Reparations

Presumably in an attempt at motivating black voters in anticipation of the midterm elections, I’ve seen several articles lately about reparations for slavery. I’m not completely unsympathetic with the idea but I think it’s an entirely political notion that founders in practice.

In order to justify it, you’d need to come up with a good explanation for why a Korean immigrant who arrived in this country in 1990 should pay reparations to a Ghanan immigrant who arrived in this country in 1990. I can see an argument for descendants of slave owners or companies that benefited directly from slavery paying reparations to the descendants of slaves. But most white Americans aren’t the descendants of slave owners, most of today’s companies didn’t benefit from slavery, and many blacks aren’t descended from American slaves. The present incumbent for one.

The past is a bucket of ashes.

14 comments

Dies Horribiles

For the last couple of days there’s been a covey of op-eds, editorials, and opinion pieces highly critical of the president from both friends and enemies. I was going to write a lengthy analytical post on the subject but I found that just too depressing so I’ll cut to the chase.

Every president wants to be judged based on the effort he puts in and his predecessor to be judged based on results. That was the whole thing behind that heckuva job, Brownie bit in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. It was judging by effort rather than by results.

I don’t honestly case how hard presidents work, how benign their intentions are, how awful the Congress is, what a mess his predecessor left him with, how uncooperative the Russians, Chinese, etc. are, or how hard it is for the president to do much about the economy, the climate, etc. I didn’t force anybody to run for president. Every president has sought the job.

Lead, follow, or get the heck out of the way.

14 comments

Waiting to Inhale

What the heck is going on? The news environment, the raw material that blog posts are formed from, is remarkably fallow these days. It’s not as though there’s nothing going on. Thailand, Iraq, Syria, Ukraine, Sudan, and Libya are all coming apart at the seams. We’ve got “boots on the ground” in Chad (remember: the Viet Nam War metastasized from a handful of military advisors over the period of a decade).

The president has added yet another scandal to his pile. This time it’s people dying waiting to get treatment from the VA and an apparent cover-up of the actual results. That’s something that should be familiar to any Chicagoan: massage the statistics rather than address the problem.

Far from being in anything resembling a robust recovery, the economy is supine.

It’s not as though there’s nothing to write about. Are they waiting for something?

13 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Is “Finlandization” an Option?

Is a a neutral posture between “the West” and Russia really an alternative for Ukraine? Reacting to a column by David Ignatius I summarize Finlandization, explain why it makes sense, and ask a few questions. I think there are more questions here than answers.

9 comments

Foreseeable Risk

My experience in life is that whenever you think you’ve imagined the worst possible outcome of a course of actions you learn that you’ve been unduly optimistic. The editors of the Wall Street Journal reacted to Secretary of State John Kerry’s pitch for the Obama Administration’s energy policy:

Secretaries of State may want to stop making statements in the form of questions, à la “Jeopardy.” First Hillary Clinton declared “what difference at this point does it make?” regarding the reasons that four Americans died in Benghazi. Then on Monday John Kerry told graduates of Boston College that even if he’s wrong about climate change, it won’t cost a thing.

“The solution is actually staring us in the face. It is energy policy. Make the right energy policy choices and America can lead a $6 trillion market with four billion users today and growing to nine billion users in the next 50 years,” Mr. Kerry said in his commencement address, referring to climate change. Then came the odd poser.

“If we make the necessary efforts to address this challenge—and supposing I’m wrong or scientists are wrong, 97% of them all wrong—supposing they are, what’s the worst that can happen?” Mr. Kerry said. “We put millions of people to work transitioning our energy, creating new and renewable and alternative; we make life healthier because we have less particulates in the air and cleaner air and more health; we give ourselves greater security through greater energy independence—that’s the downside.”

with their own scenario of downside risk:

The “worst that can happen” is that we spend trillions of dollars trying to solve a problem that we can’t do anything to stop; that we misallocate scarce resources in a way that slows economic growth; that slower growth leads to less economic opportunity for Boston College grads and especially the world’s poor, and that America and the world become much less wealthy and technologically advanced than we would otherwise. All of which would make the world less able to cope with the costs of climate change if Mr. Kerry is right.

Leave aside Mr. Kerry’s instantiation of the fallacy of the broken window. I think that even the WSJ editors are being unduly optimistic. An even worse scenario is that my speculation that carbon emissions increase faster than linearly with wealth and income is correct, that solar and wind power remain at most backup power for the foreseeable future, and that global demand for oil continues to grow, as you would expect if the Jevons paradox holds. In that case none of the neoliberal strategies that have been proposed for reducing carbon emissions, e.g. a carbon tax or “cap and trade”, will have anything but the smallest effect on emissions, we will encourage increased oil and coal consumption by the Chinese and Indians, we will have more carbon emissions and, presumably, a greater risk of climate volatility, with lower economic growth and fewer jobs than we would otherwise have had.

We can’t imagine the worst thing that could happen.

4 comments

The Secret Language of Dogs

There’s an interesting article at the Washington Post on what you can learn from observing dogs at play:

A shaggy brown terrier approaches a large chocolate Labrador in a city park. When the terrier gets close, he adopts a yogalike pose, crouching on his forepaws and hiking his butt into the air. The Lab gives an excited bark, and soon the two dogs are somersaulting and tugging on each other’s ears. Then the terrier takes off and the Lab gives chase, his tail wagging wildly. When the two meet once more, the whole thing begins again.

