Sauganash Fourth of July, 2013

In the Chicago neighborhood in which I live, Sauganash, the big event isn’t a fireworks display. It’s the annual Sauagash Fourth of July parade. The parade begins with a delegation from the Chicago Police Department, this year followed by several fire trucks.

A vintage firetruck.

The local Scout troop.

Local pols frequently participate. This not being an election year, we’ve just got the sign. D’Amico himself wasn’t there.

I think these pipers are retired Chicago police officers.

Participants from Swedish Covenant Hospital.

As you see.

This year we had the Stanley Cup. Well, an inflatable replica of the Stanley Cup.

The Sauganash Community Church had a delegation.

Here in Sauganash “parade” isn’t a noun. It’s a verb. Consistent with the Irish tradition, parade is not something you watch but something you do. Offhand I’d say at least 400 people marched in the parade. Marchers easily outnumbered us viewers. They also serve, etc.

There were both two-legged marchers and four-legged marchers. Here’s a particularly jaunty-looking fellow.

I’m guessing that the youngster in this photo, pictured here in utero, probably won’t remember this year’s parade. He or she will be back next year.

And, bringing up the rear, the Chicago Police Department.

Tally looks a little glum in this picture but she loved the parade. Fifteen years and three months.

8 comments

Offhand Remark About Egypt

To say that U. S. policy baffles me is an enormous understatement. Can someone explain to me why, after years of supporting Mubarak’s authoritarian regime in Egypt when it lost the support of the Egyptian people, we withdrew our support to give it to the new Muslim Brotherhood government in Egypt which has now lost the support of the Egyptian people? What have we gained by supporting one authoritarian government after another?

28 comments

Bringing the Police Into Disrepute

I’m not going to link to the sickening video of the police officer shooting a man’s dog dead after stopping the man for recording the police officer’s activities. The dog wasn’t attacking the police officer at the time.

I will, however, ask some questions. Did the police officer’s actions bring credit to the force? Did it make it more or less likely that somewhere a police officer will stop somebody walking a dog who will pull a gun and shoot the police officer dead to defend his property?

I think that bans on private videotaping or other recording of police actions are unconstitutional on their face but that’s beside the point. Is this really what we want the police to be doing? Do other police officers really want police officers to be acting this way?

7 comments

Will This Crate Ever Get Off the Ground?

The White House has delayed the implementation of the “employer mandate” of the PPACA AKA “Obamacare” by the simple of expedient of directing the IRS not to enforce the law:

(CBS News) The delay of a key provision in President Obama’s health-care law is being called a major setback for the president’s signature issue.

The controversial provision that requires companies with more than 50 employees to provide coverage or face fines is being delayed by a year. The rule is now on hold until 2015 – after the 2014 midterm elections.

The news came while the president was flying back from Africa to Washington. It’s a major concession in what is considered the president’s signature achievement.

Posted with no fanfare on the White House website, the administration pushed back by one year the requirement that businesses with more than 50 workers provide health-care coverage or pay fines of $2,000 per employee.

The website announcement said, “We have listened to your feedback. And we are taking action.”

The decision marks a shift in the official line on health care, which the president himself stated recently. He said in San Jose, Calif., on June 7, “I think it’s important to acknowledge this is working the way it’s supposed to.”

The concerns that the health-care law was going to hurt workers and the economy were widespread. Some small business owners said they would lay off workers so they had less than the 50 employees that brought them under the new law.

Even business owners who support health-care reform were sounding the alarm.

Earlier this year, CBS News talked to one of those small business owners, Hans Rockenwagner, who runs a bakery in California. Rockenwagner said then, “We want to do the right thing. It just seems that the whole plan was maybe a little hastily put together.”

Perhaps we should start a pool on what provision of the ACA will be postponed next. I’m guessing the health insurance exchanges, supposed to be open for business on October 1 of this year. Their postponement in turn will probably require the delay of the “individual mandate”. Or at least force a lot more waivers on hardship grounds.

Ezra Klein makes a good point in a post over at The Washington Post’s blog:

Implementing the mandate requires a complex reporting process that’s left the administration flooded with comments from anxious employers — even those who offer insurance and have nothing to fear from the provision.

On Tuesday night, the White House solved that problem, at least temporarily, by announcing that that the penalties won’t go into effect until 2015. They say they plan to use the interregnum to simplify and streamline the reporting process. Until then, compliance will be “voluntary.”

But the White House didn’t get an act of Congress delaying the penalties. They simply directed the Internal Revenue Service to refrain from enforcing the penalties.

The announcement came, accordingly, in a blog post by Mark Mazur, Assistant Secretary for Tax Policy at the Treasury Department, prompting Ben Domenech, a fellow at the conservative Heartland Institute, to snipe: “Little known fact: Constitution made Assistant Secretary for Tax Policy [the] fourth branch of government.”

Domenech has a point: This is a regulatory end-run of the legislative process. The law says the mandate goes into effect in 2014, but the administration has decided to give it until 2015 by simply refusing to enforce the penalties.

He calls for the repeal of the provision.

Whether such postponements “happen all the time”, as claimed by the White House, the move won’t foster confidence in a program that’s already on shaky constitutional grounds in any number of areas, many just waiting for implementation for the court cases to be filed.

Update

Tom Maguire notes that the “employer mandate” has been delayed until after the midterm elections: “Thereby delaying employee dumping until after the election.”

5 comments

The Compliant Press

The editors of the Christian Science Monitor complain about the Chinese government’s censoring of its press’s reports of bad economic news:

It is one thing for a government that spies on others to keep that fact a secret and even go after an employee – such as Edward Snowden – who leaks such secrets. But is it right for a government to also deny facts about the economy and then attack the messengers of those facts?

China is the latest example of this problem in which a country tries to defy the demand of global markets for transparency and honesty in financial data. Last week, the propaganda arm of the Communist Party ordered Chinese media not to use words such as “cash crunch” or “inadequate liquidity” in reporting on what has been obvious for weeks: a near-panic in financial markets as the government tries to rein in a shadow banking industry that has doubled the amount of loans in three years.

How different is a press that is compliant with authorities, to the degree of suppressing genuine news that the government finds embarrassing, from that? I would suggest that the effect is no different.

The example of the press’s treatment of President Franklin Delano Roosevelt 80 years ago, concealing the degree to which he was incapacited by paralytic disease, whether poliomyelitis or, as has been suggested more recently, Guillain-Barré syndrome, is well known. It has happened here. Can servile media compliance with the government or self-censorship happen here?

The editors of the Washington Post’s advocacy of jail time for one of its own reporters sources if not a case in point is certainly food for thought. The information is already out there, published by several other newspapers. Is national security a reasonable explanation for the Post’s views? Is there a difference between publishing troop movements and publishing the existence of the widespread gathering of telephone and Internet activity? I think we should certainly be discussing whether there is, in fact, a difference.

Is that the real reason for the Post’s views? Or are they trying to preserve contact with administration sources? Preservation to what end if they’re not willing to publish information that’s damaging or, at least, embarrassing to the administration? So they can publish White House press releases? How different is that in effect from submitting their reporting to a government department of censorship?

My own view is that the press should be neither compliant with administrations nor hostile to them. It should report the news and let the chips fall where they may. Picking favored administrations and unfavored ones like some Star Chamber may be gratifying to the editors of the big news outlets but it isn’t journalism and it doesn’t serve the interests of the country.

10 comments

They’re All Bachelors of Education

You might want to take a long, sobering look at the National Council on Teacher Quality’s evaluation of teacher preparation programs. The review evaluates programs on a number of factors including selection criteria, content preparation, and student teaching, granting a high score of four stars to a low of no stars at all.

Of the 2,420 programs sampled, only four teacher preparation programs in the country received four stars: the secondary education programs of Furman University in South Carolina, Lipscomb University in Tennessee, Ohio State University, and Vanderbilt University in Tennessee. 105 programs received three or more stars and 162 programs received no stars at all.

Considering local schools I found it gratifying that Chicago State University’s undergraduate elementary school teacher preparation program received three stars. A considerable number of Chicago State graduates go on to serve Chicago public schools. On the more sobering side Northern Illinois’s graduate program in elementary education, Roosevelt University’s graduate program in secondary education, and the University of Illinois at Chicago’s graduate program in elementary education all received no stars, meaning that after completing their programs their graduates were no better prepared than when they began.

A number of prestigious and pricey private ed schools in the area received only one star.

It seems to me that this review is useful for a number of reasons. First, if you or someone you know is considering attending one of those prestigious and pricey private ed schools, you might think about just what you’ll be getting for your money. Smart, hard-working students can go to bad schools just as poor, slacker students can attend top-rate schools. Both inputs and outputs are important. But you might as well get what you pay for.

Second, if you or someone you know doesn’t have the budget to attend an expensive school, it’s good to know that there are public schools that have top-flight programs.

Third, tax-payers might be interested in what their tax dollars are buying. That might be especially true in the Golden State where an alarming number of the California State education programs were goose-egged.

This review also highlights a problem with teacher compensation. The smartest, hardest working graduates of top-flight programs are on the same salary schedules as the lowest-performing grads of the poorest programs. The upside I suppose is that the reputations of schools are hardly secrets within the educational community and the school that you’ve attended might well affect how your application for employment is viewed.

9 comments

Unfortunate Productivity

Doug Mataconis laments, at least implicitly, Congress’s lack of productivity in the last and present Congress. In my view a more significant problem is Congress’s unfortunate productivity in prior sessions rather than its present stalemate. Examples I would give of major legislation that has practically no defenders include

No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (NCLB)
The Iraq Resolution of 2002
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002
Dodd-Frank

I’d throw in the “Bush tax cuts” (later, the “Obama tax cuts”) which did very little to help the economy and what it did was short-lived but I recognize that’s contentious. Please feel free to contribute your own examples of “unfortunate productivity”. The best candidates would be those that have very few present supporters rather than laws that are shibboleths for one side or the other.

3 comments

It’s Not the Peasants Who Are Revolting

It’s the middle class. If you’re wondering why there’s so much unrest in the world today, with demonstrations and/or popular uprisings in Turkey, Brazil, and Egypt (and here!), look no further:

The theme that connects recent events in Turkey and Brazil to each other, as well as to the 2011 Arab Spring and continuing protests in China, is the rise of a new global middle class. Everywhere it has emerged, a modern middle class causes political ferment, but only rarely has it been able, on its own, to bring about lasting political change. Nothing we have seen lately in the streets of Istanbul or Rio de Janeiro suggests that these cases will be an exception.

In Turkey and Brazil, as in Tunisia and Egypt before them, political protest has been led not by the poor but by young people with higher-than-average levels of education and income. They are technology-savvy and use social media like Facebook and Twitter to broadcast information and organize demonstrations. Even when they live in countries that hold regular democratic elections, they feel alienated from the ruling political elite.

Nearly every successful revolution has been an out-group of elites throwing out the in-group of elites. That was the case in our revolution, the French Revolution, the revolutions that swept Europe in 1848, and the Russian Revolution of 1917. The peasants tend not to rebel. When they do it’s because they’re starving and once they’re not starving they stop rebelling. They’re much more basic and don’t give a damn about the underlying systems.

1 comment

It’s the Rent-Seeking, Stupid

Rex Nutting, writing at MarketWatch, concludes his post on how the increase in income inequality is the consequence, deliberate or inadvertent, of policy with this:

Ultimately, the next generation at the top will be, the friends, neighbors, classmates and children of the current crop.

The country that once boasted of equal opportunities has re-created a self-perpetuating aristocracy. And that’s not the America I dream of.

a view that, unfortunately, I think is quite correct.

The bulk of the post is largely contrasting two different explanations for the growth of income inequality in recent decades. One of those explanations is presented by Harvard econ prof Greg Mankiw and Mr. Nutting summarizes like this:

In his paper, Mankiw explains why the top 1% are doing so well while the rest of us sprint hopelessly to catch up: The rich are simply better than us. They make more money because they contribute more to society than we do. They are smarter, have the skills that are in high demand, have better entrepreneurial instincts, and work harder. What’s more, their kids inherit these traits genetically.

I would phrase it a bit differently in two sentences. The first, practically tautological, is that the rich are rich because they get paid more. The second is that they get paid more because they are smarter and work harder. The first, as I say, is obvious. The second, however, is fallacious.

It’s fallacious for two reasons. Essentially, the correlation between income and IQ is very loose. And I don’t think there’s any scientific basis for believing that the rich work harder than everybody else. That’s just an unbased assumption, without which the conclusion would not be true. In other words, it’s begging the question.

It might well be the case that all Ivy-educated lawyers are smart, work hard, and are rich. What’s mistaken is that Ivy-educated lawyers aren’t the only people who are smart and work hard and in all likelihood there are millions of those who are aren’t rich. Similarly with medical doctors. It might well be true that docs are smart, work hard, and are rich. But they’re a lot richer than other people who are even smarter and work even harder.

I would submit that the incomes of both of those groups, along with those of many, many others in the top 10% of income earners, are due to rent seeking. And that brings us around to the other explanation, this one from Josh Bivens and Larry Mishel, who find that the main reason for the divergence in incomes isn’t intelligence or hard work but rent-seeking.

As I’ve written any number of times here, I think that the stagnation of incomes of people in the lower four income quintiles while the incomes of those in the top decile have soared can be explained by four factors:

  1. The one-way system of free trade, in which most barriers to trade in the U. S. (except for things like legal and medical services) have been removed while those of our major trading partners, e.g. China, Japan, India, remain largely in place.
  2. The importation of large numbers of unskilled and semi-skilled workers, mostly from Mexico, whose willingness to work for low wages has eroded wages among the lower income quintiles.
  3. Technological changes which have tended to erode wages among those in the middle income quintiles.
  4. Enormous subsidies, most of which have gone to those in the top decile of income earners.

all of which have been the specific result of policies. To change the outcomes, change the policies. For example, want to reduce healthcare costs? Stop voting in “doc fixes”. Allow the wages of medical doctors to fall. Their wages will still be higher than their next-best alternative.

10 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The complete announcement at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments