Case-Shiller Shows 12.4% Housing Gain

The Case-Shiller index of housing prices for major markets was announced this morning:

U.S. single-family home prices rose in July albeit at a slightly slower pace, though their gain from a year ago was the strongest in more than seven years, a closely watched survey showed on Tuesday.

The S&P/Case Shiller composite index of 20 metropolitan areas rose 0.6 percent on a seasonally adjusted basis, compared to economists’ forecasts for a 0.8 percent gain. Prices rose 0.9 percent in June.

On a non-adjusted basis, prices rose 1.8 percent.

Compared to a year earlier, prices were up 12.4 percent, matching economists’ expectations and marking the strongest rise since February 2006. Prices were up 12.1 percent in the year to June.

12.4% increase year-over-year sounds pretty good and it is. At least it’s better than if prices were declining or flat. But how good is it?

Cruise on over to this graph from Calculated Risk of the Case-Shiller index from 1976 to date. As you can see, the index is now where it stood in 2004, nine years ago. On average people who’ve bought a house in the last nine years and sell now will lose money on the deal. It will take roughly another five years of growth at the present robust level for prices to get back where they were in 2006. If you adjust the index to real prices it paints a harsher picture, so there’s no relief there.

I’m not trying to paint a gloom and doom picture. I’m just trying to inject some reality into the discussion and suggest that we probably shouldn’t depend on the economy being lead by housing.

17 comments

The Evolution of Video Entertainment

Last night’s Emmy awards marked yet another step in the evolution of video entertainment. NetFlix’s re-tread of the British original, House of Cards won an award for best direction for a drama series. That marks the first time a straight-to-streaming production has won a major video award.

IMO it’s inevitable that an increasing proportion of new video entertainment will be produced by streaming servides. NetFlix isn’t alone. Hulu has produced a number of original series, Amazon isn’t far behind, and Acorn is just now releasing newly-produced episodes of Foyle’s War, with first showings concurrently on PBS and Acorn’s own streaming service (to which I’m a subscriber).

Nowadays the action in video entertainment is really on cable with the broadcast networks producing increasingly dreary and tired shows. There are exceptions; ABC’s Modern Family and CBS’s The Good Wife come to mind. I would estimate that straight-to-streaming today is about where straight-to-cable was roughly a decade ago. It will mature fast.

How successful these straight-to-cable productions are can only be measured by whether they favor the fortunes of their parents. For NetFlix it’s so far so good. House of Cards and Arrested Development have added some subscribers and they certainly boosted the stock price. We’ll see.

1 comment

Framing Error

After probing a little more deeply into the reported cuts in the food stamp (SNAP) program, I think there’s a bit of confusion, possibly willful. Here’s the Huffington Post’s commentary:

This week House Republicans voted again to take food from the mouths of our most vulnerable citizens. After failing to get support for a $20 billion cut in food stamps during farm bill negotiations earlier this year, on Thursday Republicans passed an even larger reduction of $40 billion from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP).

These cuts show Republicans fundamentally misunderstand what poverty looks like in America. They aren’t even aware of the living conditions for their own constituents, where reports show Republican Congressional Districts saw bigger increases in suburban poverty in recent years. They don’t see that for some our economy has rebounded but for far too many the struggle to put food on the table continues.

and here’s Agri-Pulse’s reporting:

WASHINGTON, Sept. 20, 2013 – The House approved Thursday a three-year nutrition bill (H.R. 3102), with a partisan 217-210 vote, that aims to cut about $40 billion over 10 years for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and provide various reforms to the program.

All 217 votes in support of the bill were cast by Republican lawmakers. Fifteen Republicans joined 195 Democrats in opposing the bill. Five Democrats and one Republican did not vote.

House Agriculture Committee Chairman Frank Lucas, R-Okla., and other Republican lawmakers said the bill would make “common-sense” reforms to the SNAP program largely by encouraging work and ferreting out fraud and abuse.

Agri-Pulse is a news resource specializing in farming and rural policy coverage. The SNAP program is administered by the Department of Agriculture.

