes do not deceive me it’s still TeX), in presentations it’s PowerPoint.

21 comments

An Economics Scoop

Yesterday the equivalent of front page news broke in the economics world. A paper by economists Thomas Herndon, Michael Ash, and Robert Pollin found serious flaws in the research of Carmen Reinhart and Ken Rogoff which in turn had found that public debt seriously hampers economic growth. The flaws they identified include what appears to be a serious Excel coding error by Reinhart and Rogoff and a charge of using data selectively. The best analysis of the story I’ve found so far is at the Financial Times:

Carmen Reinhart and Ken Rogoff have had a bad day. The two economic historians’ research, which implied that public debt overhangs can hamper economic growth, was perhaps one of the most cited pieces of work in recent years. Their advice that high debt-GDP ratios – particularly above 90 per cent – are harmful to growth, has become a widely used point in discussion. And it’s under attack by a trio at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst – Thomas Herndon, Michael Ash, and Robert Pollin.

As FT Alphaville has noted, the issue is about one of Reinhart and Rogoff’s most heavily cited papers on the importance of debt. This paper has been accused of being the victim of fat-fingered Excel coding, as well as selective use of data and odd weighting of how different episodes are weighted, which seemed – to the authors – to make little sense.

If you’re interested in the subject of public debt or fiscal austerity, read the whole thing.

As you can imagine, anti-“austerians” are crowing. IMO the celebration is a bit premature. I have yet to see any analysis that suggests that public debt is irrelevant to economic growth or that it’s positively correlated with economic growth. The paper mentioned at the top of the post just points out that the degree to which public debt hampers economic growth isn’t as great over the 90% level as Reinhart and Rogoff’s findings had found.

How governments spend money, how much they spend, and its sources still matter.

As I have repeatedly said here, I think that there are times and circumstances when running large deficits is prudent. I don’t believe that means that all government spending is good. Governments can be just as profligate and foolish as individuals. Maybe more so.

Update

Megan McArdle remarks:

In fact, if you are among the many left-of-center people who credit Bill Clinton’s policies for the economic boom of the late 1990s, you believe that too much debt is a drag on economic growth. That’s because the only even remotely plausible mechanism for Clinton’s wondrous powers of economic restoration lies in the 1993 deficit reduction bill, which is supposed to have freed up capital to be invested in the real economy rather than getting absorbed by government borrowing. So if you’ve been excoriating George Bush’s poor economic management, and comparing it unfavorably with Bill Clinton’s responsible stewardship, surprise! You agree with Reinhart and Rogoff.

And you’re not alone. I think it’s fair to say that most economists and wonks think that at some level, government borrowing becomes a problem. And I’d guess the majority think that the problems kick in somewhere around the 100% of GDP mark.

As I’ve mentioned before I don’t think there’s any credible reason to believe that Clinton’s policies resulted in the boom of the late 90s. I think he was fortunate to be president when forces of investment and technological development that had been under way for over a decade finally bore fruit.

45 comments

Remember the EU’s Carbon Market?

Neither do they:

The European Union’s flagship program to fight global warming—a regional carbon-emissions trading system—suffered a major blow Tuesday when legislators rejected a proposal aimed at saving the market from collapse.

After the European Parliament’s rejection, spooked investors drove the already depressed price of carbon emission permits down by nearly half. Benchmark electricity prices also fell.

The legislature derailed—at least temporarily—a plan to revive prices by postponing the issuance of any new permits for between five and seven years. Electricity generators and some other industries must buy the permits to cover their carbon dioxide emissions.

Isn’t that the carbon market we’ve been urged to imitate?

Don’t get me wrong. I’ve been in favor of a carbon tax for decades if only for geopolitical reasons. But carbon markets, e.g. “cap and trade”, have always struck me as mostly a great opportunity for rent-seeking.

Speaking of opportunities this looks like a good opportunity for me to air one of my ongoing gripes. I don’t think that most of the greening of Europe has anything to do with carbon markets or high fuel taxes or environmental controls or conservation. I think that almost all of Europe’s environmental success is due to China. That’s a pyrrhic victory as anybody downwind of China’s manufacturing zone could tell you.

0 comments

Water Problems

I may start collecting these stories. I think that water is likely to be the great environmental story of the remainder of my lifetime. This one’s from nature on the challenges that droughts provide for climate science:

Reliable forecasts of future ‘megadroughts’ would be a boon to farmers and water managers. But results presented last week at the annual assembly of the European Geosciences Union in Vienna suggest that such forecasts are still beyond the reach of current climate models.

