Put to the Question

Yesterday I spent the better part of the afternoon in the endodontist’s chair. You might recall I had some problems in December and January and my dentist and I agreed that a watchful waiting strategy was the most appropriate. I watched and waited and the condition didn’t resolve itself so I determined that I needed to get it taken care of.

I had never had any major dental work done. I have all of my wisdom teeth. I have a handful of fillings, most of them more than fifty years old. Other than that and the twice annual cleaning—nothing.

If you’ve ever had your drains routed, you have a pretty good idea what a root canal is like, just with smaller tools. The dentist drills through the surface of the tooth to expose the pulp or, in my case, what’s left of it. At that point he measures the depth of the roots of the tooth and, using files the thickness of a good-sized thread, he files away the necrotic tissue. The now-hollow tooth was then filled with medicated something-or-other and given a temporary filling. If all goes well in three weeks he’ll remove the temporary filling, remove the medicated something-or-other and fill the space with gutta-percha, the bio-inert sap of a tree, a form of natural latex.

So far, so good.

I think I had the endodontist a bit spooked. Apparently, I don’t process pain the way other people do. I tend to experience a lot more pain for a given level of stimulus than I gather most people do. In some cases I experience pressure as pain. In other cases I don’t feel pain where other people might. I also tend to replay past pain. Once I’ve been in pain, it never really goes away.

I’ve become accustomed to putting up with a good deal of pain. Whatever I felt, I just had the endodontist carry on. The whole experience wasn’t any worse than a typical cleaning. That’s not saying a good deal. Some of my cleanings have been pretty excruciating. Now we’ll see. I hope to keep this tooth. I’m sort of attached to it.

1 comment

How to Make Friends and Influence People

The first paragraph of The New York Times’s account of President Obama’s meetings with foreign leaders really jumped out at me:

Over porterhouse steak and cherry pie at a desert estate in California earlier this month, President Obama delivered a stern lecture to President Xi Jinping about China’s disputes with its neighbors. If it is going to be a rising power, he scolded, it needs to behave like one.

Because scolding and lecturing has worked out so well in dealing with the members of Congress and the Supreme Court.

14 comments

Fed Watching

To my mind the two most significant paragraphs in John Tamny’s post at RCM on why the Fed won’t solve our economic problems are these:

Rather than judge companies on their individual merits, investors must waste valuable time playing junior Kremlinologist in order to divine the future actions of the second rate economists who populate the Federal Reserve. Investors aren’t doing this because our central bankers have any useful knowledge to impart, but because what should be a low-entropy monetary input has become a high-entropy, bull-in-the-China-shop distortion whose actions must be priced.

Far from a driver of positive economic evolution, a Fed that we all have our eyes on has become an economy-shrinking distraction that forces us to consider the macro over the all-important micro. Instead of focusing all of our attention on commercial ideas not yet hatched but that need investment, on existing companies that simply need new direction, not to mention healthy companies that would grow even larger and healthier if entrusted with more funds, investors must, in the words of George Gilder, spend inordinate amounts of time so that they can “predict the exercise of government power” over predicting which technology highflyer will become the next Apple, or which corporation is best suited to cure cancer.

How can the economy grow robustly without federal, state, and local governments making better choices, CEOs being held to higher standards, without our producing more of what we consume, and limiting our consumption (in the instances of healthcare, the military, and education just to name a few) to what we can pay for? The Federal Reserve is enormously influential but I don’t think even it can make that happen.

3 comments

Accidentally Trendy

Imagine my surprise when I stumbled across an article on lovage at The Wall Street Journal (hat tip: Doug Mataconis). I have a seven foot tall lovage plant in my herb garden or, as my wife calls it, “the lovage tree”. It’s been a favorite around here for some time. It has a strong celery-like flavor and its leaves can be used (sparingly!) in many recipes that call for celery.

It’s a perennial but it does die back in the winter time. I’m thinking of trying to dry the leaves this year so I can use them year-round. Maybe I’ll try freezing them.

0 comments

The Futility of Centralized Planning

Over at RealClearMarkets economics prof Jeffrey Dorfman reminds us that not only do centralized planning schemes not work, they cannot work. No matter how much data you gather, how smart your planners are, or how much control you exert, it will never be enough.

24 comments

The Seventh Son

While I was standing in the checkout line at my beloved Happy Foods (as I’ve mentioned before, I’m a daily shopper), their in-store music system which pays a rather unusual selection of material began playing Poor Side of Town. I said to the checkout clerk, a young woman in her early twenties, “I bet that you don’t know who that is.” No one in the vicinity knew. “It’s Johnny Rivers.”

