The NIMBY of Inequality

Charles Lane has turned his attention to the largest single tax break that goes to benefit the wealthy—the home mortgage interest deduction:

In the debate over economic inequality, most of the discussion is about new things the federal government should do to make the distribution of our society’s resources more even: raise the minimum wage, say, or impose higher tax rates on the rich.

But what about getting Washington to stop some policies that skew after-tax income distribution upward?

Exhibit A is the tax code’s favorable treatment of residential real estate, specifically through the tax deductions for mortgage interest and property taxes. These are projected to cost the Treasury $70.3 billion and $31.7 billion in fiscal 2014, respectively, according to President Obama’s most recent budget proposal. Home-sale capital gains up to $500,000 are also tax-free; that’s expected to cost the Treasury $52.5 billion.

These housing breaks account for roughly 15 percent of the U.S. government’s $1 trillion in annual tax expenditures.

These tax breaks go overwhelming to the highest income earners (30% to the top 1% of income earners, 73% to the top quintile) and preponderantly to the states that vote most reliably Democratic, e.g. New York, California, Massachusetts, Washington, Washington, DC.

The choice doesn’t need to be between the present home mortgage interest deduction and no mortgage interest deduction. The home mortgage interest deduction could be capped, say, at $100,000 per year in interest. That virtually by definition keeps it in place for 97% of Americans which would seem to me to be pretty inclusive of the middle class.

The kernel of Mr. Lane’s column is that if you’re in favor of a more egalitarian society you should favor measures that actually make the society more egalitarian, even if they affect your pocketbook or your lifestyle. Sadly, he jumbles income inequality, wealth inequality, and inequality, generally. He’s also assuming that outcries about income inequality are sincere expressions of conviction rather than just finding a handy cudgel to beat your political opponents with. Or just making yourself feel good about how egalitarian you are without actually being egalitarian.

3 comments

Are These What’s Wrong With the PPACA?

As if in answer to my questions a group of centrist Democratic senators plus independent Sen. Angus King, have produced a list of changes they’re proposing to the PPACA. Their proposed changes are:

  • More alternative plans.
  • Startup funds for “consumer-driven health insurance cooperatives”.
  • Direct states to develop models for sale of health insurance across state lines.
  • Raise the employer mandate to companies with more than 100 employees rather than 50.
  • Extend the availability of health insurance tax credits for small businesses and make them available to companies with 50 or fewer employees rather than the present 25.
  • Streamline reporting requirements (unspecified).
  • Allow individuals to enroll in insurance programs directly through insurance companies on a permanent basis.
  • That raises two questions for me. First, what’s wrong with the PPACA? Second, do the senators’ proposals correct those? I don’t see it but it’s possible I have blinders on. As I see it the PPACA’s main problem is that it insures too few people for too high a cost and I see nothing in the senators’ proposals that will correct either of those problems.

    I don’t oppose the PPACA. I want it to be fully implemented as soon as possible so that we can turn to the pressingly urgent problem of reforming healthcare in the United States rather than the distraction of reforming healthcare insurance. Our primary problem is that healthcare is too darned expensive. Eventually people will figure out that one of the fundamental assumptions of the PPACA—that people want healthcare insurance—is wrong or, at least, overstated. The uninsured are indifferent at best to healthcare insurance. They want healthcare to be available at an affordable cost.

    Costs are an urgent problem for state and local governments which can’t wait any longer. Here in Illinois as I suspect is the case in many states we spend more on healthcare than on education or anything else on which the state spends money. The cost of healthcare continues to rise faster than revenues and faster than revenues should be expected to increase.

    The senators who’ve made their proposals represent the far right among mainstream Democrats and given the state of the party leadership I’d be surprised if their proposals go much farther than being something to campaign on. It may be that I’m wasting my bandwidth even discussing them but so, I believe, are those who think that meaningful reform of the PPACA is likely for the foreseeable future.

3 comments

Extension

My offhand guess about extending the deadline for enrollment in the exchanges is that there is some point at which the insurance companies will balk. It also seems to me that it raises a takings issue (if you take the insurance model at all seriously).

1 comment

Quinn’s Budget Address

This afternoon I listened to Gov. Pat Quinn’s address on Illinois’s budget. I didn’t catch all of it but I caught most of it. If I had been expecting a green eyeshades-type speech, full of numbers and detail, I would have been disappointed. It was a stump speech.

Even as a stump speech it was a bit disappointing. I now know that Gov. Quinn is in favor of public education, infrastructure spending, and making the income tax hike of a few years ago permanent. I also know that he’s opposed to making services subject to the sales tax and Illinois’s excessive dependence on real estate tax. Beyond that there just wasn’t much there there.

Conspicuous by its absence was any mention of how much he wanted to spend (on anything) or how much revenue would be needed.

However, as Josh Billings (Henry Wheeler Shaw) said, it ain’t what you don’t know that’ll hurt you but what you do know that just ain’t so. The disinformation and misinformation in the governor’s speech was abundant.

For example, despite the governor’s frequent touting of Illinois’s pension reform most of the job is left to be done. An independent review of the pension reform measure found that its impact on Illinois’s public pension problem was negligible.

He also failed to mention that real estate taxes are the primary source of revenue for local governments and most of the real estate tax is securely in their hands (Illinois has more independently taxing institutions than any other state in the union). Whatever the state might do in this area will have practically no effectd. From the governor’s remarks you might conclude that education in Illinois was an accomplishment on which he could run proudly. The reality is that Illinois is last among the states in its contribution to public education. He emphasized how much Illinois had accomplished during his tenure in office while handily ignoring that the state’s credit rating had been lowered twice during that relatively brief tenure. There was nothing in his speech that would solve Chicago’s public pension problems, a significant portion of which has been fomented by the state, and one of the state’s most pressing problems.

Other than it it was a delightful speech, mostly serving to position the governor in his re-election campaign agaist Republican challenger Bruce Rauner.

5 comments

An Anti-Political Year

The final citywide turnout in Chicago’s primary elections last week was under 10%. I believe that’s the lowest in the city’s history. At just over 10% the turnout in the precinct where I worked was actually higher than the citywide average. We’re either dramatically over-registered or voters just plain weren’t interested. Alexis Simendinger of RealClearPolitics thinks there’s a strong anti-incumbent sentiment:

Less than eight months before a closely divided electorate decides which candidates they’ll send to Congress, Democrats vying for House and Senate seats face a downbeat populace that may stay home in November, while Republican candidates find themselves challenged to unite around a common vision beyond opposition to Obamacare.

Nearly five years after the end of the Great Recession, Americans express continued pessimism about the economy and the direction of the country, challenging the party that holds the White House

The survey, conducted jointly by the Tarrance Group and Lake Research Partners, found that likely voters hold both parties in generally low regard and are perilously amenable to the idea of bouncing their own members of Congress out of office.

Democratic pollster Celinda Lake, who helped unpack the data during a media event hosted by the Christian Science Monitor, described voters’ mindset this year as “ornery.”

“It’s an anti-incumbent year,” she warned.

In an anti-incumbent year, voters show up at the polls to vote the rascals out. If Chicago is any gauge, it’s an anti-political year. The voters won’t show up at all.

IMO that sort of mood actually favors incumbents. They’re more likely to have at least a little organized support to get their vote out.

Still, with 10% turnout anything can happen. Getting 5% of registered voters to vote for you could conceivably allow even fringe candidates with very highly motivated supporters to get themselves elected.

Related: Thomas Edsall, “How Strong Will the Democratic Backlash Be?” Again, if Chicago is any gauge there won’t be a “Democratic backlash”. It isn’t unknown for the number of Republican election judges in primary elections to exceed the number of registered Republicans here. Talk about your “Republicans in name only”!

I do wonder how much of a monkeywrench the incompetent debut of Healthcare.gov will throw into things. It’s darned hard for technocrats to run on competence with that kind of record or to run as a reform candidate when you’re an incumbent.

7 comments

How Do You Determine What Companies Need?

Matthew Slaughter supports expanding the number of tech workers imported into the United States:

In many recent years, demand for H-1B visas has far exceeded supply. In 2013, the government received roughly 124,000 applications in just four days—and then stopped accepting petitions on April 5. The government has closed the visa window suddenly before, as recently as 2008. All current forecasts suggest strong visa demand again this year thanks to dynamism in high-innovation sectors and continued economic recovery.

[…]

Talented immigrant STEM workers do not crowd out American-born STEM talent. Companies that cannot hire talented immigrants in America often don’t hire anyone at all. Or these companies may hire—but overseas. In 2007, Microsoft opened a research center in Vancouver, in part to “allow the company to continue to recruit and retain highly skilled people affected by the immigration issues in the U.S.,” according to the company’s announcement. In May, the startup Blueseed announced it would skirt U.S. immigration restrictions by building a barge in international waters 12 nautical miles off the coast of San Francisco. There the company could accommodate international entrepreneurs.

I completely support American companies getting the employees they need. However, I think that Mr. Slaughter is too gullible in taking the companies’ word for what they need. Quite to the contrary I think that there are plenty of qualified tech workers already available in the U. S. but the companies don’t want to pay the wages necessary to hire them. I don’t have nearly as much sympathy for them as Mr. Slaughter does.

I’ve already proposed my solution to the problem: requiring companies to advertise the jobs for which they’re trying to secure H-1B visas in a common clearing house, requiring them to hire qualified domestic workers that apply for the jobs offered in the common clearing house, and imposing substantial penalties when companies fail to comply with the wage regulations that are part of the H-1B visa program. Then, when you’ve got such a program in place, remove the quotas entirely.

I note, too, that Mr. Slaughter confuses strong sales with “dynamism in high-innovation sectors and continued economic recovery”. Wages have been pretty flat in the tech sector for a half dozen years or more. Aren’t changes in the market clearing price for labor a better gauge for determining the demand for labor than sales?

As I’ve mentioned before there’s already good reason to believe that tech companies colluded to fix wages. I don’t think these same companies would be above lying about what they need.

3 comments

It’s Not Just Putin

There’s a lot that I agree with in former Defense Secretary Robert Gates’s op-ed in the Wall Street Journal on the challenges that Russian President V. Putin presents to the West. For example his list of Russia’s particular grievances is pretty good:

His list of grievances is long and was on full display in his March 18 speech announcing the annexation of Crimea by Russia. He is bitter about what he sees as Russia’s humiliations in the 1990s—economic collapse; the expansion of NATO to include members of the U.S.S.R.’s own “alliance,” the Warsaw Pact; Russia’s agreement to the treaty limiting conventional forces in Europe, or as he calls it, “the colonial treaty”; the West’s perceived dismissal of Russian interests in Serbia and elsewhere; attempts to bring Ukraine and Georgia into NATO and the European Union; and Western governments, businessmen and scholars all telling Russia how to conduct its affairs at home and abroad.

I also completely endorse something that’s written between the lines of the op-ed but from which, unfortunately, he steps away. It’s not merely President Putin we have to worry about. He is merely an expression of what most Russians believe:

The only way to counter Mr. Putin’s aspirations on Russia’s periphery is for the West also to play a strategic long game. That means to take actions that unambiguously demonstrate to Russians that his worldview and goals—and his means of achieving them—over time will dramatically weaken and isolate Russia.

but

No one wants a new Cold War, much less a military confrontation. We want Russia to be a partner, but that is now self-evidently not possible under Mr. Putin’s leadership. He has thrown down a gauntlet that is not limited to Crimea or even Ukraine. His actions challenge the entire post-Cold War order including, above all, the right of independent states to align themselves and do business with whomever they choose.

Let me suggest something that may not have occurred to you. The largest problem in the crisis in the Ukraine isn’t Putin or Russia or Ukrainian right-wing extremists or weakness in U. S. policy. It’s Germany.

As with so many other European crises over the last twenty years the crisis in the Ukraine was fomented by Germany and is insoluble without German cooperation which so far has not been forthcoming. The reason that Germany was divided after World War II wasn’t to protect Germany from Russia. It was to protect the Europeans including Russians from Germany. Recently, some commenters here have expressed discomfort with Germany’s shouldering the cost of its own defense on the grounds of the dangers of an armed Germany. Why is a Europe dominated militarily by Germany unacceptable while a Europe dominated economically and politically by Germany is acceptable?

8 comments

What If You’re Wrong?

I really don’t have much to say about the Hobby Lobby case and the PPACA’s regulation requiring that employers provide birth control as a “no extra charge” component of the insurance they provide to their employees . Just about all that I can add is that sexual relations is not an insurable risk and, consequently, requiring birth control be provided as part of the package seems like a stretch if you’re adhering to anything remotely resembling insurance which I gather that the administration is not. It’s just a word.

See also here:

Contrary to protestations from certain entities that subvert all issues for political gain, the Hobby Lobby case is not about birth control or women’s rights or even universal health care. It is, in Dershowitz’s summation, about “whether or not the statutes in the penumbra of the Constitution require a religious exemption.”

An entire school of red herrings has been produced in arguing about this case.

I’m not a lawyer so I have no authoritative basis on which to remark about the law. Based on my reading it’s my understanding such as it is that the law of closely-held private companies is pretty mature and that they are generally held to be alter egos of their owners.

My impression, too, is that, regardless of the vitriol being poured out in the opinion pages, the government’s case is quite weak. I hold the outrageous and naive belief that the members of the Supreme Court generally ground their opinions in the law and I suspect they will in this case, too. That’s not to say that the Court doesn’t take other considerations into account as well, e.g. the Court’s reputation or possible future implications of their decisions. I think that partisanship, which since the members of the Court are human is necessarily a factor in its members’ decision, is way down on the list of reasons for Court decisions.

The Obama Administration has not fared particularly well with the Supreme Court and that’s not just due to the partisan divide. The large number of unanimous Court decisions that found against the administration is adequate refutation of that belief. Unless you think that Ruth Bader Ginsburg is a right-wing partisan hack.

Here’s my hypothetical question. What if you’re wrong? What if the Court finds unanimously in favor of the plaintiff, sending a rebuke to the administration?

21 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Don’t Take Away My Parmesan!

Around here we buy and enjoy Dubliner cheese. It’s a parmigiano-style cheese made in Ireland that’s not as good as Argentine reggianito or the real parmigiano-reggiano, produced in Italy in Parma, Reggio-Emilia, and a few other designated areas but it’s widely available, half the price of the Argentine, and a quarter of the price of the Italian.

If the Europeans get their way Kraft and other American cheesemakers will no longer be able sell Parmesan cheese, execrable as what they sell under the name is:

More than half the members of the U.S. Senate rose in defense of American dairy last week, in what could be a sign of how hard it will be to forge a comprehensive trans-Atlantic trade deal.

The trouble comes from the European Union’s rules concerning “protected designations of origin” (PDO) and “protected geographical indications (PGI).” EU law allows producers of many foods—from Parmesan cheese to prosciutto—to apply for legal protection for the names of their products. The European Commission then decides whether a name has become generic or not and then how much protection a product deserves. So cheddar gets no protection but feta does. And to be prosciutto di Parma, your ham must not only be produced near that Italian city, but it must meet a host of requirements on how long it has been aged, what the pigs have been fed, and more.

I’m not convinced by the Europeans’ arguments. At some point doesn’t common usage obliterate protection? The list of common foods that include European place names in their names is enormous—Swiss cheese, hamburgers, wieners, just to name three—and those names have been common parlance for a century of more. Practically all common names for types of cheese are derived from place names, e.g. cheddar, roquefort, gruyere, cheshire, stilton. Even the name American cheese, now the name used to describe what I usually refer to as “American-type cheeselike food product” is derived from a place name.

5 comments