Here, on the other hand, is an editorial from the New Hampshire Union Leader:

The New York Times “reported” on Friday: “House Republicans Pass Deep Cuts in Food Stamps.” The bill “slashes billions of dollars from the food stamp program,” intoned Times writer Ron Nixon. Narrative established: Republicans heartlessly devastate a program that feeds the poor.

One had to read to the sixth paragraph to find this sentence: “But even with the cuts, the food stamp program would cost more than $700 billion over the next 10 years.”

The Republican bill would cut $40 billion over a decade from a program that will still spend $700 billion over that period. It is a scratch, not a deep cut. Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said Republicans would “take food out of the mouths of millions of American children…” About those millions…

It used to be that food stamp recipients had to meet tight income and work requirements to qualify. Now more than two-thirds of recipients get on the program simply by qualifying for other federal assistance. And the work requirements have been relaxed.

Do you see the differences among them? The HP coverage is highly agonistic and emphasizes the plight of the poor recipients, victims of the awful, heartless Republicans. It fails to mention the actual scope of the cuts—$4 billion per year or making qualification for the plan more rigorous. The Union-Leader emphasizes the growth in the plan over the years without mentioning the growth in the need for the plan over the years. At least Agri-Pulse’s coverage is factual rather than being an obvious advocacy piece. None of them specifies the nature of the changes in qualifications for the plan. For that I’d need to go to the primary source material.

Isn’t that what journalism is supposed to be about? Fair and complete coverage of the sources? I shouldn’t need to re-report the story.

Based on the news coverage I can’t determine whether the cuts are warranted or not. I continue to think that the Republicans have erred in going after SNAP. The case for waste, fraud, or abuse just isn’t particularly strong and they’ve probably lost more by their framing of the cuts than they gain by the cuts themselves.

A fundamental principle of optimization theory is optimize where there’s something to optimize. So much of the federal budget is devoted to defense spending, Social Security, and Medicare that it’s hard to justify paying attention to anything else other than for strategic reasons, something absent in the case of SNAP. A principle in negotiation is don’t foreclose options—prepare for future negotiations. Cutting SNAP violates that, too.

7 comments

Shooting at the Wrong Target

I generally agree with Tyler Cowen that the food stamp program or SNAP as it’s now called is a particularly dumb target for House Republicans to go after. If they really wanted to go after a welfare state-type program for waste, fraud, and abuse SSDI is a much better target. SNAP fraud is less than a half billion dollars out of an $80 billion program. SSDI fraud is estimated at about $1.5 billion of a $50 billion program.

They’re both small potatoes in the total scheme of things. Our real problem is that there are too many Americans who are unemployed or underemployed. Fix that and waste, fraud, or abuse in federal assistance programs becomes a rounding error.

0 comments

Prediction: Quinn Won’t Deploy the National Guard

Contrary to whatever he might say:

(CBS) – Gov. Pat Quinn says he would consider using state resources to help combat Chicago street violence, but only if city officials want the assistance.

Speaking on this week’s mass shooting in the Back of the Yards neighborhood, Quinn was asked whether there have been discussions about sending in the state police or Illinois National Guard to assist Chicago police.

The governor said he’s had no specific conversations but noted state police are helping patrol in East St. Louis, another city that has its challenges with violent crime.

“It has to be done in a coordinated fashion with the local law enforcement, with their full cooperation,” Quinn told reporters Saturday.

Quinn did not specifically veto the idea of deploying Guard members in Chicago. A press aide later told CBS 2 the governor was speaking only about the possibility of using state police to help out.

I can say with high confidence that Pat Quinn won’t deploy the National Guard on the South Side of Chicago. He’s running for re-election and, of course, he’ll deplore the violent crime there. Imagine the optics of it. What’s he going to do, declare martial law? Maybe a curfew? Soldiers in military uniforms on every street corner?

People say all sorts of things but that doesn’t mean he’ll do it. I can’t imagine a move surer to put a Republican in the governor’s mansion.

5 comments

ObamaCare’s Worst Enemies

I disagree with Zoë Carpenter, writing at The Nation. I don’t think that the greatest hazards facing ObamaCare are Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, “conservative Congressional Republicans”, an organized ObamaCare resistance, or determined local opposition to ObamaCare. She’s confusing the the lightning bug with the lightning.