Johnny Rivers, originally John Ramistella, was born in New York in 1942 and grew up in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. He started recording in the 1950s. In the 1960s he had a string of hits including Poor Side of Town, Seventh Son, and Secret Agent Man. He did a lot of covers. A number of his hits were covers of Chuck Barry songs including Maybellene and Memphis. Rivers’s rendition of Memphis hit #2, outselling Barry’s original version by far (it had stalled at #84). His last hit was in 1977.

For my money Rivers is one of the greatest of all rock performers and one of the finest of all rock guitarists, right up there with Chuck Barry, Jimi Hendrix, and Eric Clapton. Few people today seem to know his name. That’s ironic because so many of them are familiar with his music. Frequently, when they think of a Chuck Barry tune, they’re actually thinking of Johnny Rivers’s rendition of it.

Although he was chronologically considerably younger than Elvis or Buddy Holly, musically he was very much their contemporary. And he’s one of the very few performers from that era who’s still performing.

4 comments

The Past Is a Bucket of Ashes

We are the greatest city,
the greatest nation:
nothing like us ever was.

Two hundred years ago 90% of all men everywhere were farmers. That had been true for a long time and even as late as the 1900 federal census that was true in the United States. Two hundred years ago in England there was a political movement among artisanal weavers called “the Luddites” (allegedly after Ned Ludd, a kid who smashed two stocking frames, knitting machines, in the 18th century). The Luddites feared for their livelihoods, worried that they would be replaced by low-waged workers using machine-driven looms. At one point the Luddites were powerful enough that they actually clashed with the British Army.

Over the period since the Luddites destroyed stocking frames and French saboteurs threw their wooden shoes into the new Jacquard looms (from sabot, a wooden shoe), the machines have improved people’s life spans and quality of life enormously, more food is being produced on less land and with fewer inputs than ever before, and only about 1% of Americans are farmers. Despite the low number of farmers, unemployment remains remarkably low.

Recently, a number of people have begun to wonder whether slow job growth not only in the United States but in much of the developed world means that we’ll never have robust job growth ever again. They are, in essence, echoing the Luddites’ concerns. Add Paul Krugman to that list. I won’t link to his recent column, Sympathy for the Luddites, because I’m reluctant to link to anything behind a paywall but you can find it easily enough. Megan McArdle is similarly worried:

Paul Krugman has a column today on a topic you don’t normally get much of from economists: sympathy for the Luddites. Back in 2001, when I sat in on my last formal economics class, this was about as daring a proposition as “Sympathy for the Devil” was as an album title.

A dozen years on, I don’t think it’s quite so edgy. I’d guess that Paul Krugman of 2000 would probably have given short shrift to the idea that we should listen to Luddite complaints. So would Megan McArdle of 2000. Both the later versions, much to my surprise, seem to have changed their minds.

What’s happened in the intervening ten years? Some of my more dour readers suggest it’s the fact that I’ve moved to Washington. But I moved to Washington from Manhattan, hardly a bastion of free market sentiment. And besides, I haven’t stopped thinking that markets are the best way to handle voluntary cooperation.

[…]

The problem is that all the proposed solutions ring hollow. Until roughly the last five years, it was possible to believe that education would be the solution: send more kids to school, retrain people for new jobs. But college graduates aren’t finding it so easy to obtain solid employment either. It’s true that having a college diploma is still much better than not having a college diploma, but that doesn’t mean that by sending more kids to school, we’re actually making the workforce more productive, much less mitigating the problem of economic change; we may just be forcing people to jump over a higher bar to gain access to a shrinking number of jobs. Paul Krugman points out that these days, highly educated workers still have to fear having their job disrupted.

And retraining only works to a point. For my forthcoming book, I interviewed a Danish photographer facing a career crisis. Could he take advantage of Denmark’s generous retraining programs, I asked? He was glum. Your forties are a bit late to be tackling a whole new career; the payoff to investing years in education is simply inherently lower than it is in your twenties. Besides, he had a new baby. What would he and his wife live on while he spent a few years in training?

Paul Krugman’s solution, a stronger safety net, is equally unsatisfying. I’m not arguing for or against a safety net here; I’m just pointing out that it won’t do as an actual substitute for the majority of the population having jobs.

For starters, it is politically difficult to imagine a really large class of people who simply permanently live off the state. The safety net is rooted in human instincts about reciprocal exchange. Of course, it isn’t all that reciprocal–the majority of people who are net taxpayers are extremely unlikely to collect much in the way of food stamps, TANF, or even unemployment insurance. Nonetheless, the moral arguments are founded in the premise that these benefits are for emergencies, and anyone can have an emergency. They will lose political support if you have one group of people paying taxes, and a different group of people who can expect to live their entire life on the dole.

