You’re Batman

This is just a passing thought and I don’t have a great deal to say about it but I wanted to pass it along. When you don’t act strictly within the confines of international law and impose your own sense of justice using the means you see fit, you aren’t the “world’s policeman”. You’re Batman.

6 comments

Whom Should We Kill?

There’s an interesting post at The Moderate Voice, re-posted from The Economist, about the state of capital punishment, particularly in the United States:

AMERICA carried out 39 executions last year. This puts the country in some unsavoury international company; only China, Iraq, Iran and Saudi Arabia put more people to death (albeit by a fairly large margin in China and Iran). Our colleagues over at Graphic Detail have plotted these executions on a rather grim chart.

For all the public hand-wringing over the death penalty, the number of places that carry it out and the number of people killed is rising. Amnesty reckons that 23,392 people are living under death sentences worldwide for crimes including treason, embezzlement and adultery.

I wish the opinion piece went into the issue in a little more depth. In the countries of Europe that have abolished the death penalty, that generally has not been done through the democratic process. Public opinion frequently supports the death penalty even in countries that have abolished it. In those countries is has been abolished by elites rather than by the will of the people. When it was abolished 25 years ago two-thirds of the French continued to support the death penalty. In today’s France about 45% of the people support the death penalty, about 40% of Britons and Canadians do.

85% of the Japanese support the death penalty; more than 70% of Mexicans do. Public opinion in China and India supports the death penalty. My general impression is that people who live in large countries are more likely to support the death penalty than those who live in small ones.

I don’t know whether I’m out-of-step with my fellow Americans, three fifths of whom support the death penalty or not. I think we continue to administer the death penalty too frequently. As of this year we applied roughly one death penalty per 9 million residents. I think its application should be very rare, even rarer than that, imposed only in those cases in which there is no doubt of the guilt of the convicted, and only for the most heinous of crimes in which the rate of recidivism is 100%. That could, effectively, mean no death penalty at all.

When immigrants come here although they may leave their material possessions behind, they bring their values and political beliefs with them. Since the countries from which we should expect future immigration continue to impose the death penalty and public opinion typically favors the death penalty in those countries more than it does here, I suspect that we should expect support for the death penalty to rise here rather than decline.

A majority of the people in the world support the death penalty. That doesn’t make them right but it’s a reality we should acknowledge.

6 comments

A Story About Values

This story starts the way all good stories do. Once upon a time, I had a friend. He was one of the half dozen or so people most influential in my life.

One day this friend had a problem and he asked me to lie for him under oath in court. I refused, not because I was afraid of being found out, but because it violates my values. I will not lie under oath, whether in court or anywhere else. That ended our friendship.

Values are manifest in the things you do or refrain from doing. They give your life its meaning. If there is nothing you wouldn’t do (or you would do anything), under the proper circumstances, you may wish you had values but you don’t have them. You have wishes.

13 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

WSJ Wonders About Transnistria, Too

The Wall Street Journal notices that Transnistria, a tiny territory about the size of Cook County, is a pretty darned good candidate for a Crimea-style annexation (just as I pointed out yesterday).

3 comments

Your Language Lesson for the Day

According to Anne Applebaum in the Russian sphere of influence today, “LGBT” means pro-Western:

Afterward, I worked it out. The lawyer meant to say that Saakashvili — who drove his country hard in the direction of Europe, pulled Georgia as close to NATO as possible and used rough tactics to fight the post-Soviet mafia that dominated his country — was “too Western.” Not conservative enough. Not traditional enough. Too much of a modernizer, a reformer, a European. In the past, such a critic might have called Saakashvili a “rootless cosmopolitan.” But today the insulting code word for that sort of person in the former Soviet space — regardless of what he or she thinks about homosexuals — is LGBT.

I think that President Obama is overstating his case when he makes the claim that Putin’s Russia isn’t the vanguard of some “global ideology”. In the recent UN General Assembly vote condemning Russia’s annexation of Crimea the vote was 100 in favor of condemning it, 11 opposed, with 58 abstentions.

Those who voted against the condemnation were Armenia, Belarus, Bolivia, Cuba, North Korea, Nicaragua, Russia, Sudan, Syria, Venezuela, and Zimbabwe. That’s a combination of countries affiliated very closely with Russia, the usual suspects, and the “Bolivarian” countries of Latin America. But look at the passive-aggressive abstentions. They include China, India, Brazil, Egypt, Iraq, Kenya, and Pakistan. They include countries on every continent and the largest countries in the world. They represent more than half of the people in the world and more than half of its land territory.

If President Putin can claim the leadership of this 21st century “non-aligned movement”, the next few years may be very troubling times. We could face a global ideology of opposition.

27 comments

More on the Hobby Lobby Case

Eugene Volokh hosts a genuinely excellent recap of the issues in the Hobby Lobby case before the Supreme Court, written by Stanford law professor Michael McConnell. Professor McConnell identifies four questions the Supreme Court must consider:

(1) Could Hobby Lobby avoid a substantial burden on its religious exercise by dropping health insurance and paying fines of $2,000 per employee?

(2) Does the government have a compelling interest in protecting the statutory rights of Hobby Lobby’s employees?

(3) Would a ruling in favor of Hobby Lobby give rise to a slippery slope of exemptions from vaccines, minimum wage laws, anti-discrimination laws, and the like?

(4) Has the government satisfied the least restrictive means test?

His answer to each of those questions is “No” and he goes into some depth in the reasoning behind his answer. Here’s a brief sample:

Even accepting (arguendo) the notion that insurance coverage for contraceptives is a compelling interest, it is hardly obvious that the least restrictive way to provide that coverage is by forcing employers to provide it. Indeed, the government’s argument that Hobby Lobby should just drop insurance altogether demonstrates that the government actually does not view it as essential that people receive insurance through their employers as opposed to from other sources. The important point for the government, it seems, is that employees who work at Hobby Lobby have access to this coverage from some source.

This could be structured in any number of ways. The government could extend the same accommodation to the small number of businesses with this conscientious objection that it already has to religious employers. It could subsidize the contraceptive coverage directly. Employers with conscientious objections could compensate for not providing contraceptive coverage by adding other valuable coverage to the employees’ plans, thus ensuring that the employer receives no financial benefit from the objection and that the employees bear no net burden. The government could allow employers to substitute cash for coverage on a tax-free and tax-deductible basis.

If you’re at all interested in this case, whether in agreement with the government’s position, disagreement, or simple curiosity, you owe it to yourself to read this post.

20 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Where Is Transnistria?

The future may hold a lot of vehement arguing over some very insignificant bits of territory.

4 comments

Give the Lady What She Wants!

Robert Kagan notes that President Obama’s attempts at giving Americans the foreign policy that they want isn’t working out particularly well for him:

The majority of Americans have opposed any meaningful U.S. role in Syria, have wanted to lessen U.S. involvement in the Middle East generally, are eager to see the “tide of war” recede and would like to focus on “nation-building at home.” Until now, the president generally has catered to and encouraged this public mood, so one presumes that he has succeeded, if nothing else, in gaining the public’s approval.

Yet, surprisingly, he hasn’t. The president’s approval ratings on foreign policy are dismal. According to the most recent CBS News poll, only 36 percent of Americans approve of the job Obama is doing on foreign policy, while 49 percent disapprove. This was consistent with other polls over the past year. A November poll by the Pew Research Center showed 34 percent approval on foreign policy vs. 56 percent disapproval. The CBS poll showed a higher percentage of Americans approving of Obama’s economic policies (39 percent) and a higher percentage approving his handling of health care (41 percent). Foreign policy is the most unpopular thing Obama is doing right now. And lest one think that foreign policy is never a winner, Bill Clinton’s foreign policy ratings at roughly the same point in his second term were quite good — 57 percent approval; 34 percent disapproval — and Ronald Reagan’s rating was more than 50 percent at a similar point in his presidency. That leaves Obama in the company of George W. Bush — not the first-term Bush whose ratings were consistently high but the second-term Bush mired in the worst phase of the Iraq war.

His explanation for the “paradox” is that Americans are ungrateful louts. I think it’s more that Americans are conflicted about foreign policy or as it’s sometimes put have cognitive dissonance about it.

On the one hand the default position for most Americans is non-interventionism, differing from the default position of American elites and opinion-makers which pushes us towards intervention. On the other we want things to go well, both for us and, mildly and at a distance, for others.

What I think have been missing from the discussions of foreign policy that have been fomented by the Ukraine crisis are the ideas of path dependency and opportunity costs. “Path dependency” is the idea that one course of action precludes another. The path in Syria that would have produced the least carnage was supporting Assad at least tacitly. It was impossible to oppose Assad and minimize bloodshed. We had to choose.

We have been alienating, aggravating, opposing, and ignoring Russia for several decades. We should not be surprised when Russia turns and says “this far and no farther” and, given Russia’s history, we should be even less surprised that they say it by force of arms.

And courses of action have opportunity costs. Waging wars that were impossible to win in Afghanistan and then in Iraq made it much less likely that we’d want to wage any war for some time to come. You’ve got to pick your wars carefully. We do not have an infinite appetite for war.

19 comments

Why Extend the Open Enrollment?

Megan McArdle proposes three reasons for the administration’s extension of the open enrollment period for the healthcare exchanges under the PPACA:

One is that the administration fears the system will crash under the kind of demand spike they saw in the last weeks of December enrollment. This is just a prophylactic measure designed to make sure that people who genuinely tried to sign up but couldn’t get through don’t get hit by the individual mandate — and show up on television, crying, shortly thereafter.

The second is that the administration knows, or strongly suspects, that most of the people who have so far bought insurance are people who already had insurance. They’re concerned that when enrollment is closed, they’re only going to be able to point to a net reduction of a few million uninsured — and that almost all the reduction will come from people on Medicaid. So they’re hoping to get a few hundred thousand or million more uninsured people to sign up during the grace period.

The third, most worrying, possibility is that the demographics haven’t really improved substantially. A lot of commentators, including me, have been expecting the “Young Invincibles” — the younger, healthier customers whose premiums will subsidize care for the previously uninsurable — to show up on the exchanges this month. So far, only 25 percent of total signups have come from young adults. And even that may overstate things, because it isn’t unreasonable to assume that the folks who selected plans but didn’t pay for them are young and irresponsible people like … well, like me at 25.

I’ll propose another. Either the administration doesn’t understand or doesn’t believe in insurance. You can’t run an insurance plan the way the administration seems to want to. There’s no way to project your costs which means there’s no way to determine premiums.

17 comments

How’s the Individual Mandate Doing?

Here’s an interesting little factoid:

The individual mandate had the least effect on those it was supposed to encourage to gain coverage—the uninsured. McKinsey & Co. surveys found that a little over one-quarter of people signing up for coverage last month were previously uninsured. Goldman Sachs analysts estimate that about one million uninsured Americans will sign up for the ObamaCare exchanges before open enrollment ends. For perspective, that’s about 2% of the 48 million uninsured.

That sounds like an awful lot of energy, time, and money expended to insure .3% of the people. Do you think the additional costs will be linear or geometric to insure the reamining 16%?

15 comments