I think the greatest hazards to ObamaCare are its supporters—over-promising and under-delivering. That’s why the roll-out on October 1 is so important for the future of the program. Nightmare stories are certain to be rebroadcast and amplified by those who oppose the program or the president or both. The public is already skeptical about the program. A clumsy or just plain bad roll-out of the program could galvanize that skepticism into outright public opposition. No social program can survive real public opposition.

5 comments

There Are No Philosopher-Kings

I struggled for quite a while before I came up with a title that really satisfied me for this post. My first idea was “In Theory There’s No Difference Between Practice and Theory”, a wisecrack of fellow St. Louisan Yogi Berra’s. The rest of it goes “in practice there is”. I went through a few other trial runs before I finally ended with the my present title which probably needs some explanation.

First, read Brad DeLong’s post on how to produce “equitable growth”, economic growth, presumably. It’s short but densely packed. Come back here when you’re done.

Who could deny the benefits of perfect stewardship of the economy by the Congress, running “large deficits–run up the national debt–in times of war, depression, or other national emergency calling for government action” but paying “down the debt in other times”? Who would oppose prudent investment or avoiding shifting “enormous resources into value-subtracting industries”? Why would anyone without a vicious or racist streak oppose millions of eager, healthy, well-educated immigrant workers, ready to take the jobs that are waiting for them?

If only there were some mechanism for directing investment swiftly and efficiently into the areas in which it’s needed rather than into areas that are likely to be “value-subtracting”!

There are some things in what Dr. DeLong has written that I’m confused about and I think I’ll put them in the form of questions.

What about our experience of the last 70 years leads Dr. DeLong to believe that such behavior by the Congress is likely?

Have we been in a continuous state of “war, depression, or other national emergency calling for government action” for the last 70 years? If not, have we paid down the debt during the times that we weren’t? If not, why not? What forces will cause that to change?

What forces are responsible for resources being shifted into “health-care administration, prisons, finance, carbon energy”? Did rent-seeking have anything to do with it?

Given the close relationship between poverty and immigrant status, is a high rate of immigration compatible with greater income equality?

The country with the highest percentage of its population having higher education is Canada at about 50%. We’re just slightly below that. Given that we’ve increased real spending on education about three-fold over the period of the last twenty years, how will we produce more education in the United States? Does spending more on education inherently produce more education?

22 comments

Their Own Facts

Nearly all of the blogs that I read are significantly farther to the left than I am or significantly farther to the right than I am. That’s one of the hazards of being a centrist but it does give me a different point of view. One of the things that I notice in my peregrinations is that the subjects that left-leaning blogs write about and those that right-leaning blogs write about have diverged almost completely. Not only is there no debate. There isn’t dialogue. They’re not even living in the same universes.

In some areas they’re symmetrical. Favorite topics in the Left Blogosphere are how awful Boehner/Republicans/the Right/Tea Party are just as favorite topics in the Right Blogosphere are how awful Obama/Democrats/the Left are. I tend to tune out when I read the words “the Left” or “the Right” and completely lose interest when I read the claims that Obama is a crypto-Muslim or a Marxist or that this or that Republican is a racist or a Nazi. You can make a case for just about anything based on selective reading, guilt by association, or being one of the select who are able to read the secret, hidden meanings in things.

In other areas they’re just on different planets. Left-leaning blogs are almost completely disinterested in foreign policy, something encountered pretty frequently, often with points-of-view with which I disagree, on right-leaning blogs. I rejoice when I find a thoughtful, well-written left-leaning blog with interesting observations about foreign policy. They’re pretty rare. You might note that I’ve added a link to my old friend Steve Hynd’s blog, Not the Singularity. He’s one of the few. Right-leaning blogs are almost completely disinterested in LGBT policy or women’s issues, something encountered pretty frequently on left-leaning blogs.

On the business and economics side left-leaning blogs tend to be more interested in income inequality and labor unions while right-leaning blogs are more interested in growth, usually with an eye to restraining or decreasing the reach of government.