I think that people who believe that high unemployment is inevitable and forever, like Lucy, have some ‘splaining to do. The number of jobs created per month in the U. S. has been at 175,000 for some time. If jobs are no longer being created, how can that be? If “good-paying jobs” (whatever that may mean) are no longer being created, how is it that hourly average wages continue to rise and the number of employees in sectors with good compensation continues to rise?

I agree that we aren’t creating jobs fast enough. I disagree with the explanation that’s being offered which IMO boils down to “we’re doing the best we can under the circumstances”. I find that a heartless rationalization. I think we’re doing the best we can given the policy preferences we’ve put into place.

I have eight nieces and nephews. They’re all in their twenties, all of them are employed at least part-time, and they all have jobs that didn’t exist a century ago. I can think of a hundred jobs that didn’t exist 100 years ago, 25 jobs that didn’t exist 25 years ago, and 10 jobs that didn’t exist 10 years ago. Here’s a list of some of the latter:

  • Social Media/Online-Community Manager
  • Elder-Care Services Coordinator
  • Telework Manager or Coordinator
  • Sustainability Manager
  • Educational Consultant
  • Search Engine Optimization Specialist
  • Medical Biller/Coder
  • Online Advertising Manager
  • Talent Management Coordinator
  • User Experience Manager

See here.

So, what jobs will be created ten years or twenty years from now? I have no idea but I genuinely believe that they’ll be there if we allow room for them. That’s the mistake we’re making now. Our policies are in deep conflict. We don’t produce a lot of jobs for people who can’t read or write English but we continue to encourage large numbers of non-speakers of English who can’t read or write to come here. We know that the jobs of the future will require, at the very least, the ability to read and write in English, numeracy, and basic computer skills and we don’t equip our children with any of those. We know that we’re importing too much but won’t act to reduce our largest import, oil. We devote billions to propping up industries that need to shrink. Our greatest single national problem is not enough jobs, we reduce the return to labor.

To change the outcomes, change the policies.

The woman named To-morrow
sits with a hairpin in her teeth
and takes her time
and does her hair the way she wants it
and fastens at last the last braid and coil
and puts the hairpin where it belongs
and turns and drawls: Well, what of it?
My grandmother, Yesterday, is gone.
What of it? Let the dead be dead.

11 comments

Father’s Day, 2013

As usual, today is a rather glum one for me. My wife’s dad died twenty years ago; my own father died nearly fifty years ago. I was not blessed with children and at this point in my life it’s pretty unlikely I ever will be. There are no fathers here to salute.

My dad died relatively young and quite suddenly, just as he and I were beginning to cultivate an adult relationship. As I’ve seen notices of his contemporaries’ passing at 80 or 90 or even older, it tears at me, like tearing off a bandage clinging to a wound. If he’d lived another ten years or twenty years, how different my life would have been! How much I’d’ve enjoyed and benefited from his unfailingly sound advice and, most of all, from his indomitable courage and unflagging energy and zest for life!

I’ve learned so many things I’d like to tell him, things about our family, things about myself. I’ve even learned some things I’d never known about him, things that took me up short in their parallels to my own life.

Instead of being able to savor relationships with my father or with my children, I’m left to tell my stories to passers-by, to anyone who’ll listen. It’s not much but it’s what I have.

Folks, love what you have while you have it. You never know long that will be.

3 comments

Tax Policy and Income Inequality

There’s an interesting post by Dylan Matthews at the WP’s Wonkblog that I want to commend to your attention. The post is, essentially, a commentary on this paper by Andrew Fieldhouse, a kid who works for the Economic Policy Institute as a “policy analyst”, which finds that the reduction in nominal tax rates for the top income earners of the 1980s hasn’t had much to do with the deteriorating condition of income inequality since then. That doesn’t particularly surprise me but I assume it will come as a bolt from the blue to the youngsters at Wonkblog, basically another word for the Center for American Progress.

Here’s the nugget. Imagine that the tax reforms of the 1980s hadn’t taken place. All other things being equal would that have prevented the increase in income inequality?

So, would we have avoided the increase in inequality over the period in question? Not even remotely. The 1979 scenario lines shows inequality rising a bit more slowly than what actually happened, but the underlying pattern is the same.

“Roughly 30 percent of the rise in post-tax, post-transfer inequality between 1979 and 2007 can be attributed to changes in the redistributive nature of tax and budget policy,” Fieldhouse concludes. “It is still the case, however, that shifts in the market distribution of income are the primary factors driving the rise in inequality.”

Again, not surprising. Sweden has experienced rising income inequality over the last couple of decades, too.

