Chicago, Neighborhood by Neighborhood: Introduction

Not long ago remarks in a comments thread reminded me of how vague or even cartoonish a view people who don’t actually live here have of Chicago. In hopes of remedying that a bit I decided to produce a series of posts that reveal a more ground-level view of Chicago. This is the introductory post in that series which I’m going to call “Chicago—Neighborhood by Neighborhood”.

It’s been said that Chicago is a city of neighborhoods. I haven’t been able to discover who first said that and I strongly suspect that most people don’t understand what it means. Chicago is actually comprised of 9 “sides”, each side is composed of multiple “community areas”, 77 community areas, illustrated above, and each community area consists of one or more neighborhoods for a total of more than 200 neighborhoods in all. In the late 1920s the Social Science Research Committee at University of Chicago identified 75 community areas within Chicago, defined by geography, sociology, and economics. In the 1950s the city annexed land to construct O’Hare Airport, adding a 76th community area. In 1980 the Edgewater community area was separated from the Uptown community area for a 77th and it’s remained that way ever since.

The boundaries of the community areas haven’t changed since they were drawn originally and I have little doubt that they’d be a bit different if they were drawn today.

As I wrote above, each community area consists of one or more neighborhoods and, in general, the community areas take their names from one of the neighborhoods in them. The community area I live in is the Forest Glen community but if I said “I live in Forest Glen” to one of my neighbors, he or she would look at me funny. We live in the Sauganash neighborhood, along with Edgebrook and Forest Glen, the three neighborhoods that constitute the Forest Glen community which is located in the Far North Side of Chicago.

Chicago’s community areas by number are:

01 Rogers Park 21 Avondale 41 Hyde Park 61 New City
02 West Ridge 22 Logan Square 42 Woodlawn 62 West Elsdon
03 Uptown 23 Humboldt Park 43 South Shore 63 Gage Park
04 Lincoln Square 24 West Town 44 Chatham 64 Clearing
05 North Center 25 Austin 45 Avalon Park 65 West Lawn
06 Lake View 26 West Garfield Park 46 South Chicago 66 Chicago Lawn
07 Lincoln Park 27 East Garfield Park 47 Burnside 67 West Englewood
08 Near North Side 28 Near West Side 48 Calumet Heights 68 Englewood
09 Edison Park 29 North Lawndale 49 Roseland 69 Greater Grand Crossing
10 Norwood Park 30 South Lawndale 50 Pullman 70 Ashburn
11 Jefferson Park 31 Lower West Side 51 South Deering 71 Auburn Gresham
12 Forest Glen 32 Loop 52 East Side 72 Beverly
13 North Park 33 Near South Side 53 West Pullman 73 Washington Heights
14 Albany Park 34 Armour Square 54 Riverdale 74 Mount Greenwood
15 Portage Park 35 Douglas 55 Hegewisch 75 Morgan Park
16 Irving Park 36 Oakland 56 Garfield Ridge 76 O’Hare
17 Dunning 37 Fuller Park 57 Archer Heights 77 Edgewater
18 Montclare 38 Grand Boulevard 58 Brighton Park
19 Belmont Cragin 39 Kenwood 59 McKinley Park
20 Hermosa 40 Washington Park 60 Bridgeport

My community area is #12.

First stop: Forest Glen

4 comments

Saving the Scent of Summer

Last night I finally broke down, harvested the basil from our herb garden, and made pesto genovese. I divided what I had made into twelve luxurious servings, used two in our last night’s dinner, saved two in the refrigerator for later in the week, and froze the rest to hoard for the depths of winter so they can be thawed and relished to remind us that summer will come again.

Our home is filled with the amazing aroma of fresh basil.

4 comments

The Navy Yard

What’s worse than a crazy, violent person with a gun? A crazy, violent person with a gun and a security clearance.

The aftermath of the mass murder at the Washington Navy Yard has been a nearly perfect example of the hypermature political system that I’ve been complaining about. Even as the story was still breaking the usual suspects were making their usual claims. Gun control advocates were calling for stricter gun control. Gun control opponents were calling for an end to “gun free” zones.

