What Goes Without Mentioning

There are contrasting takes on the “Internet sales tax” bill being considered by the Senate at the Washington Post and the Wall Street Journal.

There’s something that appears to go unmentioned in both articles. I understand how requiring online vendors to collect and remit sales taxes will improve the balance sheets of state and city governments. How will reducing retail sales improve the lots of consumers or perk up the economy?

18 comments

Take That!

Chicagoans are taking umbrage at an NYT article dissing the City of Big Shoulders:

Chicago is a great literary city.

Not just because we have many great writers, but because a book review can stir up a real shit-storm here, as in the last few days with the brouhaha over Rachel Shteir’s “Chicago Manuals” in the New York Times. This gang-review of three books is the sort of hatchet job this town hasn’t seen since the Battle of Fort Dearborn in 1812. Or since A.J. Liebling’s “The Second City” in 1952.

Liebling fathered one enduring literary tradition: New York writers lording it over Chicago. Sometimes it happens in book reviews.

But Ms. Shteir doesn’t just smack down Chicago books. She dope-slaps “poor Chicago.”

Ms. Shteir hates it here, the city where she attended college (University of Chicago) and now works (De Paul University). She despises its crime, corruption, expensive parking meters, racial segregation, macho bragging and awful winters.

Welcome to town, professor. Chicagoans hate all of that, too.

Not enough to vote the crooks out of office, of course.

Things that go unmentioned in the article linked above include that the Chicago theater scene has been more vibrant than its New York counterpart for decades. New York’s theater depends much more on out-of-towners than ours does. Other than the Met the classical music scene here, too, is miles beyond New York’s despite New York’s much larger market. The CSO is still the finest symphony orchestra in the country.

New York is no longer the center of culture for the United States. New York is the center of New York. Without the vast federal subsidies it’s enjoyed over the past decade or so it wouldn’t even be that.

2 comments

“Excess” Healthcare Spending

There’s an interesting article from the Kaiser Family Foundation, something I alluded to yesterday, that I wanted to draw to you attention. Basically, the article is pushback against any idea that healthcare costs have been brought under any sort of control:

Health spending has been growing at historically low levels in recent years. The Office of the Actuary (OACT) in the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services reports that national health spending grew by 3.9% each year from 2009 to 2011, the lowest rate of growth since the federal government began keeping such statistics in 1960. Estimates from the Center for Sustainable Health Spending at the Altarum Institute suggest that the slowdown largely continued into 2012, with health spending growing by 4.3% last year. The Kaiser Family Foundation/Health Research & Educational Trust Employer Health Benefits Survey shows similar moderation, with premiums in employer-sponsored health plans increasing by 4% in 2012.

The article goes on to identify “excess” healthcare spending, the rate of healthcare spending increase less inflation and real GDP growth. I recommend that you read the whole article—it’s fairly terse.

The graph above is from the article and it illustrates those three components of healthcare spending increase, i.e. inflation, real GDP growth (measurements of underlying economic conditions), and “excess” growth.

I see a few deficiencies in their model. The most glaring is that they’re sharply underestimating the “excess” growth, particularly over the last ten years. In 1965 healthcare spending accounted for about 6% of the economy, a relatively negligible amount. Now it accounts for nearly 18% of the economy. A simple thought experiment should tell you that, if healthcare spending accounted for 100% of all economic activity, then any increase in healthcare spending could be attributed to the underlying economic conditions which is obviously nonsense. They should be comparing healthcare spending with non-healthcare inflation and real GDP growth rather than the general rates of inflation and GDP growth.

Another thing I’m not satisfied with is in this statement:

It is not surprising that inflation and GDP are significant drivers of health spending growth. Changes in real GDP – reflecting recessions and periods of economic growth – are primarily a function of changes in consumer spending, so it makes sense that consumers will also respond to broader economic changes by adjusting spending on health care as well. This could be a very direct response (e.g., that consumers use fewer health care services as their incomes lag and they cut back on spending of other goods and services as well). It could also be an indirect effect (e.g., employers cutting back on health benefits or fewer people working and more people uninsured during recessionary periods).

and this

Consumers may perceive health care as a necessity in a way that is different from other economic goods, and therefore cut back on health spending only after exhausting other ways of trimming household budgets.

I don’t think we can have much confidence in any statement about the consumer demand for healthcare because, in general, consumers don’t pay for the healthcare they consume directly. That may be the difference between healthcare and other economic goods. IMO the only statement about demand about which we can be reasonably confident is that it would be less in the absence of the massive subsidies, amounting to between 60% and 70% of all healthcare spending, provided by government at all levels.

Nonetheless, I think the article is worth reading.

One more thing to ponder as you consider the level of “excess” healthcare spending. There is no direct correlation between healthcare spending and any output of the healthcare sector, be it life expectancy, reported health of the population, hospital beds, or even procedures performed, e.g. heart transplants, medical examinations, etc. There is a correlation between healthcare spending and total sector wages.

