What Wrong With This Picture?

While I was looking for something else at the econblog Zerohedge I stumbled cross this genuinely wry post which asks two questions. If inflation is so low:

  1. Why do the costs of the Federal Reserve cafeteria rise at a multiple of the notional rate of inflation?
  2. Why are wages at the Federal reserve rising at a multiple of the notional rate of inflation? (and faster than cafeteria prices are)
  3. <

There are graphs, of course.

In all seriousness, I suspect it’s because they’re measuring different things. That having been said, I think that while for the Fed we may be in a period of low inflation most people are experiencing things as a period of stagnant wages and moderate inflation. They’re either falling behind or barely able to keep up.

1 comment

What Private Sector?

In a bit of damage control over the criticism of VA waiting times Tim Noah retorts that the private sector is little better:

News stories about the Phoenix VA and some other bad actors indicate the wait can be many months, but an internal VA estimate—one based on “hard” time stamps and therefore less vulnerable to manipulation than the records allegedly falsified — puts the average wait at about 21 days.

Directly comparable data for the private sector are unavailable. But a 2014 survey of physician wait times found the average private-sector wait time to be 18.5 days – two and a half days less than at the VA. In Boston, which has a high concentration of top-quality private-sector hospitals, the average wait time was 45.4 days.

He’s right that there are potentially long waiting times in healthcare beyond the Veterans Administration. He’s wrong in thinking of it as the “private sector”.

The number, size, and placement of hospitals aren’t determined by market forces. They’re determined by state regulators and physicians in collaboration. The same is the case with the number of doctors and nurses. Med schools are accredited by the Liaison Committee on Medical Education, essentially an arm of the American Medical Association, the physicians’ guild. It’s a little more complicated in nursing but the final outcome is the same: the number of nurses that are trained is determined by a guild.

Add to that the two-thirds of healthcare spending that derives from government in one form or another and you have our healthcare system. Describing any part of it as “the private sector” is, at the very least, a great exaggeration. It’s as centrally planned as Stalin’s Soviet Union.

Note that I’m not arguing for a free market healthcare system. I’m just the little boy pointing out that the emperor has no clothes, in this case that there is no private sector healthcare worthy of the name.

Rather than setting up false dichotomies between government healthcare and private sector healthcare I think we would be much better served by wondering why so large a proportion of the total welfare produced by our system is reaped in the form of producer surplus.

5 comments

My Mistake

When I read the caption of James Taranto’s post, “Cocaine, Hookers and Deficits”, I thought it was going to be about Congress. Imagine my surprise when it turned out to be about revisions to Italian GDP.

I think that my confusion is understandable.

0 comments

What’s Broken?

There’s an interesting op-ed by Philip Howard at the Wsshington Post on what broke Washington. His basic thesis is that the sheer accumulation of laws is the major problem:

The main culprit, ironically, is law. Generations of lawmakers and regulators have written so much law, in such detail, that officials are barred from acting sensibly. Like sediment in the harbor, law has piled up until it is almost impossible — indeed, illegal — for officials to make choices needed for government to get where it needs to go.

I think there’s a certain amount of truth in this and that our system is particularly susceptible to such accretions. Our laws tend not to have sunset clauses and over time constituencies grow up for any expenditure for whom the expenditure has become a matter of life and death.

Something he doesn’t take note of is that we have a common law system. Under a common law system the laws enacted by legislatures are only the tip of the iceberg. The overwhelming preponderance of law is the law written by judges. We now have more than 300 years or accumulated judge-written law and in some areas, e.g. tax law, even specialists don’t understand the law.

One thing I want to caution you about. Mr. Howard is reckless in his assertion of fact. For example, when you examine his footnotes about this statement:

Special education, for example, now consumes about 25 percent of the total K-12 expenditures.

they don’t support the claim. He’s inferred it from a combination of hard data, testimonial, and guesswork. I haven’t bothered investigating any of his other statements of fact but verbum sap.

It’s an interesting op-ed nonetheless. I’m more concerned than he apparently is with his prescription.

This country’s planted thick with laws from coast to coast — man’s laws, not God’s — and if you cut them down — and you’re just the man to do it — d’you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then?

1 comment

Is Nobody Home?

I’ve pointed out before how Republican presidents tend to favor Eisenhower’s staff approach to the presidency in which very strong cabinet officers are granted substantial freedom of action while Democratic presidents prefer a more White-House centered approach with lots of micro-management from the top.

I think that President George W. Bush made a major error in handling such a staff administration by pitting his cabinet officers against one another. That’s something weak managers do.

President Obama seems to have opened a new chapter in the history of the presidency. Neither he nor his appointees seem particularly interested in the actual functioning of government. Nobody gets out in front of an issue. They’re always taken by surprise.