I think that we can stipulate that if we completely removed firearms from our society that the number of firearms-related deaths would decrease. Sadly, that’s not going to happen. Even if we went house-to-house and confiscated firearms, there are probably tens of thousands of Americans who have the knowledge, skill, and access to the equipment necessary to make even automatic weapons. A determined individual will always be able to obtain firearms and every report I’ve seen has suggested that the killer at the Washington Navy Yard was determined. Such a mass confiscation would probably reduce impulsive firearms violence, e.g. suicide using a firearm. Would it reduce the number of suicides? I have no idea. I don’t believe such a mass confiscation will ever take place and I seriously doubt that a fractional reduction in the number or increase of firearms will have any effect whatever.

I think that we can also stipulate that if everyone were armed, skilled, and responsible, the number of mass murders of the sort that occurred at the Washington Navy Yard would decrease as well. The key words in that sentence are “everyone” and “responsible”. Responsible people don’t murder people but you can no more mandate responsibility than you can benevolence or courage.

We might want to pay closer attention to the other qualifiers in my second sentence. If there’s one thing we should have learned from the events of the last several years, it’s that our national security system is seriously broken. So many things require security clearances and so many security clearances are granted that the standards for issuing them have become lax. Could the system work at all if they were issued as strictly as they should be? I have my doubts.

Under the circumstances I don’t see how anyone can give reasonable assurances let alone guarantees that private or secret information will remain private or secret with a straight face.

It is impossible to maximize the freedom of mentally ill people and ensure that they receive the care they need. We must strike a balance and the murders at the Washington Navy Yard certainly suggest that we haven’t struck the proper balance yet.

Finally, violence. It’s impossible to watch Canadian or British television without being struck by how violent, savage even, our television is. I see that as an acceptance of how violent our society is. Strong, courageous people who are mentally and morally sound don’t need to be violent or, at least, very rarely need to be violent. Can you express your disdain for those with whom you disagree in strident, even violent terms and maintain a non-violent society? I don’t see how that will work.

Update

Writing at RealClearPolicy, Robert VerBruggen explains that the killings at the Navy Yard highlight that making the system more stringent won’t help when the system doesn’t work. That includes the firearms purchasing system, the mental health system, and the security system.

18 comments

Daley Bows Out

The big news today here in Chicago is that Bill Daley, brother of former Chicago Mayor Richie Daley, has decided not to seek the Democratic nomination for governor of Illinois:

“It’s a combination of things,” Daley said. “I felt very strongly that as I began to look at this over the next five to nine years, which would be needed to straighten out the situation, that commitment, that need that energy for that stage was probably not going to be there.”

Daley said he had a change of heart in the last few weeks following his 65th birthday and the amount of time it would take to invest in a state drowning in debt and pension obligations. Daley repeatedly railed against Quinn’s leadership during his brief campaign.

In essence, Daley, who’s never won an elective office in his life, is saying that he just doesn’t want to work that hard. He’d rather have a job like Secretary of Transportation or Midwest Chairman of JPMorgan Chase, where you just need to show up every once in a while and they’ll mail you your check.

I think there’s probably a grain of truth in that. I also think that there’s no chance that Pat Quinn will stand aside for him so getting the governor’s nomination would be a fight to the end and a bruising primary fight might increase the likelihood that the next governor of Illinois would be a Republican. Daley’s a good party guy so stepping aside for the good of the party is completely in character. And preserves the family brand.

How likely is a Republican governor? I think that Pat Quinn is a good guy but neither a good campaigner nor a good governor. If the Illinois Republican Party settled on a green eyeshades sort of candidate who breathed absolutely no fire of any sort (something like Jim Edgar), they’d have a pretty good chance of winning. Never underestimate the ability of the Illinois Republican Party to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

BTW, Bill Daley used to live about two block due north of me. Nice house. I’ll show you a picture of it some time. At one point I had three Daley siblings living within a five block radius of me.

17 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

UN Report Finds Syria Sarin Use (Updated)

The UN inspectors have reported that sarin was, indeed, used in the attacks on civilians conducted on August 21, 2013. The post includes a link to the report and news articles as well as a brief summary of the report and even briefer commentary.

0 comments

Obama’s Still Relevant Here

I think the claims that Lawrence Summers’s withdrawal of his candidacy for Federal Reserve Chairman signals that Obama is becoming increasingly irrelevant are greatly exaggerated.

4 comments

Question: Political History

Can anyone give me an example of a policy which, when enacted into law, was unpopular, proved to be more expensive and less effective than advertised, and which became popular and effective over time through incremental improvements? Off-hand I can’t think of any.

10 comments

We Return to the Previously Scheduled Programming

The editors of the Washington Post call for Congressional responsibility:

Specifically, Congress needs to fund the government after the current spending law expires on Sept. 30, and it needs to raise the $16.7 trillion debt limit, which will be reached sometime in the second half of October, and which must be increased to avoid the possibility of a U.S. default.

Alas, these two pieces of what should be routine business have become entangled in the politics of Obamacare, which is to say the decreasingly comprehensible politics of the House Republican caucus. A sizable minority of GOP members insists on “defunding” the health care law before the major parts of it begin to take effect in January. According to a recent Congressional Research Service analysis, this is an operationally futile goal. It would be bad policy even if it were possible.

What’s more, it’s bad politics for the GOP to risk a government shutdown in pursuit of this chimera — a fact Speaker John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) recognizes but which has, so far, failed to sway his back-benchers. This is why Democrats are content, for now, to sit back and cheer on the Republicans’ internal feud. Also, that’s easier than countering the Republicans’ anti-Obamacare crusade with realistic budget alternatives.

I think the House Republicans should fund the government and raise the debt limit as the WP editors suggest, including funding ObamaCare. If they wish to be consistent with their members’ version of fiscal prudence they can include what they deem as responsible cuts to spending, concentrating specifically on things that Senate Democrats will find particularly objectionable, other than defunding ObamaCare. Then they can watch the spectacle of the Senate Democrats voting to paralyze government. Sadly, the likelihood of their doing that or, indeed, anything politically savvy approaches zero.

1 comment

Summers Withdraws from Candidacy

The big economic news of the day (at least so far today) is that Lawrence Summers has withdrawn his name from candidacy for chairman of the Federal Reserve to succeed Ben Bernanke:

WASHINGTON— Lawrence Summers pulled out of the contest to succeed Ben Bernanke as chairman of the Federal Reserve after weeks of public excoriation, forcing President Barack Obama to move further down the list of contenders to head the central bank.

[…]

Mr. Summers, a former Treasury secretary who has been one of the president’s top advisers, withdrew in a phone call with Mr. Obama Sunday morning. In a subsequent letter to Mr. Obama, he wrote: “I have reluctantly concluded that any possible confirmation process for me would be acrimonious and would not serve the interest of the Federal Reserve, the Administration or, ultimately, the interests of the nation’s ongoing economic recovery.”

Mr. Obama said in a statement Sunday that he accepted Mr. Summers’s decision and described him as “a critical member of my team as we faced down the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression, and it was in no small part because of his expertise, wisdom, and leadership that we wrestled the economy back to growth.”

I think it’s clear, as Politico observes, that the proximate cause of Dr. Summers’s withdrawal is opposition from Democratic senators:

Opposition to Summers among Senate Democrats has been obvious for weeks but it escalated on Friday when Sen. Jon Tester (D-Mont.) announced he would vote against Obama’s former economic adviser if he was nominated.

At least three other Democrats on the Senate Banking Committee were expected to oppose Summers — Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio), Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) and Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) – raising the politically uncomfortably scenario of Obama needing to rely on Republican votes just to get his choice for a Fed chief out of committee.

but speculation abounds as to the real reasons for opposition to the Summers candidacy. Brad DeLong suggests that it’s because Dr. Summers is, incorrectly, considered a “Monetary hawk” or a “tool of Wall Street”. Indeed, I’ve seen some claims that Summers’s withdrawal from candidacy marks the end of “Rubinomics”, economic policy dictated by and for bond traders and speculators.

National Journal says it’s due to a string of failed economic policies:

And Summers has made a lot of errors in the past 20 years, despite the eminence of his research. As a government official, he helped author a series of ultimately disastrous or wrongheaded policies, from his big deregulatory moves as a Clinton administration apparatchik to his too-tepid response to the Great Recession as Obama’s chief economic adviser. Summers pushed a stimulus that was too meek, and, along with his chief ally, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, he helped to ensure that millions of desperate mortgage-holders would stay underwater by failing to support a “cramdown” that would have allowed federal bankruptcy judges to have banks reduce mortgage balances, cut interest rates, and lengthen the terms of loans. At the same time, he supported every bailout of financial firms. All of this has left the economy still in the doldrums, five years after Lehman Brothers’ 2008 collapse, and hurt the middle class. Yet in no instance has Summers ever been known to publicly acknowledge a mistake.

and inadequacies of temperament, which I think gets to the root of the opposition Dr. Summers has been meeting in the Senate.

There is a trait that can be a fatal flaw in dealing with bigwigs, as senators unquestionably consider themselves: inadequate deference. I tend not to be particularly deferential to anyone and I’ve encountered it myself. There are really only two likely outcomes of that. Either they despise you because you don’t kowtow or, if you’ve got the goods and lay the groundwork properly, they trust you because they can rely on you to tell them the truth. Unfortunately, Dr. Summers also persistently leveraged his academic accomplishments into political judgments, disqualifying himself as “truth-teller”.

Now the speculation game is on as to who will succeed Ben Bernanke if not Lawrence Summers. Names that have been mentioned include Vice Chairwoman of the Federal Reserve Janet Yellen, Donald Kohn, a former vice chairman of the Fed, former Obama Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner who’s said he doesn’ want the job, and Roger Ferguson another former Fed vice chairman. I think a lot depends on how dearly the Obama Administration wants a Fed Chairman with close ties to it. The next nominee may be someone who hasn’t been mentioned yet.

Update

I swear I hadn’t read the observations of the Wall Street Journal editors when I wrote the above:

The real reason to oppose Mr. Summers for the Fed job is that he would have been an exceptionally political Fed chairman at a time when the institution needs the opposite. Mr. Summers is part of the Robert Rubin tong, which dominates the current White House economic staff and Treasury. If Mr. Summers had been chosen to run the Fed, he would have owed a great deal to the White House and might have turned the Fed into a political subsidiary.

1 comment

Blame Everyone

Over the last couple of days, in reaction to the fifth anniversary of the collapse of Lehman Brothers, there has been quite a bit of reflection about where we have been, where we are now, and where we’re going. Writing at The Atlantic, Derek Thompson blames everybody:

This is a failure of Fed leadership. It’s absurd for Bernanke to focus on historically low inflation while the employment-population ratio continues to drop. But it’s the system, too. The Fed is not designed to easily and immediately put money in the hands of households. A first-order effect of QE is that banks have more dollars to lend. A second-order effect is that families and firms that want loans (for mortgages, for offices) will get better terms. A third-order effect is that people with money will be more confident in the economy when they think the Fed has its foot firmly planted on the accelerator. All of this should help typical, cash-strapped families. Richer companies can hire more people and good feelings breed good feelings. But the Federal Reserve doesn’t write checks to households. It doesn’t drop money from helicopters on Sun Belt exurbs.

The federal government can “drop money” into bank accounts. In fact, it did. It’s called a tax credit. It was a part of the 2009 stimulus — a huge, historic, essential effort to help American families, directly. But the stimulus was also way too small. Whose fault was that? The White House, for being so famously wrong about how bad unemployment would be? The Bureau of Economic Analysis, for being so famously wrong about how fast the economy was shrinking? Republicans, for rejecting every follow-up effort to stimulate the economy? Washington, for clearly and repeatedly preferencing the values of the rich over the poor?

The answer is … yes. They were all all fault. For different reasons. Washington’s fiscal policy has been a tactical, statistical, philosophical, and moral failure.

I think it might be productive to think about the winners and losers over the last half dozen years. The losers are clear: those who lost their jobs and remain unemployed, those who lost their homes. The winners are clear, too: financial companies, large companies, politicians. There are, however, other losers and among them I would place anyone who believes that government policies will be allowed to operate in continuing approximation. There was one shot at the fiscal stimulus bullseye and it was wasted. By virtually every reckoning the size and, more importantly, the structure of fiscal stimulus was inadequate.

That’s why to Mr. Thompson’s list I would add Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi. More than anyone else they were responsible for the structure of fiscal stimulus in 2009. If it succeeded at its objective, then its most obvious objective must necessarily have been paying off political supporters since that what it succeeded in doing. It failed in providing fiscal stimulus timely enough or targeted enough to jumpstart the economy.

Of course, to blame everyone is to blame no one and, implicitly, to believe that nothing can be done. I do believe that there are things that could have been done and that still can be done. It is political calculation that prevents them from being done.

13 comments