Update

See also here. Note in particular the documentation of the three periods of healthcare spending growth I’ve mentioned from time to time here. From 1965 to 1983 “excess” healthcare spending was 3.1%. From 1983 to 1993 it was 3.5%. From 1993 to 2004, 1.6%. Since 2004, .8%. There’s also a nifty bar chart showing how the “excess” spending breaks down, e.g. hospitals, physicians, etc.

4 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Two Arrested in Terrorism Plot in Ottawa

This is a breaking story but the facts being reported are:

  • There does not appear to be any connection between this plot and the Boston Marathon bombing.
  • The plot was “al Qaeda-supported” whatever that means.
  • Two men have been arrested, neither Canadian citizens.
  • It is being reported that the plot was guided from Iran.
0 comments

Rewriting History

The U. S. Bureau of Economic Analysis is revising how GDP is calculated and extending the revision all the way back to 1929:

Billions of dollars of intangible assets will enter the gross domestic product of the world’s largest economy in a revision aimed at capturing the changing nature of US output.

Brent Moulton, who manages the national accounts at the Bureau of Economic Analysis, told the Financial Times that the update was the biggest since computer software was added to the accounts in 1999.

“We are carrying these major changes all the way back in time – which for us means to 1929 – so we are essentially rewriting economic history,” said Mr Moulton.

The changes will affect everything from the measured GDP of different US states to the stability of the inflation measure targeted by the Federal Reserve. They will force economists to revisit policy debates about everything from corporate profits to the causes of economic growth.

The change they’re making involves capitalizing research and development and the category referred to as entertainment, literary and artistic originals. Formerly, R&D was counted as a cost of doing business. Going forward it will be treated as an investment.

Another aspect of the revision is that they will count what has been promised in pensions as liabilities rather than just what is paid into the plans. That could have a drastic effect on what’s shown for states with large, underfunded public pension plans, e.g. California and Illinois.

Nobody really knows how the change will affect what we think we’ve always known or, indeed, whether it will be a better indication of economic events than the old approach was. With any luck it will highlight how perverse some of our policies have been.

10 comments

The Amazing Vanishing Production Gap

This post from RealClearMarkets makes a very interesting point:

America’s jobs figures reveal more than high unemployment, they show a declining productive capacity. Job loss remains a major U.S. problem, but the loss of productive capacity, which lies beneath it, is an even greater and longer-term problem. And unlike unemployment, it is something the vagary of statistics cannot long hide.

March’s jobs report showed a curious anomaly: low job growth (just 88,000), yet a fall in the unemployment rate from 7.7% to 7.6%. The reason such a push-me-pull-you result could occur was a fall in labor force participation by 663,000 and in the participation rate from 63.5% to 63.3%.

Looking askance at this interaction is not looking a gift horse – job creation and unemployment’s rate fall – in the mouth. It is about asking a fundamental question: How long is the continuing decline in America’s productive capacity sustainable?

If you are to maintain a Keynesian strategy for dealing with our present economic doldrums, you must maintain that there is a gap between present potential production and our present production. The usual illustration of this is to extend 2007 GDP in a straight line and point out the separation between where that line would be now and present GDP.

The large of number of unemployed persons is taken as prima facie evidence that the production gap such an illustration reveals is something real. My position is that at least some of that gap is, in fact, illusory, the product of the housing/financing bubble. Nothing in Lord Keynes’s theory suggests that you will increase production beyond the supposed production gap by boosting aggregate demand.

As the number of people in the labor force and the labor force participation rate shrinks doesn’t the production gap shrink along with them?

17 comments

What Could Possibly Go Wrong?

Well, let’s see. The big banks rather clearly lied, at least some of the time:

One of the lingering questions from the financial crash is whether the banks that sold junk subprime mortgage-backed securities were honestly deluded themselves, or consciously misrepresented their product. A new paper from the Center for Real Estate at the Columbia Business School suggests that, at least some of the time, they were lying.

Here’s how we know. During the 2000s, a very large share of residential mortgages were originated by relatively thinly-capitalized “mortgage banks” that held the mortgages only until they had a sufficient number to sell to a money center bank that, in turn, would package them into bonds secured by the underlying mortgage cash flows and sell them to investors. In the later years of the housing bubble, the mortgages underlying such securities were heavily concentrated in subprime properties, since they carried sufficiently stiff interest rates to make them attractive to investors after all the supply-chain players had pocketed their fees.