You really get whiplash trying to read blogs from both the Left and Right blogospheres.

13 comments

Life in the Petri Dish

In anticipation of what might be thought of as the official kickoff of ObamaCare on October 1, there are several articles out there with latecoming realizations about the implications of the law. Chad Terhune, writing in the LA Times, observes:

The doctor can’t see you now.

Consumers may hear that a lot more often after getting health insurance under President Obama’s Affordable Care Act.

To hold down premiums, major insurers in California have sharply limited the number of doctors and hospitals available to patients in the state’s new health insurance market opening Oct. 1.

New data reveal the extent of those cuts in California, a crucial test bed for the federal healthcare law.

These diminished medical networks are fueling growing concerns that many patients will still struggle to get care despite the nation’s biggest healthcare expansion in half a century.

Consumers could see long wait times, a scarcity of specialists and loss of a longtime doctor.

“These narrow networks won’t work because they cut off access for patients,” said Dr. Richard Baker, executive director of the Urban Health Institute at Charles Drew University of Medicine and Science in Los Angeles. “We don’t want this to become a roadblock.”

Read the whole thing for the quantitative rather than just the qualitative implications. The editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are concerned about the same thing:

As reported by the Review-Journal’s Jennifer Robison on Sept. 12, Nevada’s insurers are expected to control the costs of dozens of coverage mandates by slashing the number of doctors and hospitals they contract with, creating what local employee benefits consultants call “skinny networks.”

If you like your doctor, and your doctor isn’t in your new skinny network, then guess what? You will not be able keep your doctor. Period.

Ms. Robison noted that it’s still not clear how skinny those networks will get, because plan designs won’t be available until Oct. 1, when the Silver State Health Insurance Exchange starts selling policies. That’s just 12 days away. And Nevada isn’t alone.

I don’t think they’ve realized the full set of implications. Assuming that the plan is successful, access to healthcare will increase. That, after all, is the purpose of ObamaCare. Physicians don’t have a lot of slack capacity. If anything, they’re overworked. If you increase access without an increase in capacity, it will result in price increases or some other form of rationing. It may also, as suggested in the linked article, actually reduce the supply of physicians, a perverse result if there ever was one. Crank in the “skinny networks” and you have the makings of a real crisis.

That’s been my concern about healthcare reform since it was being so hotly debated back in 2009. There’s an argument that the greatest problem in our healthcare system is excess demand but I think it’s inadequate supply and, sadly, healthcare reform as it was enacted into law did nothing whatever about supply. Except, possibly, decreasing it as the preceeding articles suggest.

Well, we’ve got a real-life experiment to test the hypothesis. Life in the Petri dish is fun, isn’t it?

20 comments

The End

When did the financial crisis end?

As I see it there are only a limited number of possible answers:

  1. There was no financial crisis.
  2. It ended in 2008 (Hennessey and Lazear’s contention).
  3. It ended some time after 2008 (at least implied by the president in his remarks on the five year anniversary of the fall of Lehman Brothers).
  4. It’s still ongoing.

I think the financial crisis is still ongoing. Although a lot of small banks have closed their doors since 2007, the financial crisis wasn’t caused by small banks. The big banks are even bigger than they were five years ago. They still have a boatload of bad paper on their books.

Despite its decrease from its peak, the percent of loans delinquent or in foreclosure is higher than it was five years ago.

If the ratings agencies had been doing their jobs, there would have been no financial crisis but very little has changed with the ratings agencies. Their ratings are still required for publicly-traded companies, their number is still limited by law, and they’re still paid by the companies they’re purporting to rate.

Total consumer credit is significantly higher than it was five years ago. A lot of that is in the form of education loans.

The Federal Reserve continues to apply “extraordinary measures”. Apparently, they’ve now become ordinary.

We have made no structural changes in the financial system over the last five years. The notion that Dodd-Frank has fixed the problem is laughable and even Dodd-Frank is being stripped of its enforcement powers.

If you pump enough air into it, you can keep a balloon with a hole in it inflated. That doesn’t patch the hole.

So, when did the financial crisis end? Please give your evidence.

4 comments