Sloan Coats of Columbia University’s Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory in Palisades, New York, and his colleagues tested whether a state-of-the-art climate model could simulate the droughts known to have occurred in the southwest during the past millennium. The model incorporated realistic numbers for factors that affect temperature and rainfall, such as atmospheric carbon dioxide levels, changes in solar radiation and ash from volcanic eruptions.

It also incorporated changes in the El Niño/Southern Oscillation (ENSO), a recurring temperature anomaly in the tropical Pacific that greatly affects weather in the western United States and many other parts of the world. (The warm phase — El Niño — often brings torrential rain and flooding; the cold phase — La Niña — tends to bring drought.) The team then compared the results of its simulations with data from the North American Drought Atlas, a detailed compilation of droughts based on the thickness of tree rings.

The results were puzzling. Although the simulation produced a number of pronounced droughts lasting several decades each, these did not match the timing of known megadroughts. In fact, drought occurrences were no more in agreement when the model was fed realistic values for variables that influence rainfall than when it ran control simulations in which the values were unrealistically held constant. “The model seems to miss some of the dynamics that drive large droughts,” says study participant Jason Smerdon, a researcher at Lamont-Doherty who studies historical climate patterns.

I think I can tell them why. Is bad water management a major factor in producing droughts? I strongly suspect it is. In the particular case of the El Niño/La Niña oscillation I think that a lot is the consequence of a hot spot on the coast of China.

1 comment

The Disruption Economy

According to the Small Business Administration, every year more than 600,000 businesses close their doors. That’s one a minute. Obviously, it’s a normal, commmonplace event.

Entire industries and trades vanishing or, at least, becoming shadows of their former selves has happened regularly. The example most often given is buggy-whip manufacturers. I have not been able to determine whether a buggy-whip manufacturer was, indeed, one of the Dow companies in the 1900s but I suspect that was a line of U. S. Leather.

Printing is full of examples of whole industries vanishing practically overnight. Lithography was supplanted by photoengraving. Offset printing disappeared as digital imaging replaced it. Compare the number of printers shops today with the number forty years ago.

Now imagine a world in which not just individual businesses or even industries and trades vanish but in which complete business models, groups of industries, are failing and being replaced by new ones practically on a daily basis. I think that’s the world we’re in now and that’s what I think about when I read about companies like Aereo that are taking on the broadcast and cable industries:

For as little as $80 a year, his firm allows subscribers in New York City to record programmes and watch live broadcasts over the internet. Aereo rents each subscriber a fingernail-sized antenna, which it houses in a warehouse in Brooklyn.

Television companies loathe Aereo. It does not pay networks for the free-to-air channels it streams. It allows people to receive content without paying for the bundles of channels from which cable firms derive their profits. Broadcasters have sued Aereo for copyright infringement and filed a request to shut down the service (this was denied on appeal on April 1st).

“Aereo is stealing our signal,” grumbled Chase Carey, the president of News Corporation, which owns Fox, a broadcast network, on April 8th. Mr Carey has threatened that if Aereo continues, Fox could turn itself into a cable channel and charge viewers for carriage. Haim Saban, the chairman of Univision, a Spanish-language broadcaster, has said the same.

Why does a one-year-old firm with an undisclosed number of subscribers make media moguls so agitated? Aereophobes see Mr Kanojia’s firm as a pesky parasite that flouts copyright law and profits from distributing content that it does not pay for. Supporters point out these are free-to-air networks, and say Aereo has designed a clever and legal technology to give customers what they want: the ability to watch live programmes and recordings cheaply, and on devices other than a TV set.

That challenge was always inherent in broadcast’s move from analog to digital.

That’s not an isolated example and the professions are not immune. IMO higher education’s business model is not long for this world. The big law firms’ business model has already changed and there are hundreds or thousands of young lawyers standing dazed in the wreckage. One of the insufficiently remarked-on aspects of the PPACA is how much it changes physicians’ business model

Retail has been in ferment for decades. Soon there will only be online sales as exemplified by Amazon.com, boutiques (which are mainly a hobby business), and Wal-Mart. J. C. Penney’s problems, still being covered in the business pages, are that there is no room for yet another commodity retailer. Penney’s is not alone. Sears has the same problem.

The challenge for workers in this environment is not just that you don’t have the narrow skills needed due to the changes going on around us. That’s what’s we’re being told but I think it’s an error. The real challenge is when everything you’ve learned over the last five or ten or twenty years has become wrong.

5 comments

The New Times

All the News That’s Fit to Print That Fits the Narrative

2 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post on the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments