Blog Post Title of the Day

I’m pretty confident that the blog post title of the day goes to Crooks and Liars for “Texas Legislator Claims Rape Kits Prevent Pregnancy During Marathon Legislative Session “.

I’m also pretty confident that nothing can prevent pregnancy during marathon legislative sessions. Except, possibly, marathon legislative sessions.

0 comments

The Radical Court

I have a question. It’s not hard to find complaints about the radical conservative faction in the Supreme Court (Scalia, Thomas, Alito, and sometimes Roberts). There are Left Blogosphere blogs where such complaints are practically daily things.

Here’s my question. Don’t SCOTUS decisions that are 7-1 with the sole dissent being Ruth Bader Ginsburg weigh against such complaints?

2 comments

Standing

Quite a few smart people are suggesting that the Supreme Court might reject both the DOMA case and the Prop. 8 case on the basis of standing. In a very good Plain English post at SCOTUSblog on the cases, Amy Howe writes:

But there’s a chance that the Court might not even get to the question whether DOMA is constitutional at all. The case may have a fatal procedural flaw. In a normal case that comes to the Court, the party that lost in the lower court is the one asking the Court to review the case. But this is not, as you may have figured out by now, the average case. Windsor and the United States won in the lower court, by getting a ruling that DOMA is unconstitutional. And to make things even more complicated, usually it is the federal government that appears in court to defend the constitutionality of federal laws, but the government isn’t doing that here; House Republicans are doing it instead.

The fate of California’s Proposition 8, before the Court in Hollingsworth v. Perry, seems murkier than DOMA’s. Proposition 8 was a response to a 2008 decision by the California Supreme Court ordering the state to begin issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples. Before the end of that year, California voters had passed Proposition 8’s ban on same-sex marriage. A few months later, Boies and Olson filed a lawsuit challenging the ban on behalf of two same-sex couples who wanted to get married. (My earlier “Plain English” posts on the case are available here, here, here, and here.)

The sponsors of Proposition 8 defended it in court, because the State of California refused. The two couples prevailed in the federal trial court and then in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, with the latter holding that Proposition 8 was unconstitutional because it took the previously granted right to marry away from gays and lesbians just because people didn’t like them.

That might well be the case but I think it would not only be foolhardy on the part of the court, it would be reckless. Having taken the two cases, I think the court has a moral obligation to render a decision on them rather than just letting the decisions of the lower court stand. That could have been accomplished simply by refusing to take the cases, saving time, money, anguish, and the court’s dignity. Furthermore, the effect would be a statement by the court that executives (and judges!) defend and uphold laws at their discretion, an attack on the rule of law.

If the justices believe, as the Obama Administration and the state of California apparently do, that the Constitution is defended by striking down the DOMA and Prop. 8, that’s what they should say.

Update

From comments, reference to a post on the likelihood that justices have their eyes on history in the DOMA case:

It’s a very Legal Realist take on the SCOTUS, in which Adam is basically saying that whether or not the Supreme Court Justices follow the election returns, they definitely have their eyes on the history books (or at least swinging Anthony Kennedy does). Which is consistent with the view my friend Mitu Gulati and I took of the Court in our article How Do Judges Maximize?

and from that post another one on why that could be a disaster:

Allowing DOMA to survive in this way might be an appealing “second-best” option for the Court’s conservatives. They might well prefer a clear ruling upholding DOMA but recognize that they don’t have five votes for that outcome. Kicking the case back to the trial court would enable the law to live on. Indeed, for conservative justices who, like Kennedy, might be concerned about how history will view them, this option might even be ideal. Their reputations won’t be tarnished nearly as much as if they voted to strike down the law.

[…]

A decision not to enforce DOMA would also risk establishing a dangerous precedent. The reason why the administration has enforced the law to date is because that’s the president’s obligation under the Constitution, which says he “shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed.” Failing to enforce a duly enacted law could be seen to violate this constitutionally imposed duty and set a terrible example for future presidents to pick and choose which laws they’ll enforce. Would Obama want to empower a President Rubio to decide unilaterally that Obamacare is unconstitutional and refuse to implement it? Refusal to enforce DOMA could even spark impeachment attempts by a Republican House that already smells blood in the water over the IRS scandal.

which very much echoes what I’ve written above.

1 comment

The Court’s Range of Options

At the San Francisco Chronicle Mark Sherman has what I think is a pretty fair analysis of the Supreme Court’s options in deciding the fate of the Defense of Marriage Act and California’s Prop. 8. I think he’s a bit sanguine about the prospects of overturning Prop. 8 by proposition but otherwise it struck me as a reasonable analysis.

Here’s a prediction: if the court strikes down both the DOMA and Prop. 8 within 60 days there will be suits filed somewhere challenging some state’s laws against polygamy.

17 comments

Power and Information

Given the most recent revelation about government data-gathering and analysis, that Britain’s GCHQ has collected and analyzed vast number of phone calls and shared them with the NSA, it might be a good time to re-read H. G. Wells’s 1897 novella, The Invisible Man. Recall that Wells wasn’t just a science fiction writer but a student of history and futurist. In the novella invisibility isn’t only the power of stealth; it is the power of information. And, ultimately and inevitably, it brings madness and misery right along with it.

The quote of the day today surely belongs to Richard Haass, now president of the Council on Foreign Relations but formerly Director of Policy Planning for the State Department. Speaking on ABC’s This Week in defense of the NSA’s data collection, Mr. Haass noted: “It’s impossible to keep this information secret”. Remember that when you’re assured that every phone call you make and every Internet site you visit will be kept strictly private from local law enforcement, the courts, your competitors, your wife, and your boss.

I wonder how many of those defending the NSA’s data collection and analysis projects have unlisted telephone numbers. What do they have to hide?

You also might want to take a look at law prof Laura Donohue’s explanation of why the NSA’s surveillance activities might be legal but they’re also unconstitutional.

5 comments

Anticipating Supreme Court Decisions

The Supreme Court, as is not unusual, has saved its most controversial cases for last, presumably so the justices can beat a hasty retreat after announcing their findings. Of its eleven remaining cases at least four are of some significance.

In Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin the court has considered a challenge to the university’s use of affirmative action in its undergraduate admission standards.

Windsor v. U. S. is a challenge to the Defense of Marriage Act, which limits federal benefits to opposite sex couples and requires interstate recognition only to opposite sex marriages.

Hollingsworth v. Perry is a challenge to California’s Proposition 8 which limits marriage to heterosexual couples.

Shelby County v. Holder is a challenge to Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act, which requires certain state and local jurisdictions to gain approval from the Justice Department when seeking to change their voting statutes.

There’s a pretty good review of these cases here at The Atlantic.

So far this session the Obama Administration has not done particularly well:

Historically, there is no single litigant more successful in the Supreme Court than the United States. The court usually pays special attention to the arguments of the government’s representative, the solicitor general, whose office is known to have the best lawyers and the longstanding respect of the justices. Studies show that, in the past, the solicitor general won approximately 70 percent of its cases in the Supreme Court. That’s why the solicitor general is often referred to as the “10th justice.”

This term, however, the executive branch has lost far more cases than it has won. Although there are still some decisions to come—and one or two cases are mixed decisions that are hard to categorize—so far the court has clearly decided 24 cases in which the United States was a party. Fifteen of those cases went against the government, while only 9 sided with the administration. That’s a winning percentage of only 37 percent—a huge drop from historical patterns.

Some of that can be attributed to the Court’s faction of more conservative justices. That does not, however, explain all or even most of the administration’s setbacks. In quite a few cases the administration’s positions have been rejected unanimously by the court or by six or seven justices. I think it would be fairer to say that the Obama Justice Department has been pushing the envelope of the prevailing state of the law.

The SCOTUSologists are now predicting that the majority opinion of all four of these cases are likely to be written by justices from the more conservative faction of the court. I honestly have no idea what that might mean or what it sigifnifies as to how any of the four cases above will be decided. With respect to the affirmative action and VRA cases, it was always understood that these provisions of federal law would be temporary. The questions that are now being considered are how long temporary is and under what conditions the provisions will be deemed unacceptable.

With respect to the DOMA and the Prop. 8 cases, what I find most interesting is how they will be decided in combination. If the DOMA and Prop. 8 are both thrown out as unconstitutional, the effective result will be allowing homosexual marriage in all states and territories and under federal regulations and statutes. If DOMA and Prop. 8 are both upheld, the laws of the majority of states and the federal government in this regard will be upheld and the fate of same-sex marriage will remain a state matter.

The circumstance in which DOMA is upheld and Prop. 8 is struck down is IMO the most bizarre. In essence, it will leave same-sex marriage up to the states to decide but will ban their deciding it in any way other than approval. I’m not sure of how to interpret the DOMA’s being struck down while Prop. 8 is upheld.

I’ve stated my opinion on the subject of same-sex marriage here previously: I think the best policy decision is one that abolishes civil marriage entirely.

8 comments

Seeing Things

Have any of you, while awake, sane, and sober, ever experienced a hallucination? Seen a ghost?

Have any of you experienced any form of extrasensory perception, similarly while awake, sane, and sober?

I’ve experienced both. I’ve seen deceased pets, weeks, months, or years after they’d died. I also knew immediately when my dad died. As soon as the phone rang and I’d had no warning that he was even sick.

I think these things are much more common than many people think. By some reckonings about 10% of the population have experienced hallucinations at least once in their lives.

10 comments

How the Leopard Got His Spots

Writing at The Fiscal Times, David Francis reveals the maze of procedures, federal departments, independent contractors, waste, fraud, and abuse that resulted in Edward Snowden receiving his security clearance. There’s every likelihood that nobody really understood the requirements for the clearance and that background checks were never performed. I wonder how expensive getting a security clearance would be if the people who were responsible for overseeing the process actually did anything.

The Senate committee may not have learned much about Edward Snowden but I suspect they learned more about the OPM than they ever wanted to know.

I think that many of the penalties that have been proposed for Mr. Snowden are excessive and hyperbolic but whatever he’s finally indicted for and/or convicted of his superiors at Booz Allen Hamilton and the officials at the Office of Personnel Management responsible for overseeing the process should be subject to the same degree of severe treatment. Not that that will ever happen, of course. One of the purposes of the Civil Service Code is to prohibit personal responsibility.

In complexity, there is safety.

More here at Bloomberg.

One more thing. I strongly suspect that the reason so many outside contractors are used by the federal government is explicit or implicit hiring freezes. Hiring more people to do the work would expose them to criticism for padding the federal workforce. The fees of outside contractors can be hidden in all those billions of unaudited budgets. And after leaving the federal government you can always go to work for one of those outside contractors. It’s perfect.

2 comments

How Not to Solve Problems

One of the things I find so frustrating is the lousy approach to problem-solving we employ. The way I prefer to approach problems is

  1. Identify the objectives.
  2. Analyze the costs of alternative strategies.
  3. Analyze the benefits of alternative strategies.
  4. Consider secondary effects.
  5. Evaluate alternatives taking costs, benefits, secondary effects, and potential roadblocks into account.

Judging by the way Congress approaches problems their method is something like this:

  1. Identify who’s squawking the loudest.
  2. Pick the solution that will quiet them down while providing the greatest political benefit to you.

Take the fractious argument going on over immigration reform, for example. Immigration policy, by definition, is the process by which you determine who gets into the country to live or work and the terms under which they stay. If you were to judge simply by the published accounts of the “Gang of 8’s” plan for comprehensive immigration reform their main objectives are

  1. Legalize the people who are in the country illegally.
  2. Identify their path to citizenship.

Other than a handful of activists does that really solve the U. S.’s immigration problems? I don’t see it.

I think that members of both parties will be bitterly disappointed in the outcome of this latest attempt at immigration reform if it maintains its present contours. If the amnesty of 1986 is any gauge, only a minority of those eligible for citizenship will seek it. It’s really not that important an issue.

I would think that the two most important action items for immigration reform would be how we can get the workers we need and want and how we can keep anybody else out. I’m unquestionably wrong about that.

1 comment

Cui Bono?

Not only does a proposal’s making objective sense not particularly make the proposal more likely to be adopted, it’s practically a guarantee it will not gain much support. That was my reaction to William Hazeltine’s Fiscal Times op-ed on healthcare reform for the United States, based on Singapore’s model:

Singapore teaches us that patients must understand that health services cost money and that they should pay a portion of those costs. It teaches us that hospital and doctor incentives must encourage them to provide the best service at the best price. Government can create a framework of rules that does that. And it does not have to be a cold-hearted solution. The framework must also assure that people have the ability to pay, and it must provide a safety net for those who cannot. Lastly, all health costs and outcomes should be transparent to the patient and the payer.

Who would support such a plan? Not healthcare providers. The sad reality is that any healthcare reform plan that actually reduces costs necessarily means that providers get less money.

Certainly not the elderly. Higher co-pays, even for the wealthiest elderly, will be fought tooth and nail if only on a slippery slope basis.

Not most Americans with employer-supported healthcare. For most Americans, employer-supported healthcare comprises a hefty and rising proportion of their total compensation. Making them pay more or receive less necessarily means demanding that they take a pay cut.

A lot of the increase in costs in healthcare are necessary to support healthcare’s growing bureaucracy. Anyone who owes his or her job to inefficiency isn’t likely to demand its end. And, as I’ve mentioned before, bureaucracies do not scale linearly. The medical bureaucracy for a country of 300 million won’t just be 60 times larger than one for a country of 5 million souls. It will be closer to 100 times the size or larger. That’s a lot of inefficiency.

I guess the bottom line is that it’s a lot easier to implement a sensible plan in a relatively small, authoritarian polity than it is in a large boobocracy.

7 comments