The Will Rogers presidency. I don’t know nothing but what I read in the newspaper.

2 comments

Profiles in Cowardice

The Illinois legislature has once again demonstrated that they’re willing to make the hard decisions unless there’s the slightest chance they might have to pay a political price for them in which case not so much:

SPRINGFIELD-A so-called “doomsday budget” filled with spending cuts went down in dramatic fashion Friday, drawing only five “yes” votes and thrusting the whole debate over a 2015 state spending plan up for grabs one week away from an adjournment deadline.

A $34.8 billion package was put up on the board in the House early Friday and drew only minimal debate before members rejected the plan by a 5-107 vote.

The plan, sponsored by Rep. Fred Crespo, D-Hoffman Estates, was cast as an alternative spending approach since a bid to extend the 2011 temporary income tax permanently drew only 34 House Democratic votes during an informal poll taken earlier this week by House Speaker Michael Madigan, D-Chicago.

“You’ve got to be for something, folks,” Crespo said before the vote.

Once again they’re kicking the can down the road to the veto session. This will have the dual effect of postponing re-approving the tax hike until after the November election and enabling the criminally incompetent and self-serving Illinois legislative majority to blame the otherwise impotent Republican minority for their own nonfeasance.

In Illinois our problems aren’t caused by partisan gridlock but by the cowardly and grasping majority. Democrats control both houses of the state legislator by significant majorities and the governor’s mansion. In theory they can pass anything they care to. In practice they refuse to act because it might jeopardize their offices.

In Illinois more than 80% of state legislators run unopposed. Don’t expect elections to change anything.

The Illinois credit rating limbo. How low can you go?

3 comments

Income Inequality Among the Lower 99%

There’s a very interesting and highly technical article at Science on the sources of income inequality among those below the top 1% of income earners, a persistent subject of interest in this blog. I genuinely wish the author would produce another, comparable set of data that excludes workers in the healthcare and education sectors since I think those sectors skew the returns to education severely. If a substantial component of the income inequality below the top 1% of income earners is largely attributable to those sectors, it would merely demonstrate that policy is capable of producing income inequality, something that I think should surprise no one.

0 comments

Life, Art, and Economics

Defects in data occur frequently. You may have too few samples; some may be anomalous. Dealing with these defects may be art form as much as science and the methods for doing that include interpolation, extrapolation, and smoothing. Interpolation is when you construct new data points within the range of known data points. When you draw a line between two data points, you’re interpolating.

Extrapolation is the process of estimating, based on the data points you actually have, the values that might be observed beyond the observed range. When you draw a curve longer than the data you actually have, you’re extrapolating.

Smoothing is when you make the data points you have look better. Sort of like when you blur the focus on a photo of an old lady. It’s doing what you think nature would have done if she had a better sense of aesthetics. When a graphic artist uses Photoshop to make a model appear taller or thinner or give her a narrower waist, he or she is actually creating a picture of a model who does not exist in real life.

There’s something of a brouhaha going on now in the econblogosphere. Thomas Piketty, author of Capital in the Twenty-First Century, the book that’s causing a stir in econ circles days, is being accused of photoshopping his data:

Thomas Piketty’s book, ‘Capital in the Twenty-First Century’, has been the publishing sensation of the year. Its thesis of rising inequality tapped into the zeitgeist and electrified the post-financial crisis public policy debate.

But, according to a Financial Times investigation, the rock-star French economist appears to have got his sums wrong.

The data underpinning Professor Piketty’s 577-page tome, which has dominated best-seller lists in recent weeks, contain a series of errors that skew his findings. The FT found mistakes and unexplained entries in his spreadsheets, similar to those which last year undermined the work on public debt and growth of Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff.

The details are in the linked article but some of the things found include anomalies, just plain errors, and what appear to be smoothing. How damaging are the discoveries?

For example, once the FT cleaned up and simplified the data, the European numbers do not show any tendency towards rising wealth inequality after 1970. An independent specialist in measuring inequality shared the FT’s concerns.

Dr. Piketty, of course, rejects the notion that his data manipulations were deliberate or intended to deceive.

The data manipulations don’t prove that his conclusions are wrong but his retort or the defense of his supporters don’t prove that they’re right, either. I suspect this is something that will be debated for years.

3 comments

The Underpants Gnome Theory of Healthcare

  1. Market discipline would produce a better healthcare system.
  2. ?
  3. Profit!

The editors of the Wall Street Journal complain about the evils of “government healthcare”:

President Obama addressed the Veterans Affairs scandal on Wednesday, saying he’s waiting for an Inspector General “audit” of what went wrong. And the press corps is debating whether VA Secretary Eric Shinseki should be fired. These are sideshows. The real story of the VA scandal is the failure of what liberals have long hailed as the model of government health care.