The study’s authors examine a massive $2 trillion database consisting of nearly all non-agency residential mortgaged-backed securities (ones not guaranteed by Fanny or Freddie) sold to investors between 2005 and 2007. The buyers were sophisticated investors, predominately institutions like pension funds, endowments, or middle-market banks. The authors then compared borrower data provided to investors with data on the same borrowers maintained by a large private credit agency. They focused on two specific data points – whether the home was actually the borrower’s primary residence, and the presence of a second lien. Mortgages on second homes or investor properties and first mortgages on homes encumbered by second mortgages are both historically among the more likely to default.

The researchers were able to pair data from the two databases across a very large sample of the loans. They were conservative in their definition of incorrect data. For example, they did not count a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) as a second mortgage – although it is – and they did not label a property non-owner occupied unless the borrower listed a different primary residence for at least a full year after the mortgage closing.

The results showed that 13.6 percent of all the loans misrepresented one or the other of those two data points. More than a quarter of the loans with non-owner occupants were reported as primary residences, and 15 percent of loans with non-HELOC second mortgages were reported as lien-free. (It’s actually difficult for a bank not to notice a second lien.) As might be expected, default rates on such loans were significantly higher than defaults on loans made to owner-occupants and without second liens.

and were rewarded for their malfeasance. What could possibly go wrong?

30 comments

The Search for the Goofus Bird

In an editorial in the Washington Post in criticism of the European Unions flailing environmental policy one passage leapt out at me:

The centerpiece of the European Union’s climate plan — indeed, the only major climate policy that acts across all member countries — is a slowly declining continent-wide cap on emissions. By allowing companies to buy, sell and bank permits to pollute under that cap, the program puts a price on European carbon dioxide emissions. Designed properly, the scheme should encourage companies and consumers to reduce the carbon-intensity of the goods they purchase and invest in cleaner alternatives.

But the Europeans didn’t design the policy properly. For a variety of reasons that E.U. officials should have anticipated, the market for carbon permits has all but collapsed. And in a Tuesday vote, the European Parliament rejected a slapdash rescue plan.

If the continent wants to rediscover its ambition on climate change, individual member states will probably have to do it on their own. But European governments have proved themselves to be incompetent central planners, counter-productive and wary of thinking pragmatically.

The emphasis is mine. There are no such things as competent central planners. The very idea is a contradiction in terms. The act of central planning obscures the economic signals that are necessary for successful central planning. Expecting to find competent central planners is the equivalent of mounting a search for the goofus bird, an imaginary creature that builds its nest upside down and flies backwards.


“For, although common Snarks do no manner of harm,
Yet, I feel it my duty to say,
Some are Boojums—” The Bellman broke off in alarm,
For the Baker had fainted away.

in a doff of the hat to a frequent commenter. Actually, they’re all Boojums.

0 comments

The Worst Case Scenario: Economic Recovery

In an op-ed in the Washington Post Drew Altman and Larry Levitt of the Kaiser Family Foundation warn that recent slowing of the rate of increase of healthcare spending may be illusory:

The idea that we have licked the problem of health-care cost increases is no more probable today than it was in the past.

Our nation has made no fundamental change in how health care is paid for or delivered.

Congress has not passed sweeping legislation to contain health costs, although it did make inroads into moderating the growth in Medicare and health-insurance premiums through the Affordable Care Act (or Obamacare, as it is sometimes known). Increases in Medicare payments to insurance companies, hospitals and other health-care providers are getting trimmed. And the law is fostering a number of small-scale experiments around the country that are showing promise in delivering health care more efficiently. Big increases in insurance premiums for individuals and small businesses are now scrutinized by federal and state officials, and insurers are required to provide rebates if their administrative overhead and profits are too high.

Still, if claims that the health-cost problem has been reined in seem like wishful thinking, that’s because they mostly are.

I think the situation is actually somewhat worse than they’re portraying it. Healthcare spending now comprises upwards of a sixth of the economy, rising towards a fifth. At that scale, a 20% increase in spending rather than a 30% increase, for example, means that half or more of the general rate of inflation can be attributed to increased healthcare spending. That’s something that will only be aggravated as healthcare, buoyed by its massive federal and state subsidies, grows to absorb more and more resources.

The authors go on to suggest that much of the slowing of the rate of increase can be attributed to the slow economy and patients deferring care. If that’s the case, an economic recovery would present a worst case scenario for healthcare spending increases. Healthcare spending would increase sharply, absorbing much of whatever economic growth we managed to achieve.

Healthcare spending isn’t the only area in which economic recovery could pose serious problems. For example, if interest rates rose faster than than income does, interest on the debt could devour the federal budget. We’ve deferred care on the healthcare system and may pay the penalty for it.

2 comments

I Learned Something Today

This morning on ABC’s This Week program, Martha Raddatz said that the Russian authorities had asked the FBI to investigate the older Tsarnaev brother, Tamerlan, in 2009 because they believed that he was in contact with Russian Islamist terrorist organizations. That was always a reasonable speculation based on what had been reported but that was the first time that I had heard a confirmation that the Russians had instigated that investigation.

5 comments