I think the essential problem is that you might increase the nominal tax rate on the highest income earners but it’s darned hard to raise the effective tax rate. That’s especially true when your tax system isn’t just a way of producing revenue for running the government but is also intended to reward good behavior (whatever that is) and punish bad behavior (ditto). People can change their behavior to reduce their tax liability and the higher your income the more freedom you have to do that.

However, let’s assume that tax policy can’t do much about income inequality and, further, let’s assume that you want there to be less of it. What do you do? Mr. Matthews presents his preferred list which, unfortunately, to my eye varies from the unlikely to the downright mistaken.

#1 on his list is increasing the density of trade unionism in the United States. Now, I don’t know what the economic effects of increasing trade unionism in 1930, 1940, or 1950 were but I have a pretty good idea of what they are today.

Think about a rectangle. You calculate the area of the rectangle by multiplying the height times the width. If the height of the rectangle increases, the area of the rectangle does not increase if the width decreases correspondingly. That’s how trade unions have worked for the last several decades. They’ve raised the height (wages) by decreasing the width (the number of people receiving the wage). As I write this we have 20 million people who are unemployed or underemployed. We don’t need to raise the wages of those who remain employed by throwing more people out of work.

Let me present a few proposals from my list.

First, stop redistributing from the top 1% of income earners to the next 9% of income earners. That would require a major overhaul in our healthcare system, either towards a full-fledged national health system or in favor of catastrophic care insurance only (AKA “high deductible plans”). Other things would be required as well, e.g. abolishing the payroll tax or lowering it and increasing FICA max, disincentivizing investment in purely financial assets (as opposed to expanding facilities, buying equipment, doing R&D, etc.), and so on. Sadly, practically all of our healthcare, education, immigration, and trade policy is predicated on the notion that if you redistribute within the top 10% of income earners it will trickle down to the remaining 90%. I see very little evidence of this happening.

Second, stop importing so much. Our high level of imports renders fiscal stimulus much less effective than it otherwise might be. Put more money in somebody’s pocket and it doesn’t increase economic activity so that their neighbors can find a job. Instead it increases economic activity in Germany, China, Japan, and South Korea.

Third, reduce military spending.

Fourth, make producing as much energy as inexpensively and cleanly as we can and distributing it more efficiently and securely a national priority. Not just “alternative energy”. Coal, natural gas, and nuclear, too. Use the proceeds from reducing military spending to improve the grid.

6 comments

The Insecure Thumb Drive

I couldn’t resist posting on this since it ties in with a number of things I’ve mentioned over the years here. The LA Times is reporting that Edward Snowden, Glenn Greenwald’s informant on the secret NSA data-mining projects, smuggled his info out of the NSA facilities on a thumb drive:

WASHINGTON — Former National Security Agency contract employee Edward Snowden used a computer thumb drive to smuggle highly classified documents out of an NSA facility in Hawaii, using a portable digital device supposedly barred inside the cyber spying agency, U.S. officials said.

Investigators “know how many documents he downloaded and what server he took them from,” said one official who would not be named while speaking about the ongoing investigation.

Snowden worked as a system administrator, a technical job that gave him wide access to NSA computer networks and presumably a keen understanding of how those networks are monitored for unauthorized downloads.

“Of course, there are always exceptions” to the thumb drive ban, a former NSA official said, particularly for network administrators. “There are people who need to use a thumb drive and they have special permission. But when you use one, people always look at you funny.”

My clients who are genuinely concerned about security have disabled all USB ports on workstations, have banned Bluetooth, don’t have writable CD or DVD drives on workstations, and, generally, don’t allow any removable device on workstations. Being looked at “funny” as the primary deterrent sounds like a pretty low level of security to me.

How is it that low-level employees (since, by all accounts, Snowden was a low-level employee) are in a position to dictate policy? Where is the enforcement? There is an obvious management problem that has not received nearly enough attention in this affair. We’re seeing quite a bit of that these days.

There’s a certain amount of cognitive dissonance involved on the part of those defending the federal government’s surveillance and data-mining projects. On the one hand you’ve got to believe the government will keep all of this data and analysis perfectly secure while we have the testimony of our sense that’s not the case. We wouldn’t be having this discussion if the government had been able to keep the information perfectly secure.

The NSA’s case is similar. They need all of this information to prevent attacks but if there’s one thing the Boston Marathon Bombing proves it’s that however much they’re gathering it isn’t enough.

There’s a case to be made (not a case I agree with, mind you) that if gathering, collating, and analyzing every sort of electronic communication makes us even a little bit safer, then gather away! What if it doesn’t make us a bit safer? What if it exposes us to new insecurities as, for example, if hackers get hold of the data or the analyses?

12 comments