Don’t take our word for it. As recently as November 2011, Paul Krugman praised the VA as a triumph of “socialized medicine,” as he put it: “What’s behind this success? Crucially, the V.H.A. is an integrated system, which provides health care as well as paying for it. So it’s free from the perverse incentives created when doctors and hospitals profit from expensive tests and procedures, whether or not those procedures actually make medical sense.”

Ah, yes, the VA lacks the evil profit motive. What the egalitarians ignore, however, is that a government system contains its own “perverse incentives,” such as rationing that leads to treatment delays and preventable deaths, which the bureaucracy then tries to cover up. This isn’t an accident or one-time error. It is inherent in a system that allocates resources by political force rather than individual consumer choices. The VA is ObamaCare’s ultimate destination.

I think they’re missing some basic things. We haven’t had anything approximating free market healthcare in the United States for about a century, there are basically no prospects for ever having such a system again, no one would like going back to such a system, and the promise of a free market healthcare system is that it would optimize welfare in the economic sense of producing the greatest quantity of healthcare at the lowest prices for those willing to pay. It does not promise that ordinary people won’t drop dead in the streets of preventable causes, that the diseases of the poor won’t spread to the rich, or that a world with free market healthcare would be one that any of us would want to live in. All of those things require some level of “government healthcare” so we’re stuck with it.

The challenge that we face is how to be prudent stewards in the face of scarcity and human nature. Minimizing the role of government or maximizing it are trivial in difficulty by comparison. They’re the easy, simple-minded, and completely unsatisfactory solutions. Prudence is always the scarcest commodity.

20 comments

Journalism and the Google Economy

I see that Internet entrepeneur Mike Hudack has a complaint about today’s journalism that may relate to mine of yesterday:

It’s well known that CNN has gone from the network of Bernie Shaw, John Holliman, and Peter Arnett reporting live from Baghdad in 1991 to the network of kidnapped white girls. Our nation’s newspapers have, with the exception of The New York Times, Washington Post and The Wall Street Journal been almost entirely hollowed out. They are ghosts in a shell.

Even these three survivors face great challenges and I doubt anyone would call them “healthy” or laud their courage in journalism. They just report what people tell them, whether it’s Cheney pulling Judith Miller’s strings or Snowden through the proxy of Glenn Greenwald doing roughly the same. They seem incapable of breaking real, meaningful news at Internet speed. It’s why they like Twitter so much. Twitter does the hard work for them.

He continues in that vein. I wonder if Mike realizes that he has or, more accurately, other hes in the wacky world that the Internet has brought us have fostered the attitude that may be once of the factors underlying the change.

Once upon a time a small number of people derived their incomes from coupon-clipping. I don’t mean the coupons for soap or frozen dinners in newspapers or online. Bonds used to have coupons attached to them. When the coupon matured the bearer of the bond could clip the coupon and present it for payment. “Coupon-clipping” was a symbol of wealth and indolence.

The modern equivalent of coupon-clipping is passive income. Put Google Adsense ads on your web site; earn money. That’s “passive income”.

There are two things missing from that model. The first thing is what’s referred to as “the long tail”. A very small number of sites garner most of the hits and, consequently, most of the income. Most of the sites earn very little income. Pennies or a few dollars a day is commonplace. In other words living on passive income is only a viable business model for a small number of sites.

The other thing that’s missing is that somewhere somebody must be making or selling something from which that income ultimately derives. No sales; no passive income.

How does that relate to journalism? Somehow the society has been infected with the idea that you, too, can earn millions from passive income, forgetting that there’s got to be underlying economic activity for that to work. In the newspaper business that’s either advertising or stuff that people want to read.

Newspaper advertising is on the skids through a combination of Google, mobile technology, and Craigslist. The political blogosphere has demonstrated that there’s very little reason to pay to read opinion. That leaves reporting and doing reporting that people will pay to read has always been difficult and you don’t earn passive income from it. Ben Franklin didn’t make money from his newspaper. He made money as a printer and produced his newspaper when business was slow and he had time on his hands.

I think there’s a dream of reporter-free news media with stories written by computers, gleaned by scouring the pages of Twitter or Facebook. What I can’t figure out is why anybody would pay to read those stories.

Reporting is a craft, it’s learned by doing it, and you can’t step out of J-school and expect to be a competent reporter. It requires patience and tenacity. I think it’s possible to earn a little money by reporting but probably not enough to pay off J-school debts and have a middle class lifestyle and certainly not enough to have the lifestyle of a physician let alone that of a financier.

1 comment