Watch a couple of dogs play, and you’ll probably see seemingly random gestures, lots of frenetic activity and a whole lot of energy being expended. But decades of research suggest that beneath this apparently frivolous fun lies a hidden language of honesty and deceit, empathy and perhaps even a humanlike morality.

My experience has been that dogs have a very well-developed sense of fairness. That varies somewhat from dog to dog, of course, just as it does from human to human. The most extreme example I’ve ever known is that our first dog, Qila, when offered a treat in exchange for some behavior or other (sit, stay, etc.), would refuse the treat if the behavior wasn’t something he wanted to do.

I don’t think that this

Other studies have revealed that dogs yawn when they see humans yawning and that they nuzzle and lick people who are crying; scientists consider both behaviors displays of empathy, a rarely documented trait in the animal kingdom.

is being properly interpreted. For dogs yawning is a sign of stress. When you yawn, they assume you’re stressed and yawn back to calm you down. However, not only do I think that dogs have empathy, I think their sensory equipment is much better attuned to identifying what’s wrong with you than ours are. We’ve got to ask. Dogs know where your aches and pains are by your scent.

2 comments

It’s Too Early to Tell

Apparently, there has been no measurable increase in the number of new sick patients as a result of the PPACA

In our previous report, we saw that, at least for the first quarter, a national sample of 12,700 physicians across the athenahealth network did not see an increase in new patients[1] due to the ACA. While not all new patients are newly insured, an increase in this population would suggest that coverage expansion is having an impact on medical practices. Instead, the percentage of total provider visits with new patients actually dropped slightly in the first three months of 2014 compared to 2013. Several factors may help explain why the ACA’s coverage expansion has not led to an immediate and measurable impact:

  1. The number of newly insured patients in the first quarter of 2014 may have been too small to have a measurable impact.
  2. Not all newly insured patients required care.
  3. It may require weeks or months for patients to schedule appointments and be seen.
  4. Our data suggests the influence of new patients on provider activity may take considerable time to unfold. Figure 1 shows the percentage of visits by new patients to Primary Care Providers (PCPs) at practice locations active before 2011. New patients account for 15% to 20% of office visits in the beginning of the year, growing as a proportion throughout the year. Note that a patient defined as new at any point during 2014 remains classified as new throughout the entire calendar year. In other words, these new patients are tracked as a cohort as the year progresses. We chose this definition to measure the level of effort physicians place in treating patients that are new to the practice across the year.

That’s a mixed bag. On the one hand it suggests that the new load on the healthcare system may be bearable but on the other it undercuts the argument in favor of the PPACA. The PPACA may have been the easiest thing for the Democratic Congress of 2009 to enact but it may not have been the reform that was needed. As to whether it will be sustainable, it’s just too early to tell.

The linked post is interesting in general and worth reading in full.

9 comments

When Your Friends’ Defense is a Criticism

Speaking of relationships does this description by Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schulz of President Obama’s relationship with Congress

sound like how you would approach cultivating the relationships that are necessary for you to succeed at doing your job? Sounds to me more like some combination between not doing something because you think it’s futile and not doing something because you don’t like it.

2 comments

First Day at School

Yesterday I spent the day working with my new client and I got a much better idea of what they actually wanted me to do. There’s a difference between the pretext under which they’re retaining my services and the reason they need me. The pretext is that I have skills they don’t have. The reason is that they need somebody to organize a major project they’ve undertaken. The way I’m putting the pieces together the VP of Sales has retained me and another chap to work as a team. The other chap will be his alter ego in working customer relations and I’ll be a sort of project manager/mouthpiece.

I was impressed by several things in my first day. I’m having to cope with a variety of nuisance issues—commuting (about twenty minutes), parking (paid), getting lunch (much easier when much of what you do is out of your home), etc. I was surprised by how bumbling everything was. An organization of this size really should be much smoother.

No one has business cards. That’s surprising to me. Nearly every company I’ve ever dealt with from Fortune 500 giants to mom-and-pop shops has had business cards. Clearly, they do not view what they’re doing as a matter of relationships.

And it’s a millennial world. They really are not self-starters and have very little idea of how to organize anything. It will be an adventure.

9 comments

Swiss Nix Minimum Wage

Swiss voters have rejected a $25/hour minimum by 3 to 1:

BERLIN — Swiss voters resoundingly rejected on Sunday a proposed minimum wage that would have been the world’s highest, a move widely seen as reflecting an aversion to state intervention in the liberal economic policies that are the bedrock of Switzerland’s prosperity.

Trade unions had sought a minimum hourly wage of 22 Swiss francs, or $24.65, in what they said was an effort to ensure fair salaries for workers in the lowest-paid sectors, such as retailing and personal services. Switzerland has no national minimum wage.

As the article notes, the Swiss generally believe that wages are best negotiated between workers or their unions and employers. That’s what is meant by “liberal” in the context of the article.

The out-sized minimum wage would mostly have applied to unskilled foreign or rural workers and I’m a bit surprised by the result. I saw the measure as being mostly anti-foreign. The Swiss have rejected it which I would see as a favorable sign.

0 comments